Statement and press conference by Mr Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the reforms necessary to implement a "politics of civilisation", announcing in particular a new chapter in the preamble of the Constitution, a new method of calculating growth and a reform of the financing of public broadcasting, and describing his foreign policy as a "diplomacy of reconciliation", in Paris on 8 January 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

8 January 2008 · Press conference on the reforms necessary to implement a "politics of civilisation"

Context
Sarkozy addressed a press conference in Paris on January 8, 2008, outlining his 'civilization policy' and announcing constitutional, broadcasting, and foreign policy reforms.
Main themes
Civilization policy, human ideal in politics, French republican values, constitutional reform, public broadcasting reform, diplomacy of reconciliation, globalization challenges, social cohesion, French identity, political renewal, historical precedents of civilizational change, growth measurement reform
Duration
~165 min
99th percentile
Words
19,760
99th percentile
Sentences
949
99th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
10.1
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

949 sentences in 100 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, on the evening of December 31, while presenting my wishes to the French people, I expressed my intention to implement a policy of civilization so that France can be the soul of the new renaissance that the world needs. I know that this policy of civilization has raised many questions among a great number of you, and I am pleased that this meeting gives me the opportunity to address them, for this is not just a formula for the occasion but a deep conviction and a strong commitment. I have indeed expressed this conviction during the presidential campaign, and I made this commitment before the French people, and I fully intend to uphold it. I was elected promising profound change; I was elected promising a true break with the habits of thought, with behaviors, with the ideas of the past that have led our country to the situation it finds itself in. I was elected at the end of a campaign in which values held a central place, whereas for decades it had been almost impossible to mention values in political debate. In this campaign, I spoke of life, morality, authority, identity, culture, integration, and civic duty, but I also spoke of love, openness to others, and humanism. I spoke of respect, respect for oneself, respect for others, respect for difference, and I spoke of diversity. I spoke of what we want to pass on to our children; I emphasized the necessity of making them love what is great, what is beautiful. I wanted to place man at the heart of politics.

So if politics does not express the idea we have of man, of his freedom, of his responsibility, of his dignity, what does politics express? And how can it change the world, how can it make it better, how can it contribute to making men a little happier and their lives a little less hard? How can politics lead to a little less violence, a little less injustice, a little less misery, a little less suffering, if it is not driven by a constant concern for a human ideal? During the presidential campaign, it was indeed this question of the human ideal that was raised by most candidates, each in their own way. And if things unfolded this way, it is because the French people longed for a profound change in the nature of political debate; it is because the French felt that politics was no longer going deep enough into the issues, and that, fundamentally, politics said nothing about the essential, everything about technique, everything about the quantitative, nothing about the essential. The distrust of the French towards politics, which had grown over time to the point of undermining our democracy, was fundamentally due to the feeling that politics had become powerless. And why had it become powerless? For a simple reason: because politics never addressed the real causes of problems, as it confined itself to managing and dealing with the consequences of problems. It did not concern itself with what determines people's lives, the feeling of their personal fulfillment.

The policy of civilization is the policy of life; Edgar Morin said it was a policy of man. The policy of civilization is the policy that is necessary when it is time to rebuild reference points, norms, rules, and criteria. This is not the first time that this necessity has arisen in our country. The need to rebuild rules, reference points, and norms has emerged in our country every time a great political, economic, technological, or scientific shock has shaken intellectual and moral certainties, institutions, lifestyles, and God knows there were certainties. This was the case with the Renaissance, when suddenly, in a country that was crumbling, people said to themselves, well, it is possible. This was the case at the end of the 18th century and the beginning of the 19th century with the Enlightenment; it was the case with the industrial revolution at the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century; it was again the case in the immediate post-war period, after the great crisis of civilization of the 1930s and 1940s. What is the Declaration of the Rights of Man if not the fruit of a policy of civilization? The school of Ferry is a policy of civilization. Secularism was the fruit of a policy of civilization. Social security, labor rights, public service were the fruits of a policy of civilization. At each era, the answers are different, but the challenge is always the same: how to reconcile order and movement, how to reconcile the identity that must be defended and the modernity that must be embraced? How to help the new world to be born and to organize itself when the old one has not yet finished disintegrating? How to rehumanize society? How to allow man to regain the upper hand? How to put the necessary change at the service of this man, and how to appropriate new knowledge? These are eternal questions that we must answer today. So today, we must rebuild our relationship with time and space, our relationship with others and with ourselves, disrupted by globalization, disrupted by technology, disrupted by science. We have to combat the slippages and excesses of our own civilization, whose principles, values, and institutions are no longer sufficient to meet the needs that our own civilization has generated. Here, in my view, are the essential questions. Edgar Morin, again, said that the imperatives today of a policy of civilization are identity resourcing - knowing who we are - it is not trivial to reflect on who we are. Moralization, solidarity, conviviality, which he opposes to the ills of our time, which he defines as isolation, compartmentalization, anonymity, degradation of quality of life, irresponsibility, these objectives I make my own. After decades of deferred reforms, of failed reforms, after decades of a single thought that it would have been so comfortable to continue, of conservatism, of mass unemployment, of loosening social ties, of a decline in social mobility, of stagnation of wages, of devaluation of work, of deficits and debts, urgency is everywhere, and I am surprised that one can wonder if we are going too fast, when I am so aware of the impatience of the French. Moreover, those who demand an immediate assessment and immediate results are the same ones who describe us as too hasty and too impatient. We must know. The French can no longer wait; well, it is with François Fillon and his government, with the majority, that we strive to respond to this urgency. So, in the period we are in, if we no longer want to feel like we are enduring, if we want to put an end to a society, and it is serious, where children feel that they will live worse than their parents, which is exactly the opposite of progress, and which is new because it has probably never happened in our country, then we must inscribe politics in the long term and in the depth of a project of civilization. This is what I wish to do in 2008, not to distance myself from the problems of daily life or to make the difficulties that assail the French forget, which would be so complicated to resolve, but on the contrary, I want to return to them, but I want to return to them by giving us chances to win, not by doing like the others, to fail, because that is what it is. If others have failed, it is not because they were worse, it is because the strategy was not the right one, and we want to embrace another strategy, driven by a project of civilization, precisely because we want to succeed. So, of course, it is the environment, health, urban planning, architecture, education, social protection, the revaluation of work, but look, do we believe that Alzheimer's disease, dependency, depression, the malaise of the suburbs, integration or youth unemployment, are not problems posed to our civilization, which require something else to be resolved than a few management measures or a few additional credits? Who can think that if we put 3% more here we will solve these problems? Who would dare to say that to the French? When for 30 years we have been doing it this way, and it has not worked. And who can ask me to conduct the same policy with François Fillon's government? "Mr. President, just a few more credits," but for what results? As little as the others? Others did not fail because they were left or because they were right, because they lacked talent, for they had talent, they had convictions, and it did not work. I was elected for it to work, so do not blame me for wanting another strategy, because I am trying, with that, to give us margins that did not exist for others. So, do we believe that the digital revolution, or that of biotechnologies, does not call for a transformation of civilization? Do we believe that civilization can emerge unscathed from the excesses of financial capitalism, or from global warming? And who does not see that the common culture or the shared morality that allows us to talk to each other, to understand each other, and even, ladies and gentlemen, to tolerate each other, are values of civilization that condition our daily lives? Who does not see that to the violence, insecurity, and fear of the other, which engenders rejection, exclusion, and withdrawal into oneself, we must oppose politeness, which is a form of respect, authority, which is the expression of legitimacy, education, which socializes and emancipates? Who does not understand that to regain faith in the future, to rediscover the taste for living together, to create well-being and better living, and even to increase purchasing power, to reduce unemployment and precariousness, we must not only manage better, but first change our ways of producing, working, learning, and living, this is the heart of a project of civilization, otherwise we will not succeed.

In 2008, this policy of civilization will first be expressed in the desire to make our democracy an irreproachable democracy, thanks to the reform of our institutions, which I wish to be ambitious, inspired as it is by the work of the commission chaired by Édouard Balladur. We must stop talking about a better balance of powers and decide to revalue the role of Parliament. The role of Parliament will be revalued by the very important initiatives we will take on the agenda - we have never seen a Parliament that gains autonomy and power without being able to control a large part of its agenda - and by giving citizens new freedoms. But limiting ourselves to the mere modernization of rules and procedures will not be enough. It seems to me that the time has come to add to the fundamental rights that form the foundation of our Republic the new rights that our time calls for. After the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen of 1789, after the preamble of 1946 on social rights, which must not be touched, because they are great universal texts, I wish for the preamble of our constitution to be supplemented to guarantee the equality of men and women, to ensure respect for diversity, and its means, to make possible genuine integration policies, to respond to the challenge of bioethics. I have asked Mrs. Simone Veil, whose vision is well known, to chair the commission that will be responsible for drafting a draft text. She has accepted, and I am infinitely grateful to her, for no one was more qualified than she to accomplish such a delicate and fundamental task. It is a matter of ensuring that on the philosophical, moral, and ethical issues posed by modernity, our constitution is ahead of its time and not behind, and as has so often been the case in the past, that France, the homeland of human rights, shows the way to all men, and perhaps that enough has happened in the last 60 years for us to write these new rights and these new questions.

It is with the same determination to implement a policy of civilization that I wish to engage in a reflection on ways to escape a too quantitative, too accounting-based approach to measuring our collective performances, because if we remain prisoners of the restrictive view of GDP, we cannot hope to change our behaviors and ways of thinking. If the criteria, if the indicators of wealth remain the same, how are we going to change our way of producing and our way of thinking? To change everything, we first need to change our judgment criteria; we need to take into account quality and not just quantity. If we want to promote a different type of growth, we must change our instrument for measuring growth. Once again, France wants to set an example by taking the initiative to bring together a group of very high-level international experts to reflect on the limits of our national accounting and GDP, and on the best way to overcome them so that the measurement of economic progress is more comprehensive, so that it better takes into account the real conditions and quality of life of the French, who can no longer bear the growing gap between statistics that show continuous progress and the increasing difficulties they experience in their daily lives. This undermines trust, because no one believes in the statistics anymore. Two Nobel Prize winners in economics who have worked extensively on these issues have agreed to lead this reflection. Amartya SEN has agreed to provide me with his advice, and Joseph STIGLITZ to chair the committee of experts; I thank them, their international expertise will be extremely valuable for defining these new criteria.

2008 will be the year of the implementation of what was decided during the Grenelle de l'environnement; it will be the beginning of the construction of another growth, another model of development; it will be the start of a profound change in our civilization, in its relationship with nature, in the idea it has of its responsibility towards the planet, and even towards future generations. In this spirit, if the High Authority that will speak tomorrow raises serious doubts about the GMOs currently cultivated in France, I am willing to invoke the safeguard clause until the European Commission resolves the issue. I do not wish, moreover, for the GMO law to be discussed in haste. We must not be mistaken about what we wanted to do with François FILLON and Jean-Louis BORLOO: the Grenelle de l'environnement is a major political turning point; it is not a communication operation. The Grenelle de l'environnement will be scrupulously respected; it is a matter of the credibility of the State and of politics.

In 2008, the policy of civilization will be expressed in schools. Last year, I wrote to all educators in France to present the educational project that I had placed at the heart of my campaign; well, now is the time to implement it. Many changes have been made in schools in 2007. Now, it is about getting to the heart of the matter, that is to say, taking care of what we want to teach our children, what we want to pass on to them in terms of knowledge, values, and cultures; in short, to establish what human ideal we want to propose to them, and to organize studies, programs, rhythms, and teacher training to achieve this. The letter to educators is exactly for me the illustration of what the objectives of a policy of civilization can be. I will be involved in the implementation of the orientations I have defined in this letter, to build a school of knowledge, civility, respect, and culture; a school where we instill a love of learning, intellectual curiosity, open-mindedness, a sense of effort and work, of thought, but also respect for the authority of the teacher, politeness, where we teach civics. Together with François FILLON and Xavier DARCOS, we will prioritize primary education, which has been neglected for too long without seeing that its weakening was the main cause of the increasing difficulties in middle schools. Tackling the problems of middle schools is good, but if we continue to let so many children leave primary school already accumulating failures, how do you expect middle schools to succeed? This policy will take time, time to be implemented, time to produce its effects, but the relationship of our children to culture, knowledge, and thought is what is most essential for the future. It is in schools that the society and civilization of tomorrow will be built. So, whatever the difficulties, we do not have the right to retreat; there have been too many abandonments, too many renunciations in the past to retreat again—besides, by constantly retreating, we will end up back at square one—but that is no longer possible; the debate about schools cannot be reduced to the sole question of status. The status is important, but still, the content of an educational policy, of what is taught in schools, of what we expect from schools for our children, does not belong solely to professionals; it belongs to everyone. We must make commitments and achieve results. Schools must once again become everyone's business, and not just that of specialists. Schools must be placed back at the heart of politics as they once were, instead of being kept at a distance, as if it were a subject too complicated or too risky for politics to tackle—“wait, don’t talk about it, please, we’re going to have a demonstration”—there you go, very well, well, by not talking about it, we end up having a demonstration, a beautiful result, with considerable discomfort, teachers who are remarkably dedicated and who have a constant identity problem, and I do not observe that demonstrations resolve it; if that were the case, with all the demonstrations that all governments have had, they should be in nirvana of happiness. So, the time has come to get to the bottom of the problems on this issue.

In 2008, the policy of civilization will be expressed in the profound renovation of our universities, dear Valérie PECRESSE. Together with François FILLON, we have allocated considerable resources to make up for a backlog accumulated over decades, which has left our universities—in a word—dilapidated, and this is not an insult to anyone, as teachers are more victims than culprits in this matter, but a state of dilapidation... We must recreate universities where one wants to study, where one has the means to study. We must create campuses that are places of conviviality and intellectual effervescence. We must offer our students a framework and living conditions that reflect the importance we attribute to knowledge in our civilization. Well, in 2008, we will select the top 10 major university renovation projects that will testify to the ambition of our policy in this area, because I am well aware that no government says, “no really, the university is not my priority”; they all say that, and in the end, what do we see? Nothing. Well, in 2008, we will launch the top 10 major renovation projects; at least we will see, and we will see concrete results.

The policy of civilization in 2008 will be expressed in a youth policy, because our society does not give its youth the place it should have; it does not provide them with the means for their autonomy and integration. By treating its youth so poorly, our society sacrifices its future. So we will break free from immobility, from a society of acquired advantages and rents, “don’t touch my advantage,” “don’t touch my rent,” “don’t touch anything and change everything.” How do we do that?

I want the break to allow us to implement this project of civilization, which we also express in politics, which will tackle the malaise in the suburbs head-on. We will talk about this policy at the beginning of February. It will be a policy of integration, a policy that will primarily concern people, that will support them, that will give all those who want to succeed the means to do so, to compensate for those who face particular disadvantages, to help those whom life has tested to overcome the challenges they have faced. It will be a policy of equal opportunities, which will aim for every young person in disadvantaged neighborhoods to receive training. Every young person to whom the State grants the right to training must respect certain duties. No rights without duties. We will place the Republic not only in the territories; we will place it in the people, at the service of the people. This will be a policy that cannot be separated from the renovation of schools, the modernization of public services, the support of the unemployed, the securing of professional paths, housing policy, and the consequences of the Grenelle de l'Environnement. It is a policy that will be concerned with the response our society will provide to fundamental questions, such as how to give a chance to someone who has experienced failure. Our society is fantastic; it is suspicious of success, suspect in every way, and is so fascinated by failure that it considers it insurmountable. So there you go, it is not good to succeed because it is suspect, and necessarily, in success, there is something fishy. And at the same time, the one who fails, that person is not given a new chance. But how do we do it if we cannot fail, cannot get out, cannot bounce back, cannot succeed? Can we even pose the problem of the malaise in the suburbs without addressing that of the city? I want to address the problem of the city in 2008, not as a simple management issue, but as a question of civilization. It is a problem that has arisen every time the relationship between man and space and time has been disrupted. It is a problem, the city, that our civilization has not been able to master. What kind of city should we strive to build at the beginning of the 21st century? It is a major political subject. Well, I would like us to provide a French response to this question. What is the city in which we want to live? That is why I launched the reflection on “the Grand Paris,” by which I mean the great metropolis that is the Paris agglomeration, which must be considered in its entirety, because the Paris agglomeration forms a whole. This reflection should not be initiated first from the perspective of institutions, from the perspective of governance—but pardon me if I surprise you—but from the perspective of urban planning, from the perspective of architecture, sociability, conviviality, quality of life, and the place of man in the city. I want to make this project the laboratory of human modernity. I want it to be the opportunity to put France back at the forefront of urban planning and architecture. Urban planning and architecture are profound levers of a policy of civilization. We never talk about it. Look back at the political debates of the last thirty years in France; architecture is never mentioned in politics, nor urban planning. I will personally get involved in this project. Naturally, everything will be done in consultation, in association with the residents of Île-de-France, with their elected officials, with mayors, with general councils, with the regional council, but I will say one thing: I will not let this project get bogged down. I will not let anyone block it. The situation of the Paris agglomeration has become unacceptable; the harshness of life it imposes on too many of its inhabitants, the human costs, the ecological costs, the social costs generated by these dysfunctions are unbearable. Paris must regain its vitality, its radiance, its attractiveness, its creativity. Paris must once again become for the whole world the symbol of a way of life, of the most beautiful city in the world, so that it astonishes, surprises, and fascinates again; well, the policy of civilization will be expressed through a major architectural ambition in this regard.

We will also take action in 2008 against the compartmentalization and bureaucratization of society, through the continuation of state reform and administrative reform. But the policy of civilization will be expressed in an unprecedented renovation of public broadcasting, unprecedented. At least, there was an expectation, good. First, of course, in the reorganization of external broadcasting, which has become - Christine ALBANEL and Bernard KOUCHNER will not deny me - absolutely necessary. But I propose that we accomplish in 2008 a true cultural revolution in public television. Public service exists because it has a particular mission. If public channels operate according to the same criteria, the same requirements, the same logic as private channels, then it is not very clear - in fact, it is really not very clear - why there would be a public service. I apologize, this is very original what I am saying, but I mean it. The public service, its requirement, its criterion, is quality. Its vocation is to offer the greatest number access to culture, it is to promote French creation. I do not mean that public television must be elitist or boring, there is still a gap, but only that it cannot operate according to purely commercial criteria. I therefore wish for the specifications of public television to be profoundly reviewed, and that we consider the total elimination of advertising on public channels, which could be financed by a tax on the increased advertising revenues of private channels, and by a tiny tax on the turnover of new means of communication, such as access to the Internet or mobile telephony. Here is a revolution that, by changing the economic model of public television, will completely change the stakes of cultural policy in our communication society. We must know what we want, do we want to change or do we want to continue, I want to change. And I will change without taboos, and we will have results, and we will assume the consequences of these strategic choices. I am very pleased that the left, which has never dared to do this, which has always talked about it without drawing any consequences, sees what it is like to have a government that decides on a number of priorities.

The policy of civilization will, of course, be expressed in health policy, which is one of the fundamental values on which our idea of man rests. There is a particular issue that has been avoided for too long, and which can no longer be avoided, thanks to François FILLON and Roselyne BACHELOT for taking care of it, it is the hospital. No one wants to touch the hospital. But after all, the hospital, there is so much hope, there is so much dedication, there are a million people who devote themselves to illness, to suffering, to misery, and we watch the problem of the hospital worsen a little more each day without doing anything. Well, just as I used a strong word for the university, I want to say it, despite the dedication, the competence of doctors and paramedical teams, the hospital is in decline. And the 35-hour workweek dealt it the final blow. There you go, well in 2008, we will change the governance of the hospital, from top to bottom, because the hospital is no longer governed, because in the hospital today, everyone has enough power to say no, and no one has the power to say yes. I wish to transform the underutilized hospital structures to accommodate elderly people, who have difficulty finding housing suited to their needs. I want to emphasize the necessity of guaranteeing everyone equal access to quality care, regardless of each person's means, regardless of the territory or the neighborhood, an effort must be made in favor of emergency services, to help young doctors settle in rural cantons and in suburbs, and to stop having the same doctors established in the same neighborhoods.

Of course, in 2008, we will continue the policy of enhancing work, because work is an essential value, it is what allows everyone to find their place in society, it is what weaves social ties, work is not servitude, work is emancipation. Work is a means of conquering one's freedom. I will certainly have the opportunity to answer your questions on the subject. In 2008, we will introduce more equity into the economic system, and in the will - I weigh my words - to ensure that employees are not eternally deprived of the share that belongs to them in the success of companies. There is a problem, when companies are successful, the distribution of the consequences of success between shareholders and employees must be rebalanced. That is the policy we will carry. That shareholders are rewarded for their investment is very good. But it cannot be the alpha and the omega. Employees must have the just reward for their efforts. Well, exemptions from charges will be conditioned on salary negotiations. And I would like to be taken seriously when I say this. This is not a principle petition. With the Prime Minister and the Minister of Finance, we will go all the way, because it is not legitimate, because it is not acceptable that a company, which makes a lot of profits, does not reward its employees. We talked about it in 2007, we will do it in 2008. I will not be a prisoner of any lobby. I want to be the president of all the French. And I know perfectly well that I am expected on this appointment. No one will be disappointed, both supporters and opponents. In 2008, the policy of civilization will be expressed in our ability to better share rents and profits, to share more equitably the results of everyone's efforts. That is why we will go much further in terms of participation and profit-sharing. We will create regulatory and fiscal conditions so that participation and profit-sharing can extend to all companies, all, even those with fewer than fifty employees. And for that, we are ready, with the Prime Minister, to have a differentiated tax on profits for companies with fewer than fifty employees that would engage in participation and profit-sharing. I want employees to be able to freely choose between profit-sharing, which is paid immediately, and participation, which remains blocked for a certain time, in exchange for tax advantages. I want stock option programs and the distribution of free shares to benefit all employees of the company and not just a few. If a few want to benefit from it, no problem, all the others will benefit too. I want the very level of participation and profit-sharing to be significantly raised, we will see, but finally, a doubling, even a tripling of the participation reserve, is not something that would shock me. Here too, Ladies and Gentlemen, we have been talking about participation for years, well, the time has come to do it, and to do it in a significant, heavy, ambitious way, so that finally people believe in it, and that it is not one of those perennial issues in political life against a majority dance from one majority to another, without taking the measure of the problem. By constantly saying that there are risks, by constantly saying that we must wait, no one believes in it anymore. And we have all the disadvantages without any of the advantages. And moreover, we kill the idea. Well, if the idea is good, we implement it. If the idea is not good, we stop it, but we do not continue with a homeopathic dose, because with the homeopathic dose, the French feel cheated. And we want the French to have confidence. So we will give ourselves room for maneuver, we will go much further, and much stronger. I add that I look forward to the criticisms. When we proposed with François FILLON the unlocking of participation funds, I was told: oh, oh, oh, this is dramatic, you are preventing companies from defending themselves. Okay, now that we propose to double or triple the participation reserve, the same people will not tell me that we are doing too much! Well, coherence is for everyone. There you go.

This desire to go much further in profit-sharing goes hand in hand with the desire to promote an entrepreneurial capitalism, and a family capitalism, more rooted in the territories. So in the face of the rise of extremely aggressive hedge funds and sovereign funds, which obey no economic logic, it is out of the question for France to remain without reacting. It is out of the question to let it happen. France assumes the political, strategic choice to protect its companies, to give them the means to defend themselves and to develop, well, the CAISSE DES DEPÔTS, we will make it an instrument of this policy of defense and promotion of the essential economic interests of the Nation, and let us stop opposing this industrial will, which is ours, with liberalism, it is absurd. All countries, including the most liberal, when it comes to defending their interests, do so with determination, and they are right. If the Americans do not defend their interests, who will? No one. And we would look perfectly ridiculous to be less liberal than others, and moreover, to defend our interests less. We can be perfectly liberal, believe in the market economy and say: we will defend our companies. We will not support companies that have no chance, but I remember the debate on ALSTOM, I heard some who made editorials at the time, who have been more discreet since, and ALSTOM is today one of the most beautiful industrial successes in France. And I still have PECHINEY stuck in my throat. Yes, this giant of chemistry that disappeared without anyone lifting a finger. This is not my conception of an industrial policy in a country like ours. We cannot defend all companies, we cannot defend all trades, we cannot defend all industries, but we cannot find ourselves with hedge funds that swoop down on a company, that strip it, that sell it, and we say: excuse us, it’s globalization, we can’t do anything about it. That is not true. Others defend themselves, we will defend ourselves. And the CAISSE DES DEPÔTS will find a real strategy, of course, with its independence, but finally, a real strategy. Financial capitalism needs to be moralized. When I first said this, I remember the skepticism, well now, since the subprime crisis, there is less skepticism, and we have been able to send a joint letter, Madame MERKEL, Mr. BROWN and I, to those who see that we cannot continue like this, France will take initiatives. Free competition, I say it as I think, is no longer compatible with all kinds of dumping. Here too, we will take initiatives. We cannot continue. Reciprocity must become the rule. At the podium of the UN General Assembly, I called on the world for a new economic and ecological deal.

France will take new initiatives this year to moralize capitalism, particularly during the French presidency of the European Union, which will begin on July 1. Moreover, this presidency will be another opportunity for France to promote a policy of civilization. But what do Europeans want? Well, citizens across Europe are calling for protection. Europe was built, imagined to protect, not to worry. And I assert that one can be perfectly European and put Europe at the service of protection. And those who ignore the community preference have, it seems to me, understood nothing of the European ideal. If we created Europe, it was precisely for the community preference; otherwise, there was no need to create Europe, at least not political Europe; we could have just let Anglo-Saxon Europe, that of the great market, take its course. But wanting to create a political Europe while forbidding oneself to utter the word protection makes no sense. And in their wisdom, the peoples of Europe have perfectly understood this. Europe must protect; Europe must not make us more vulnerable. Europe must enable us to act, and Europe must not suffer. Europe needs a policy of civilization; it needs to de-bureaucratize, to humanize itself; it needs more politics and less bureaucracy. This is what we achieved with the simplified treaty. But I am well aware that the simplified treaty alone will not bridge the gap between Europe and citizens. That is obvious. It is a means. But by the end of the French presidency, I would like Europe to have a policy on immigration, a policy on defense, a policy on energy, a policy on the environment. And from that moment on, we will understand what Europe means in the daily lives of people. So the policy of civilization, finally, France must promote it on a European and global scale, not to impose a model of civilization on the world, but to make shine the universal values that are ours. And we want to oppose this policy of civilization to violence, terrorism, and fanaticism. I would like to say to all those who asked me to cancel my trip to Algeria because an Algerian minister had let slip unacceptable remarks - imagine if I had canceled my trip to Algeria a few days before barbarians blew up a bus filled with young Algerian students; we would have looked foolish. And naturally, after canceling the trip, I would have rushed to express my dismay and solidarity with people I would not have wanted to go discuss with! I was very happy with my trip to Algeria, which was extremely important to me. And similarly, to all those who were surprised that I said we would stay in Afghanistan because a battle against barbarians was being fought there - I was there a few days before the assassination of Mrs. BHUTTO; Afghanistan borders Pakistan, where Bernard KOUCHNER went, and I thank him for that. We would have looked foolish to withdraw from Afghanistan a few days before the assassination of Mrs. BHUTTO, where naturally those who were asking me to withdraw from Afghanistan would have shed crocodile tears over the same BHUTTO. We would have looked foolish. A little consistency is probably the most difficult thing for some.

Finally, France will do everything possible for the G8 to become the G13. Here too, finally, listen, I was very surprised in Heiligendamm; I want to say it diplomatically, but really, what is it? We meet for two and a half days without China, without India, without Brazil, without Mexico, without South Africa, simply two and a half billion people that we forget? So, of course, we invite them for lunch on the third day. The most extraordinary thing is that they come. Well, France says: we cannot organize the world of the 21st century with the organization of the 20th; it is not possible. China, India, South Africa, pardon, which I had forgotten, Latin America, continents of a billion inhabitants, that matters; we cannot act as if it does not matter. So, I know there are difficulties; Japan is very pleased that China is present, Italy wonders if its place... it doesn't matter; these are problems I can perfectly understand. But can you imagine that we can settle the great affairs of the world with eight, ignoring half of humanity? That seems strange to me. And similarly for the Security Council, as a permanent member, France will do everything possible for Germany, Japan, Brazil, India, and a large African country to become permanent members of the Security Council. They say: look, it's amusing, it doesn't work, but how do you expect it to work? We have the organization of the 20th century for the 21st century; it cannot function. We cannot consider that we will resolve the great questions of the planet without asking the opinion of a single African country, a billion inhabitants, or a single South American country, a billion inhabitants. What is astonishing is that it works so well with such an unbalanced organization. So France will be the advocate for these countries to demand an organization that corresponds to today's world, not yesterday's world. And I do not see what is shocking about defending one's ideas. So, I am told: it's complicated, we must wait; well, if we have to wait every time it is complicated, we will wait a long time. And I, at the end of my term, would say: well, it's complicated. Well, there is no point in doing politics if it is to wait. We must tackle the biggest problems and get to work on them. And I will do everything possible for the missions of the IMF and the World Bank to be rethought because the world needs the IMF and the World Bank, but not with the same reasoning, because the goal is not to let certain countries die that have been healed; that is not the goal. There you go.

On immigration policy, I have asked Brice HORTEFEUX to advance on two extremely important points in my eyes. First, to go all the way with a policy based on quotas. We have been talking about it for too long; everyone knows it is the only solution; well, we must take the step and stop wanting to protect some, not to shock others, because with that, we only have disasters. We must implement the quota policy based on reception and integration, but we must welcome people we can accommodate because we want to integrate them; if we welcome people we cannot integrate, well, we cannot welcome them. Well, we must go all the way with this logic. And that will prevent human tragedies. And then, I asked him a second thing in agreement with the Prime Minister, which is to eliminate this French oddity that, regarding the rights of foreigners, there are two orders of jurisdiction, one public, one judicial, and, excuse me, with contradictory jurisprudences. Well, choose the one you want, but choose one! Let there be a jurisprudence on the rights of foreigners, respectful of human rights, but which still allows for an immigration policy based on quotas, negotiated with the countries of origin, based on a great ambition for co-development, and a jurisdiction that deals with the rights of foreigners. I do not know if it should be administrative or judicial. What I know is that we must stop having two. In all countries, in great democracies, there is one, and that is how we solve problems. And I also wish that each year, Mr. Prime Minister, before Parliament, we can debate the immigration policy for the following year. How many people we have welcomed, how many people we want to welcome, why this secrecy, why this heavy shroud, why on one side the hysterics of zero immigration, and why on the other the posers in absolute generosity? What does that give? It gives an unemployment rate for foreigners in France that is between 20 and 30%, a nice result, gentlemen the generous! A nice result! By not debating, we only have the disadvantages. Well, that is over. In 2008, we will debate it. And governments will be obliged to explain to the country what their immigration policy is, to assume their choices, to claim them, and to be accountable for this policy. Of course, there will be the Union for the Mediterranean which - you know - for me, is the project of civilization par excellence.

We are working for the mutual recognition of the rights of the Palestinian people and the Israeli people, for the independence of Lebanon, a long road, and for diversity. I will fight for this idea in 2008. Diversity, why diversity more than democracy? Because when we fight for democracy, some countries say: ah, post-colonial, you want to impose your system on us. When we fight for diversity, that argument falls away because throughout history, in this region of the world, they have lived together; there have been Muslims, there have been Jews, there have been Christians. And diversity is not valid for us and not valid for others. And why must we defend the independence of Lebanon? Because Lebanon is a symbol of diversity. And why must we defend Israel, besides the fact that it is a major political fact of the 20th century? Because it is a symbol of diversity. And I say that it is perfectly normal and natural that we recognize French Muslims the same rights as others, I mean in terms of religion. And I have always supported projects to open mosques. But let things be perfectly clear: diversity should not occur here while churches are closed elsewhere. Diversity is good for everyone. Diversity is a universal principle that must be respected everywhere, diversity, reciprocity. There you go, it seems to me, a good way to consider today's problems.

Finally, what French diplomacy wants to do is a diplomacy of reconciliation; France must talk to everyone. Frankly, the somewhat ridiculous uproar over Mr. KADHAFI's visit, when I see how he was received in Spain by the King of Spain and by the socialist Prime Minister, I think the socialist international must be in bad shape. And when I see the behavior of a number of states and leaders, I think: if we do not receive people who have renounced terrorism, who have compensated the victims, who have released hostages, if we do not accompany them towards respectability, what will we do with others, and what will we tell them? Of course, we must share civil nuclear technology because if, to the south of the Mediterranean, in relation to us, you have misery and underdevelopment, once there is no more oil and no more gas, do you think at that point we will have democratic governments? And of course, we must support Mr. BOUTEFLIKA's government because no one wants a Taliban government in Algeria, and of course, we must help Mr. MOUBARAK in Egypt, a country of 76 million inhabitants, because what do we want there? The Muslim Brotherhood. And of course, we must accompany Libya on the path to respectability, and I do not regret having tried with Syria, even if we did not achieve results, because France wants to extend a hand. France wants to be honest; France wants to be good faith. And when the Syrians did not respond to France's calls, I drew all the consequences by condemning Syria's attitude. France must talk to CHAVEZ; France must talk to a number of people in the world because France carries a diplomacy of reconciliation. And I was very proud and very happy with two events organized by Bernard KOUCHNER - the conference on Darfur, which took place in Paris, which was an unprecedented event, and the conference on funders for the Palestinians, which raised seven billion three hundred million dollars - which clearly shows that France is back.

There you go, ladies and gentlemen, it is time for me to answer your questions. I am sure they will be fascinating in substance by definition, and I realize that I have not presented you with any wishes. It is not because I do not think them, but I see you so happy and so fulfilled in your comments that I thought it was unnecessary to present you with wishes. Finally, still, at the end of my little speech, I wanted to tell you, after all, they are sincere. So I do not know if you want us to organize the questions... no, we are not organizing anything at all, and I will try to adapt.

QUESTION - Mireille LEMARESQUIER, France Info. Mr. President, I am the president of the Association of Presidential Press, and previously, this meeting served, well, allowed the president or the president of the presidential press to present their wishes to the head of state, so I present you with all my wishes. Health, love, and success, success for you and for the French people. There you go.

THE PRESIDENT - I imagine you have thought about the order of presentation...

QUESTION - Ah no, because it is a rather traditional order in our country, health first...

THE PRESIDENT - It touches me, it touches me.

QUESTION - So Mr. President, the press is not in very good health, it has economic problems, it also has problems in exercising its profession. 17 French journalists were arrested around the world last year. I just want to say and remind our colleagues that two French journalists are currently in prison in Niger and have been since December 17. They issued a call yesterday to the Nigerien head of state for clemency, but there are also other problems that journalists face in France. The protection of sources of information. So there have been - and I am not talking about your mandate - but there have been in recent months, in recent years, searches, police custody, indictments, and during the electoral campaign, on April 12, in response to a questionnaire you sent to Reporters Without Borders, you stated, "I am ready to enshrine the right of all journalists to protect their sources in the law of July 29, 1881, on press freedom, and to extend to their homes the guarantees provided in the premises of a press enterprise." So my question, Mr. President, in my capacity as president of a professional journalists' association, will you make a strong decision in the coming weeks for the respect of source protection, one of the pillars of press freedom, and you know that press freedom is one of the pillars of democracy?

THE PRESIDENT - Madam President, first, regarding the protection of sources, whether in professional premises or in private homes, my answer is yes. A journalist worthy of the name does not give up their sources. Everyone must understand this, must accept it. I sometimes find myself ambivalent about the respect for a certain professional ethics by some of your colleagues. I have never hidden it and I take responsibility for it. But just as at the time of the caricatures of the Prophet, I thought it was not very skillful, I prefer the excesses of caricatures to the absence of caricatures. I prefer the excesses of the press to the absence of the press. So the answer is very precise: in 2008 we will make this text. Second element: a number of your colleagues have been imprisoned or are still imprisoned. I still call on some of you to be reasonable and cautious. Just because you are a journalist does not mean you should break the law. I do not want to complicate certain situations today, but you know perfectly well what I am alluding to, and I myself went to fetch some of your colleagues, notably in N'Djamena. It did not earn me eternal recognition, but I went to get them and we brought them home. But at times I would like some to be cautious, because we are obliged to take risks to go fetch some of your colleagues who took risks that had nothing to do with the ideal of their profession, which were simply due to certain carelessness. Finally, I want to tell you one thing, I do not share the analysis of many of you on the problems of the press. Many of you think that the problems of the press are due to excessive concentration, which is perfectly inaccurate. The problems of the press are due to two things: undercapitalization that does not allow media outlets to invest, and a second thing, which is the most important, is a distribution that does not work. I am sorry, I will certainly upset some, but the first problem of the press in France is distribution. I am thinking of the written press. The newspaper today is no longer accessible, there are fewer and fewer kiosks, delivery costs a fortune. When I was a student, it was enough to take the metro, stretch out your arm to get your newspaper; today millions of residents in our cities have to take a detour to buy the newspaper. No. What needs to be done is a modernization plan for the distribution of the press, and Mr. FILLON's government is ready to go very far on the subject. That seems much more intelligent to me than the grand, somewhat ridiculous declarations we have recently witnessed about the ownership of such or such of your colleagues. Finally, I want to say, regarding newspapers, that people with means investing in a newspaper is very good news, and we cannot say the press is an industry and refuse to have shareholders to finance this industry. And we cannot ask newspaper owners to have as their only ambition to lose money; that is absurd, we need to think a little bit. And I do not see how that harms independence. What harms independence is that one can no longer buy their newspaper because there are no longer places where it is sold. That harms independence. That one cannot have delivery because a large number of your colleagues do not have the means to do delivery, that harms. And really the government, isn't that right Christine, is completely ready to engage in consultation with you to see how we can give you the means to have a distributed press.

QUESTION - Mr. President, hello, I extend my best wishes to you. So there is politics, political life, you have spoken to us about it. There is private life and, indeed, when one is head of state, well the two converge. So it is true that all the French are asking themselves this question, even the whole world, we see India asking protocol questions, I am sure that even your ministers are asking themselves this question, so I will ask you this fundamental question: are you going to marry Carla BRUNI and when?

THE PRESIDENT - What is extraordinary is that you were kind enough to wait for the second question. Roselyne FEBVRE, "the whole world is hanging on this extraordinary question." No, it is your sentimental side and after all, I am one too. Listen, how should I respond? You know, being President of the Republic does not give the right to happiness; one does not have more right to happiness than anyone else, but not less than anyone else. I have thought a lot about this question, I did not want to lie and I have registered in a break with a deplorable tradition of our political life. That of hypocrisy, that of lies. And Roselyne FEBVRE, must you and your colleagues trust me to ask me questions that you would never have asked a single one of my predecessors while you knew. When I say Roselyne FEBVRE, not you, too young of course, your political life started eight months ago with me, well, in all fairness, but still, and it is very satisfying for me, France is evolving. Here is what was covered by a leaden cloak for one of my predecessors whom I do not allow myself to judge, everyone has their life - life is so difficult and so painful, here is that his journey, it is true that it was not Luxor, it was Aswan, at least 200 kilometers away, with a presidential plane and different families, everyone knew, no one spoke. And with Carla we decided not to lie. We do not want to instrumentalize anything, but we did not want to hide. I did not want a photo of me to be taken in the early morning, gloomy, I did not want a photo of me to be taken in the evening and I did not want you to describe the same hypocrisy under the cloak. You know in 2007, I divorced, it was not the happiest time of my life, I saw a lot of articles, I thought that some who wrote these articles must have never divorced to write such things, like that I divorced to mask the strikes on special regimes. I did not hold it against them, I simply felt ashamed for them to be so far from the realities of life, because the life of a president, on these essential questions that are those of love, is like the life of anyone else. I will make a confession: I get up in the morning and I go to bed in the evening, like a number of millions of French people, there you go. And so with Carla we decided to take responsibility and take responsibility for what? In December, we had the original idea of going with her son to Disney, there are photos, well very well, if these photos are too painful, do not send photographers anymore, we will come to terms with it and when we went to Egypt on vacation, we decided, extraordinary, to visit the pyramids, very original. And if you are afraid of being instrumentalized, do not send photographers, our vacations will still be excellent. And then you understood, it is serious, but it is not the JDD that will set the date.

QUESTION - (Inaudible)

NICOLAS SARKOZY - I answered: it is serious and it is not the JDD that will set the date. There is a strong chance that you will learn about it when it is already done. That is an answer.

QUESTION - It is already done?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - It is not a threat. I specify that I am responding on our behalf because I thought that perhaps you would ask me the question.

QUESTION - Mr. President, during your wishes on December 31, you mentioned mistakes, a rare term in this circumstance. Can you elaborate and explicitly mention the few mistakes you think you may have made since your election?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Honestly, that is not the purpose of the press conference. What do you want me to say? You tell me: it is rare that I mention mistakes. Oh really? Frankly, I have been in politics for 30 years, I believe I am the one who has most often acknowledged that I lost. I acknowledged that I made mistakes when I lost in 1999, in 1995. Since eight months, have there been things we missed, that we failed? Yes, I would have liked us to go faster on a number of subjects. I take one example: I was talking about immigration earlier, it was I who told Brice not to go all the way with the quota policy. Well, I think that was a mistake. Because a policy must be implemented in its entirety. I also think that on a number of economic choices, it is always a mistake to play small. When you choose a strategy, you have to really choose it and sometimes I let myself be impressed by the Prime Minister, by the weight of the administration and habits: "there are no means," "we should not do." I am thinking in particular of the question of the deductibility of loan interest. There you go, I think we should have gone further, because it is not an economic calculation, a accounting calculation, it is a will that is ours. There is no reason for you to pay taxes on the interest you pay to your bank after all. It is not an accounting matter. I could take others, but well, that is already not bad, two examples spontaneously, like that.

QUESTION - Mr. President...

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Third example - excuse me Anita HAUSSER - the question of social VAT. I think we made two mistakes. The first is to use this word which is absurd. It has nothing social about it, so we would have done much better to talk from the beginning about the transfer of charges from production to consumption. Social VAT is a mistake, it is an expression that means nothing, which is false besides. And secondly, I think it was also a mistake to talk about it without doing it. Either you do it, or you do not do it and in that case you go all the way.

QUESTION - Can I ask my question?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Ask whatever you want. There are only women asking questions...

QUESTION - You spoke about the situation in which our country finds itself, François FILLON spoke of a situation of bankruptcy, would you...

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Of a situation ...?

QUESTION - Of bankruptcy. Would you say the same thing? On the other hand, you have set very ambitious goals. Will a single term be enough for you to achieve them? And if it were not possible, what choice would you make if you had to make one?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - For the next term?

QUESTION - No, currently, because ultimately you want to make a small revolution, so you will have to make choices anyway. What are your real priorities?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - In economic matters?

ANITA HAUSSER - You have addressed all the subjects.

NICOLAS SARKOZY - That is the goal after all...

ANITA HAUSSER - Yes, that is not a reproach.

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Thank you. If you want, I deeply believe that this is a question of method on which we have worked a lot with François FILLON. Everything is interconnected in modern society, everything is connected. You cannot hope to achieve results if you do not change everything at the same time: if you do not modify vocational training, if you do not change education, if you do not change research, if you do not change the university, if you do not change the sanctions for unemployed people who refuse a valid job offer. Everything must change at the same time, and that is why we have some leeway. It is because we are developing a dozen major reform projects at the same time that we can push them through. If we had done the reform of university autonomy - which is considerable - alone, we would have focused all the conservatisms from both the left and the right against it. We would not have passed it. If we had done the reform of the ANPE-UNEDIC merger alone, we would have mobilized all the conservatisms against it and we would not have succeeded. And if we had said: in 2007, we will only address special regimes and nothing else, we would arrive in 2008 exhausted. The priority is to reconcile identity and modernity, it is to opt for change in our country. That is the priority. In all aspects, there is a need for change. There is so much immobility, so much conservatism, so much heaviness that you cannot hope... What do you want? One reform in the first year, one reform in the second year? No! We want to set the country in motion. We want to make France a young, dynamic country and achieve results. That is what matters. Well, "bankruptcy," François had the opportunity to come back to this term by saying that it was not his initial idea. Moreover, a country that has 15% savings compared to its GDP is not bankrupt. What is true - and he was right - is that a country that has presented a budget deficit for 26 years poses a problem. So the difference in appreciation was only about that. You ask: is there another five-year term? But if you knew how I am not in that mindset. Yes, it was not quite your question, but it is entirely my answer and I wanted to tell you. Why do I tell you this? Because the French need to know. I have a passion for action, I want to act. And I have observed my predecessors, with their immense qualities: when you want to last, you put your energy into the service of duration and no longer in the service of action. I want to act, I want to achieve results, I want to change the country, I want our team to achieve these changes. And for that, I must absolutely forbid myself from thinking about any perspective whatsoever. I have dedicated 30 years of my life to being elected President of the Republic, well, I want to make something of it. I want my five-year term to be useful. I want people to say: "with the whole team, they changed the country, they achieved results." France will no longer be the same and for once, it has changed. It was not always the same policy with people who said and did not do. I want to change things. And for that, we make a choice. And the choice is to play fully, as usefully as possible, these five years and to forbid myself from even imagining the prospect of a second term which has so justified the inaction of the first. And by the way, if we look at things with historical hindsight, we see that very little has been done during the second term, regardless of the quality of the individuals.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you spoke about foreign policy and the necessity for France to talk to everyone. Nevertheless, can we not consider that it was a mistake to rush to congratulate Vladimir PUTIN for an electoral victory, when all of Europe was questioning the regularity of the vote? And furthermore, regarding the visit of Colonel QADDAFI, did talking with Colonel QADDAFI require such pomp, to be received twice at the Élysée, to have a presidential hunt? Wasn't that a mistake, doesn't that weaken France's voice and image internationally?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - From the moment you choose to receive a foreign head of state, you might as well receive him well. Honestly. If on top of that, it is to be ashamed of it and to receive him through the back door, it is better not to do it. Either you assume the choice to receive him... When I went to Tripoli in July, I told him: you let the nurses go, you settled the dispute with the victims of the UTA DC10, France will receive you. So if I understand correctly: a small mediocre visit where we would have given him: entrance, main course and no dessert, where he would have entered through the Coq gate, that would have been acceptable? There was no pomp, none. He stayed five days because he wanted to stay five days before going to Spain. There was no particular pomp, there wasn't even a grand state dinner, that is to say those dinners with 300 or 400 people. So the pomp, you can remove the word, it did not exist. But I assume: France received him, France receives its guests well or else it is no longer France. And who would have understood that we receive someone to humiliate him? In that case, it would have been better to say: we do not receive you. No problem.

Now regarding Mr. PUTIN, the matter is much more interesting. I believe it is perfectly ridiculous to blame Mr. PUTIN for an election of which all international observers will tell you that he is the most popular politician in Russia and that regardless of the undeniable problems that occurred during this election, he would have been elected anyway. There is not a single person who knows Russia who would say otherwise. So you suggest that I do not congratulate someone for an election that everyone knows was unavoidable. I even told him: but why did you do that, when everyone knows you were elected? What should be reproached to Mr. PUTIN is not being elected. He has restored pride to Russia, he is the most popular politician in Russia. What should be reproached to him is what he does with it, regarding human rights within Russia or regarding Chechnya. I add: what a strange conception of international politics it is to blame someone for their election and the next day, to ask that same person whom you reproach for their election to help you resolve the crisis in Iran, to help you resolve the crisis in Darfur, to help you ease tensions in the world. Extraordinary. Here we have someone we consider normal to offend PUTIN by considering his election illegitimate and the same people ask the same PUTIN, illegitimate, to resolve the world's crises. What is the logic? I prefer to congratulate PUTIN by saying: but why did you do that, but congratulations anyway on being elected, rather than keeping silent when I go to Moscow, where I see NGOs, where I talk about human rights and where I ask a number of questions. What should be reproached to PUTIN is not his election, it is what he does with it, if indeed there is something to reproach him on the substance. That is France's position. But what an incredible logic from all these self-proclaimed teachers who say: we need Russia to resolve the world's crises - notably what Mr. PUTIN has done on Iran, which is positive - and at the same time say: we must offend him. Here is someone we need, whom we ask for things, who is respectable enough to help us convince Iran to stop dancing on the edge of the abyss. And this person, whom we ask to do this, we refuse to congratulate him for an election of which we know, moreover, that this election, whatever criticisms we may make of it, was perfectly certain and perfectly legitimate.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you mentioned a few minutes ago the reform of public television and you spoke of the necessity for a reorganization of French external audiovisual. You have had for a few days on your desk a number of quite concrete data on the contours that this reform could take. Will it also be a revolution or not, and who? when? and how? please?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Listen, we have worked a lot on the subject with Bernard KOUCHNER and Christine ALBANEL, I want it to be as quick as possible, in any case this year. The idea would be to create a "France Monde" label, that is to say a holding company that would group the resources of TV5, France 24, and RFI, according to modalities to be debated, which would allow all these networks composed of great professionals to carry a much more massive presence of France than it is today. We can pool resources, we can rely on complementary networks of correspondents - quite remarkable, I think of RFI - we can give a new editorial identity to TV5 and we can take advantage of the success of France 24. The problem is that one is well broadcast and has an editorial problem, the other has no editorial problem but is not well broadcast enough, and the third needs to rely on the other two because it is only radio and needs television. So there are other questions that we are debating and which are the subject of discussions among us. We do not necessarily agree on everything. I think that a public channel, France Monde, which would keep the identity of each of the participants, of course, but a public brand can only speak French and that with taxpayer money, I am not willing to finance a channel that does not speak French. But on the other hand, we can perfectly have subtitling by region: Spanish, Arabic, English to carry a French vision. Between Al Jazeera, an Arab vision, and CNN, an Anglo-Saxon vision, we would like to carry a French vision. But to carry a French vision, I really prefer that we carry it with the French language, because carrying a French vision with the Arabic language or with the English language may be interesting, but we will have a hard time being understood.

QUESTION - Mr. President, we know that you want to speak before Parliament, so if this constitutional reform takes place, when will this speech take place? Will it happen in 2008? What sense does it have? What could be the theme of this first speech? Is it not reinforcing what some already qualify as "hyper-presidency"? I dare not, to finish, ask you if this speech, if it were to take place in 2008, would take place before or after your wedding, we will find that too heavy.

NICOLAS SARKOZY - There will not necessarily be a connection, honestly. First of all, "hyper-presidency," but Mr. GUERRIER, explain to the French what the situation is today? If it were me who had this idea... What is the situation today? When the President of the Republic wants to address Parliament, he can do so today and, hold on, he delivers a message read by a third party before Parliament standing and silent. You have to find it anyway. If it were me who had this idea, I might have sparked some mockery. Here is the situation today. Is this the situation we want to keep? Prohibition of debating the president's text. Listening religiously standing. Ridicule does not kill anymore, fortunately. I add, Mr. GUERRIER, what is still extraordinary: here is that the French Parliament can invite any head of state to speak before it, except the French head of state, and here is that the French head of state can speak before any Parliament in the world, except the French Parliament. Is this democracy? Is this the logic? Is this competition? But for the head of state to go speak before Parliament, it puts an end to hypocrisy. If the head of state believes there is something to say to Parliament, he goes to Parliament, he speaks, and Parliament can debate it. By the way, Mr. GUERRIER, just look at the United States: is there a democracy in the world where Parliament has more importance than in the United States? The American Congress, there is no one who thinks they do not have power. Well, precisely, in this democracy which is an example of the powers of Parliament, the President of the United States comes to speak every year. Go explain to the members of Congress that because the President comes to report on the state of the Union, they have less power. You know, a little reflection does not hurt, even on institutions.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you mentioned the words: diversity, integration, equal opportunities, but no longer the terms that you liked very much, in 2003 in particular, and then afterwards too: positive discrimination. You said at one point, "if the idea is not good, we stop it." I am a girl from overseas, from La Réunion. For us, those words, we did not really like them. Positive discrimination. Do you no longer like those words either?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Madam HINTERMAN, I have championed the idea of positive discrimination, I have developed it, I have fought for it, but what interests me is not the vocabulary, it is the reality. What is the reality? It is that when you have a color that is not the majority, when you come from a neighborhood, when you have a name that has a connotation that is not the majority, you have more difficulties than others to get by. Equality, for me, is not giving everyone the same thing, it is giving everyone according to their difficulties, their history, and their handicap. So I willingly withdraw the word if we get back to the substance. And so in this text - this third text to which I attach, as you have understood, great importance - I would like the commission to work on this idea: how do we achieve diversity in our country? How do we experience it? Look at the magistrates, do you see diversity? Look at the police commissioners, the gendarmerie generals, look at the prefects, do you see diversity? Diversity is not expressed enough in our society. And I am very proud of François FILLON's government, because we will never again have a government like we did before François FILLON's government, because the government represents diversity. Whether we call it positive discrimination or not, I am so indifferent to that, vocabulary has no meaning. What I want is for every French woman, every French man, wherever they come from, to feel that they have a chance to succeed. What I want is for social promotion to become a reality again. What I want is for the French elites to represent French diversity. They do not represent it today: same suit, same school, same training, same appearance. A country is upside down when its head does not resemble its body. I want this diversity, and to want it, there will be this text in the preamble of the Constitution. I do not cling to words as long as we give a chance to realities. Mr. JOFFRIN?

QUESTION - Mr. President, Laurent JOFFRIN from Libération.

NICOLAS SARKOZY - No, it is first Mr. JOFFRIN.

QUESTION - Please. Thank you, Mr. President, good morning.

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Good morning.

QUESTION - My question is as follows: you frequently, if not continuously, occupy the media scene, you are the originator of most, if not all, government initiatives, regarding the Prime Minister you used, I believe, the word "collaborator" once, and your ministers, we learned recently, will have their actions evaluated according to criteria defined by private organizations, and some of them - I believe this is not a secret - are on probation. Is it not true that you have already changed the Constitution? You are the head of state or the head of government in the democratic world who holds the most power. Is it not true that you have established a form of personal power, to say the least an elective monarchy?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Here is a moderate question, which shows that Mr. JOFFRIN from Libération is in great shape. Well, he has the right to his opinion on elective monarchy. But after all, monarchy means hereditary. Do you think I am the illegitimate son of Jacques CHIRAC who put me on a throne? Mr. JOFFRIN, a cultured man like you, to say such a big nonsense! Me, from the monarchy?

QUESTION - Elective.

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Okay, so if monarchy is election, then it is no longer monarchy, Mr. JOFFRIN ... Oh no, excuse me Mr. JOFFRIN, words have meaning, they must have meaning for you if they have meaning for me. Either it is a monarchy, so it is heredity, in which case I would like someone to explain to me who I am the heir of? Who put me - I come to it, but when it hurts, you should not protest right away, because it shows - either it is election and in that case it is not monarchy. I did not steal my responsibility from anyone, Mr. JOFFRIN, I was elected democratically.

Then the power. There is a constitution, Mr. JOFFRIN, because do you imagine that General de GAULLE did not tell Michel DEBRE or his prime ministers what he wanted? Do you think Valéry GISCARD d'ESTAING did not tell his prime ministers what he wanted? This even led to Jacques CHIRAC's departure. And do you think, to take a recent example, that Mr. RAFFARIN dictated his line of conduct to Jacques CHIRAC? Did I invent the Fifth Republic? But Mr. JOFFRIN, it is an obsession, personal power, you were already talking about it regarding General de GAULLE. It is recycling, Mr. JOFFRIN. We are in the society of sustainable development, get with the times. Is that all you could find? What personal power? I take responsibility, I say: it is me who was elected, it is me who bears the failures and successes, it is me who takes the maximum of hits. Personal power, but have you counted the number of front pages that you, Libération, have dedicated to me? It is you who create my personal power. And what is democracy if not that we elect someone to make a policy and that this person we elected assumes their choices. It is the very definition of responsibility. Irresponsibility - the one that consists of saying: "I asked the Prime Minister, who did not do it, to reduce unemployment, I change Prime Ministers" - that is not democracy. I said: I work as a team with François FILLON. By the way, I challenge anyone to find the word "collaborator" in any of my writings or any of my statements. I would be very interested to find it. You must have that in your archives Mr. JOFFRIN? We make a team and I take the share of responsibility that is mine. But what do you think? That people elected me to hide?

Then the word probation regarding the ministers. I will not return the compliment. I am always very sensitive to people in fragile situations. The ministers are not on probation, they must work. In no case, Mr. JOFFRIN, I appreciate you too much for that, but you must know what it is to work under difficult economic conditions, you must know what it is to find an audience, a readership, to have the trust of those who elect you or those who read you. The ministers work, assume their responsibilities. By constantly announcing a reshuffle, one day you will be right. That is for sure there will be one day, but not now. We are a team that functions perfectly well, and I challenge anyone to find a President of the Republic and a Prime Minister who accept so many debates within the government, without any tension and without any problem. It is a bit strong to say "personal power", "authoritarian". When Fadela, when Rama, when Bernard, when others, at a given moment, expressed differences, what did I say? Nothing. That is how you lead a team, through tolerance and openness. So I know it bothers you, because you did not believe in openness, you thought I would do like the left, that is to say a touch of openness. I asked left-wing ministers to remain left-wing men and women, and to agree on a government contract to move forward together. I respect their differences, they respect mine. It is far from any conception of personal power. Where do you see personal power? Of course it changes: I take my responsibilities, I assume them, and when there is a mistake, I pay, and I pay "cash", but that is democracy. And in all democracies in the world, it exists like that. Moreover, we are going to reform the Constitution where the President's power of appointment will be framed, where the powers of Parliament will be strengthened and where we will create a defender of fundamental rights of the person enshrined in the Constitution, so that everyone can assert their rights. You are quite happy to live in a country like that, Mr. JOFFRIN. Only, of course, it is not the left that does it, it is us. That is the whole difference.

QUESTION - I have two brief questions. You mentioned, and you honestly acknowledged that you borrowed your idea of a civilization policy from Edgar MORIN. Edgar MORIN recognized you, just last night on FRANCE INTER and France CULTURE, as a genius, saying that you were a "brilliant strategist" because you had co-opted the National Front, eliminated the left, reduced the center, etc. But he also said: it is curious, there is not in the civilization policy and the desire for rebirth and rupture of Nicolas SARKOZY, the enthusiasm that Léon BLUM and the Popular Front inspired in 1936, de GAULLE in 1945, and MITTERRAND in 1981. In your opinion, why is there not this enthusiasm? Is it your fault or is it ours?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - No, let’s be simple, it is yours, no. I received Edgar MORIN at length yesterday, who is a truly remarkable man, and if Edgar MORIN said "brilliant strategist", listen, that makes for a good start to 2008 anyway. He himself was more moderate when he saw me. He told me: there is 75% of what you say that is good, which leaves me a margin of progression of 25%. Coming from a man like Edgar MORIN, that is important. But enthusiasm, well, what are we talking about? About BLUM who almost got lynched? In his time do you think BLUM inspired enthusiasm when he was pulled out of his car? By the way, for me, the BLUM I admire is not the BLUM of 1936, it is the BLUM of the Tours Congress. There you go, everyone can have their vision of history. That is to say the BLUM who, genuinely brilliant, when there is no television, when there are no means of communication, imagines that communism will become an absolute dictatorship. He is brilliant, authentically, at that moment BLUM. Finally, sorry, I think that BLUM is one of the great men of our history - we even let ourselves go, at Henri's, to talk about it - but he is brilliant in 1920 because he sees, he reads what is going to happen, while so many intellectuals in the 60s - let’s not be cruel Mr. LEVAI - will make a little visit to the Soviet Union and see nothing of what BLUM had precisely described forty years before. But to describe the Popular Front as a long quiet march, with enthusiastic people, is a re-reading of history. And you know how much I liked a very great French intellectual named Jean-Michel GAILLARD, who wrote a magnificent telefilm called "Thérèse et Léon". Re-read it and you will see that, on the road to Léon BLUM, this road was marked by trials, doubts, criticisms of absolute virulence, which were not simply criticisms because he was Jewish, but simply because we always have more enthusiasm when we look back at the record of a man or a woman. As for me, I do not trigger enthusiasm ... Well, listen, not triggering enthusiasm and getting 31.5% in the first round, what would it have been if I had triggered enthusiasm? Getting 53% in the second round, what would it have been if people liked me? Honestly, that is debatable. Now, that people do not have enthusiasm, you have to understand them Mr. LEVAI. They have been asked for efforts for 30 years and they see no results. But I would still like to tell you one last thing: there was one French person out of two who did not vote in the last election, there are 85% of French people who vote, do you think that is not enthusiasm? In any case, it is an enthusiasm that I am satisfied with.

QUESTION - Mr. President, do you wish that 2008, in your mind, be the year of the end, at least real, of the 35-hour workweek?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - To put it as I think, yes.

QUESTION - Mr. President, your popularity rating has seen a severe drop, like that of your predecessors, after 7 months of rule - I introduce myself, Christine CLERC, independent journalist...

NICOLAS SARKOZY - That is kind for the others.

QUESTION - Do you feel that you are responding to the concerns of the French who are watching us by developing a civilization policy project rather than giving them concrete things on purchasing power? I believe that is what they expect from you, mainly at the beginning of this year.

NICOLAS SARKOZY - I observe that polls, when they are very positive, are described as being perfectly relative, and when there is one that is less positive - and still - it becomes the truth and the prophets. Very well, in any case, no one can prevent commentary, and I would like to say to Christine CLERC: still, I have a certain experience in political life and I cannot imagine spending 5 years at 70% popularity. That is not the goal. The goal is to get things done. Obviously, I disagree with what you say, Christine CLERC, sorry to say it: purchasing power is an expectation, but it is not the only one. When you say: the concrete concerns of the French, what we expect from school for our children, that is a concrete concern of the French. Being able to walk in the street peacefully, dear Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE, is a concrete concern of the French. Not being afraid in the subway is a concrete concern of the French. Having an immigration policy worthy of the name, do you think that is not a concrete concern of the French? Having a city where it is good to live, discussing urban planning and architecture, is that not concrete? Talking about hospitals, is that not concrete? But how do you see the concrete? As for purchasing power, what do you expect from me, to empty coffers that are already empty, or to give orders to companies to whom I have no business giving orders? If that is your conception of politics, we are mistaken, we are not talking about the same thing. Reducing the French political debate to the sole question of purchasing power is absurd, it is all the more absurd because I was the first to talk about it, and when we voted, with François FILLON and Christine LAGARDE, on the bill last summer, when we allocated 14 billion euros for the purchasing power of the French, many observers said that I was making a mistake because it was a demand-side economic strategy when we should have been pursuing a supply-side economic strategy. And here are those who in July criticized the demand-side economic strategy aimed at giving purchasing power to the French are the same ones who tell me: why don’t you talk about purchasing power? Inconsistent. Of the 14 billion, two-thirds are for overtime, but the overtime has been done by workers, by employees of very small businesses, small businesses, it works. But that money, is it not purchasing power? Simply, the purchasing power we give to the French is based on additional work, not less work. And when with Luc CHATEL we modify the Galland law, we raise the question of triple net and we move towards negotiability to lower prices, is that not purchasing power? What is it? Finally, listen, do not let yourself be overwhelmed by words that have no meaning behind them. So, the only object of a President of the Republic would be to say: here is how much the minimum wage will increase, and to empty coffers that have been emptied elsewhere. Is that politics for you? Well, that is precisely the opposite. And by the way, if that were enough, Christine CLERC... Since everyone has done it and it has solved nothing, why would you want me to continue? As for increases in the minimum wage, if it were enough to raise it so that there are no more unemployed and more purchasing power... One wonders why we talk about it since everyone has done it and it has not worked. But you could also tell me: since you have been President of the Republic and since François FILLON's government has been in place, unemployment has continued to decline, that is purchasing power given to the French. We are at a historically low level. So obviously, it does not depend on me because it is decreasing, but if it had increased, someone would have stood up saying: but do you realize, you have been president for 8 months and there are so many thousands more unemployed. Who stands up to say: you have been president for 8 months and there are 100,000 fewer unemployed? If I am the one who could have lost the war, I can also be the one who has won it a little.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you told us earlier that urgency is everywhere, some of your ministers and our advisors tell us that the machine is not responding very well, do you share their analysis? I am talking about the machine of the State, the administration.

NICOLAS SARKOZY - No, I think there is a lot of goodwill, but there are a lot of burdens and a certain skepticism from some administrations who say: this will pass and they will change before we ourselves change. This is the heart of the state reform that we are implementing. I did not answer earlier, I apologize, about the issue of evaluation. Evaluation does not only concern ministers, it will also concern administrations. We are implementing a policy, this policy must be applied. If it is not applied, we draw all the consequences. It is not a question of lack of loyalty, it is more a question of lack of enthusiasm. There is a feeling that, in certain places in the State, they have seen so much, heard so much, been disappointed so many times that they no longer believe in it. Well, it is up to us to provide that extra enthusiasm that is sometimes lacking. But I trust civil servants and their loyalty, and I have no specific example of disloyalty that can be attributed to any particular administration.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you did not mention during your 2008 wishes, in your calendar, the municipal and cantonal deadlines. It is nevertheless the first barometer of your presidency, the first judgment of the French. Do you plan to invest yourself in this campaign and is the fact of not talking about it intentional?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Listen, I did not talk about it because I did not think it was the subject of concern for the French. Will I invest myself in the campaign? Will François FILLON invest himself in the campaign? Yes, because it would be curious for you to tell me: it is a political issue and, to use your phrasing, "you will be judged," and that we must draw the conclusion that I should not get involved, so I should remain like the happy man in the manger, waiting to see the mobilization of all our opponents, and tell our voters: stay at home. I will engage because the very concept of depoliticized elections is absurd, because they are the same voters, and therefore I will engage in the role that belongs to the President of the Republic. I can say that the Prime Minister will engage in the role that belongs to the Prime Minister, as will the ministers, to mobilize our electorate and to say that the forces of change, of movement, that the forces of modernity, come together and express themselves. So, in any case, that does not change anything, because even if I do not engage and the elections are not good, will anyone here hold it against me, on the grounds that I did not engage? No one. Everyone knows that these are always complex appointments, we will see what happens, but my true judge of peace is at the end of my term. The French did not elect me for a year, they elected me for five years, so the appointment is at the end of five years, for the French to say: did he do his job well or did he do it poorly? So naturally, I would prefer that we win them, but I will also see it by engaging and with hindsight. Retrospective on the analysis, commitment to the operational.

QUESTION - Mr. President, you have often lamented the discredit suffered by politicians, a discredit that you attributed in particular to the fact that they do not always assume their responsibilities, you have often affirmed your desire to see the nobility of political action rehabilitated. How is the use of a private firm to evaluate the actions of government ministers compatible with this desire you have expressed? I specify that my question concerns the use of a private firm and not the principle of evaluation itself. Thank you.

NICOLAS SARKOZY - I do not see how the use of a private firm rather than a public one adds to or detracts from the discredit of political leaders. That is to say, if we believe, at a given moment, that to evaluate not the ministers but public policies there is a firm of specialists, should we not use it, Carole BARJON, on the grounds that it is private? It is a strange conception of discredit and of France. We are trying to take, with François FILLON, the best to do something very difficult which is the evaluation of a public policy. And if there are specialists in a private firm who want to help us, why should we not use them? It is quite curious. So, what bothers you? That it is private or that it is evaluated? I do not mind that it is private and it is my duty to evaluate, that is my answer.

QUESTION - We are talking about evaluation, how do you evaluate your own record of these first months at the Élysée?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Listen, it is really not for me, Vanessa SCHNEIDER, to answer that question, it would be perfectly inappropriate. I see that every day I am evaluated and I consider that it is quite normal. Every day, I am criticized and if one does not want to be criticized, one should choose another profession than mine.

QUESTION - Are you satisfied with these first months at the Élysée?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Do I give you the impression of being depressed? Frankly, I will tell you one thing, I am passionate about what I do, I try to do my best, I engage with all my soul, with all my strength, I do not hold back any of my feelings, I try to be worthy of the responsibilities that the French have entrusted to me, I do it without any qualms since I try to be sincere at every moment of my speeches. I said that I would not lie, it is something that I have deeply ingrained in me. That means: am I comfortable with what we have done? The answer is yes. But by the way, if I were not comfortable with what we had done, why would I have done it? Why? Authenticity shows on my face, I do not cheat, I do not fake. I have been in political life for thirty years, no one has caught me with my hand in the jar of lies. One can disagree with what I do, one can not like me, that is perfectly understandable, acceptable, normal, that is democracy, but no one can say that I have lied, that I have distorted. What we are implementing with François FILLON is what we said we would do. I did not lie during the campaign, I have not lied since the campaign, and I take responsibility. So I understand that it is curious in France because one does not take responsibility when one is part of the French elite in general, it is even the hallmark. We hide behind the single thought, all of us, like sheep, we think the same thing at the same time. I try to take responsibility. So I am not satisfied, Vanessa SCHNEIDER, because I see well the immensity of what remains to be done, of what we have to do, of what remains to be built, but at the same time, I am comfortable with what we have done. What we have done, for better or for worse, we wanted to do it, so if it is a mistake, it was a deliberate one.

QUESTION - Mr. President, the global economy seems quite bleak: we have rising oil prices, we have poor economic figures from the United States, Jacques ATTALI, to whom you have entrusted an important mission on growth, even speaks of a possible crisis like that of 1929, a repeat of the 1929 crisis. Do you feel that the French economy is sheltered from these upheavals? Or, on the contrary, will this modify your plans, your reforms, and what the French expect?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - The international situation is not as good as we could have hoped, but to those who ask me the question: does this bother you? In any case, Ruth ELKRIEF, if it weren't this problem, it would have been another. And what can we do about it? That's how it is, we have to take responsibility. But again, I refer you to the choices we made with François in July when everything seemed to be going well, when we weren't talking about the subprime crisis that hit in August: when we said that we needed to inject money into the engine of the French economy, experts said: but he is crazy, everything is fine, why is he doing it? And today, if France is reacting somewhat better, it is because we did that. And what do we want to do anyway, subprime crisis or not, mediocre international situation or not, what do we want to do? Free the forces of labor in France. The French problem is well known: we do not work enough while others work more. Whether the winds are favorable or against us does not change the diagnosis. It makes the journey a bit more difficult, but it does not change the strategy. France will get through this by freeing the forces of labor, by allowing people who want to work more to be able to do so, by allowing people to build a retirement at the age they want - if they want to work more, they should be able to do so - by giving more flexibility in our labor law, by strengthening training and education. But what do subprimes have to do with it? It does not change the diagnosis. Even if there were 18% global growth, France would still have the problem of the 35-hour workweek, the problem of a labor law that does not protect employees and that hinders hiring, the problem of vocational training that leaves 500,000 job offers unfilled. Understand me, Ruth ELKRIEF, it makes our task more difficult but on the economic diagnosis and on what needs to be done, it changes nothing. The diagnosis remains the same.

QUESTION - Are you worried?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - Worried? But if I were worried, I wouldn't be President of the Republic. This is not a job for the worried. Frankly, I know calmer people: editorialists... It's difficult, but the advantage of the editorialist is that their editorial is not constantly thrown back in their face, the next one... whereas we, who are the actors, we have results to deliver. But that does not change anything fundamentally, it does not change anything at all. We are implementing a strategy of profound changes in our country that does not take into account the cyclical uncertainties, because precisely we want to reform France deeply, which needs it. So, it changes the conception we can have of the moralization of financial capitalism, and the responses we must provide, it changes in urgency, but on the French strategy... Listen, for 25 years we have been saying, when there is 5% global growth, it is good when France has 2%, and when there is 3% global growth, it is good when France is at 0.5. Well, we want something else. We want, when the world has 5, to have 5, and a little more, we want to fully seize global growth. And for that, these are endogenous, French causes. Let's stop saying and thinking that France's problems are solely the problems of the international and others. It is also, it is primarily the problems of the French, that's it. What do you want me to say? The diagnosis is perfectly known and it is on the basis of this diagnosis that with François FILLON we have put in place an economic strategy, Christine LAGARDE, social, Xavier BERTRAND, to achieve results. And we will achieve these results. And I tell the French: we will be at the rendezvous of results, because we will fight to make the changes that have worked everywhere else in the world. All those who have done what we are doing have won. We will win too. And it is not a question of weeks, or months, or subprimes, it is a question of conviction. I carry this conviction and I will carry it to the end because I am sure we are on the right path and that all those who have done it elsewhere have had results. We will have these results.

QUESTION - Mr. President, every day there are men, women, children, and even babies who are treated like criminals simply because they are undocumented foreigners, so do you not think that the policy of numbers that you advocate, namely 25,000 expulsions per year, is the cause of these excesses that increasingly shock the French, at the forefront of which, by the way, is Jean-Pierre JOUYET, your Secretary of State for European Affairs, who has expressed some indignation about it? And I wanted to know if you confirm that Brice HORTEFEUX would be evaluated based on the number of deportations?

NICOLAS SARKOZY - First of all, to be treated like criminals is insulting to these unfortunate people, because criminals go to prison, undocumented foreigners do not go to prison, Madame MURACCIOLE, excuse me. I am sorry, but words have meaning. A criminal goes to prison, an undocumented foreigner is in a detention center. If you have visited a prison and a detention center, you can easily tell the difference. And I do not allow anyone to say that in France we treat people without papers like criminals, that is not true, it is false. Secondly, what is the solution? If you do not send back people who do not have permission to stay in our territory, then explain to me how you convince people who want to come to apply for papers? It is extremely interesting, Madame MURACCIOLE, explain to us a bit about your strategy. If not having papers gives the right to stay in France, perfect, then why do those who take the trouble to get papers ask for them, if the result is the same? I would like that to be explained to me. In a state of law, Madame MURACCIOLE, when a judge issues an expulsion order, democracy means executing that expulsion order. When you are in administrative detention, you have recourse to the administrative judge, and, or, to the judge of liberties. When the administrative judge or the judge of liberties confirms the administrative detention, you can say whatever you want, the duty of the state is to obey the law and to expel, that’s it. And therefore, consequently, it is not Brice HORTEFEUX who will be evaluated, it is the immigration policy that will be evaluated. I would like to add one last point, Madame MURACCIOLE. By not expelling those who should have been expelled, we have encouraged the presence in France of networks, criminals this time, who exploit human misery, because when you do not expel people, networks from around the world bring these unfortunate individuals to the country where we do not expel, precisely because we do not expel, and at that moment we are complicit with criminal networks. I would like to add one last point, I see that my ideas are progressing, since Mr. ZAPATERO, the Spanish Prime Minister, declared a month ago that there would be no more massive regularizations, because Mr. PRODI, the socialist Italian Prime Minister, declared 15 days ago that there would be no more massive regularizations, and do you know what they both asked me? That France, Italy, and Spain carry out collective expulsions. What the Italian socialists and the Spanish socialists are doing, do you not think that France should do it? It is not a question of inhumanity, it is a question of a state of rights. In a state of rights, we have papers, and Madame MURACCIOLE, in your home you are at home, and you do not let anyone into your home without your permission. Well, France is a bit like your home too, we do not enter France without permission, and when we enter France without permission, we are sent back to our country, we are not criminals for that, but it is called a state of rights, do not repeat it, with rules, rules that must be applied, and by not applying them, we have led to catastrophe. Last figure, there are 475 million young Africans under 17 years old, 475 million, and the Strait of Gibraltar is 14 kilometers, that’s it.

QUESTION - Mr. President, Francis BROCHET, from Le Progrès de Lyon. You spoke earlier about promoting diversity. How do you plan to apply it to the suburbs, and will you go to explain it in the suburbs, in Vaulx-en-Velin, as has sometimes been announced?

THE PRESIDENT - Not necessarily in Vaulx-en-Velin, but I will go to the suburbs, I will go with Fadela, as the Prime Minister has been, and we will present an extremely ambitious plan at the beginning of February. The characteristic of this plan is that it will rely more on people than on territories.

QUESTION - We have talked about opinion polls in which your approval rating seems to be eroding in recent weeks, particularly among the working class and among workers. You spoke about purchasing power, but these are not the only criticisms often mentioned in these polls, I am sorry to bring it up, there is also a question of style, Mr. President, and a discomfort that seems to be caused by your way of displaying your private life or going on vacation in a friend's jet, Mr. BOLLORE, while you have significantly raised your salary. Do you understand this discomfort in these working-class areas or do you think it is exaggerated, that it is invented?

THE PRESIDENT - I would like to tell you that regarding the display of private life, I understood that it bothered you, so consequently, you will no longer send reporters from BFM TV to follow me everywhere I go, or from any other television station, so we have made progress, we have made progress in that regard, since to all those who say that I am doing too much in this area, I would like to remind you that I have given no instructions to any editorial office to send a force of reporters, cameras, photos, for a purpose that was naturally simply transparency and not to improve the sales of their own media outlet. Let’s move on. Regarding the salary, things are perfectly clear, what is it about? When I became President of the Republic, I was told: you must set your salary, oh really. I said: why should I set my salary, no, there must be a rule. No, there is no rule. There is no rule, you do exactly what you want, and then, if you have pensions, you can, unlike all the French, combine your pensions and your salary. So you set it. I said: no, I will not set it, because it is not for me to set it. The only salary in the public service that was not set by Parliament and by law was that of the President of the Republic. Did you have the courage and honesty to say it? Do we consider that it is normal? Did we ask my predecessors what they earned, and how they earned it, and how their remuneration was set? I am the only one who decided that the Court of Auditors would control the budget of the Elysée, no one had done it before me, no one. I am the only one to ask Parliament to set my salary, no one had done it before me. The president set it, Parliament set the salary, majority and opposition agreed on this point. Parliament set the salary of the President of the Republic at the same level as that of the Prime Minister. Did anyone think to say: it is shocking what the Prime Minister earns? Can anyone say that it is shocking that the President of the Republic earns what the Prime Minister earns? Can anyone say that it is shocking that the President of the Republic has his salary set by the majority and the opposition in a transparent vote in Parliament? And moreover, I myself asked that henceforth, the President of the Republic not be able to combine pensions and salaries. And if you want a confidence, in the end, it gives me a little less than what my predecessor earned by combining pensions and salaries. Here is my answer, because I find that dishonesty, not yours, of course, but dishonesty has its limits, it is called transparency. I am an honest man, I have not had an increase in my salary. I earn the same as my predecessor. The difference is that I earn it after a vote from Parliament, which puts me at the same salary as the Prime Minister. And allow me to tell you that this is called populism, that those who said it was a 140% increase, we wonder what it is compared to, as if anyone can imagine that a President of the Republic would be satisfied with 7,000 euros a month before me. Finally, regarding travel and the famous plane, what do we prefer, that I travel at the expense of the French taxpayer, and that I bring a second family on another plane of the French taxpayer? That didn’t shock you? It turns out that there weren’t any, and it also turns out, I saw that Mr. HUCHON, very nice otherwise, told me that he could take a commercial flight without any problem. That’s true. I do not dispute that there are security issues for a head of state, which means that, moreover, the head of state is followed in his security by a doctor, by an aide-de-camp, who keeps him in contact with the French army for the atomic bomb, that he is followed by transmitters, who install and allow to know that he is permanently reachable, that he is followed by about ten people, and that it is not necessarily very simple to put these ten people on a charter to Sharm el-Sheikh. There you go. But... with you, why not, on the same charter, to make sure that you can control everything. There you go. It did not cost a cent to the French taxpayers. And then, I will tell you something else, I take responsibility. So, you tell me that there is a malaise, but what does it change when there is no malaise? So, there is a malaise, but then what would you like to say for all those who have been defeated, I must say that some who wanted to give me lessons on transparency regarding private life...

QUESTION - Thank you. The German news agency ADPA. Mr. President, you said that we must help many countries interested in civil nuclear power, are you aware that these countries, including in the Arab world, are capable of managing nuclear waste, and that they are capable of protecting sites against terrorist attacks? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - My answer is absolutely yes, and moreover, what is the other solution, Madam? What is the great problem of the world? To avoid a conflict between East and West. If you explain to Arab countries that they do not have the right to civil nuclear power because they are Arab, you give an extraordinary incentive to Iran, whose whole thesis is that it must acquire nuclear weapons, because precisely, the West does not want to provide the energy of the future. Therefore, I am convinced that we must help these countries on the path of development and open them access to civil nuclear power. I add that if they have the wisdom to choose French technology, that is even better. And it is better that it is French technology than another technology. Perhaps one last question.

QUESTION - How do you plan to act to transform the G8 into a G13, and to bring into the United Nations Security Council some countries like Brazil, India, South Africa, or Germany? Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT - Well, listen, I think I can achieve this by appealing to common sense, by finding allies and by evolving the thinking on this subject. I have already expressed myself on this issue, I wrote to all the participants in the G8 to ask them this. I spoke about it with the Japanese Prime Minister, I spoke about it with the American President. We must achieve results. I add that I recently had lunch with Mr. BAN Ki-Moon, I told him that the reform of the UN Security Council could no longer wait, because the world could no longer wait. I will also be judged on the results.

Ladies and gentlemen, one word, I would like to tell you that, first of all, thanking you for your presence, your attention, your questions. I would like to tell you that I will have the opportunity to hold press conferences again because it is an exercise, it seems to me, that a responsible President of the Republic should engage in. You ask questions on behalf of your viewers or your readers. It is quite normal that I can answer them, regardless of the subjects. And you know, what was abnormal was to think that the presidential word is strong, solely on the pretext that it is rare. Because a rare presidential word is a presidential word that does not account for its responsibilities, which, in a way, flees from them, which shelters behind others. The rhythm of democracy is the rhythm of reactivity, we must be accountable. And what kind of President would I be if I demanded results from the government and distanced myself from it in my own practice? Therefore, I would really like that each year, we have at least two or three opportunities to meet in this way, perhaps less solemn, so that you can exercise your profession, and that I can assume my responsibilities. Thank you.