Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, during the presentation of the conclusions of the Grenelle Environment Forum, on France's commitments to sustainable development, Paris, October 25, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

25 October 2007 · Presentation of the conclusions of the Grenelle Environment Forum · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the closing session of the Grenelle Environment Forum in Paris on October 25, 2007, presenting France's commitments to sustainable development.
Main themes
Grenelle Environment Forum, sustainable development, environmental revolution, France's climate commitments, greenhouse gas emissions, renewable energy, multi-stakeholder dialogue, global ecological New Deal, behavioral and policy change, tribute to Al Gore and Wangari Maathai, NGO and union cooperation, European Commission support
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,697
93rd percentile
Sentences
377
97th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
9.4
15th percentile
Syntax
2.68
11th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
55th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 36%35%
  • Institutional 25%24%
  • Economic 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 6%5%
  • Social 6%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

377 sentences in 128 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Mr. President of the Senate,

Mr. President of the National Assembly,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Mr. President Al Gore,

Mr. President Barroso,

My first thought goes to all those who have worked towards the success of this Grenelle of the Environment, which will remain an important moment in our society's awareness that it can no longer live in wastefulness, that it can no longer neglect the consequences of its way of living, producing, and consuming on the future of the planet.

I want to acknowledge José Manuel Barroso, President of the European Commission, who demonstrates here Europe's commitment to sustainable development. I know that thanks to him we can count on the support of the Commission to carry out the true revolution we want to undertake. For it is indeed a revolution that this Grenelle of the Environment invites us to, which today concludes the first phase of its work.

A revolution in our ways of thinking and in our ways of deciding. A revolution in our behaviors, in our policies, in our objectives, and in our criteria.

I want to express to José Manuel Barroso the full support of France and, if he allows me, my personal friendship.

I also want to acknowledge the presence of Mr. Vice President Al Gore, and Ms. Wangari Maathai, both Nobel Peace Prize laureates. They are among those who embody this revolution, who wanted it before anyone else, who announced its necessity before all, who did not hesitate, particularly you, Mr. President Al Gore, to defy skepticism in your own country, to challenge prejudices, and to confront conservatisms.

You are part of those who have taught us to look far ahead and not to remain prisoners of short-sighted calculations.

You have called us to our responsibilities. You have forced us to question the world we will leave to our children.

And you have made us understand that we have exceeded the limits of what our planet can bear.

France has no reason to be ashamed of what it has done so far.

Our greenhouse gas emissions are 21% lower per capita compared to the European average, and even 30 to 40% lower compared to our large neighbors. That is not an excuse. France is the second largest producer of renewable energy in Europe. France has an invaluable natural wealth.

France is not lagging behind. But France now wants to be ahead. And that is the entire change, José Manuel, that we want to propose today in France. Our ambition is not to be as mediocre as others on the objectives, it is not to be average. Our ambition is to be ahead, to be exemplary. France has advocated at the UN for a global economic and ecological New Deal. France cannot hope that its call will be heard if it does not impose the highest demands on itself. How can we become an example if we are not capable of applying to ourselves the rules we would like to see adopted by others?

It is in this spirit that I wanted this Grenelle.

The Grenelle is shared reflection and proposal. It is a success. It is a success that we owe to the non-governmental organizations of ecology that have risen to this unprecedented role.

I am convinced that if we had told a number of them, "soon you will work with him"... That was not a given!

It is a success that we owe to the unions that have managed to seize this subject, which I know is new for a number of them. It is a success that we owe to the entire agricultural world that had the courage to revisit old positions. It is a success that we owe to the companies that have also managed to be present. It is a success that we owe to the elected officials who understood the demands of the population.

And then, of course, it is a success, I want to pay tribute to him, that we owe to Jean-Louis Borloo, whom I want to particularly acknowledge, to Nathalie Kosciusko-Morizet, to Dominique Bussereau, and to all their teams. Jean-Louis, you have risen to the challenge I set for you. I believe we can applaud you.

So now that it is the success of everyone, it falls to the Prime Minister and me to make the decisions.

The Grenelle is an unprecedented event. You have all remained until the end, at least until the moment I am speaking, at the negotiating table. Compromises have been found on previously taboo subjects. And, dear François Fillon, a very heavy responsibility now awaits us. It is simple: do not disappoint. What I have to say to you is simple: as Head of State, your proposals, I take them as my own, I will carry them out and implement them.

I would like this policy to first and foremost be a policy of adherence.

We must have the courage to decide differently, to change methods, to prefer decisions arising from negotiation rather than decisions arising from administration. And let us recognize that the "dialogue of five" - unions, businesses, NGOs, elected officials, and administration - is an unprecedented success.

The Grenelle is not an end, it is a beginning. And we will entrust "the five" with the follow-up of what has been decided in common. We will establish several working groups, "housing," "transport," etc.

But I propose that, for all major projects, all, for example those submitted to public inquiry, the negotiated decision "by five" replaces the administrative decision.

This is a complete change in the logic of governmental decision-making. It is a revolution in the method that we will measure the implications of in a few years, and I propose to give environmental NGOs their place in our institutions, particularly in the Economic and Social Council.

We must have the courage to recognize that we can no longer define policies while ignoring the climate challenge, while ignoring that we are destroying the conditions for our survival.

First principle: all major public projects, all public decisions will henceforth be arbitrated by integrating their cost for the climate, their "carbon cost." All public decisions will be arbitrated by integrating their cost for biodiversity. Very clearly, a project whose environmental cost is too high will be rejected.

Second principle, we will reverse the burden of proof. It will no longer be up to ecological solutions to prove their worth. It will be up to non-ecological projects to prove that it was not possible to do otherwise. Decisions deemed non-ecological must be motivated and justified as a last resort. This is a total revolution in the governance method of our country, and we will immediately apply this principle to transport policy. The Grenelle proposes a break, and well, I propose to make it mine. The priority will no longer be on road catch-up but on catch-up of other modes of transport.

We will also apply it to waste management policy. The priority will no longer be solely on waste treatment but on waste prevention. We will retain all proposals that allow for the prohibition or taxation of unnecessary waste such as "over-packaging." The priority will no longer be on incineration but on recycling waste. It will have to be proven for any new incinerator project that it is indeed the last resort. There will no longer be incinerators without permanent and transparent control of the emissions produced. There will no longer be incinerator projects without the destruction of waste serving to produce energy. With these principles established, I know that you have not concluded on this point and that the work of the Grenelle must continue. The Government awaits your conclusions.

We want a policy of truth. Wangari Maathai and Vice President Al Gore had the courage to proclaim it: our model of growth is doomed. Worse still, the maintenance of peace in the world is doomed if we do nothing.

Climate change, our fellow citizens must not reduce it to the melting of snow on ski slopes. Climate change means hundreds of millions of climate refugees. Climate change means an acceleration of major disasters, droughts, floods, cyclones; in a certain way, it is Darfur where millions of poor people are driven by hunger and thirst to other regions where they come into conflict with populations that have been settled for centuries. Climate change means new epidemics. It means exacerbated conflicts over access to water and food.

We must therefore have the courage to say that the rise in hydrocarbon prices will be permanent. We must have the courage to say that there will be no more oil before the end of the century. We must have the courage to recognize that we do not know all the long-term effects of the 100,000 chemical substances marketed. We must have the courage to recognize that we have not always been exemplary.

The French have the right to know. They have the right to know the truth about today's and tomorrow's threats. They have the right to form their own opinion. This is a strong demand of the Grenelle. We will therefore create a right to total transparency of environmental information and expertise. All data, without exception, will henceforth be communicable, including on nuclear and GMOs. The only limits will be the secrecy of private life, much to be done in this area, national security, and industrial secrets.

This policy of truth is a policy of responsibility. No one should be able to say that they did not know. We are all accountable for our actions. This allows me to return to the question of the precautionary principle. Proposing its removal on the grounds that it would hinder action rests, in my eyes, on a great misunderstanding. The precautionary principle is not a principle of inaction. It is a principle of action. It is a principle of action and expertise to reduce uncertainty. The precautionary principle is not a principle of prohibition. It is a principle of vigilance and transparency. It must therefore be interpreted as a principle of responsibility. Responsibility is part of the values I wanted to carry in the electoral campaign.

I also want to reopen the debate on responsibility and take mine. Those who pollute rivers for years, those who design and sell a chemical product, those who create a new genetic product, must be held accountable for their actions even years later if a tragedy occurs. And well, we will break down, with Europe, the legal barriers to go after polluters wherever they are. It is unacceptable that a parent company is not held responsible for the environmental damage caused by its subsidiaries. It is unacceptable that the principle of limited liability becomes a pretext for unlimited irresponsibility. When one controls a subsidiary, one must feel responsible for the ecological disasters it may cause. One cannot be responsible in the morning and irresponsible in the afternoon. This will not be the policy of France.

I want to return to the issue of GMOs: the truth is that we have doubts about the current interest of pesticide GMOs; the truth is that we have doubts about the control of the dissemination of GMOs; the truth is that we have doubts about the health and environmental benefits of GMOs.

I do not want to contradict you, José Manuel, with the European Union. But I must make choices. Well, in respect of the precautionary principle, I wish for the commercial cultivation of pesticide GMOs to be suspended. This pending the conclusions of an expertise to be conducted by a new body created before the end of the year in close consultation with you, the Grenelle of the Environment, and with the European Commission. I take my responsibilities here too. We will respect our commitments.

And, the proof of this will, José Manuel, is that I commit to ensuring that France transposes the directive on the subject by Spring 2008. But I cannot be caught in flagrant contradiction; there is a precautionary principle. There are pesticide GMOs, I want to suspend because it is in the name of the precautionary principle. At the same time, France plays its role in Europe. France is not unaware of its obligations. We will transpose the directive and we will discuss it together. The Grenelle establishes new principles to frame research and the cultivation of GMOs. I think of the principle of transparency. I think of the right to cultivate with or without GMOs. I think of the obligation to prove the health and environmental interest of GMOs. These principles, Jean-Louis will include in the transposition bill. And, at least, there will be a rule, transparency. Everyone will take their responsibilities.

So this suspension of the commercial cultivation of GMOs and pesticides does not mean, I want to be clear here, that we must condemn all GMOs, especially the GMOs of the future. We must accelerate research. I do not accept that research plots are destroyed. What we are proposing, in truth, is the return of democracy: debate, transparency, decisions made exclusively for reasons of general interest and not just commercial ones, responsibility; the counterpart will be the return of everyone to the field of democracy and the rule of law: debate and controversy, not abuse and violence. And no one will make me accept or think that it is normal to violate private property. I want to say that I respect the opinion of those who do not share my views, but I want to have the honesty to tell them that in the sincere commitment of the government, there are also principles to which we hold.

In the same spirit, I want to say a word about nuclear energy. To clearly show that one can want a policy of truth and address the issues. It is illusory in France to want to meet the climate challenge, our primary challenge, without nuclear energy. Today, we have no other choice, unless we give up growth. This reality, I have always defended before and after the elections.

But that does not mean at all that nuclear energy must be the sole solution to the climate challenge. Not at all. Our first priority, and this is one of the conclusions of the Grenelle, our first priority is to reduce our energy needs. The goal is to improve our energy efficiency by 20% by 2020. And our second priority is to aim for an objective of over 95% of electricity that has no impact on the climate, that is to say, without carbon. In my eyes, this is the only relevant objective to combat climate challenges.

We have nuclear energy. Even if I do not want to create new nuclear sites, I know that we must not give up this energy. But I will take up the principles you propose, particularly that of transparency.

Just as we have the national nuclear program, which was launched in 1974, to reduce our energy dependence, I want to initiate a national renewable energy program, with the same ambition. Why oppose renewable energy and nuclear energy, when everyone feels that we need both? We want to make France the leader in renewable energies, even beyond, José-Manuel, the European objective of 20% of our energy consumption by 2020.

However, I am against a form of haste that ultimately results in environmental degradation. Wind turbines yes, but first on industrial wastelands, and far from iconic sites. And, frankly, when I fly over certain European countries, it does not inspire confidence. We must also review the policy of support for biofuels for the future without calling into question the commitments made. I want the priority to be given to the development of second-generation biofuels that are more relevant in the face of environmental and food challenges.

And we will prioritize the territories where the notion of energy independence makes sense. I think of Corsica, which must be able to be energy independent. (There was a foolishness to say, you must suggest it to Mr. JACOBI!) Energy independence is very important. And imagine what we can do for Corsica as well as for our overseas departments and communities. And I announce that as of 2008, we will launch the Réunion 2030 Program. We can truly, Madam Minister of the Interior, give these territories the opportunity to be laboratories of research in the service of renewable energies.

In the same spirit of efficiency, the Government will engage with Michel Barnier in a major plan for the energy autonomy of agricultural operations.

There will indeed be a reduction in the share of nuclear energy in our energy consumption, and there will be a reduction in the share of "carbon" energies, harmful to the climate. We will continue to explore nuclear energy and we will launch a plan for the development of renewable energies. Why choose when we need both?

I would like to say that environmental policy is an investment policy.

To equate ecological policy with a "step backward" is a sham. The greatest pollution is observed at least as much in rich countries as in poor countries. The greatest aggressors of the climate are rich countries and poor countries. And let us be realistic. It is a lost cause to try to convince developing countries that they must remain sustainably poor because growth would be forbidden to them. And it is a lost cause to try to convince the French that they must live in scarcity for the well-being of future generations.

The challenge is to invest massively to create the conditions for tomorrow's growth. We will therefore decide on a major national sustainable development program.

I echo the words of Vice President Al GORE. He wants a "Marshall Plan" for France as well as for the planet. It succeeded in 1947, it must succeed today. Sir Nicholas Stern estimated the necessary investment at 1% of GDP. I remind you that the Marshall Plan at the time represented 2% of GDP. Who, today, can contest that at the time the Marshall Plan made the Glorious Thirties possible? The solution is not in the accumulation of public spending and taxation. We will succeed through investment. First, investment in research, in technological progress, in behavioral progress. Innovation, inventiveness. We will invest one billion euros over four years for the energies and engines of the future, biodiversity, and environmental health. Where we spend one euro on nuclear research, we will spend the same euro on research on clean technologies and on preventing environmental damage. We want to be exemplary on both sides.

We will invest massively in transportation.

I say it, the State was wrong to disengage from the development of urban transport. The challenge today is indeed the congestion of city centers. I will restore state participation for the construction of bus lanes, bike lanes, or trams. More than 1,500 kilometers will be built outside the Île-de-France.

The TGV is a tremendous advance. We will build 2,000 kilometers of new lines. And I propose to establish the principle that the cleared railway lines be allocated to freight. That is 2 million trucks that will no longer cross France from North to South by 2020.

We will rehabilitate river and maritime transport. France has tremendous assets. I propose an investment plan for river connections that will remove an additional million trucks from the roads by 2020. And I commit to revamping our ports so that goods finally enter through the ports and not just through the roads. We will have to discuss this with certain trade unions.

And then a massive investment policy in buildings.

This is a priority and it is urgent. We want to reduce energy consumption by buildings.

I propose to adopt two rules. By 2012, all new buildings constructed in France will meet the so-called "low consumption" standards; and by 2020, all new buildings will be energy positive, meaning they will produce more energy than they consume. Why 2020? Because we do not currently have the companies and workforce necessary, and a considerable training effort is required.

The major challenge lies in the 30 million old homes and buildings. We will double the number of old buildings renovated each year and increase the number of renovated old homes to 400,000 per year. This program will start with the 800,000 degraded HLM (social housing) units.

Finally, I will adopt a simple rule for all household appliances, televisions, high-fidelity systems, and other equipment that are responsible for the explosion of household energy budgets. As soon as an alternative exists at a reasonable price, the most energy-consuming appliances will be banned. We will do this as of 2010 for incandescent bulbs or single-glazed windows.

A massive investment policy in agriculture.

Sustainable agriculture, there are 800 million people who die of hunger. And by 2050, there will be three billion more human beings. We will not be told that we do not need agriculture! Agriculture is a major issue. So we do not want an agriculture that exhausts our soils, an agriculture that increasingly uses dangerous chemical products. This message, José-Manuel, I will carry from the very beginning of the French presidency of the European Union, for the second half of 2008, during a major orientation debate on the founding principles of the Common Agricultural Policy for 2013.

The Grenelle debates have shown that great progress is possible to develop high-quality environmental agriculture and fishing.

From now on, all public canteens will offer at least one meal per week from organic farming. This is a minimum. We will set much more significant goals with the Prime Minister in the months and years to come.

And I commit to ensuring that the specifications for collective catering impose labeled products or those from certified farms. There are quality producers; it is up to the State, to the public specifications, to help them. Not through speeches but through decisions. What we will not do by will, we will encourage through obligation.

And the State will be a pioneer as of 2008; all ministries and administrations will conduct their carbon balance and engage in a plan to improve their energy efficiency by 20%.

As of 2008, the public procurement code will be reformed so that environmental clauses are no longer an option but an obligation. As of 2008, all public building projects will comply with the best energy performance standards.

And as of 2009, all new vehicles of the administrations must be clean.

This grand program is not an expense; it is an investment. It is the most profitable investment we can make today.

For the building sector alone, we will create 100,000 jobs and new training pathways.

In the new energy sector alone, 50,000 jobs will be created.

France's energy independence will improve, and we will manage to reduce household energy bills by almost 40% by 2020.

We want an incentive policy.

The Grenelle has been a tremendous revealer. The French expect great ecological ambition. So of course, there are suspicions. But the main challenge is no longer to convince. The main challenge is to decide.

I propose to create a right to an alternative for all. Environmental decisions must not leave anyone facing a wall or an unsustainable situation. If prohibiting access to a city center for cars prevents someone from going to work, then the community must offer them an alternative transport solution. We cannot punish people. We must incentivize them.

I am told that this policy is expensive and that new taxation must be created to finance it.

These are the same people who contest environmental policy and who are convinced that we cannot do anything more.

Pollution is a cost to society. Pollution is a debt that we leave to our children.

I believe that the renovation of buildings can be profitable in less than 10 years thanks to the reduction of the energy bill.

As for transport, I note that no one was previously concerned about the cost of roads. Can we not finance alternative transport by reducing the funds allocated to road construction?

We must also stop viewing ecological taxation as an instrument to finance the State's additional expenses.

So I make a commitment: the revenues from the Grenelle will go to finance the Grenelle.

I propose that we tax the trucks that cross France and use our road network. José Manuel, there is no reason for France to accommodate all the trucks that avoid the roads of our neighbors. This tax will serve to finance public transport.

The Grenelle proposes an annual ecological tax on the most polluting new vehicles. I hope that this tax will allow for the withdrawal of old polluting cars through a progressive and sustainable scrappage bonus to help purchase a clean vehicle.

And to be incentivized to change behavior, nothing better has been found than the pricing system. Today, prices do not reflect the reality of pollution and scarcity. You propose labeling everyday consumer products to indicate their carbon cost. This is a first step.

I want to go further. I want to raise the question of the price of carbon. And with José Manuel Barroso, we have the inventor of this system. It is not normal that a product that crosses the world costs less than a local product because the price of its transport and production does not include its greenhouse gas emissions.

I raised this question with the European Union. We were the first to subject our major companies to a quota system to limit their harmful emissions to the climate. It is not normal that competitors who import the same products into Europe are not subject to any obligations.

I do not want to close this file on the grounds that it would be complicated. It must be addressed at the community level. We must, Mr. President, study the possibility of taxing products imported from countries that do not respect the Kyoto Protocol. We have imposed environmental standards on our producers. It is not normal that their competitors can be completely exempted. Well, I propose that, within six months, the European Union debate what constitutes fair competition. Environmental dumping is not loyalty; it is a European problem that we must address.

The Grenelle concluded that it is necessary to study the creation of a "climate-energy" tax, that is to say, a tax on fossil fuels.

I want to establish the following principles:

I am against any additional taxation that would weigh on households and businesses. There is no question of increasing the rate of compulsory levies. And the government is against any levy on the purchasing power of households. Any new tax must be strictly compensated.

Ecological taxation only makes sense if it allows for changes in behavior. It only makes sense if it promotes new modes of production, new innovations. It does not make sense if it unjustly penalizes our fellow citizens and unnecessarily penalizes our businesses.

When a clean product exists, it must be cheaper than a polluting product. I ask you, José Manuel, to create a reduced VAT rate on all ecological products that respect the climate and biodiversity. I will fight for this.

I agree to go further in reflection. Ecological taxation should not be reduced to a compilation of small taxes. A profound revision is needed. The goal is to tax pollution more, particularly fossil fuels, and to tax labor less.

I commit to ensuring that the general revision of compulsory levies considers the creation of a "climate-energy" tax in exchange for a reduction in labor taxation to maintain competitiveness, Madam Minister of Finance, and to preserve purchasing power, Mr. Union Leader.

Finally, a new democracy is an impeccable democracy.

We will ask that Parliament, each year, monitor the implementation by the government of a sustainable development policy.

Sustainable development can no longer be a policy that ignores biodiversity. Managing nature is not a luxury of rich countries. It is a necessity.

We will launch a national program to combat land artificialization. Urban planning documents must respect the principle of maintaining biodiversity, including by allowing for compensation measures.

The sciences of nature will regain their place in education and in the highest assemblies of scientists. And we will create the "green framework" in France, and why not in Europe, which will allow species to develop, migrate, and survive climate change.

A sustainable development policy can no longer be a policy that ignores the issue of environmental health. Asthma and allergies are skyrocketing. Childhood cancers are affecting more and more families.

We will multiply by five the funds dedicated to environmental monitoring.

It is high time to take seriously the growing use of pesticide products, of which our farmers are the first victims.

I ask Michel Barnier to propose to me within a year a plan to reduce pesticide use by 50%, the dangers of which are known, if possible within the next ten years. You see that I have followed the strength of your work until these last minutes. It is up to us to engage all institutions in service of this policy.

It will therefore be up to Parliament to adopt a program law that will set the principles and objectives of France's long-term sustainable development policy.

It will be up to Parliament to monitor the commitments made.

It will be up to Parliament to decide on the creation of Environmental Commissions within the two assemblies. How can we say that the environment and sustainable development are a priority if there is no commission, no place to debate it properly? And we will give more freedom to local authorities to decide on their own environmental policy. It will be up to them, for example, to freely decide on the possibility of creating urban tolls... And those who wish to go further can request an experimental law. Listen, let us move beyond these absurd debates between proponents of urban tolls and opponents. But what is the point of having given management autonomy to local authorities if we do not allow them to responsibly decide on financing major projects that will help relieve congestion in their city centers?

This is therefore a choice, and it is the choice of responsibility and trust.

We want an impeccable democracy in the face of the expert, an expert who is too often absent or contested. We want to rebuild the process of public decision-making by instilling a true culture of evaluation. It is time to group the 45 bodies, 45 instances and expert organizations concerned. I want to profoundly reform the foundations of public decision-making to restore trust.

This ecological "New Deal," France will not carry it alone. It wants to carry it with Europe. At the forefront of European environmental policy, with the Commission, with Parliament.

Mr. President, France will support all the Commission's initiatives to increase standards. And I am thinking of vehicle emission standards. We need the most demanding standard for all.

The European Commission's proposals for energy and climate will be strategic for the future of Europe. I hope that the work will be accelerated and that we will be able to define our policy under the French Presidency.

Europe has always been ahead of the game. Europe, thanks to you, has created the "carbon market" to compel large companies to limit their pollution. France has not always been exemplary and not always ambitious on this point. Well, we will place ourselves at the forefront of this fight.

Mr. President Barroso, I will support your most ambitious proposals. I will ask that quotas be set by sector and not by state in order to avoid power struggles. I will ask that pollution rights be allocated by auction, up to 100% if the sector allows it.

And then, I will ask you to equip us with a genuine policy to combat environmental dumping, to impose on producers outside our borders the respect of our requirements. I am thinking of the carbon tax as well as the obligation to control the impact of chemical substances marketed in Europe.

And then, enough is enough; we impose rules on our farmers that they accept, we must not accept that we import into Europe products that do not respect any of the rules that we impose on our own producers. That is not fair.

There you have it, you understand, the time for action has come. We have waited too long. We can no longer wait. Our responsibility is primarily moral, and it is individual.

I do not believe, like President Al Gore, that one can absolve oneself of one's own faults in the name of the faults of others.

You know, Mr. President Barroso, Mr. Vice President Al Gore, to get to where we are today, for a man like me to deliver a speech proposing so many changes, for our political families to be able to accept to hear this speech, and perhaps even to support it, for a government of the Republic, isn't that right, Mr. Prime Minister, to be ready to make public commitments, it takes conviction... How can you expect us not to keep them?

To assume the complexity, the difficulty, the trials, the decisions that I have just announced.

For there to be NGOs or trade union organizations in this room that imagined themselves a thousand miles away from our own opinion, from our reasoning system, and that no one has left the room until now, is because France is changing, gentlemen Presidents.

But this change in France, we want to put it at the service of Europe and the world. If France has understood that its duty is to act, it is because Europe must act and the world must react.

I would like you to understand one thing, that what we have decided to do, we have done both in the name of feeling and in the name of reason. We have done it amid difficulties of all kinds, and I am well aware that with the government and the Prime Minister, we will encounter inertia, routines, selfishness, blindness, ideologies...

But I tell you one thing: what I said this evening, we will do, and we will do it together. Thank you for understanding that.