Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, in response to questions about the Internet revolution, in Paris on May 24, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

24 May 2011 · G8 summit preparation (Internet discussion) · Paris

Context
Sarkozy addressed a Q&A session at the e-G8 Forum in Paris on May 24, 2011, ahead of the G8 Summit, discussing internet governance and digital economy policy.
Main themes
Internet governance, G8 digital summit, trust between governments and internet users, creative freedom, intellectual property, digital economy growth, taxation of digital sector, monopoly regulation, digital infrastructure investment, internet revolution, democratic society challenges
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,651
83rd percentile
Sentences
174
86th percentile
Readability
60
87th percentile
Grade
10.0
20th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
7th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 48%45%
  • Geopolitical 16%15%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Institutional 9%8%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

174 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Q - Mr. President, challenge accepted. You said: why not every year before the G8, in any case, as far as I am concerned, I am ready to take on the challenge and I hope my friends will follow me.

If you agree, we will move on to a small question-and-answer session, and I will perhaps start with a question that comes out of everything we have seen on the Internet over the past three weeks, whether it be bloggers, "tweeters," or "facebookers," they have expressed themselves and broadly what they say is the following: you wanted there to be a discussion about the Internet at the G8 level, and they have broadly two reactions. The first: "it's fantastic, wonderful." Here is a head of state and here are the heads of state of the most industrialized countries who are going to take an interest in this sector that is part of their daily lives and is extremely important. You have a second reaction that says: "oh dear! This is not possible, they are not going to meddle in this, what are they risking by touching this?" What is your reaction to these two reactions from Internet users?

R - You know, when Internet users are wary, when they are afraid, they resemble all citizens who, by definition, express reluctance in the face of any initiative. One of the first problems of our democratic societies is the lack of trust. But if I, as a head of state, were to take initiatives only when people are happy, when people are confident, frankly, I could stay in bed all day, regardless of the field, especially with this new world that is the Internet. I thought we needed to overcome this artificial wall of distrust. There cannot be, on one side, the virtual society, and on the other, the real society. They are the same actors who, at different moments in their lives, express themselves online or in real life, and I said to myself: "we have things to discuss among ourselves."

At the moment when your evolution reaches maturity, what are the mechanisms you need to be encouraged, what taxation, what minimum rules are you willing to accept or refuse? The question that fascinates me, that of creative freedom - you are creators - how do we compensate for it? The question of intellectual property, how do we handle it? The question of monopolies, how do we regulate it? Is it up to Maurice Levy, if heads of state remain in their club discussing among themselves? with the experience of the Internet, in general, the experience of the electoral campaign? There, you are at maximum risk.

If we get closer, if we listen to you, if we try to understand, as I tried to do in France, to get closer to this world that I knew so little about and certainly from the outside, suddenly I see entrepreneurs who resemble other entrepreneurs, I see women and men who are creators, who are not outlaws, who create growth and who want to live in a world with values that are universal values. Why be wary? What risk are we taking? Do you think that everyone will lose their identity because they came to express themselves with heads of state and government? On the contrary, every revolution at the first stage of its maturity needs, like the person digging a tunnel, to support it, to consolidate it, to install it to prepare for the second stage. Beyond concerns about image, I thought there was no risk in taking this initiative. It has not been so simple to get heads of state and government to carve out time to talk about the Internet when we have Japan and an unprecedented nuclear crisis, when we have the Arab revolutions, when we have financial crises, when we have global growth to bolster, when we have so many subjects to discuss. And yet, I thought it was a recognition for you, of your importance and influence, and that one is never wrong when calling on the responsibility of one's partners, while in truth, I have not been very impressed by the reactions of distrust; on the contrary, it encouraged me to confirm the organization of this e-G8.

Q - Hello, Mr. President, digital technology appears, day by day, as a force that reconfigures the way modern economies are organized. How do you think states can concretely support this process so that digital technology becomes an accelerator of growth? Thank you.

R - This is not an easy question because, to tell you the truth, we have tried not to be overwhelmed. We have tried to understand what is happening, the colossal extent of the changes in the relationship with the consumer and in the relationship with the citizen.

So, there are two things that are quite easy to do - well, quite easy, classic in any case - investment in digital infrastructure. For France, we have decided to invest 4.5 billion euros because, without these infrastructures, regardless of your ingenuity, there is no possible contact between millions of Internet users and you.

The second element, we have decided to significantly strengthen our training system, which allows me to tell you that, for the first time in our history, our universities are now autonomous. Infrastructure and training, we are investing without counting in these two areas.

But it goes much further because the arrival of digital technology imposes new behaviors on us. I will take just one example, that of transparency. I have long thought that in the management of states, there are no more secrets; everything is known. But with the Internet, everything is known immediately. And this changes for us in a considerable way the management of our states and our governments. I mean that our reactivity has had to accelerate enormously because every decision is immediately global, every controversy is immediately global, every economic commitment has consequences in all countries. I am convinced that a head of state who was a head of state ten years ago and who became a head of state today would not recognize the podium for leading a state.

Finally, and this is the whole purpose of our meetings, we are trying to take advantage of the exponential growth potential that you represent. Essentially, we try not to take any measures that could stifle this growth and to draw inspiration from the mechanisms that have allowed this growth. We are not there yet. And I believe that for all my fellow heads of state and government, it is the same; we are listening, we are alert, we are hesitating on decisions to be made.

For example, in France, we have decided to create a National Digital Council; I have committed with the main actors of the Internet in France that the government will not make any decision without seeking their opinion. So, we can disagree, but beforehand, they will give their opinion and, in exchange, they have committed to playing the game of dialogue and responsibility. I am therefore unable to definitively answer your question; perhaps in a year, I will be able to respond in a more precise way. Right now, we are really in the realm of mutual discovery. We see these two worlds, we try to make them converge without losing your youth, without losing your exponentiality, without losing your dynamism, and at the same time, making you understand that you cannot exempt yourselves - how to say? I know that the word is not popular with you - from minimum values or minimum rules.

There you go, that is the meeting point and the balance point that we will try to find. It is really about keeping everything you bring us, keeping everything you bring and at the same time, understanding that there is a minimum foundation of values, of rules that should not hinder your development but that will allow us to continue together towards much higher growth rates.

Q - Hello, Mr. President, you said it yourself, everyone has noted the importance of the Internet in the Arab revolutions; it started in Tunisia. However, many bloggers did not feel as supported as they had hoped by France. Today, dozens of bloggers are in prison in Syria, Bahrain, Libya, and Yemen. What is France doing for them? What can France do tomorrow for these cyber-dissidents? And do you think that tomorrow, the defense of a free Internet could be a weapon of diplomacy for democratic countries?

R - Thank you for asking me this question. Just one point of disagreement. I do not think it started with Tunisia. Let us not forget the Iranian Internet users. It is not because it did not work. Understand me, it is not because the revolution through the Internet in Iran unfortunately did not lead to the departure of Mr. Ahmadinejad, but they were the ones who started. The role of the Internet in Iran has been considerable. And I hope that one day, Iranians will also have the right to live freely.

Secondly, free Internet. Well, now it is clear; it is a criterion for determining whether we are facing a democracy or a dictatorship. From this point of view, it is the advanced sign of dictatorship or the advanced sign of democracy. Is the Internet free or is the Internet not free? That is the dividing line. And all those who have wanted to confine the Internet in their country have aligned themselves with the camp of dictators.

You say that we have not done enough; it is your right to think so. I will speak to you very frankly; the Jasmine Revolution, the Tunisian revolution, we were surprised when it happened; I readily acknowledge that. I have difficulty knowing in the world who was not surprised. I do not use it as an excuse to exempt myself, but we have drawn a number of conclusions from it, and we have changed France's policy in this regard. Until now, let us put it plainly, whether left or right, all foreign policy was organized around one word, the word "stability." And in the name of stability, we preferred two Germanys instead of one; in the name of stability, 80 million Europeans found themselves behind the Berlin Wall; and in the name of stability, we tolerated dictatorships. Things have changed because the people, the Arab peoples have taken charge. And that has counted a lot, you see, in the decision I made to intervene in Côte d'Ivoire so that the democratic will of the Ivorians triumphed; to intervene in Libya, because if we had not intervened in Libya, Benghazi would have been massacred by a tyrant. The situation in Syria is unacceptable.

And so now, the Internet has become the scale of credibility of a democracy or the scale of shame of a dictatorship. We are only at the beginning of a phenomenon, but it will only grow and flourish, and I think that dictators who want to silence a people, now with the Internet, they will no longer be able to do so in the silence of the international community. Things have changed in a much deeper way than one might imagine. And believe me, I am aware of this, and it has counted a lot in our decision to intervene in Libya, which was not an easy decision.

Q - Mr. President, hello, I would like to have your opinion on the significance of including the Internet issue specifically at the G8. In what way is the G8 an appropriate body to discuss the future of the Internet? Thank you.

R - It's quite simple, because I do not believe in minimum rules of national dimension. There would still be an extraordinary contradiction, Miss, to say that the Internet abolishes borders, that the Internet abolishes territories, that the Internet expands space, and to continue to act as if legislations, rules, and values were only national. And I said to myself, after all, the Internet is very powerful in the most powerful economies. What is the G8? It is, apart from China, the largest economies in the world. Could we not try to harmonize our proposals between the Internet and us on an international level and not simply on a national level? What does national regulation or national discussion mean about an Internet that has no borders? It makes no sense. And I hope to start with the G8, one day go to the G20, and finally reach the United Nations General Assembly because it is a global phenomenon. So global value, foundation of rules at the global level; otherwise, it makes no sense. That is why I wanted the G8.

I found that for us, heads of state and government, it does us good to be confronted with your world. It can rejuvenate some who need it, it adds a bit of spice and it changes things. I think that heads of state and government, you see, must speak to the future, not just to the past. We carry the history of our countries; our countries are not blank pages, and whether we like it or not, we are part of a historical process. But we often talk about the past, we often talk about the present, and not enough about the future, and you are the future. I wanted there to be this meeting between the future and the heads of state of the present, so some told me: "they will think you want to control them." Can you imagine that I think that is possible? It makes no sense, and at the same time, I think it is important for you to be heard, to be listened to, because in many of those I have met, there is a fear that through clumsiness or ignorance, decisions will be made that complicate, or even could kill the work of your companies. So there was this global dimension and this desire to exchange, to reassure each other, to see if we could have a common language. I believe it was really useful; your numerous presence testifies to that, but the interest of my colleagues, they all told me: "but then, how is this going to happen? What are you going to do? What are we going to say?" I said: "we'll see." Not everything should be predetermined; we must also leave a bit of life.

Q - I was happy to see the recognition that the government does not own the Internet and cannot claim sovereignty over the Internet. The United States officially calls the Internet the 8th continent; it is a new territory, and what gives the Internet all its freedom is indeed its structure, its free and open structure. So, I have a small request to make, as we open this e-G8 forum, I believe we all understand the principles of the Internet, but I would like governments to make a sort of Hippocratic oath for the Internet and commit first and foremost not to harm it.

R - Honestly, it is not very difficult to answer this question. Not to harm you, but of course, why would you want us to harm you? You are a potential for extraordinary growth and knowledge. I like your expression "the 8th continent," but what do you mean by harm? Really, I will pay attention to that.

But does raising the issue of security against terrorism mean harming you? Do you say: "you are creators, what you have created must be respected, but respect also other creators," is that harming you? Saying: "you wanted this 8th continent to be the continent of freedom and openness, be careful not to create new monopolies," is that harming you? Saying: "there are sacred universal values, for example, the protection of a child against the turpitudes of certain adults," is talking about this harming you? I do not believe so.

I believe that what would harm you would be not to recognize in you responsible, competent, intelligent people, citizens, citizens of the world, but citizens and responsible. What would harm you would be to refuse even to mention the problem for fear that you would not understand it. I think that you who have understood the future so well, you are capable of understanding this. So, if you want me to take the oath not to harm you, there is no problem. I can even tell you that you are nice, that I prefer the sun to the rain, that I prefer companies that make money to those that lose it, that it is good to live here. Ask me for stronger commitments.

What I can tell you is that, and I am convinced that for my fellow heads of state and government, it is the same, we are fully aware of the power that the Internet represents and at the same time of the fragility of this ecosystem. And that we must not take measures that would complicate the development of this system, yes. And I think that with the best intentions, we could do that. So we must be careful. I think that in this market you are creating, which is not yet stabilized, we really need to be careful before making decisions. I think that the term definitive regulation is totally inappropriate for your sector. We must evolve with a lot of pragmatism, experience, and we must choose rather to do nothing than to do harm in such a growing and therefore unstable sector. That is the oath I would be willing to take, and by the way, you coming here is still a good sign because if you thought it had no interest, you would not have come. I truly believe it is very important that we continue to dialogue and respect each other, and what we, the heads of state and government, want is not to make mistakes in this world that is yours, under construction and extremely sensitive, extremely fragile, extremely powerful at the same time, so as not to destabilize it.

Q - In your opinion, how can the Internet change the work of government and administrations?

R - You know today, as a head of state, my team spends more time knowing what is said on the web than knowing what is said in the press. It is a considerable change. Until now, the first time I was a minister, we waited, we say in France for the release of a major evening newspaper to know what was being said. Now the major evening newspaper is yours, and it is every second; it is at 3:00 in the morning, it is day and night, there is no more Sunday, there is no more weekend. There is not even May 1st in France, when there is no press, but there is always the Internet. This has completely changed things, and moreover - and this is a good evolution - it leads each country to be less self-centered, less national narcissism, because information is shared at a global level. For us, it is an absolutely considerable change, but it has not yet reached its conclusion; to tell you that we are trying to understand, we are trying to adapt, we are trying to have as little delay as possible. I believe that in the face of this, we need a lot of humility and that the evolutions have not yet reached their conclusion.

Q - Like every year, this year you will again receive a contingent of heads of state from Africa at the G8 Summit. Since 2000, it has been like this. Mr. President, can we count on you to not only explain to them that the Internet is an accelerator of growth but also a tremendous tool for development and rooting of democratic governance and that consequently, it is not a sector that represents enemies? We can see it; in many countries, we do not invest in the infrastructure that will develop these sectors, and very often, in fact, we take back what the gentleman said: "they do harm," they block the development of this sector. Can we, Mr. President, count on you to convey this message?

R - The African continent will have 2 billion inhabitants in 30 or 40 years. Of the 2 billion inhabitants, more than 70% will be under 20 years old. Africa is the youth of the world. Who would be crazy enough to think that young Africans would not be the first to want to develop the Internet? You can count on us; I will tell them, they already know it. In the same way, I will tell you one thing, in Africa as elsewhere, the old reflexes are over. No one can control or stop the Internet, so maybe North Korea will remain for a while longer, with a madman who is turning his country into the Middle Ages. But Africa is 12 kilometers from Europe across the Strait of Gibraltar. The Internet will spread there like wildfire, and with the Internet, the aspiration for growth, the aspiration for knowledge, the aspiration for democracy. Those who want to prevent this will be swept away; that is my absolute conviction. I add that for the development of Africa, and especially for all these children who need training, the vector for disseminating knowledge for African teachers that the Internet represents is absolutely colossal. Do not doubt for a minute the power of the revolution that is underway.

Finally, ladies and gentlemen, before I leave you, I would like to tell you how sensitive I am to the fact that you accepted this meeting. It was not easy for us to open up, but I suppose it was not easy for you to accept this invitation and to play this card. We will try to ensure that no one is disappointed.