Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on strengthening the social dimension of globalization, in Paris on May 23, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

23 May 2011 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed ministers and ambassadors in Paris on May 23, 2011, outlining France's G20 presidency agenda on financial regulation and social globalization.
Main themes
Social dimension of globalization, financial market regulation, 2008 financial crisis, global unemployment, economic inequality, G20 French presidency, financial capitalism reform, growth and development, social protection, fair competition, ILO and labor standards
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,896
74th percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
10.6
28th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 58%55%
  • Social 18%17%
  • Institutional 17%16%
  • Ceremonial 5%4%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

159 sentences in 56 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Gentlemen Ambassadors,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

A little less than three years ago, in the summer of 2008, the financial crisis that had been brewing for months suddenly escalated, bringing the global economy to the brink of disaster.

The bankruptcy of one of the largest American financial institutions triggered an unprecedented crisis of confidence. The global banking system was on the verge of collapse. Within a few weeks, bank financing dried up, plunging the world into an exceptionally severe economic crisis. This earthquake, for it was an earthquake, caused by the chaotic functioning of financial markets, inevitably spread to the rest of the economy, destroying growth, jobs, and purchasing power everywhere.

In the aftermath of this crisis, I promised the French people that I would do everything possible to reform the financial capitalism that had led us to disaster, for it is indeed financial capitalism that has led us to disaster. And if some have forgotten this and would like to return to the behaviors of yesterday, we must put a stop to them. We cannot accept to recognize the same situations that we have only just emerged from.

That is why I wanted the French Presidency of the G20 to tackle the roots of the crisis and lay the foundations for effective regulation of financial markets. The word "regulation" is not a dirty word; there is no market without rules. A market without rules is no longer a market. At the same time, we must identify and bring together the conditions for growth that will provide our populations with well-being and confidence in development.

It is essential to strengthen the social dimension of globalization.

The crisis we have just gone through has had devastating effects on the labor market: 30 million more unemployed in less than two years. That is the result of the anarchy that has reigned in financial markets and a number of financial institutions. 30 million unemployed in two years. There is their record! To those who tell me: "we shouldn't have too many rules," here is the result of private financial institutions that did not want to be regulated. 30 million unemployed in two years.

In most regions of the world, the effects of the crisis have not yet been resolved; in some countries, they have even worsened.

These dramatic consequences of the crisis have exposed certain imbalances of globalization. The surpluses accumulated by some have served to finance the deficits of others, but one thing is certain: inequalities have increased everywhere.

The rise in average living standards, which is good news, no longer hides the resentment of the marginalized by globalization. Between the billion poorest people and the billion richest people, the gap in GDP per capita has increased by 60% over the past seven years. In the majority of OECD countries, while extreme poverty has decreased, at the same time, the gaps between the richest and the poorest have widened.

Globalization creates painful tensions, and these tensions are multifaceted: tensions for entrepreneurs facing increasingly fierce competition. This is good, except that this competition is not always fair, which is a serious problem. Tensions for millions of workers without social protection. Tensions for families and communities disrupted by relocations. Let us not forget the migratory pressure that finds its source in today's inequalities and in the ecological dramas of tomorrow.

Through the action of the G20, we have been able to cushion the impact of the financial and economic crisis on our societies. We have been able to avoid protectionism and retreat into ourselves. But we must go further. The coordination of stimulus plans has been a step in the right direction.

We have implemented measures to preserve the financial sector. Financial institutions have thus regained a sense of nationality, even as major private financial institutions explained to us, before the crisis, that they were global companies without nationality. During the crisis, those who had no nationality did not go to the wrong counter! They miraculously regained their nationality! The same ones who explained that state intervention was illegitimate and that, if states had been managed like them, they would be bankrupt. My God! We were right not to emulate their practices. These institutions were fortunate to find the signature of states to guarantee their own credibility. This was not, ladies and gentlemen, a century ago; it was just a few months ago.

Together, we decided to do everything possible to limit the impact of the crisis and to protect employment. But to believe that the crisis is a mere parenthesis would be, I use a strong word, but one I believe in: "irresponsible." The crisis has not been a parenthesis; it has been a revealer of dysfunction and anarchy, and the same causes would produce the same effects tomorrow if we do not reform them powerfully.

The preamble of the ILO constitution, which was not drafted yesterday, as it was written in 1919, at the end of one of the deadliest wars in our history, reminds us that "universal and lasting peace can only be based on social justice."

The ongoing revolutions in the Near and Middle East demonstrate that this aspiration for social justice is shared in all regions of the world, but they also demonstrate that the response to this expectation can no longer be made solely at the national level.

For decades, the response was exclusively national. Indeed, even we, in Europe, had planned that our pension systems, our health systems, our protection systems were national and not community-based.

Things have changed, and it is now essential to better coordinate our national actions, to lay the foundations for a global economic governance of which the G20 is a precursor.

Today, the major institutions have done remarkable work, dear Director-General SOMAVIA. I know that the International Labour Organization has long been committed to implementing a fairer and more effective international governance.

The "Declaration on Social Justice for a Fair Globalization" (2008) and the "Global Jobs Pact" (2010) have proposed guidelines that commit us all, as member states of the ILO. And in June 2010, the International Labour Conference rightly emphasized the need to improve coherence between economic, financial, and social policies, and between the institutions that carry them.

I also want to remind you that full employment objectives are included in the founding texts of the IMF and the WTO.

We can also be pleased that the World Bank will soon adopt a "Social Protection and Jobs Strategy." It has also partnered with many initiatives to develop targeted social safety nets for the most disadvantaged, such as the "Bolsa Familia" program in Brazil, for which I want to commend the Minister of Social Affairs, Carlos Eduardo GABAS.

Regional development banks are also increasingly taking into account the implementation of fundamental rights and principles.

France's conviction is that we must go further.

The G20 must take responsibility for this new ambition because it brings together the main members of the relevant organizations.

Our goal is to establish new tools for enhanced coherence; it is to ensure that globalization is based on social progress to strengthen economic progress.

I am convinced that openness and globalization are opportunities, but we cannot accept that this leads to an unbearable increase in inequalities or unemployment. Let us remember that there are 8 out of 10 people in the world who have no social protection system. That a third of individuals in the world have no access to any health service or facility. That there is a billion inhabitants, the poorest billion, whose life expectancy is 51 years, while the life expectancy of the richest billion is 80 years.

We must break out of these deadlocks of globalization. I want to convey this idea that globalization is undeniably progress; there is no other possible strategy than to accept globalization. But because we accept it, we must regulate it and avoid the deadlocks of globalization.

To do this, it seems to me that we can act on three levers:

- First, encourage the development of social protection floors.

I know, I am French, so I am suspect in this regard. I would like to explain myself to you.

I do not believe in a single social model; I have never believed in it. But the crisis has shown us the importance of social protection mechanisms to cushion the effects of the economic crisis.

What I mean is that a social protection floor can be an element of economic development, and I would like to defend this idea. There is not one side social and the other side economy. In a country like France, if we experienced a recession less severe than that of other European countries, practically one of the least severe, it is because we had this social protection system that acted as an economic development system during the crisis. This is a new way of presenting things, but I believe it is interesting and deserves to be shared. Economies perform better when there are effective social protection schemes because they lead to improved employee productivity and foster balanced and sustainable growth. We do not realize it when growth is good, but when things go wrong, we understand what we call the importance of stabilizers. Social protection acts as an economic stabilizer.

I know that building a social protection floor in each country will take time. It is obviously not about imposing the standards and social systems of the richest countries on the poorest countries.

But we must make progress. We have the work of the commission chaired by Ms. BACHELET, which is doing remarkable work with all its members, including Martin HIRSCH, whom I salute. But we must move forward. And sometimes I think I would like the ILO to pound the table harder because I am not sure that through mere courtesy and diplomacy we will ultimately advance at the speed that the crisis demands.

- Next, and I thank Xavier BERTRAND for having initiated it, we must put employment at the heart of our economic choices.

We all agree on the need to promote strong, sustainable, and balanced growth; this is the central objective of the G20.

But are we sure that social policies and employment policies have all the place they deserve in our crisis exit strategies? I do not believe so. The OECD and the ILO have shown in their previous work: if we want to return to the employment level that prevailed before the crisis by 2015, we need to create 110 million jobs across all G20 countries, or 22 million per year to return to the pre-crisis employment level. I am not saying that this will happen just because we put employment at the heart of our crisis exit strategies. But what I do know is that if we do not put it there, it has no chance of happening.

In this area, I want to highlight the important step that has been taken at the European level, dear Christine and dear Laurent, with the pact for the euro.

Building on the expertise of the OECD and the ILO, G20 countries could consider ways to facilitate access to vocational training, the development of apprenticeships, or the anticipation of skills needs and guidance. This must be a major topic for the G20.

All of these questions also bring us back to the measurement of well-being and development in our societies. I want to reiterate my conviction that the GDP instrument cannot summarize our perception of economic and social issues. If we only measure the quantity of growth, we miss a reality. Indicators cannot be solely quantitative indicators. They must also be qualitative indicators.

The recommendations of the STIGLITZ-SEN-FITOUSSI commission and the work of the OECD on new well-being indicators, dear Angel GURIA, must allow us to better take into account the social and environmental dimensions of growth. Simply because if countries that care about social and environmental issues receive no recognition in growth indicators, why would they care about social and environmental issues? Since it would be judged at best by not taking it into account, at worst as a handicap.

- The third lever is that of increased respect for labor rights.

You know my commitment on these issues. The French presidency calls for establishing a system of rules among nations that lifts everyone up; we must refuse competition without rules that would drag everyone down.

And let no one come to accuse us of being against free trade or market economies. With every fiber of my political commitment, I am for free trade and for market economies. But the values that are ours, if that leads to dragging everyone down, are we not going down the wrong path? In that case, let us take the country with the lowest wages and the lowest social protection and align ourselves with it. If we do that, do you believe the world will be happier, more stable, more secure? Can we not aim for upward harmonization? I address the Director-General of the ILO: France cannot accept that the eight ILO conventions on fundamental labor rights are not ratified by all G20 members, who are mostly also ILO members.

I would like to emphasize this point. If a country is a member of an organization, as no one is obliged to be a member of the ILO, and the ILO sets eight standards as a minimum floor for social protection, how can we understand that these eight standards are not ratified by these countries? I ask the Director-General of the ILO to ensure wide publicity for these ILO standards and for their application. This is not a single social model; it is a minimum social floor.

These standards include, for example, the prohibition of child labor and forced labor. Some might think that this is not ambitious enough, but realize, it is a minimum! And now that the ILO is participating in the G20, which France has advocated, I want this question to be clearly posed to the world. Who applies the eight standards? Who ratifies the convention? And who could be against that? No one. Of course, we must put energy into fighting the temptation of protectionism, because that is not the solution, but let us put the same energy into fighting for the application of the eight minimum standards. At that moment, the citizens of the world will understand that globalization can be a progress.

I would like to conclude by saying that it would be counterproductive to fall back into the old debates that would pit the economic dimension against the social dimension of globalization. Each needs the other. I am not naive; this requires giving up certain reflexes, and we will not accomplish everything in one day. The French presidency has thus been able to rely on the work of the summits in Pittsburgh and Washington. We will pass the baton to Mexico. We will involve social partners in the G20 process, because otherwise, it is the very legitimacy of the G20 that would be at stake. This is no small matter. France has done a lot for the creation of the G20, and so you will find no criticism of the G20 in my words. It is wonderful to have a G20 of business leaders, but social partners must be involved in the work of the G20.

The fact that, since Pittsburgh, social partners, employers, and unions have participated in the G20 discussions dedicated to social issues is, in my view, a considerable advance. But now that you are face to face, or side by side, it must produce results.

The conference that brings us together today is important in this regard. For the first time, labor ministers and representatives of social partners will dialogue with leaders of major international organizations to reflect on ways to strengthen the social dimension of globalization.

I hope that your discussions will address all topics, to better reveal the obstacles we will have to overcome. A stronger globalization that benefits workers and social progress is the ambitious roadmap entrusted to you. I will be very attentive to the proposals you make, as will the peoples of the world.

And let no one tell me that it is impossible! It is simply difficult, but if it were not difficult, others would have taken care of it before us. But if you do not take care of it, then we will be in a situation that could become absolutely uncontrollable. That is the issue. Everyone has their ideas, everyone has their constraints; it is difficult for everyone, but by talking to each other, by meeting, by developing strategies, I believe we can legitimize this idea: economic progress and social progress go hand in hand. They are not mutually exclusive.

Let us make an effort towards one another, step out of our usual postures, the free traders without heart or the generous without vision. We are in the 21st century, which will be the century where we turn our backs on ideologies, those ideologies that caused so much harm in the 20th century. Let us be pragmatic and be convinced that the maximum number of citizens of the world must benefit from the economic progress generated by globalization. This is the only possible path for us, and it will be the ambition of the French presidency.

Thank you.