Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, notably on the development of Africa, democratization in Arab countries, the future of the European Union, and the economic and financial crisis, in Paris on August 31, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

31 August 2011 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed French ambassadors in Paris on August 31, 2011, outlining France's foreign policy priorities amid the Arab Spring, African democratic progress, and the European debt crisis.
Main themes
Arab Spring and democratization, African development and democracy, European Union future, economic and financial crisis, French foreign policy, Libya conflict, Côte d'Ivoire crisis, South Sudan independence, Horn of Africa famine, Islam and democracy compatibility, G20 priorities, demographic transitions in Arab world
Duration
~43 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,196
92nd percentile
Sentences
282
94th percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
2.90
34th percentile
Vocabulary
2.28
68th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 49%48%
  • Economic 30%30%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

282 sentences in 116 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Mr. President of the Senate,

Mr. President of the National Assembly,

Mr. Minister of State, Minister of Foreign Affairs and European Affairs,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors,

We are all aware that we are living through an exceptional year marked by the intensity and significance of very different events that have unfolded since January, from the Ivorian crisis to the Arab Spring, from the Japanese disasters to the Libyan clashes, not to mention, of course, the debt crisis.

The time has come to fully grasp these events, what they mean for France, for the European Union, and for the G20.

I am pleased to do so before you, Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors, who have competently implemented and explained our country's actions under the authority of the Minister of State, my friend Alain Juppé.

I want to start with the African continent: 2011 will undoubtedly be recorded in history as the year of major progress for democracy in Africa.

First, in sub-Saharan Africa, with the recognition of President Ouattara's election in Côte d'Ivoire, putting an end to 10 years of strife; in Guinea, with the first democratic election since independence, which saw the victory of President Alpha Condé; in Niger, where, following an exemplary transition, the election of President Issoufou marked the return to constitutional order. In total, throughout sub-Saharan Africa, more than twenty major elections will have taken place throughout the year.

With these democratic advances come those of peace. In Sudan, it is indeed the freely and massively expressed will of all the concerned populations that has put an end to a civil war lasting over 20 years and given birth to a new, still fragile state: South Sudan. These advances make the Somali crisis and the famine affecting the Horn of Africa even more unacceptable. The whole world must mobilize even more to put an end to these tragedies.

The progress of democracy is also accompanied by that of development. For the past 15 years, African economies have experienced growth of over 5% per year. Do we know that from 2001 to 2010, 6 of the 10 fastest-growing economies in the world were African? Do we realize that the continent's population will double by 2050? Africa will then be more populous than China.

For France, these two facts justify that the economic takeoff of Africa becomes a real priority for Europe. The proximity of the African continent is an opportunity for our economies.

This dynamic Africa, France wants to be by its side. It wants to accompany it in its march towards democracy and development. It wants to build with it a balanced and modern partnership. The Charter of French Companies in Africa launched at the Nice Summit, the new defense agreements concluded with certain states—agreements that are finally transparent—have laid the groundwork. We must go even further!

Let us stop only seeing what is going wrong! The African continent is taking off! It is the youth of the world!

In North Africa, it is indeed the youth that kicked off the "Arab Springs." From Tunisia, then Egypt, they spread from the Maghreb to the Mashrek.

What did these young people say, almost in unison? They did not say "down with the West," or "down with America," or "down with Israel." They demanded freedom and democracy, respect and dignity. They showed that, in our connected world, the expectations of peoples are the same in the South and the North of the Mediterranean. They demonstrated that there is no "Arab exception" condemning peoples to dictatorship, but rather universal values.

This democratic earthquake has sometimes been compared to the fall of the Berlin Wall and the collapse of the communist bloc. This is true in terms of historical significance. But I see three differences that make the subsequent events much more complex.

The first difference is demographic. The countries of the Soviet empire had completed their demographic transition. Those in the Arab world are only just beginning it—youth represents nearly two-thirds of the population, bringing millions of often educated young people into the job market each year.

The second difference lies in the disappearance in 1990 of the last of those ideologies that caused the misfortunes of the 20th century, allowing democracy to flourish across the European continent. In the South of the Mediterranean, where religion remains a central reference, the whole issue of the Arab Springs is to show by example that the affirmation of these values is in no way opposed to Islam. Rooting democracy means, of course, organizing free elections, but it also means accepting the alternation of power; it means respecting the rights and choices of individuals and minorities.

The third difference, finally: for the countries of Central and Eastern Europe, the path to follow was clearly laid out: it was European integration. In the South of the Mediterranean, there is nothing of the sort, of course. And this highlights the importance of developing partnerships, in respect of the independence and sovereignty of these states. At the Deauville Summit, the G8 made a strong and long-term commitment, proposing $40 billion to Tunisia and Egypt between 2011 and 2013, as well as the opening of the EBRD and its unique expertise.

Since Deauville, two other countries have joined this partnership, Morocco and Jordan. They demonstrate that genuine reforms can lead to results as significant as revolutions.

It goes without saying that if the new Libya wished to join the Deauville partnership, it would be very welcome! Tomorrow, we will welcome here at the Élysée the new authorities of Tripoli. With all the represented countries, with the UN, the Arab League, the African Union, we will turn the page on dictatorship and fighting and open a new era of cooperation with democratic Libya.

But beyond that, who does not see the relevance of the Union for the Mediterranean to respond to the expectations of the peoples? The time has come to relaunch and refound the UPM, and France will present its proposals to its partners in the coming weeks. The deadlock in the peace process must not prevent the UPM from being the engine of a true renaissance of the Mediterranean!

During these events, France, more than other countries, has been called out and criticized. This is the price of history: here, it did too much, at the risk of being accused of "neo-colonialism"; there, not enough and not quickly enough, and now it is charged with culpable indifference!

With a bit of hindsight, I believe everyone will recognize that France has been the most engaged country, following clear principles—principles that underpin our country's new policy.

An obvious fact, first, that must be recalled: it is the peoples who make history—they alone can take their destiny into their own hands. And while the direction of the movement towards freedom and democracy is predictable, no one can anticipate its triggering, let alone provoke it from the outside.

What is new, after decades during which the stability of the existing regimes prevailed, both in the East and in the South of Europe, is France's determination to accompany the movement of peoples towards democracy.

This is the meaning of our initiatives with the "Deauville Partnership" of the G8 and within the framework of the European Union.

This is also the full meaning of our military actions in Côte d'Ivoire and Libya.

France, and this is its honor, has been able to take the initiative and show the way at two decisive moments: in Côte d'Ivoire first, when the outgoing president, refusing the election results validated by the African Union and the United Nations, sought to maintain himself through terror and massacres; in Libya then, when the populations demanding freedom were threatened with extermination under the fire of Gaddafi's cannons, tanks, and aircraft.

These choices by France were just, politically and morally. We also ensured to act with the full support of the Arab League and our partners in the African Union. And of course, we acted on the basis of an explicit mandate from the United Nations Security Council.

We have advanced the respect for international law—not with words but with actions. By mobilizing the Security Council on these two crises, we have concretized for the first time a principle of action that France succeeded in having adopted by the UN in 2005: the responsibility to protect.

For the first time, at our initiative and on two occasions, in Côte d'Ivoire and Libya, the Security Council authorized the use of force to protect populations victimized by their own leaders. And for the first time, unanimously, the same Council referred the crimes of Libyan leaders to the International Criminal Court.

It is rightly said to us: and the massacres in Syria? I regret that the Security Council still does not assume its responsibilities in the face of the Syrian tragedy. But the power in Damascus would be wrong to believe it is protected from its own people. The Syrian president has committed the irreparable. France, with its partners, will do everything legally possible to ensure that the aspirations of the Syrian people for freedom and democracy prevail.

With the European Union, it has already taken its responsibilities by sanctioning those responsible for the repression in Syria, as it did in Iran when the immense popular movement of 2009 was crushed by force.

Another lesson from our intervention in Libya must be drawn today. I want to talk about France's return to NATO's integrated command. What did I hear when the decision was made! France would lose its independence! Its image would be destroyed in the Third World! In light of the facts, let us note that this has not been the case.

NATO has proven to be an indispensable tool in the service of our military operations. The United States, not wishing to engage strongly in Libya, for the first time since 1949, NATO served a coalition led by two determined European countries, France and the United Kingdom. It was because we had regained our full place in the integrated command that this was possible.

Even better: to those who predicted negative reactions from the Arab world, I remind you that three countries—the United Arab Emirates, Qatar, and Jordan—participated from the outset in the coalition's operations. As for our Libyan friends, they demanded more actions from NATO every day!

The fighting in Libya provided the best response to the prophets of the "clash of civilizations and religions": side by side, Arab, European, and North American forces helped a martyrized people realize its aspirations for freedom.

One last lesson must be drawn from the Libyan crisis, and it concerns Europe. In this crisis, through the initiative of France and the United Kingdom, Europeans demonstrated for the first time that they were capable of intervening decisively, with their allies, in a conflict open at their doors. This is a remarkable progress compared to the wars in Bosnia and Kosovo.

That said, let us not fool ourselves: beyond Libya, Europe is threatened by "strategic shrinkage." What do we see? A continuous decline in defense efforts—the invocation of "soft power" that serves as a facade for renunciation—and, too often, blindness to threats.

However, the world is changing. President Obama has presented a new vision of American military engagement, which implies that Europeans take on more of their responsibilities. If we do not draw the consequences, if we do not take into account the realities of the world, Europeans will prepare for difficult awakenings.

There will be no credible defense in Europe without robust military capabilities and real industrial and technological policies. This is the meaning of the decisions made by the European Council during the French Presidency in 2008 and of the Franco-British partnership. Together, France and the United Kingdom represent half of the budgets and two-thirds of defense research. United as never before since the Lancaster House Treaty, our two countries are practically the only ones in Europe to meet the standard of 2% of GDP dedicated to defense.

Much remains to be done for Europe to live up to the ambition it has set for itself. France, for its part, remains determined to assume all its responsibilities.

This is what we are doing in Afghanistan. We can be proud of the work accomplished over the past three years in Surobi and Kapisa by our soldiers and our cooperators. Ten years after September 11, the progress on the ground and the strengthening of Afghan forces have made it possible to engage the transfer of security responsibilities and to plan the withdrawal of a quarter of our contingent in the coming months. By the end of 2014, Afghan forces will have taken charge of the country's security.

Aware that they can no longer win militarily on the ground, the Taliban are increasingly resorting to acts of terrorism. They strike blindly and hope to bring us to renounce. We will not renounce.

The transition decided by the Afghans and the 48 countries of the coalition will be implemented. It will profoundly change the nature of our engagement with the Afghan people, which will remain essential. We must prepare for this. This will be the subject of the Bonn meeting in December. This is the meaning of the Franco-Afghan Treaty that we agreed upon with President Karzai.

We will thus be able to support the efforts of national reconciliation with the insurgents who renounce terrorism and respect the Constitution. This reconciliation will only be possible if neighboring countries respect the sovereignty and security of Afghanistan.

But let us be clear: progress in Afghanistan does not mark the end of the terrorist threat. The death of Osama bin Laden is a great victory for which we must congratulate President Obama. But Al-Qaeda, even weakened, remains present. This is particularly true in Pakistan, whose evolution is concerning. It is also true in the Arab world and in Africa. Vigilance is more necessary than ever, and the French authorities remain fully mobilized to secure the release of all our hostages.

The other country I want to talk about is Iran. Its military, nuclear, and ballistic ambitions pose a growing threat. They could also lead to a preemptive strike against Iranian sites, which would trigger a major crisis. Iran refuses to negotiate seriously and engages in new provocations. In response to this challenge, the international community can provide a credible answer if it demonstrates unity, firmness, and imposes even tougher sanctions. We would be wrong to underestimate the effects: they are becoming increasingly noticeable.

This context of hope with the Arab springs, but also of threats from the Sahel to Iran, does not diminish the relevance of old crises, starting with the Israeli-Arab conflict. On the contrary, it makes resolving it more urgent.

The only true security is peace. It is primarily through the creation of a Palestinian state that we will achieve it. And Israel, whose right to exist and to security is inalienable, will be the first beneficiary.

The parameters for resolution are known: President Obama recently reiterated them very well. It is on this basis that the peace negotiation must be relaunched, and each party must understand that it is in its interest.

In the event of failure, in a few weeks in New York, the member states of the United Nations will have to vote on the State of Palestine. I hope that the 27 countries of the European Union will speak with one voice, and that together we will assume our responsibilities. France is working on this.

But whatever the outcome of this vote, we will then find ourselves facing a peace process to be rebuilt. I therefore wish that before embarking on a new cycle of fruitless attempts and missed appointments, we seriously question the negotiation method. I have already had the opportunity to say it: it must change.

The role of the United States is undeniable and irreplaceable, but everyone can see that it is not sufficient. We need to broaden the circle of negotiation, reflect on the role and relevance of the Quartet, and give everyone their rightful place according to their relations with the parties. Let us keep in mind that the European Union is Israel's largest economic partner and the largest donor to the Palestinians.

France will make specific proposals on this subject to the main actors in the region, to the United States, and of course to its European partners. The prolonged and dangerous deadlock of the peace process, as well as the developments in the Arab world, underscore the urgent necessity of this.

Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors,

To exert its full political weight in world affairs, the European Union must first remain the leading economic power. To do this, Europeans must resolutely pursue the actions they have undertaken to restore their accounts and strengthen their growth.

The euro is a major issue: let us not forget that it represents nearly 30% of global foreign exchange reserves. In 10 years, it has established itself as a strong and stable currency. The eurozone is not the sick man that some describe, but rather a zone of wealth and prosperity—a key pole of the global economy—a mobilizing project that structures European construction.

The crisis we are experiencing affects all advanced economies. It is the direct consequence of the financial and economic crises of 2008 and 2009. The decisions we made then, in Europe and at the G20, to save the global financial system and to revive growth were essential to avoid a dramatic collapse. But they have led to an increase in deficits and public debts.

The situation is, moreover, less concerning in the eurozone than elsewhere: public debt there reaches 85% of GDP compared to 100% in the United States, or 200% in Japan—and the actions to control public deficits are more effective there: in 2012, the public deficit of the eurozone as a percentage of GDP will be lower than that of the United States, the United Kingdom, or Japan.

Nevertheless, several countries in the eurozone are experiencing excessive debt and loss of competitiveness. Remarkable progress is underway in Ireland and Portugal. I also want to commend the efforts of the Greek people and the determination of their government.

Beyond these countries, we experienced an unprecedented speculative wave targeting Spain and Italy over the summer, while the fundamentals of these two economies did not justify such attacks. I want to commend the courageous measures taken by these two countries.

I want to tell speculators that we will not let them run rampant without reacting. We will take all necessary measures to strengthen the eurozone. For in defending the euro, we are defending Europe, but also our prosperity, savings, and the purchasing power of the French.

Let us be clear: what this crisis has also highlighted are the shortcomings of our economic and monetary union. It is clear that the single currency must be accompanied by deeper integration of our economies, increased coordination of our economic and budgetary policies, and a coherent institutional architecture that allows us to make the necessary decisions effectively.

Over the past year, significant progress has been made in this direction:

Thanks to the strengthening of the Stability and Growth Pact, which increases budgetary discipline and coordination of macroeconomic policies.

Thanks to the adoption of a Pact for the euro, which will mobilize our resources to increase our competitiveness.

Finally, thanks to the establishment of the foundations of a true European Monetary Fund, with the strengthening of the current European Financial Stability Facility and the creation of the future European Stability Mechanism, as France has demanded.

These advances are major. They were unimaginable just 18 months ago. The crisis context has not yet allowed us to fully appreciate them, especially since their first effects will only be noticeable in a few weeks or months.

But we must go further. True to their historic mission and aware of their responsibilities, France and Germany have jointly taken initiatives during my meeting on August 16 with Chancellor Merkel.

We propose that the eurozone be based on two pillars:

The first pillar is a true economic government: it will be embodied in a summit of heads of state and government of the eurozone that will meet at least twice a year, and more if necessary. It will have a stable president appointed for two and a half years. This is an old request from France: it will soon be a reality.

The second pillar is increased coordination and surveillance of economic policies within the eurozone: beyond the advances I mentioned, France and Germany want all eurozone states to enshrine a rule of balanced public finances in their Constitution. This is an essential element to ensure, in the long term, the credibility of our European commitments regarding public finances. Through this issue, it is the effectiveness and credibility of the action of states, of all states in the eurozone, that is at stake.

Finally, France and Germany have decided to strengthen their economic integration. We will make progress towards fiscal convergence by working on a common corporate tax whose rates and bases will be harmonized by 2013.

The 50th anniversary of the Élysée Treaty, in January 2013, should be an opportunity to take a new decisive step towards the convergence of our economies in the service of growth and employment.

After the euro, the greatest European achievement is undoubtedly the free movement within the Schengen area. But, let us say it plainly, the removal of internal borders is only viable if the external border, now common, is secure. Let us not be mistaken: in the face of migratory pressure, if the external border of the Schengen area is not maintained, the Schengen area will not survive.

It is to preserve Schengen that France has proposed to develop the joint management of the external border. We must strengthen European instruments, such as Frontex. We must establish an effective inspection system. We must be able to restore border controls of a state if it is unable to ensure the guarding of its portion of the external border. These innovations, requested by France, have been approved by the European Council. They must now be implemented through the adoption, notably in the European Parliament, of the necessary legal texts. On this fundamental issue, everyone must take their responsibilities.

Beyond the euro and Schengen, the European Union must strengthen its action in several areas of major importance:

I am thinking of agriculture and food security, which are two priorities of our action within Europe, but also for the G20 in Cannes.

I am thinking of industrial policy, which is no longer a taboo subject among the 27.

I am thinking of international trade, which must be based on a simple principle: that of reciprocity and fairness in exchanges.

On all these subjects, Europe must take the initiative. If it is united and determined, it has every chance of being heard because it represents 30% of global GDP and 60% of public development aid.

Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors,

For 60 years, the European Union has been inventing a new form of collegial governance based on the practice of compromise. Today, it is still Europe that remains the main driving force for building the world order of the 21st century, often at the initiative of France.

It was France that proposed the creation of the G7/G8 in 1975—it is also France that, on behalf of the Union, suggested in 2008 the convening of the summit that would become the G20. It is France that has the honor of presiding over the G8 and G20 this year. However, experience shows: these two informal groups are the only ones capable of providing the necessary impetus to address the global problems of our time and to establish a fairer and more effective world order.

What was said when we proposed the working themes of the two summits! Excessive ambition! Unacceptable interference in an Internet that would develop perfectly on its own! Interventionist intent regarding raw material markets, which would have no operational problems!

Today, no one contests the proposed themes.

At the G8 Summit in Deauville, the results were there, whether regarding partnerships with Africa and the "Arab springs" or regarding the Internet: for the first time, the heads of state of the main concerned countries adopted a joint declaration that establishes the principles for the development of this major phenomenon of our time. I hope that the American presidency of the G8 next year will allow for further progress.

The G20 Summit in Cannes, in two months, will be a crucial moment to mark new progress in economic and financial cooperation among partners representing 85% of global GDP.

In the face of the sovereign debt crisis, concerns for global growth, market instability, and volatility in raw material prices, international cooperation within the G20 is even more necessary today than it was in 2008.

Our primary objective is to consolidate the recovery of the global economy. Growth is essential to create jobs, lift billions of human beings out of poverty, and reduce deficits and debts.

Markets have lost their compass: they demand both a reduction in deficits and debts, but are immediately concerned about the impact of deficit reduction on growth.

Austerity policies at the global level would be worse than evil. They would threaten recovery and risk plunging us back into recession. The reduction of deficits and debts, which is essential, must be gradual and above all credible. Rather than immediate spending cuts that would weigh on growth, we must undertake the necessary reforms to strengthen the sustainability of our public finances in the medium term. This is the very purpose of the pension reform we have conducted in France. Above all, our strategies must be credible: they must fit within medium-term frameworks such as the golden rule, already adopted according to IMF figures, by 80 countries around the world.

This strategy will only be possible if accompanied by a rebalancing of global demand and growth. Emerging countries, in this context, have a very important role to play. Consider that in China, private consumption accounts for only 35% of GDP compared to 60% in the euro area and 70% in the United States!

To reduce global imbalances, it is essential that these countries rebalance their development model towards domestic demand. This is a question I discussed in a positive atmosphere with President Hu last week during my visit to Beijing.

What we want is for the G20 to agree in Cannes on an action plan for growth, including specific and concrete commitments from the major economies.

The issue of macroeconomic imbalances cannot be separated from the reform of the international monetary system. This issue has been at the heart of the debates over the past year: some have even spoken of a currency war. Everyone feels today that the absence of a balanced and representative international monetary system is costly for the global economy. Since the Nanjing symposium, we have made a lot of progress. We now have a precise and concrete agenda defined by the French Presidency.

The international monetary system must first and foremost be more representative of the current global economy. The SDR must be able to include new currencies. We must then strengthen our instruments to combat financial crises. IMF surveillance must be enhanced, and we must equip it with the necessary means to address systemic crises. Isn't it time to consider that surplus countries could invest part of their reserves in the IMF to strengthen its resources? Finally, we must reach common recommendations on the management of capital flows.

I hope that on all these subjects, finance ministers can come up with concrete proposals in view of the Cannes Summit.

I also spoke to you last year about the regulation of commodity markets. The action plan adopted in June by the G20 Agriculture Ministers addresses the main challenge: that of production. The famine in the Horn of Africa, treated urgently with the FAO, as well as the suffering of nearly one billion humans victims of permanent malnutrition, are scandals; but these scandals will only cease when the world reinvests massively in agricultural production.

An ambitious agenda for market transparency and regulation of derivatives is also necessary. We need to define rules for agricultural derivative markets comparable to those in place for financial markets, with penalties for abuses of dominant position.

The French Presidency has sought to make development a major priority of the G20. This is a condition of its legitimacy. But it is also and above all in everyone's interest to reduce poverty and the development gaps between nations. The Cannes Summit will focus on food security and on concrete infrastructure projects.

But I also wanted the G20 to talk about development financing. In the face of the difficulties of developed countries to increase public aid and the scale of the challenges to be met in the most vulnerable countries, everyone knows that innovative financing is a necessity. I have long advocated for the creation of a tax on financial transactions. During my meeting with Chancellor Merkel on August 16, we decided that France and Germany would make a proposal to their European partners in September. Our goal is for Europe to set an example of what can be done, so that others rally to this initiative in Cannes. I hope you will be very active in the next two months to advocate for this idea in the countries where you are stationed. France is and will remain at the forefront of the fight for the poorest.

In Cannes, it is also the new world order that will progress. The legitimacy of the G20 comes from its effectiveness, from its ability to decide. But the implementation of the decisions made necessarily involves the organizations that bring together the entire community of nations.

The reforms, to be completed, of international financial institutions must be complemented by those of other organizations that have the responsibility to implement the G20's decisions: the WTO, the ILO, the FAO, to name just three examples. And thus, gradually, the entire multilateral system born in 1945 will adapt to the demands of the 21st century by better integrating social progress and environmental protection into global governance.

Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors,

Globalization is the dominant phenomenon of our time. Its effects now extend to all fields of activity, to all spaces of our planet. The interconnection of economic, financial, social, political, and ecological systems on a global scale that results from this is accompanied by increasing instability and growing vulnerabilities.

In the face of these risks, there is only one possible response: solidarity and a spirit of responsibility. This is the path that France proposes to its partners in the European Union and the G20. With one conviction: if we were disunited, unable to make the necessary decisions, we would head straight towards dramatic consequences for all.

United, Europeans can, on the contrary, make their Union a pole of wealth and unparalleled influence.

United, the G20 countries can establish the new global governance and the essential rules to make the 21st century an unprecedented century of shared prosperity.

Thank you.