Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on actions in favor of industry in France, in Marignane on March 4, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

4 March 2010 · Statement on actions in favour of industry in France · Marignane, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed an industrial policy gathering in Marignane on March 4, 2010, presenting measures to reverse France's deindustrialization and strengthen its industrial base.
Main themes
French industrial policy, deindustrialization, industrial competitiveness, trade balance, job losses in industry, economic growth, 35-hour workweek impact, general assemblies on industry, Germany and Italy comparison, reindustrialization strategy
Duration
~48 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,716
93rd percentile
Sentences
345
96th percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
9.2
13th percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 76%75%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

345 sentences in 60 paragraphs

Dear Christine LAGARDE, Dear Christian ESTROSI,

Mr. Mayor of Marseille, Dear Jean-Claude GAUDIN,

Presidents of the region and the department,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

France must remain a great industrial nation. It owes this to its history, it owes it to its economy, it owes it to its people.

We, the French, have been pioneers in this field, pioneers of the industrial revolution. Our history includes men like Denis Papin, Clément Ader, Gustave Eiffel, Marcel Dassault, our great inventors, our captains of industry, thousands of anonymous working families who have written great pages of our history of France and founded industrial France.

I have a deep conviction that a country without industry has nothing to sell and ultimately ends up impoverished. I contest the idea that we should give absolute priority to services and abandon industry because the day industry is gone, for whom will services work? All the nations that are developing today base their growth on industrial development.

The unions proposed that we organize a general assembly on industry. I announced its launch in September because it had become urgent, in truth, to start from scratch in reflecting on the state of industry in our country.

These general assemblies were a first. Why a first, by the way? Because for too long in France, industry has been equated with pollution, factories with inconveniences. And we have forgotten to make the French love industry. And we had not conducted a comprehensive reflection on the future of industry. We had not ensured that the debate on the future of industry permeated all of society.

France will not have sustainable growth without a strong industry.

The general assemblies on industry were a great success, for which I want to congratulate Christian ESTROSI. The national committee conducted a very thorough reflection, driven by the momentum of its president whom I want to thank, Jean-François DEHECQ.

And in essence, the crisis served as a trigger, because after the violent blows it dealt to our factories, we can clearly see that we cannot remain without reacting. I still tell the representatives of business leaders, dear Laurence PARISOT, that even without the crisis, it would have been necessary to organize the general assemblies. That the crisis is a revealer but that we should have been concerned about the future of industry long before because deindustrialization began before the crisis.

I will cite figures that are indisputable. I ask you to reflect on them; it is my duty to confront France with realities to live in the real world and not in a virtual one.

France began to massively deindustrialize starting in the year 2000. It is very simple: since that date, we have lost half a million jobs in industry. I present these figures, and those who disagree should contradict me, and I would be very happy to respond. Half a million jobs in industry lost. Today, industry employs 13% of the French active population; it was still 16% ten years ago. We are, worse, the largest European country that is the most deindustrialized. To those who would tell me that this is a phenomenon affecting all countries, no. Industry produces 16% of French added value compared to 23% in Italy and 30% in Germany. Can you explain to me what is the fatality that makes the share of added value produced by industry in Germany twice as large as in France? And that our Italian friends are doing so much better than us?

In 2007, our trade balance excluding energy became negative for the first time in 20 years! And our share of European exports has decreased by a quarter since the year 2000, in European exports, that is to say simply in relation to our European neighbors. I am not talking about China, I am not talking about India, I am not talking about Mexico, I am not talking about Brazil. We have lost a quarter in European exports since the year 2000.

I am sorry for these figures, but they are relentless. So from that moment on, you understand the importance I attach to this visit here today in Marignane and to industry. I am told, "Oh, you are coming because there are elections!" You really have to understand nothing about the situation... First of all, in France, there are always elections, so if we take care of industry when there are no elections, frankly, stay in the situation you are in and wait. You will wait a long time! I believe that there is no fatality; I believe that our country has deliberately hindered its own industrial development for years. I say it, it is serious, but I stand by what I say. I try to look at the situation as it is, face to face. Yes, we have hindered our industrial development first with the 35-hour workweek, even if this truth does not please everyone, I respect everyone's opinion, but when we imposed the 35 hours only on French industries and companies, we should not be surprised by the result we obtained! When you impose in a globalized world, in a company like this one that exports 65% of its production, when you expose your companies and your industries, you should not be surprised. That the whole world has decided to do 35 hours, why not, but when we are the only ones, who benefited? Our neighbors. And who was penalized? Our workers. When it is necessary to put the dots on the "i" regarding convictions of such importance, I believe that we have a duty, we the state officials, the political leaders, to tell the truth.

And we have a second problem, the rate of payroll taxes which is unique in Europe. This question of financing our entire social protection solely on the value of work is an unavoidable subject. If we increase the cost of labor, we will relocate work. And do not look any further, my desire to refuse tax increases is because it is not the solution, as it will increase the cost of labor and we will relocate work. And then I must say a third thing, I take my share of responsibility in this, an accumulation of uncontrolled regulations in all areas.

So in addition to that, Jean-François DEHECQ diagnoses it, we have an industry that innovates too little, 7% of our added value compared to more than 10% in all countries where industry is strong, Germany, Sweden, or Finland. You know, it is not necessary to reinvent the wheel; we just need to draw inspiration from what those for whom industry is a priority have done.

Our industry innovates too little but it invests too little. Industrial investment in France has decreased by 35% between 2000 and 2009. And before the crisis, it had already decreased. I take an example, the automotive industry, it represents 10% of the French active population, I speak broadly - that is to say, the dealers, the resellers... I am not just talking about those who manufacture. Do you hear this well? In France, investment in the automotive industry has decreased every year, without exception, since 2000. I cannot accept this, especially with a French manufacturer of which the State is the largest shareholder.

So, the economic policy we have been pursuing since 2007, Dear Christine LAGARDE, makes the recovery of industry an absolute priority, absolute. Because I understand well that people say, "Yes, well, speeches are not what will revive industry." That is for sure. What have we tried to do?

The research tax credit at 30%. The research tax credit, two-thirds of the research tax credit goes to industry. And thanks to the research tax credit, you know the controversy over the famous TEPA, well in the TEPA, there was the research tax credit. Well, thanks to TEPA, thanks to the research tax credit raised to 30%, R&D spending in French industry did not decrease during the crisis. So it works. The other day, I was talking with the Minister of Budget, he said to me, "Oh dear, if you knew what the research tax credit costs me," I said to him, "Good! 2 billion 200 million, good because it proves that it works! If we reimburse, it proves... Because finally, French industries are reinvesting in France!

The abolition of the professional tax means 2 billion euros less in taxation for industry per year. My dear compatriots, ladies and gentlemen, the professional tax only existed in France. For a company like Eurocopter, it is a little less than 5 million euros in levies per year. What sense can there be in wanting to defend industry and keeping the professional tax? I say this to my friends as well as to those who are not! I know that by abolishing the professional tax, I did not please everyone. But you know why I chose industries over local authorities? I will tell you. Because industries can relocate, local authorities cannot. And that is a significant difference! Oh, I have had debates, and my friend Jean-Claude GAUDIN has helped me so much in the Senate, I have had debates, but a choice had to be made. And I also tell elected officials, the day there are no more factories, no more companies in France, who will come to pay the professional tax? You will lose it from the base! It should not be surprising that it is the people from Moselle who go to work in Luxembourg and not the Luxembourgers who work in Moselle, that it is the people from Savoie who go to work in Switzerland and not the Swiss who come to work in France. Because if we continue to tax our individuals and our companies more heavily in France than our neighbors, then it is growth, added value, and business creation that will go to our neighbors rather than coming to us. Well, this policy is irresponsible!

Furthermore, we have taken a number of measures to support the equity of companies, the ISF scheme...

The national loan, ladies and gentlemen, will allocate 6.5 billion euros specifically to industry, in automotive, aeronautics, digital, health, and green chemistry.

I also do not forget the competitiveness clusters that we created with Christian ESTROSI. I do not forget the autonomy of universities. You know for me, as Head of State, when I see that Paris VII has been able to attract an American Nobel Prize to its university, I say to myself finally something is happening in French universities! Since I have been in politics, for how many years? I see our best students, our best researchers, our best teachers leaving for abroad. It pleases me when I see foreign teachers, researchers, Nobel Prize winners coming to France! And this has been initiated by the autonomy of universities.

So the General Assemblies have recalled a number of things, and we need to ensure follow-up and consequences.

The central issue of French social charges. All border industrialists will tell you, at the Swiss, German, Belgian, Spanish border: on the other side of the border, the same employee earns more and costs less.

So I know well that we have the system of social charge reductions. Dear Laurence PARISOT. But I note that the current system of charge reductions benefits industry little, because industrial wages far exceed the minimum wage. The manufacturing industry represents 21.2% of the wage bill but receives only 14.7% of the charge reductions. So it is the sectors most exposed to international competition that benefit the least from charge reductions. Look for the error! And I tell parliamentarians and social partners, we will have to work on this issue. You understand well that my idea is not to call into question the charge reductions, which cost the state budget very dearly, but at least that these charge reductions go first to our companies most exposed to competition. And you see, 21% of wages is the manufacturing industry, 14.7% of charge reductions for them.

We cannot remain deaf to these truths any longer. The financing method of our social protection is a major issue; we need to deepen our reflection on this question. We must not confuse speed with haste, but we can no longer continue to base our entire system exclusively on the taxation of labor with the risks of relocation that this poses.

I wish for a national conference on industry to meet regularly to extend, dear Jean-François DEHECQ, the work of the general assemblies. We need a body that brings together companies, employees, sectors, and the Government at regular intervals to specifically address the problems of industry.

I think, for example, of the frenzy of regulatory machinery. Public administrations are so eager to engage with industry that they invent new constraints for it every day. Therefore, we will launch an examination mission of the regulatory framework for industry starting this March, and in September 2010 we will propose concrete measures for relief and simplification. It is not possible to continue like this. Each Ministry has its own idea, each Ministry complicates the production process in our country. And Presidents EMORINE and OLLIER will also be able to address this issue in order to help us lighten this regulatory framework. Furthermore, I announce that we will invest 500 million euros from the national loan to support companies' investments in improving their production tools, particularly to make them less polluting. This does not mean giving up on environmental preservation, but we will put half a billion euros to help you bring your factories up to standard.

We will also create a strategic reflection and exchange body for each major sector. We saved the automotive industry because we thought about the automotive sector. I ask Christian ESTROSI, along with the major players in each sector, large companies, subcontractors, and competitiveness clusters, to establish and lead these strategic committees. The Ministry of Industry must be able to finance and provide precise analyses for each sector. Three hundred million euros from the national loan will be specifically dedicated to investing in this sector policy. Understand me well, if General DE GAULLE had not wanted nuclear energy, there would be no nuclear energy today. If the State had not invested to become a 33% owner of the Chantiers de l'Atlantique, there would be no shipbuilding in France. And if in 2004 I had not bought 22% of Alstom, there would be no high-speed train manufacturing in our country. I am not saying that we need to be present in all major sectors, I am saying that we will put 300 million euros from the grand loan so that sector by sector, with your minister, you can look at what you need and what we will do to help you.

So I would like to say a word about the relationship between our great industrial champions, dear Louis GALLOIS, and SMEs. In the most successful sectors of neighboring countries, the relationship between the prime contractor and subcontractor is a long-term partnership based on trust and innovation. The prime contractor does not simply pressure prices; on the contrary, it helps its subcontractor acquire the methods and tools necessary to progress, for example, through robotization or a new organization of work. I fear that in French groups, we have allowed the purchasing management to obsessively focus on price, with a scandalous, sometimes open, encouragement of relocation. I will not accept this, because it is deadly for the future of our industry. I have countless examples of large groups that exert such pressure on their subcontractors. What do you want to do when you have 50 or 100 people in the company and a single client who has been led to relocate because they were asked to!

We need to change things. I do not believe we will do it by increasing regulations. I want the Government to establish, and I say this to the head of the CGPME, Jean-Marc ROUBAUD, a mediator for subcontracting modeled after the credit mediator. Listen, the credit mediator, René RICOL, has done remarkable work; it has helped unblock cases. This is not a question of law; it is a question of a door you can knock on to find someone who can help you. I want a mediator for subcontracting. Subcontractors must be respected and valued; we cannot destroy the fabric of French SMEs; we must help them.

So he will, of course, work in a network with the internal mediators of large groups and the credit mediation. I ask Christian ESTROSI and Christine LAGARDE to do this by the end of March.

Furthermore, we need to evolve European policy. I know from experience that it is difficult. Finally, when I look at China, Brazil, India, and the United States, they are not ashamed to have an industrial policy. It is only in France that we say, "Oh my, this President is interventionist!" But what are we talking about? Do you think the Chinese do not care about the future of their industry? And do you think the world's most liberal nation, the United States, does not care about the state of its industry? That Mr. OBAMA is not behind Boeing or so many others? It is only here that we are surprised that a President of the Republic is interested in industry and wants to defend it. I will ask Herman VAN ROMPUY and Manuel BARROSO to take initiatives for a genuine European industrial policy.

The time is ripe; we just need to think it through. I want the conception of European competition to evolve first. There is a European market, so competition must be analyzed in light of the European market and not in light of each of the 27 markets. Otherwise, how can we create large European groups? What is the large group in the world that can conquer export markets without being dominant in its domestic market? And what is the point of having created a European market if we analyze competition as the French market, the German market, the British market? This is a major error. We need a European industry. Therefore, we need to analyze market shares to free up competition in light of the European market. I add that it is still unbelievable that Europe prohibits support for exporting industries. Europe prohibits it! But its Asian competitors deploy massive funding on their own territory as well as in global markets. Go ask President JINTAO if he does not support his companies!

After losing the competition for consumer goods, Europe is now competing for major contracts.

We cannot be the only economic zone in the world that unilaterally applies the precepts of free trade in complete ignorance of the behavior of its major competitors. All major countries now require a significant portion of their production to be localized on their territory in every major contract. The United States has imposed that a majority of the expenditures of their stimulus plan benefit American companies. China only accepts foreign technologies after an audit so thorough that they have no secrets left for the Government.

If Europe is sincerely for free trade, it must not accept these practices and must give itself the means to enforce the rules. The best situation for everyone, Mr. President, would of course be that markets are open on both sides, but the worst situation for Europe is one where its market is open while others are closed to it. Therefore, we must strengthen Europe's anti-dumping arsenal and apply a general principle of reciprocity regarding standards. Christine LAGARDE will make specific proposals to the European Commission in the next three months to act in this direction. You have understood well, France is not for protectionism; France demands reciprocity.

Environmental policy is a major issue. Europe, to date, is the only major economic zone to have established binding rules for reducing greenhouse gas emissions, but if it is the only one imposing this burden on its industry, Europe will soon have no industry left. This does not mean it will deprive itself of steel, fertilizers, or cement. But steel, fertilizers, and cement will be produced elsewhere, under more polluting conditions than here. We will have therefore relocated emissions and imported unemployment. I do not accept this reasoning; I will never accept it. We must therefore make carbon pay for imports when they come from countries that do not make efforts. We will do this at the same price and under the same conditions as for our own industries, in full compliance with WTO rules. France demands a carbon tax at the borders of Europe. I will actually go further. What is the point of imposing traceability rules and very strict animal welfare conditions on our farmers while massively importing meat into Europe from countries that ignore food safety and traceability of farms? It makes no sense. We must refuse this evolution.

Finally, we must address the issue of currencies and exchange rates. There was a time—I believe it was Mr. JOSPIN who said this: "A politician who talks about currency is an irresponsible person." I do not want to misrepresent him. I apologize if it was not him, but I believe it was. But why? I do not understand. We had an euro at 1.50 dollars for months. Now, for all of French aeronautics, I speak under the control of Louis GALLOIS, we manufacture in the euro zone and sell in the dollar zone. This means that our industrialists have lost, roughly speaking, 50% of competitiveness and productivity due to the perfectly artificial reason of the dollar's degradation compared to the euro's revaluation. This is unacceptable. No one can resist it. And if we accept this, it means that soon we will no longer be able to manufacture airplanes, helicopters, cars, or trains in the euro zone because we will be robbed by monetary disruptions that paralyze our industry and our companies. This is unacceptable; it is unacceptable!

We need a new Bretton Woods. Bretton Woods was in 1945, which is quite normal; the first nation in the world, the United States of America, had won the war. There was the Marshall Plan. We needed a single currency just as there was a single power. Who can say that in the 21st century—Bretton Woods was 65 years ago—the global monetary system does not need to be rethought? Who can say that there are no new currencies that have come to the forefront of the global economic scene, like the yuan, for example? Therefore, as the president of the G20 and G8 at the end of the year, France will propose the organization of a new international monetary system. Moreover, I would like to tell you that when we say, "My God! My God! The euro is very weak at 1.36!" frankly, talk to industrialists to find out if it is very weak. There is a significant issue here to establish parity and equity in international exchanges, and once again, I do not see on what grounds political leaders cannot talk about currencies. I observe that when there was a crisis that nearly swept the entire world, those who said that we should not talk about currency, I am talking about bankers, suddenly found the address of political leaders. Similarly, we have been told for years that companies no longer have a nationality. But when the crisis hit, they did not get the wrong counter. I do not say this to be unpleasant; I say it because it cannot be that there is no nationality when everything is going well and that there is a nationality when money is needed, because at that moment, it is not fair. There is an element: global companies. It did not matter where they were located, and when the crisis hit, everyone remembered their country, and no one got it wrong.

We will create a tool immediately aimed at relocating industrial production in France: We will create a relocation bonus in the form of 200 million euros in repayable advances financed by the national loan.

I want that with everything we have done, companies relocated in France receive a bonus, are supported, and are encouraged. In truth, all of this aims to reconcile France with its industry.

I would also like to make a suggestion: why not resurrect the France brand, "made in France"? Is it so bothersome for consumers to know when they buy a product whether it is made here or elsewhere? There is no protectionism in this; it is transparency. I want us to be able to see what is made in France and what is not. I think this is very important for a number of our compatriots.

I also want the industry to reach out to the youth. That factories open their doors to high school students and that industrialists come into classrooms to present their profession, in connection with economics or technology lessons. That we set up a senior-junior tutoring system, where experienced employees can dedicate 20% of their working time to training young people in these professions.

The State will also profoundly review its role as a shareholder in major industrial companies. Frankly, the representation of the State in companies of which it is the owner or co-owner is a major issue. And I do not share the choices that have been made. Let me explain: when the State is an owner, it is represented by such and such a person, excellent in their own right, representing the technocracy of the Budget or the technocracy of this or that administration. I want administrators who play their role, who are passionate about industry. I want the ministers, particularly the Minister of Industry, to have discussions twice a year with the leaders appointed by the State about investment strategy when the State is a shareholder in a company.

I do not accept, I want to say, because this is what I believe deep down, that the large French private automotive group PSA has two-thirds of its workforce in France and that the other car manufacturer has only one-third of its workforce in France, while the State owns 15%. Let it be understood, creating factories abroad is fine with me to gain market share, but manufacturing cars abroad to bring them back to France causes pollution, and I do not accept that. Otherwise, why did the State invest 6 billion euros to help the French automotive sector survive? There is a question of balance and choice in the administrators.

For all these years, I do not blame anyone, but how is it that the State has allowed this to happen? There are administrators on the Board of Directors. They are not there simply for the attendance fees or to see how much profit we make at the end of the year, but to establish a genuine industrial policy: what about electric cars? Where will the Clio 4 be produced? These are still national issues. You cannot blame me for being concerned about this. It is not because I am President of the Republic; it is because the State owns 15% of a large company. It is the largest shareholder! So if the State does not take care of its company, it should sell its shares! But it cannot stay inside and not take care of it. That makes no sense. It lacks coherence and logic.

I know there will be debates: "Is he liberal? Is he Colbertist? Is he interventionist? Is he socialist?" No, that is not possible. It is not a question of ideology; it is a question of pragmatism. Others do it, my dear compatriots; if we do not do it, we will wipe our industry off the map, and we do not have time to react. The world is moving much faster than we imagine. A strategic mistake is paid for immediately. While a good decision takes years to produce its effects. We cannot delay the moment of choice. I also wish that in this policy of choosing administrators, we recover to defend the interests of the State, industrialists who have had significant experience and can provide us with their advice.

The French Agency for State Holdings manages very well; it manages from a patrimonial perspective. But I want the representatives of the State as a shareholder to manage industrially, strategically, to have a vision, and to defend their ideas. We cannot simply say, as in Vilvoorde, we cannot do anything! Because if we cannot do anything, we will despair the people. They did not vote for us, whatever our responsibilities, to say: "We cannot do anything, we give up, we do nothing." The future of the Chantiers de l'Atlantique concerns me. The future of CMA-CGM concerns me. The fact that the German postal service created DHL and is one of the most modern companies in Europe concerns me, and it played a role in the change of status of the Post Office. The development of freight for the SNCF is a subject that concerns us. We have the best social security system in the world; I say this in front of Jean-François DEHECQ, it is not for us to let the entire pharmaceutical industry leave. Otherwise, what is the point? What will be the future of our children? Where will you work? What will happen in our country? We cannot simply have green spaces, public gardens, and museums. Of course, we need... In this beautiful region. I would even say tourism. Tourism cannot be a mono-activity. I have seen it, particularly in the most rural departments, where there are no more farmers, there is no development of tourism. Because we need a production activity that goes hand in hand with a tourist activity. It is a considerable issue.

I will conclude by apologizing for being too long, but you understand, I am passionate about these issues. There is the problem of mobilizing the savings of the French for industry. Life insurance, which is one of the investments most supported by the State, invests less than 25% in stocks. This is the height of inconsistency. Let me explain. Life insurance consists of the State providing tax advantages to attract long-term savings. The main provisions, I believe, are that before eight years, you have the right to use your savings, but it has tax consequences after eight years. But of this savings, only a quarter goes to the stock market. And if we follow the new regulations, it will be even worse. I want to tell Christine how much I support her in her fight to evolve this at the global level.

But I want us to be able to attract capital for our companies and for our industry. There have been proposals made, dear Jean-François DEHECQ. I promised the social partners to discuss with them: should we have an industrial savings account? I want to say that all of this, by September, we will have decided. There will be a new savings vehicle to finance industry.

Let things be very clear; this is an absolutely major issue, and Christine LAGARDE will open this project to propose a new tax framework by summer that will clearly encourage savings to be directed towards equity financing for companies. I am talking about an industrial savings account; it does not matter, see with the social partners what is best. We need to do something.

I will conclude with innovation to say just one thing: I will never touch the massive support policy for innovation that I have built since 2004. I say this to business leaders. It is cardinal for me; you can go ahead; we will defend this framework.

I will simply announce two measures that will complement it: First, I want to reform the absurd tax framework on patent income, which encourages the exploitation of our patents in foreign subsidiaries rather than in France. Have we seen anything more coherent? We will do this right away. Secondly, I believe, Jean-François ROUBAUD, that it is important to make the early reimbursement of the research tax credit permanent for SMEs. This is something very important for your cash flow. Frankly, I want to tell you that the early reimbursement was not designed to be structural but to respond to the acute cash flow crisis of companies in 2009. That said, we have seen how much the early reimbursement of the research tax credit has amplified the positive effect of the research tax credit for small businesses, whose characteristic, dear Laurence PARISOT, is that they are constantly in search of cash flow. We will therefore make the early reimbursement of the research tax credit permanent for SMEs.

Ladies and gentlemen, it is far from my intention to say that we have solved all the problems of industry. I was reading, on the plane this morning, a rather well-done article that said: "Yes, yes, in fact, it is a difference in culture and tradition; others have always been more industrial or not." Move along, there is nothing to see. No, first of all, because France has an industrial tradition, and I do not see why we should abandon it. I want to say how much we have martyrs in Lorraine during the steel crisis in the 1960s, to explain to Lorraine that there was too much steel and that the future was not in steel mills and that everything had to be closed. And we were very clever, twenty-five years later, when there was a shortage of steel and prices were skyrocketing! We need to look a bit at the long term and not just the short term.

I am not saying that we have solved everything. I ask you to believe in the determination to provide structural answers to this question. French industrialists are not alone in facing the crisis and the structural problems they face. I am sure that in Parliament, there is a majority, regardless of political families, to understand that France must remain a land of production and that we must mobilize all our energy in service of this ambition. It is not about adhering to a school of thought; it is about achieving results.

I deeply believe that there is nothing more useful for our country than to engage in this fight. Ladies and gentlemen, thank you.