Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on efforts to ensure the security of the French people, in Paris on May 28, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

28 May 2009 · Statement on efforts to ensure the security of the French people · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed French government officials in Paris on May 28, 2009, outlining measures to combat rising delinquency and gang violence amid economic crisis.
Main themes
Public security, delinquency and crime, gang violence, youth unemployment, economic crisis, urban violence, drug and arms trafficking, law enforcement performance, crime statistics, social exclusion, republican order, culture of results
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,665
90th percentile
Sentences
262
94th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.70
13th percentile
Vocabulary
2.36
85th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 53%52%
  • Social 37%36%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

262 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen,

Several serious issues of concern have led me to gather you here today to talk about the security of the French people.

We are living in a particularly difficult period, marked by an economic crisis of unprecedented scale since the end of the Second World War. The worsening youth unemployment threatens to have a particularly harmful impact on the balance of our society by fostering a sense of frustration and exclusion among those who embody the future. This is an absolute tragedy that mobilizes the Government.

In this context, we must more than ever ensure the security of the French people, who need to feel all the more protected in their daily lives as economic difficulties grow. However, in recent months, we have witnessed the emergence of new forms of violence, deeply traumatizing for our fellow citizens. They stem from both urban violence and classic banditry, motivated by the lure of easy money.

But let there be no mistake, delinquency rarely arises from social suffering. Delinquency simply results from the attraction of easy money. In any case, it never solves anything. For decades, the dominant ideology was based on the idea that misery naturally engenders crime, which can therefore only be addressed through social measures. This naivety continues to permeate the discourse of some segments of the French elite. I say exactly the opposite: it is crime that fosters misery by exacerbating exclusion and the stigmatization of a part of French society. The economic crisis is therefore an additional reason to strengthen our determination to combat delinquency, without hesitation, without concession, and without the slightest complacency. Do not let yourselves be intimidated by the dictatorship of good feelings, by the single thought that would excuse the perpetrators of violence and seek to blame the defenders of republican order. The French people, in their overwhelming majority, stand with the authorities of the State.

I am well aware of the difficulty of your mission, having served as Minister of the Interior for four years; I fully understand its complexity. That said, we have a demand for results.

The culture of results and performance has always been at the center of my actions. We must have no taboos regarding figures, and I have always advocated for the greatest transparency. When the figures are unsatisfactory, the responsible attitude is not to hide them, but rather to take the necessary measures to improve them. But when they are good, it is right to say so and to congratulate you.

Thus, despite what some may say, certainly with a memory that is too short, considerable progress has been made over the past seven years. The number of crimes and offenses has decreased by nearly 15% between May 2002 and May 2009. It had increased in the same proportions in the preceding years. Based on the unprecedented peak reached in 2002, two million crimes and offenses have been avoided for our fellow citizens. Never has the clearance rate for cases been so high. It was 25% in 2002. It exceeds 39% over the last three months. These results, my dear compatriots, are not fictitious. They are not manipulated. These results correspond to the exploitation of the statistical state 4001, whose bases have remained unchanged since the early 1970s. They are not miraculous either; these figures are the fruit of your work, that of the police, that of the gendarmes. And I want to congratulate Ms. Alliot-Marie, all the officials, all the military personnel who contributed to achieving these good results.

But we must also tell the truth when less favorable developments occur. If we want public discourse to regain credibility, we need transparency and truth. The results of recent months contrast with the trends observed over the past seven years. Crimes and offenses increased by 4% in March, and by just over 2% in April. The figures for May will likely be difficult. However, behind these figures, there are additional victims. I am absolutely determined to do everything possible to ensure that the results of the last three months are accidental and do not indicate the beginning of a reversal of trend.

The reality is that new forms of delinquency have developed recently: gangs, violence in schools, drug trafficking, and arms trafficking.

About twenty neighborhoods in the Paris region are particularly victimized by gang violence. A tiny minority of thugs, who represent only a few percent of the population in these neighborhoods, are trying to impose the law of the jungle on residents who only want one thing: to live in peace. Police services have counted more than two hundred gangs in the Paris region, comprising 5,000 individuals, who are multiplying brawls and assaults. The search for confrontation with law enforcement marks the peak of this drift. It is particularly serious. When one physically attacks a person tasked with protecting, assisting, and caring for the residents of a neighborhood, it is the national community that is targeted. Attacks against police officers or gendarmes are nothing less than a challenge to the Republic.

France recorded 25,000 acts of violence against agents of the public force in 2008. The French people were particularly shocked by several recent events. On March 14, 10 police officers were injured by gunfire in Les Mureaux after falling into a real ambush set by about thirty thugs. Recently, two police officers were injured during a scuffle with a group of about twenty thugs in Essonne. In Villiers-le-Bel, insults and stone-throwing against law enforcement have now become part of the daily landscape. On May 17 in La Courneuve, a new step was crossed with the attack on a police vehicle using a military weapon in an attempt, absurdly, to free criminals. We must put an end to these criminal drifts immediately. We will not allow the authority of the State to be trampled upon. The assailants in La Courneuve will be found sooner or later. We will allocate the necessary resources for this, and they will be severely punished. Let no one count on impunity.

Violence in schools is another form, not of incivility, a term far too weak, but of delinquency, of crime, even of barbarism. On March 10, about twenty hooded individuals, armed with sticks and iron bars, broke into the Jean-Baptiste Clément high school in Gagny. During this attack, they vandalized the premises and injured four people, one educational assistant and three high school students. A few days later, the principal of Garges-lès-Gonesse was injured while courageously helping a high school student who was being beaten with a hammer. On May 15 alone, a fifth-grade girl was injured by a knife at the Saint Gabriel college in Tourcoing; three high school students from the Thomas Jean Main vocational school in Limoges were evacuated by emergency services after being assaulted with batons and iron bars; a student from the Capouchiné college in Limoges narrowly escaped a gunshot. And in Fenouillet, a teacher was seriously injured by a 13-year-old student. We are therefore witnessing a normalization of the presence and use of weapons in schools. I hear the good consciences crying scandal when the Minister of National Education proposes to install security gates at the entrance of schools. Of course, it is regrettable to have to come to this; but how else can we act in such a context? Wait for the irreparable to happen? This situation is intolerable. And once again, we are confronted with a handful of thugs who poison the atmosphere of schools, compromising the work and success of the vast majority of young people who only want to study in peace. The tranquility of schools, regardless of their neighborhood or type of education, is an absolutely fundamental condition for the equality of opportunity that the Republic must guarantee. Schools must be sanctuarized, protected from any form of violence. This is an absolute priority for the authorities of the State.

The rise of criminal trafficking is a global reality to which our country is not immune. Drugs are one of the obvious causes of the climate of violence affecting many neighborhoods. They largely explain the phenomena of urban violence, gang brawls, and bloody settling of scores. The hatred of police officers corresponds to a strategy of dealers who seek to protect their trafficking. In 2008, 180,000 offenses related to drug legislation were recorded, an increase of 11%. 65 tons of cannabis were seized, twice as much as in 2007. The results reflect the activity of customs and police services. But they also express, let us face the situation, the scale, depth, and gravity of the problem. Every day, fast tracks transport this product through Spain and France. We are also seeing a resurgence of cocaine and heroin trafficking from Afghanistan. This trafficking calls for a single response: to combat it, to suppress it without the slightest concession. Finally, alongside the activity of criminal networks, new forms of predatory violence are developing. Armed robberies targeting small businesses reached 7,000 in 2008, a 25% increase. This is an unbearable phenomenon. Commerce is the foundation of social life in neighborhoods. We will not allow small, greedy thugs to persecute honest and courageous workers, just as we will not allow the activity of burglars, which is so traumatic for our fellow citizens, to restart.

We have an obligation to deliver results. I have made commitments, and they will be respected. You see that I am painting a clear picture of the situation.

So, it is not a matter of recounting the history of all the reforms accomplished over the past seven years, but I would like to emphasize a single point that illustrates the refusal of fatalism. When we proposed minimum sentences with the Keeper of the Seals, Rachida Dati, there was a chorus of protests, including from some of our own friends. We stood firm in the face of warnings, alerts, and the cries of alarm from all the good consciences. Minimum sentences were voted on by Parliament. They are a success. Since the law came into effect, 14,000 repeat offenders have been sentenced to a minimum sentence, of which 36% were imprisoned. From now on, on the territory of the French Republic, when one is a repeat offender, one is sentenced much more severely than when one is a first-time offender. And everyone knows that 5% of offenders commit 50% of the crime. This is a reality that our fellow citizens can no longer tolerate, exasperated by the impunity of repeat criminals.

I now wish, together with the Prime Minister, for three other fundamental reforms to profoundly transform the conditions for combating insecurity by forging new tools for action for law enforcement. If delinquents adapt, we will adapt as well.

Yesterday, the Council of Ministers approved the law on the orientation, programming, and performance of internal security, known as LOPPSI II. Dear Michèle Alliot-Marie, this text aims to provide the police and gendarmerie with new legal means to combat crime. This text is decisive. It notably paves the way for investigators to use the so-called serial method, which facilitates the cross-referencing of information collected during distinct cases. This new tool will allow us to optimize the use of information technology in criminal investigations. It is a decisive step forward in the service of a modern and effective police force.

The attachment of the gendarmerie to the Ministry of the Interior is another fundamental reform. Finally, listen, we had two security forces obeying two different strategies developed by two different ministries. We had arrived at a completely absurd system: even the communication network of the police was not compatible with the communication network of the gendarmes, and neither was compatible with that of the firefighters. Is this worthy of a modern State?

The principle of unified command of security forces is a decisive step for security policy in France. From now on, the police and gendarmerie are placed under the authority of the Minister of the Interior at the national level and, I emphasize, under the authority of the prefect at the local level, excluding judicial missions, of course. The 145,000 police officers and 100,000 gendarmes therefore fall under a single command. I expect a lot from this: increased complementarity, pooling of resources, sharing of skills and technologies.

This reform is decisive. I want it to succeed. I have always told the gendarmes that their military status would be maintained, and I believe that the complementarity of the two forces, one civilian and the other military, is an asset for France's security policy. I wanted this reform; it must be carried through to completion as soon as possible.

Finally, the creation of the metropolitan police falls under the same logic. But criminals do not recognize administrative boundaries. We must put an end to the absurd compartmentalization that severely penalizes the effectiveness of law enforcement. The organization of security in France must take into account the logic of unified command at the level of the metropolitan area, the crime basin. Initially, it will concern the Paris region, in the spirit of "Grand Paris." Then it will extend to other metropolitan areas based on needs.

An interdepartmental public security directorate will therefore be placed under the authority of the police prefect, with jurisdiction over Paris, Hauts-de-Seine, Seine-Saint-Denis, and Val-de-Marne. This service will exercise, at the scale of Paris and the three departments, all the competencies related to public security: prevention, repression, general information, intelligence on urban crime, road safety, public order. The police prefect will thus be responsible for security not only in Paris but also in the inner suburbs. It is by delegation from the police prefect that the prefects of the three departments of the inner suburbs will continue to exercise, under his authority, their prerogatives in matters of security and public order in their department.

Once again, we must act quickly.

Before the summer, a decree will establish the interdepartmental public security directorate. In the following months, a law will allow for the necessary transfers of competencies between the department prefects and the police prefect.

Crime ignores our administrative boundaries. We must adapt to be more effective.

These reforms will profoundly transform the exercise of security missions in our country. It has been necessary to challenge taboos, habits, and conservatisms. I count on your personal commitment to publicize these reforms and to give them their full significance.

Security is a global issue that involves all public actors. The cause of our failures largely lies in compartmentalization, turf wars, and a lack of communication. This is the very purpose of today's meeting. Prefect, prosecutor, academic inspector, tax director, customs director must exchange their information, jointly establish departmental security policies. I wish for each department, at the initiative of the prefect, to establish a security task force bringing together the main authorities concerned, which will meet every month to define public policy in terms of security.

The priority today is the reconquest of sensitive neighborhoods. I want a complete mobilization of law enforcement on this major imperative. We will first focus on 25 neighborhoods, 21 in the Paris region and 4 in the provinces. These 25 neighborhoods are plagued by crime, drug trafficking, and arms trafficking. The presence of law enforcement must be constant, visible, and massive. No street, no basement, no stairwell should be abandoned to thugs. I want immediate increases in operations in the housing projects in the form of genuine groundwork, and these operations should continue for as long as necessary over the coming months. The common areas of buildings, apartments, and squatted basements will be subject to thorough searches. I ask you, ladies and gentlemen, the prefects, prosecutors, and academic inspectors, to personally visit these neighborhoods to demonstrate the authority of the State, as long and as often as necessary. The number of security forces in sensitive neighborhoods will be increased. Madame Alliot-Marie will carry out redeployment operations of mobile units to strengthen the resources of the police and gendarmerie in the neighborhoods that need them most. I particularly want 200 additional officers to be assigned without delay to Seine-Saint-Denis. This will give us the means to dismantle the violent gangs that sow terror in the neighborhoods. I wish for the proposal for a law submitted by Mr. Estrosi to be voted on quickly, Mr. Prime Minister, which will allow for the qualification of a crime and the punishment of three years in prison for merely belonging to a gang.

I ask the relevant ministers to develop an action plan against arms trafficking.

We must put an end, while there is still time, before a catastrophe occurs, to the normalization of carrying weapons in the street, public transport, and schools. The judicial police and intelligence services will mobilize on this issue. Madame Alliot-Marie will establish a joint working group between the Judicial Police Directorate and the DCRI to make proposals to combat this phenomenon. A reflection must begin without delay on ways to improve the regulation of the arms trade. I ask Madame the Keeper of the Seals to present me with proposals to toughen the repression of arms trafficking. This issue, of course, transcends national borders, and I suggest the creation of a joint European investigation team on this type of trafficking.

We will safeguard schools.

Violence within the school institution, against teachers and students, is intolerable because it touches on what a society holds most precious: its children who carry its future. The proposed law presented by Mr. Estrosi includes a reform of criminal qualifications sanctioning intrusion into a school; it will now be considered not merely an offense punishable by a simple fine, but as a crime. Violence committed against a national education agent will constitute aggravating circumstances not only when it occurs inside the establishment but also when it is committed outside the establishment if it is related to the teachers' mission. This will be the case, for example, of a teacher assaulted in public transport. This reform will ensure that teachers receive the protection currently afforded to agents entrusted with public authority.

184 of the most sensitive establishments will undergo a security diagnosis, after which all necessary measures will be adopted to protect them against intrusions. I invite the prefects, rectors, and prosecutors to ensure the smooth progress of this process.

I ask them to proceed with the systematic implementation of a system of designated police officers in the establishments. This does not mean organizing a permanent police presence in the establishments, but it is imperative that systems are put in place so that police intervention, in case of difficulty within the school premises or its surroundings, occurs almost instantaneously.

There is no question of tolerating the presence of weapons within school premises. Management and supervisory staff must in the future have the means to ensure that students do not carry weapons. To this end, they will receive specific authorization that will allow them to open backpacks and bags, and if a student possesses a weapon, to take all necessary consequences. Ladies and gentlemen, I say this with gravity. Let us never forget that on March 11 in Winnenden, Germany, there were 17 deaths in a school. Each of us is therefore placed before our responsibility.

Each rector will be able to have a mobile team of agents, trained for this purpose, who will support school heads pedagogically in case of specific difficulties related to discipline in a high school or middle school.

To complement this system, I wish for the possibility of widely opening the civil reserve of the national police to be studied quickly. This system will allow for the assignment of retired police officers as well as experienced and qualified volunteers from diverse backgrounds to specific missions, particularly the securing of schools and their surroundings. Recruitment will be open to all citizens based on a physical and moral aptitude test, similar to what is successfully practiced for volunteer firefighters. These volunteers will receive appropriate training. Their mission will be twofold: monitoring sensitive sites and maintaining close and permanent contact with middle and high school students.

Ladies and gentlemen, video surveillance is a fundamental means of security policy. The presence of a camera is the most deterrent tool for a delinquent, as it allows law enforcement to identify, arrest, and have the authors of offenses prosecuted by justice. 10,000 cameras have been installed with state funding. The LOPPSI 2 will provide us with the legal means to give a new impetus to this policy.

We will thus expand the ability of private legal entities to view the surroundings of their buildings and installations by extending it to places particularly exposed to acts of terrorism or risks of aggression or theft. We will give the prefect the authority to set a minimum duration for the retention of images to allow police and gendarmerie services to have information and exploit it. We will facilitate the procedures with the departmental commissions responsible for issuing opinions on renewal requests and the prefectural services responsible for processing them. The immediate objective is to set up 75 standard municipal systems and ensure, where necessary, the protection of schools.

I regret the reluctance of some elected officials to engage in the path of video surveillance. Video surveillance does not threaten freedoms; video surveillance protects the freedom to move and come and go in one's neighborhood safely. I invite the prefects, prosecutors, and academic inspectors to engage in dialogue and persuasion with the most reserved elected officials. I count on them to ensure that common sense prevails over ideology or calculations in a matter as essential for the security of the French people.

We must finally rethink policing methods, adapting them to new forms of crime. The establishment of regional intervention groups in 2002 has been a real success in the fight against crime. There are currently 34, which have become an essential tool in the fight against criminal trafficking. The results obtained in 2008 are remarkable: 1,000 operations that led to the detection of 3,000 offenses and the seizure of 21 million euros.

We will generalize the method of the GIR and will now systematically involve customs, tax services, and social organizations in the fight against criminal trafficking. We must hit traffickers in their wallets. The fundamental issue of crime cannot be resolved otherwise. I ask the Minister of Budget to assign tax services a mission directly related to the fight against trafficking in the neighborhoods. Two specialized officials should be specifically assigned to each of the 25 most sensitive neighborhoods. Their role will be to detect signs of undue wealth in order to trigger repression mechanisms against traffickers. These tax officials will work in close coordination with justice and police services. Likewise, I absolutely want customs to be given a priority mission in sensitive neighborhoods and to intervene massively there in the context of close cooperation with other security forces. And I say clearly to customs and tax agents: there is no professional secrecy that holds, in my eyes, between state services when the security of the French people—or that of the State—is at stake.

I ask Eric Woerth to consider improving the texts intended to allow for the fiscal apprehension of sums derived from these illegal activities. I am thinking in particular of the necessary modernization of taxation on lifestyles based on signs of wealth that do not align with what the administration knows. We must improve procedures, strengthen investigative means so that tax audits lead to criminal consequences. I wish for specialized groups to be established in urban security services most affected by violence, focusing on combating criminal trafficking, particularly drug and arms trafficking. People who have never worked a day in their lives and who drive expensive cars with impunity must answer to tax authorities, and tax authorities must demand that criminal proceedings be initiated.

I am aware that the efforts of the police, the tax authorities, and customs only make sense if they are followed by an adequate judicial response that is sufficiently deterrent. I too often hear law enforcement officials express their discouragement following the release of offenders who then taunt these same law enforcement agencies and give the fragile heads of neighborhoods the idea that one can do anything with impunity. On the contrary, I have noticed, particularly over the past two years, a genuine commitment from prosecutors to combat insecurity. I want to thank them for that. Security forces must be irreproachable in terms of the quality of procedures, and while I hear complaints from law enforcement about excessive leniency, I also hear complaints from the judiciary about procedures that are not exemplary enough. We are going to make a considerable effort. I ask Mrs. Alliot-Marie to broaden the recruitment field for judicial police officers, who need to be more numerous and better trained. An additional 1,000 judicial police officers will be trained.

A plan to combat burglaries will be implemented without delay in the ten departments most affected by this phenomenon.

Finally, crime prevention has been far too neglected in recent years. I had a law passed in March 2007 to set objectives, define principles and modalities, and provide the legal means that were lacking. I insisted on placing mayors at the heart of the system within the framework of a new generation of local security contracts. However, I note that very few have been signed: 22 in 2007, 6 in 2008, 1 in 2009. I deeply regret this. Security is everyone's business, and we must mobilize and hold all local actors accountable around this priority. An active policy of crime prevention and victim assistance is not just a juxtaposition of initiatives taken by ministries each in their own corner. It is a global strategy, with objectives, evaluation of results, and coordination of actions. I therefore ask the Prime Minister, if he is willing, to urgently convene all the relevant ministers and prepare a government plan for crime prevention and victim assistance for September.

You understand, ladies and gentlemen, that I am calling for a strong and constant mobilization in favor of the security of the French people. For this, it is necessary that the results of your actions are carefully studied and monitored to measure their effects and to redirect them if necessary.

I ask the Minister of the Interior for a monthly follow-up of crime statistics by department. Each month, the prefects will have to establish a dashboard of the main figures for their department, including the evolution of violence in schools. It will include a presentation of the police and judicial responses to acts of delinquency. It is not enough to have a good clearance rate for cases; it is also necessary to know the follow-up given by the judicial authority to violence and crime. I want these reports to lead, Mr. Prime Minister, to the preparation of an annual report to Parliament on security, which will be jointly drafted by the Minister of the Interior, the Keeper of the Seals, and the Minister of National Education.

Ladies and gentlemen, the French people elected me to restore the authority of the State throughout the territory of the Republic. The vast majority of our fellow citizens wish for this authority of the State to manifest itself everywhere and in all circumstances. We do not have the right to disappoint them. I know they can count on your commitment, your dedication, and your effectiveness. As for you, you know that you have my full confidence in the accomplishment of this great work, which I will personally oversee. I am committed to achieving results; we will achieve results. Let this message be clearly heard throughout the territory of the French Republic. There will be no weakness in the fight against delinquency. The Republic stands for values. These values are trampled upon by the violence of a minority. It is not this minority that will win. The message is clear, the strategy is set. You are the actors of this strategy.

Good luck and good work.

Thank you.