Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the future of social protection, in Bordeaux on June 4, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

4 June 2009 · Congress of the French Mutuality · Bordeaux, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the French Mutuality Congress in Bordeaux on June 4, 2009, outlining his vision for the future of social protection and healthcare.
Main themes
Social protection, solidarity and responsibility, mutualist movement, French Mutuality congress, healthcare system reform, aging population, individual life projects, active solidarity income (RSA), dependency care, professional mobility, social security adaptation, collective destiny
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,788
84th percentile
Sentences
242
93rd percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
10.4
25th percentile
Syntax
2.72
14th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 66%66%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

242 sentences in 54 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister, dear Alain,

Mr. President, dear Jean-Pierre DAVANT,

Ladies and gentlemen,

You have honored me by inviting me, for which I thank you. The congress is an event for your movement, and it is for me as well. Every three years, thousands of mutualists gather to contribute, through concrete proposals, to the construction of tomorrow's social protection. I am happy to participate in your discussions. The presence of the President of the Republic at the congress of the French Mutuality is, in essence, a tradition. If I am among you today, it is not only out of a taste for tradition. It is primarily because I want to salute the actions of the women and men who, within the mutualist movement, implement essential values for our society every day: solidarity, partnership, innovation, and quality. It is also because the future of social protection, that of the health system, are top priorities for our country. And if it were easy, we would know it, and if one person alone had the solution, we would know that too. To meet this challenge, we must be united and conceive solutions for the future together.

Mr. President, I believe this congress will be the last that you will preside over. I sense your feelings, imbued with both pride and emotion. I want to pay tribute to your leadership of the French Mutuality. You have maintained the unity of the mutualist movement. You have made Mutuality a significant entity in the social debate and in our economy. For all this, Mr. President, dear Jean-Pierre DAVANT, you deserve our esteem and recognition beyond, of course, the debates we may have had and the disagreements that are normal in a democracy. You are a courageous man who has taken on his responsibilities.

Ladies and gentlemen, our social needs are considerable. The global crisis we are experiencing only exacerbates them. But beyond the current crisis, there are underlying trends. Deep within each of us, there is a need for protection, protection against the uncertainties of existence. This need applies, of course, to oneself, to one's family, and to one's loved ones.

It is a natural need for security that also stems from a cultural dimension. The solidarity we are likely to benefit from is a means of marking our belonging to a community, to a group of individuals united by a higher purpose. Solidarity is about making an individual life project coherent with a collective destiny: that of our Nation. Solidarity, in a certain way, allows individuals, secured by rules recognized by all, to take risks and be responsible. I do not understand why we should oppose solidarity and responsibility. On the contrary, I believe they are the two branches of the same tree, that one does not go without the other, that one complements the other. What unites solidarity and responsibility is the person and the project they carry in their life.

Precisely, today, after several decades of the generalization of social security, we feel the need for solidarity to be exercised more for individuals than for categories. The challenge is no longer just to apply solidarity in favor of fragile individuals because they are sick or because they have lost their job. Solidarity is about supporting the individual throughout their life so that they can successfully carry out their project. Solidarity is not only defensive; it is offensive. It is because each of us will be convinced that we can count on national solidarity that we can develop a personal, individual project. Taking risks, because there is the safety net of solidarity. The care for the dependency of the elderly and disabled individuals shows this. It must be organized around an individual project based on the pursuit of greater autonomy.

Solidarity must take into account the mobility of individuals. Career paths are becoming less and less linear. Professional mobility is increasing, sometimes simply because the mobility of capital and the ownership of companies leads to changes in strategy, scope, and management, which are in themselves factors of mobility. Social protection must adapt much more responsively to the stages of each of our lives. That is why I wanted the active solidarity income. With the RSA, anyone who returns to work or increases their working hours will see their resources increase. It is for the same reason that I wanted the declaration of resources for the adult disability allowance to be quarterly rather than annually. This measure will be implemented at the beginning of 2010. Solidarity must adapt to the pace of a faster world.

Our social needs are the result of an aging population. We have gained fifteen years of life expectancy since 1950, and the trend continues.

Aging raises new questions for social protection.

With age, all sorts of diseases can appear that we did not suffer from under the same conditions in the past. Today, we are witnessing the emergence of new cancers, many forms of visual impairment, and Alzheimer's disease. These new diseases sometimes correspond to new treatments whose costs are significant.

The lengthening of life means that the number of people with chronic diseases continues to rise. These diseases affect 15 million of us. They account for 80% of the increase in health insurance expenditures. It is normal for solidarity to reduce the out-of-pocket expenses to a minimum for the care provided to those affected. But continuity, quality of care, and patient involvement are crucial. For proper management of chronic diseases, prevention and patient education are essential. They must enable individuals to maintain their quality of life so that they can continue to live and work as normally as possible.

End-of-life care is a subject that was not discussed in France just twenty years ago. The development of palliative care is a profound change for healthcare professionals. The palliative culture is too little spread in France. It is not about curing but about accompanying, so that everyone can die with dignity. It is about engaging in dialogue on a difficult topic with the patient but also with their loved ones. It is about facing the inevitable. With the increase in life expectancy, solidarity is pushed to limits it has not known until now.

Finally, we have an increasing need for services. The primary purpose of social protection is to protect the individual's income. But income support is not enough. Social needs are increasingly needs for solutions: meal delivery, software, personal services, training, professional guidance, advice.

In total, the trends I have just described create new needs. The demand for solidarity has probably never been as great as it is today, and the severity of the crisis only reinforces it.

In the face of this demand, I am well aware, Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen, that we need concrete responses more than grand principles. In the face of this demand, the resources of national solidarity—who could claim they are infinite? They are not. The growth of our economy, even when we emerge from the crisis, will likely not allow basic social protection systems to cover all new needs. The balance of mandatory schemes is already under pressure, and these pressures will intensify. We must be clear-eyed.

The concrete responses we must provide to social needs must therefore be based either on national solidarity or, Mr. President, on other systems that draw inspiration from it, and of course, on the French Mutuality. We will have to make choices. We will need to identify sources of funding that are both equitable and compatible with the growth of our economy.

Health is an illustration of the challenges ahead for social protection. Our health expenditures represent 11.3% of GDP, placing France in third place just behind the United States and Switzerland. But hear this figure: in 2009, health insurance expenditures will increase by more than 3% while our GDP will decline by 3%. That represents a gap of 6 points! This is primarily what national solidarity is about: allocating resources where the priorities are.

But let us not be deluded; maintaining this trend sustainably is not guaranteed. So to give ourselves the means to do so, we must make simultaneous progress, as you mentioned, Mr. President, in two directions: the quality and efficiency of care. It is pointless, once again, to oppose the two. Quality and efficiency go hand in hand because, to better care for the sick, we need to create room for maneuver. And let us agree together that in these two areas, we have immense work to implement.

The condition for quality and efficiency is well-trained healthcare professionals, in sufficient numbers, maintaining their knowledge and practice throughout their lives, harmoniously distributed across the territory and cooperating with each other. Everyone agrees on the principle; does it happen, however? I thank you for your discretion; everyone understands what it is.

We must achieve this objective. Mr. President, the "Mutualist Health Priority" project, which aims to guide the sick person according to criteria of quality and efficiency, will be a powerful ally in achieving this.

The availability of healthcare services is the foundation of quality. The evolution of medical demographics will reduce the available supply by 2025. We have taken measures: the numerus clausus has increased from 3,600 to 7,600 between 2000 and 2009, and we will need to maintain this level over time. We will develop multidisciplinary health centers that allow a given number of professionals to care for more patients. To prepare for the future, the "Hospital" law provides for the creation of public service practitioner scholarships for medical students wishing to settle in certain regions that are fragile in terms of medical density, either in private practice or as salaried employees. This provision will take effect from 2012. I do not naturally question the freedom of establishment, but it seems normal to me to say that liberal doctors have, in a certain way, a public service role. This role is recognized by the national solidarity of which their expenditures form a large part of their income.

The permanence of care is the very expression of the public service role of liberal doctors. It is also one of the determinants of the availability of healthcare services. The permanence of city care is the first response to the concern of parents whose child has a fever at 8 PM. It cannot rely solely on hospital emergencies. That is not possible. There must, yes I say, "there must" be a liberal medical response, whether by phone or in person, to non-life-threatening emergencies throughout the territory. Otherwise, the attendance at emergency services will continue to rise uncontrollably: 10 million in 1998, 13 million visits in 2004, 16 million in 2006. If we are not careful, we risk consuming all the resources of health insurance.

The Hospital law entrusts the responsibility for the permanence of care, which is currently dispersed, solely to regional health agencies. It encourages healthcare facilities to cooperate more with each other and with their environment. This should result in less congestion in emergency services and, for the patient, less waiting. In short, Mr. President, more quality and more efficiency.

Our health system leaves significant social inequalities. The gaps in cancer mortality between executives and workers, believe it or not, have widened over the past twenty-five years. I hope that the second cancer plan will help reduce these inequalities because they are intolerable.

We still have a long way to go to ensure that every patient has the assurance that every act of care has been provided at the right time, by the right professional, according to international quality standards. We must develop and disseminate protocols to guarantee a uniform level of quality and efficiency across the territory. I place new hopes on the personal medical record, which is not a bureaucratic chimera. By allowing better information sharing among professionals, we will reduce the number of unnecessary acts and secure the practice of caregivers. The first deliveries will take place in 2010. The hospital cannot remain outside the personal medical record. Healthcare facilities must accelerate their digitization. It is under this set of conditions that we will have taken a significant step towards quality and efficiency.

The last lever, which is not the simplest, is that of evaluation. Evaluating quality, evaluating the efficiency of a collective function that represents 200 billion euros each year, is the least we can expect from ourselves. Evaluating the compliance of practices with international standards, both in the community and in hospitals, is a necessity. Evaluating medication prescriptions, evaluating healthcare facilities, and, dare I say, evaluating patient satisfaction. Evaluating the efficiency of acts, evaluating the efficiency of therapeutic strategies. The High Authority of Health has a key role in this matter. It must contribute to spreading the culture of evaluation in healthcare provision. Evaluation is essential for quality and efficiency.

Allow me to mention the role of university hospitals, the CHUs. I want to reaffirm the importance of their triple mission: care, teaching, research. CHUs must be places of excellence that place research at the heart of their strategy. I said: "research." Because the quality of research depends on the quality of teaching and care. The training of caregivers must, to meet the challenges, be based on research. And today's research produces tomorrow's care.

I want to pay tribute to Professor Jacques MARESCAUX. I have taken his proposals very seriously. The reform of CHUs is fully integrated into the Hospital Bill. There are not two reforms. There is only one reform, that of the hospital and that of the CHUs, which will place our most advanced hospitals at the heart of French biomedical research.

There has been much concern about the fact that as President of the Republic, I have committed so much alongside our Minister of Health to the reform of the hospital. 1,100,000 people, considerable problems. If the President of the Republic does not engage in the reform of the hospital, what will he engage in? When it is such a place of passion, pain, joy, and also conflicts of interest. Choices had to be made, Mr. President, I have assumed them. And who can think that we can keep the hospital outside the issue of health insurance reform, when the hospital represents 50% of health insurance expenditures?

Of course, when we make changes, we say half "yes" to some, and completely "no" to others. It is not always pleasant. The French hospital system was heading for disaster if it was not reformed.

Social needs are immense. The challenges for social protection, for health, are no less so. National solidarity, funded by compulsory levies, will continue to fulfill its mission. But alongside it, other forms of protection are called to develop. The identity of the French Mutuality predisposes it to this.

This is an opportunity for me to express my respect for the values of your movement, the mutualist movement. To express my respect for a movement that fundamentally makes the general interest an act of faith. My respect for a movement that performs a social utility. You are not limited to your main profession, to complementary health insurance. You are much more than an insurer - I have nothing against it, much more than a manager of health centers, clinics, or optical shops. You are a living synthesis of solidarity and the market, of solidarity and responsibility, of the time of the active and the time of retirees.

Let us recognize that our society is often marked by the temptation to retreat into oneself. Corporatism, short-term interests, the preservation of "one's own," and immobility are reflexes that are not easy to shake off. It is not so common today to engage in reflection driven by the general interest, especially when this reflection is the work of thousands of people like you, the mutualist elected officials.

I therefore want to pay tribute to this uniqueness that is the soul of the French Mutuality. You are sometimes criticized, you have even sometimes been mocked, a certain elite has mocked you. Well, I say that France can take pride in Mutuality, in its values and its daily action in service of millions of French men and women!

You are called, you actors of the mutualist movement, along with other actors, to play a leading role in social protection.

This role is primarily institutional. You sit on the board of the National Health Insurance Fund. I tell you: it seems normal to me that you are represented on the supervisory board of the regional health agencies that will be set up soon. Mr. President, yes, we have had disagreements, but we have also had agreements. You are an essential partner, and that is very good.

This institutional role is, in my eyes, the symbol of a new partnership between health insurance and the French Mutuality that I wish for.

A protocol was signed by Roselyne BACHELOT, Eric WOERTH, and yourself in July 2008. This protocol emphasizes the need for "responsible coordination between the basic health insurance schemes and complementary organizations on risk management as well as on the financing of health expenditures." Its provisions remain very relevant, and I ask the Government to implement them fully and quickly.

I will highlight, among the constitutive elements of a new partnership between health insurance and Mutuality, three themes.

First, complementary insurers will participate, alongside health insurance, in conventional negotiations in the fields of optical and dental care. In these two areas, complementary organizations provide a significant level of coverage. They have developed services that help the insured choose the best benefits at the best price. It is therefore legitimate for you to be able to sign the conventional agreements. This should have been done a long time ago, and I am very happy to announce and propose it to you.

The second theme is the issue of excess fees. Just because we agree beforehand does not make it less important. It seems to me that we need to immediately define the subject. Excess fees are not a problem in themselves. I am only talking about the excess fees of surgeons, anesthetists, and obstetricians-gynecologists: because they can represent a significant amount for acts that are anything but comfort care.

The optional sector must allow for better regulation of rates than sector 2, accompanied by quality objectives. Pricing freedoms will be better covered by health insurance and complementary insurance, which will allow for better access to care. For this option to be adopted by the largest number of specialist doctors, specific advantages must be associated with it. These advantages must make the optional sector attractive compared to sector 2.

I note that the conventional partners have not reached an agreement on this subject. Should the legislator take back control? I ask the Government to prepare for this. Excess fees in clinics lead some of our fellow citizens to forgo care, which is unacceptable. As everyone knows, I have a great friendship, since you spoke of the American people, in any case of its representative for the American people, but I do not want a system that excludes 15% of the population from health care coverage. The issue of excess fees has been on the table for years. It is time to address it. This is the second issue we will tackle in the coming weeks.

It happens, Mr. President, that the positions of the Government and those of the French Mutuality on this matter are close. They were not necessarily so a few months ago. I know I can count on the mutualist movement to engage in the optional sector and to lead other actors in complementary health.

The third theme, finally, is the coverage of chronic diseases, certainly one of the most difficult subjects. Much remains to be done to ensure more continuous and better quality care. The long-term illness scheme has focused on the financial aspect of care, which is essential. But the quality of care does not receive sufficient attention. When nearly 10 million people are affected, when thousands of hospital days can be avoided through appropriate care, it is clear that the quality of follow-up for these diseases is a major issue. On this subject, as on others, the French Mutuality is a prominent partner of the State and health insurance.

The Government will systematically and thoroughly study, Mr. President, the proposal of the mutualist movement on chronic diseases. I wish that when the contours of the project are clarified, experiments be launched by the Government and Mutuality to improve the quality and efficiency of their care. After all, you have ideas, and we have the will to engage in dialogue. Let us make this will and these ideas meet, let us experiment. We will evaluate the results before, perhaps, generalizing these new modes of intervention by complementary organizations. My proposal is made in good faith. You have convictions, well, let us experiment, evaluate together, and if it is positive, we will generalize.

I want to move forward methodically. But my objective is clear. I wish, within the framework of a demanding partnership, to entrust new responsibilities to complementary organizations. The basic schemes will not be able to finance everything. Choices will have to be made. We will create the conditions for a solidary, equitable, efficient coverage, centered on quality, of the new social needs whose coverage cannot rest exclusively on national solidarity. Within the framework of the Hospital Bill, the aid for the acquisition of complementary health insurance has been increased from 200 to 350 euros per year for those aged 50-59 and from 400 to 500 euros per year for those aged 60 and over. Thanks to this increased aid funded from public funds, the percentage of French people without complementary insurance - currently 7% - will decrease.

Other tools can be mobilized to guarantee our fellow citizens a solidary and efficient social protection. I am thinking of so-called "responsible" contracts which, in return for compliance with certain coverage standards, benefit from tax and social aids.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen,

You will have noticed that there seems to be a community of views on many subjects between us. I do not say that we agree on everything, but we agree on the essentials: to respond to the social needs of tomorrow, we must ensure the sustainability of social protection by laying the foundations for a new partnership between the basic schemes and the complementary organizations that respect the rules of solidarity. Mutuality, given its particular identity, both as an insurance and care operator and as a movement of social utility, must be at the forefront of this partnership. It must be a driving force for other complementary organizations.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen, Mr. President, let us work together now to build sustainable solidarity.

Thank you.