Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on efforts to reduce the public finance deficit, in Paris on May 20, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

20 May 2010 · Second conference on the deficit · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the second deficit conference in Paris on May 20, 2010, outlining France's strategy to restore public finance balance amid the eurozone crisis.
Main themes
Public finance deficit reduction, eurozone crisis, fiscal responsibility, economic recovery, public spending reform, French economic policy, European economic governance, stimulus policy, structural reforms, public debt, competitiveness, collective budgetary effort
Duration
~18 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,203
62nd percentile
Sentences
123
73rd percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
2.76
18th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
73rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%50%
  • Institutional 33%33%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

123 sentences in 56 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The second conference on the deficit has allowed us to take stock of the situation of our public finances and the strategy we intend to pursue to restore their balance.

I had wished at the first conference for several working groups to meet and submit the reports we have just discussed. I want to thank all the working groups and the authors of the reports for the quality of their diagnosis and their proposals.

Our exchanges have been particularly rich, and I thank each of you for your participation.

The eurozone is going through the most serious crisis in its history. Thanks to the mobilization of the Franco-German duo, all the Member States, and all the European institutions, we have put in place an exceptional plan of 750 billion euros to combat speculation and support the recovery efforts implemented by certain Member States of the eurozone.

Beyond these measures, citizens expect us to undertake the necessary reforms to consolidate the Stability Pact, equip Europe with a genuine growth strategy, and achieve the economic governance for which France has advocated so strongly. We will quickly make proposals to our partners in this regard.

The situation of public finances in the eurozone is now at the heart of the debate. The course of our economic policy must be clearly defined and explained. There must be no ambiguity about our objectives, nor about the means to achieve them, nor about our mobilization.

After the financial crisis of 2008, we pursued a stimulus policy to support activity. We accepted the loss of revenue linked to the economic slowdown. We chose to act on investment so as not to sacrifice the future for the present.

This policy has borne fruit. The targeted measures we have taken have been effective. They have helped to mitigate the impact of the crisis on our fellow citizens. Without the government's action, the growth rate would have been close to -5%, instead of -2.6% according to the latest figures from INSEE. The budgetary impulse has revived growth as early as the second quarter of 2009, at an average rate of +0.3% per quarter for the past year.

But this unprecedented mobilization plan against the crisis was intended and designed from the outset as temporary. The deficit cannot reasonably remain at its crisis exit level without posing a threat to future growth.

The gradual cessation of support measures in 2010 and the reduction of deficits starting in 2011 are therefore neither a novelty nor a problem if we wish to ensure sustainable and lasting growth.

As the recovery progresses, we must now return to the path of balance in our public finances. The widening of our deficits during the crisis was fully justified because it supported the economy. With the recovery, the restoration of our public finances is equally justified. It is neither a matter of austerity nor laxity, but of responsibility: this is the policy we are pursuing, with the government, with consistency and determination.

In announcing savings measures, we are neither yielding to market pressure nor to panic. We are not embarking today on a turn towards austerity heralding massive tax increases and salary cuts. I refuse this strategy that would undermine the recovery of growth.

The report by Messrs. CHAMPSAUR and COTIS serves as the starting point for this second session. I wanted it to be made public so that we can share this observation.

What does this report tell us? I take away three major lessons.

The crisis has indeed deepened our deficits, but the problem we must tackle is much older. For thirty years, our country has experienced an increase in the weight of public spending and an increase in its debt. Since 1974, we have not voted for a balanced budget when we should have been in surplus on a regular basis. Over thirty years, public debt has risen from 21% of GDP to 77% of GDP in 2009. This demonstrates that, while the crisis has accelerated our difficulties, it is far from being the sole culprit.

The second lesson: the effort to restore balance to our public finances can only be a collective effort. It must involve all actors in spending: the State, of course, but also social security administrations and local authorities, whose expenditures have seen very rapid growth over the past 20 years.

The third lesson is that the adjustment of our public finances is not incompatible with a growth strategy; on the contrary. Increasing taxes or accepting that public spending represents a growing share of our national wealth would seriously compromise our competitiveness.

We cannot separate the state of our public finances from the competitiveness of our economy and the sustainability of our social protection system. The structural reforms we are undertaking are one of the keys to restoring public accounts. With the great loan, we are investing massively in research and innovation. With the reform of the professional tax and the tripling of the research tax credit, we are making France one of the most attractive countries for investments and research centers. With the pension reform, we will encourage activity and preserve the balance of our social system by taking demographic changes into account.

Our strategy is clear, it is coherent, and it is long-term. Starting in 2011, we will strictly strengthen control over spending, we will refuse general tax increases, we will proceed at the pace of the economic recovery, and we will continue the reforms that restore growth. It is this strategy that will allow us to reconcile the restoration of our public accounts and the recovery of growth.

In my view, the effort on spending must have two essential characteristics. It must be maintained over a long period: it is a long-term effort. It must be shared by all administrations: it is a collective effort. The objective to which we are committed, to return to a deficit of 6% of GDP in 2011, and to 4.6% of GDP in 2012, must be respected.

This is not about making blind cuts in public spending. It is about establishing the rules that will allow us to strictly control spending sustainably over the entire decade.

1) Let us start with the State. We will continue and deepen the rationalization methods we have implemented over the past three years.

First decision, State spending will not increase in value over the next three years, excluding pensions and debt service.

Second decision: we will continue the non-replacement of one civil servant for every two who retire: 34,000 civil service positions will continue to be eliminated on average each year. This policy has allowed for the elimination of 100,000 public jobs since the beginning of the legislature. This effort will be extended to State operators (3,000 job cuts as early as 2011, 9,000 by 2013). As has been the case for the past three years, these job cuts will be based on real reforms, examined and validated within the framework of the general review of public policies. They will therefore not be made in a blanket manner, at the cost of a lower quality of service. On the contrary, the reforms will improve the quality and efficiency of public services.

Third decision: regarding operating and intervention expenditures, the government has set a goal of reducing them by 10% by 2013, including 5% as early as 2011.

I will hold a Public Policy Modernization Council by summer. All the reforms supporting these savings will be presented there.

Fourth decision: we are currently conducting an exercise to inventory all tax and social niches with the aim of eliminating 5 billion euros of niches. These eliminations will be decided in the fall as part of the finance bill and the social security financing bill.

2) Regarding health insurance expenditures, the measures taken by the government since 2007 have helped to curb the dynamics of health spending without compromising the quality of care.

The target for the growth of health insurance expenditures has been set at 3% in 2010, after 3.3% in 2009. We will continue to adjust this target: it will be set at 2.9% in 2011 and 2.8% in 2012.

Moreover, while it has sometimes been difficult to meet the health spending target, all measures will now be taken to ensure it is achieved. This will be the case as early as 2010, where we will meet the announced 3%.

Mr. Raoul BRIET's report identifies several measures to strengthen our system for managing health spending. These proposals will be implemented. In particular:

- The role of the alert committee will be expanded. It will now be able to express an ex ante opinion on the construction of the national health insurance expenditure target. It will also ensure continuous monitoring and will submit a first opinion to the ministers by April 15 on the execution of the previous year's health spending target.

- The alert threshold, currently set at 0.75%, will be gradually lowered to 0.5% by 2012-2013.

- All or part of the new measures will only be implemented if the health spending target is met. Similarly, a portion of the allocations will be put in reserve at the beginning of the year and will be delegated as the health spending target is met.

3) Regarding local authorities, the Champsaur-Cotis report demonstrates that local spending has increased faster than can be explained by decentralization.

Under the Constitution, local authorities are financially autonomous. But there is not a local taxpayer and a national taxpayer; there is only one taxpayer, the French taxpayer. Local authorities must therefore contribute to the national effort to restore public accounts. To do this, it is necessary to achieve a genuine moderation of local spending.

I thank Mr. Gilles CARREZ and Mr. Michel THENAULT who led the work of the working group dedicated to local spending. I announce today three decisions.

- First point: the proliferation of standards that leads to an increase in local spending is no longer acceptable. I therefore request that an immediate moratorium be applied to regulatory standards concerning local authorities, except for any mandatory international standards. I also encourage ongoing work that examines the cost to local authorities of the existing stock of standards.

- Second point: transfers from the State to local authorities will now remain stable in value. It is normal for the State to apply to local authorities the same rule it adopts for its own spending. This is a measure of collective accountability regarding the challenges of restoring our public finances.

- Third point, I want this freeze on State allocations to local authorities to be accompanied by a real strengthening of equalization, within the framework of State contributions, particularly at the level of municipalities and intercommunalities. Furthermore, these allocations will be adjusted according to criteria of good management to encourage local authorities to reduce their spending in the same proportions as the State. I ask the Government to study, in conjunction with Parliament and associations of elected officials, the modalities that this adjustment could take.

By controlling spending and implementing reforms, over the long term and with mechanisms encouraging responsible behavior, we will reduce our deficits without compromising the recovery.

But I would like to go even further.

We must today change our way of managing public finances by profoundly reforming the financial governance of administrations, particularly of the State and social security. I announced at the first session of our work, last January, that I wanted France to adopt a rule of balance for all its public administrations. I confirm this to you today.

The restoration of public finances must not be the commitment of a Government, but of the Nation.

It must therefore be long-lasting, and for that, the governance of our public finances must be modified.

That is why I wish to implement a constitutional reform: I ask the Prime Minister to initiate consultations with political parties and political groups in the National Assembly and the Senate based on the final conclusions of the report by Michel Camdessus, which will be submitted to me in June.

This reform should allow:

- first, to confer on the finance law exclusive competence over tax provisions;

- secondly, to strengthen the power of Parliament by allowing it to vote on the commitments regarding public finances that we make to our European partners;

Finally, this reform would require each government elected by the ballot box to commit to a five-year trajectory for the deficit. Each government would also have to commit to the date by which public finances will be balanced.

As you can see, ladies and gentlemen: the recovery of our public finances concerns us all, beyond political divides and beyond a single legislature. This recovery will focus on spending, it will be shared between the State, local authorities, and social security. It will be implemented over the long term, it will be enshrined in our fundamental law.

The goal of this entire strategy is still and always growth. In the absence of budgetary adjustment, it is our growth and our social model that are at risk. It is for this purpose that the decisions I have just presented to you have been made.

Thank you.