Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on Franco-German cooperation, particularly within the framework of the Eurozone, in Freiburg (Germany) on December 10, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

10 December 2010 · Franco-German summit (Sarkozy and Fillon with Chancellor Merkel), Franco-German cooperation and the Eurozone · Freiburg, Germany

Context
Sarkozy addressed a Franco-German summit in Freiburg, Germany on December 10, 2010, affirming European solidarity and joint economic governance with Chancellor Merkel.
Main themes
Franco-German cooperation, eurozone defense and stability, European integration, euro-bonds debate, tax system convergence, G20 French presidency, international monetary order reform, European solidarity, debt crisis response, Franco-German brigade and military cooperation
Duration
~12 min
41st percentile
Words
1,391
41st percentile
Sentences
65
43rd percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
10.6
27th percentile
Syntax
3.07
57th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
24th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 55%55%
  • Geopolitical 26%26%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

65 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Thank you, dear Angela. François Fillon and I would like to thank you for the idea of organizing this summit in this beautiful city of Freiburg. I would like to express how important, in the eyes of France, collaboration with Germany is. And for us, it is an honor to receive German soldiers in a framework of peace on the territory of the French Republic.

I have always been surprised that the Franco-German brigade is perceived as a deployment of French soldiers in Germany. We are two sovereign countries, two countries at peace, two countries that are founders of Europe, and so know well that, for all the French, this is a new signal of the depth of our friendship and the desire to root the friendship between the German and French peoples in a definitive way.

Of course, with Mrs. Merkel - and I will not revisit what she has said since I fully share her opinion - we talked about Europe and the euro. Let things be very clear, we are deeply attached to the euro. We will defend the euro because the euro is Europe, and Europe is a part of the future of our countries. Europe is the non-negotiable part of the future of our countries. Our determination is total, Germans and French.

And I must say that the trust and friendship between us strengthen each time, and I am happy to see the convergence of our analyses, which will lead us to make structural proposals regarding the best way to root Europe and the euro in the course of the year 2011.

Furthermore, with François Fillon, we have decided on the convergence of our tax systems with Germany, and I thank the Chancellor for her openness; it is very important. We cannot tell our partners: "we are in the eurozone, we must converge to defend the euro," and we, Germans and French, set a bad example. Therefore, this German and French convergence is, in our minds, only the prelude to the necessary economic convergence in the eurozone, of course, and more broadly in the entire European Union.

Finally, regarding the G20, it is not that France wants to associate Germany with its presidency; it is that France wants to work hand in hand with Germany on the ambitious objectives that are ours, particularly on the definition of the new international monetary order, where Chancellor Merkel will play an essential role in China and then throughout the year to present, in France in November at the G20 Summit, the first proposals for reform of the international monetary order.

Ultimately, we would like to experience this French Presidency with our German friends and more broadly with our European friends. Europe has ideas, a model, and it is now that these ideas and this model must be defended on the international stage. At the beginning of this 21st century, a new world must correspond to new ideas. And these new ideas, it is Germany and France that must, at the forefront, carry them.

Thank you.

Q - Is your refusal to consider the creation of European bonds and an increase in the financial stability fund definitive, or is the door still open for the future? And then recently, on Tuesday I believe, the German Minister of Economy and Finance expressed his willingness to consider more mutualization to respond to the debt crisis in exchange for more European political integration. What do you both think about that?

R - Regarding the mechanism, I have told you, we will do what is necessary to defend the euro, and I have nothing specific to say, except to affirm a very determined political will.

As for "euro-bonds," I fear I have not fully grasped everything. If it is about raising debt to the European level, that would have a disincentivizing effect for each state. However, we want exactly the opposite, which is to hold states accountable and not to disempower them.

If one day there is more integration, a much more harmonized economic policy, can we talk about it again? Perhaps. But in the current state of affairs, France's position is exactly the same as Germany's position.

Q - Madam Chancellor, the President of the Eurogroup, Luxembourg Prime Minister Jean-Claude Juncker, has strongly criticized Germany, particularly for rejecting the idea of "euro-bonds," and said that Germany is being simplistic. Did that affect you, Mr. President?

R - Listen, sir, I am very happy to answer this question. When it came to creating a support mechanism to help member countries of the eurozone that were under attack, the first contributor to this support mechanism is Germany, and the second contributor is France. I think we cannot label as selfish countries that are the first and second contributors. In political life, there is what we do and then there is what we say. Germany, by agreeing to be the first contributor, and France, by agreeing to be the second contributor, have demonstrated their European solidarity, and I do not think there are lessons to be learned in this regard.

Secondly, regarding the "euro-bond," I do not think we were consulted before this idea was put forward, and therefore it is not insulting anyone to say that we disagree; it is simply expressing an opinion. If we had been told beforehand, perhaps we could have understood better, but after all, we cannot be the only ones who cannot express our opinion. I am not convinced that French citizens and German citizens would be very happy if Mrs. Merkel and I accepted to mutualize the debt of all of Europe when there is not enough economic harmonization, not enough fiscal harmonization, not enough budgetary harmonization. We need to think - it is not forbidden - calmly, especially when facing a crisis of this nature.

Germany and France, we have been led to make proposals. We made them with one concern: solidarity in Europe, the interest of the euro, and the interest of European construction. And if we had not made these proposals, there would have been no alternative. Everyone has the right to have ideas; none are unbearable, and regarding "euro-bonds," perhaps even one day, if we manage to achieve more economic integration, more fiscal integration, more budgetary integration, we can talk about it again. But in the current state of affairs, there is a saying in France that goes: "one should not put the cart before the horse."

Q - Madam Chancellor, you mentioned earlier structural weaknesses within the eurozone and indicated that you would like to put these issues on the table next week in Brussels. Specifically, what commitments do you expect to address these weaknesses in the eurozone?

R - Yes, exactly. Next week we will agree on the drafting of the treaty reform, which is already something very important, to ensure the sustainability of the mechanism we created during the year 2010. We are formulating a common observation that this is a structural crisis and that therefore structural responses are needed. We will provide structural responses together, Germans and French, in the service of Europe. This is the work of the first weeks of the year 2011.

Q - There was this agreement in Deauville. Were there any agreements during the walk in Freiburg, as there were during the walk in Deauville? And will you support Mr. Weber's candidacy for the head of the ECB?

R - I understand the romantic aspect of the walk in Deauville. But I would like you to note the substance of the discussion in Deauville. And I must truthfully say that the Chancellor and I are getting better and better at working together, understanding each other's red lines, and converging our efforts. It is also for this reason that the next Secretary-General of the European Council will be a German. France was happy to support with all its strength the candidacy of a remarkable man, for whom I have much respect and friendship, if he allows, Mr. Corsepius.

I must say that - was it the snow or the number of people who were there - it felt like the whole city of Freiburg was present. But we did not discuss the issue of the ECB, as it does not arise today. But there is no doubt that we will talk about it when the time comes.