Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on French foreign policy, notably military presence in Afghanistan, France's attitude towards the revolutions in Arab countries, and the Eurozone crisis, in Paris on January 20, 2012.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

20 January 2012 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed ambassadors in Paris on January 20, 2012, outlining French foreign policy on Afghanistan, Arab revolutions, and the eurozone crisis.
Main themes
French military withdrawal from Afghanistan, Arab Spring revolutions, eurozone crisis, French foreign policy, tribute to fallen soldiers, Taliban and terrorism, European economic integration, Libya intervention, French proactive international role, Greek debt crisis, Maastricht Treaty shortcomings
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,382
80th percentile
Sentences
217
91st percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.72
15th percentile
Vocabulary
2.19
45th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 45%38%
  • Economic 23%20%
  • Ceremonial 14%12%
  • Institutional 11%10%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 16%

217 sentences in 60 paragraphs

Monsignor the Nuncio,

I thank you for your words and I ask you to convey to His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI my very respectful wishes. I have great regard for the Pope, as you know, and we all have a very emotional memory of his visit to France and the speech he delivered, Monsignor the Nuncio, in this very room.

Mr. Minister of State,

Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors,

Four of our soldiers have been killed. I want to pay tribute to their sacrifice. And for the head of the Armed Forces that I am, it is always a moment of great solitude in the face of my responsibility, before the shattered fate of these brave young men, who honor the French army, who have the spirit of sacrifice.

France's commitment in Afghanistan was decided about ten years ago. I have continued this decision, to stand alongside the Afghan people in their just struggle against the forces of obscurantism, barbarism, and a return to a medieval climate in a country where women and little girls were martyred.

The governments that made the decision to send the French army to Afghanistan, I believe, made a good decision. But the French army is in Afghanistan in service to the Afghans, against terrorism and against the Taliban. The French army is not in Afghanistan for Afghan soldiers to shoot at them.

I have therefore decided to send the Minister of Defense and the Chief of Staff of our armed forces immediately to Afghanistan. Until then, all training and combat assistance operations of the French army are suspended.

The Minister of Defense will report to us, along with the Prime Minister and the Minister of State, on what he will have seen in Afghanistan. And if the security conditions for our soldiers, as well as the conditions for recruiting Afghan soldiers within the Afghan army, are not clearly defined and secure, France will immediately draw all the consequences. We are friends of the Afghan people, we are allies of the Afghan people, but I cannot accept that Afghan soldiers shoot at French soldiers.

If the security conditions are not clearly restored, then the question of an early return of the French army to France will arise.

This return was planned for no later than 2014. I will discuss this issue with President Karzai during his visit to France.

The French army stands alongside its allies, but we cannot accept that even one of our soldiers is injured or killed by our allies. This is unacceptable and I will not accept it.

Undoubtedly, my following remarks will have a less dramatic dimension. It is a difficult decision that we will have to make in the coming days, but I must assume it in front of the French people and in front of our soldiers.

There is war. There are the objectives we have set for ourselves, and then there are security conditions that, if not clearly established, prevent us from doing the work we have to do. Everyone is faced with their responsibilities. In any case, as the head of the armed forces, I will take mine.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

2011 will remain in history as a year of upheavals. Upheavals with the "Arab Springs."

Upheaval with the tsunami in Japan and the Fukushima disaster.

Upheavals within the eurozone: Greece, Portugal, Ireland, and even Spain and Italy facing unprecedented difficulties.

Throughout this year 2011, France has been proactive. Proactive in Côte d'Ivoire, where for ten years, Côte d'Ivoire, long presented as the Switzerland of the African continent, found itself without elections. France took its responsibilities and France is proud to welcome President Ouattara for a state visit in a few days. Proactive in Libya, to protect millions of Libyans and the inhabitants of Benghazi from the murderous madness of a bloodthirsty tyrant. Proactive in Europe, alongside our German friends, to provide the eurozone with the governance and operational rules it lacked. Proactive at the head of the G8, proactive at the head of the G20 to address the major issues of the world.

In 2012, we will similarly be proactive in the face of the multiple dangers we will face.

First, the danger for Europe. Let us be clear, the eurozone remains in danger.

Banking crisis, public debt crisis, multiple difficulties. We have achieved results in Ireland and even in Portugal. It is now essential that the entire Greek political class understands that decisions cannot be delayed any longer to resolve the problems Greece is facing. What has been done in Ireland, Portugal, Spain, Italy, and even Germany and France, our Greek friends must do. And the later this is done, the more difficult and painful it will be.

The first lesson of this crisis is that the euro, by its very existence, imposes an integration of our economies that the authors of the Maastricht Treaty underestimated the necessity of. It is good to have the vision of a common currency, but it is somewhat dangerous not to think about the conditions to achieve this common currency.

We have had to catch up on this delay by establishing a number of rules, which we have put in place, and which will allow the eurozone to emerge from the crisis it is currently in.

I tell the ambassadors of all countries that are not from the European continent, we have established a true economic government of the eurozone, with a stable president, regular summits. The very idea of economic governance was a taboo idea a year ago.

The government is an economic reality.

Why this government? It is the summit of heads of state and government, for a simple reason, that democratic legitimacy can only come from heads of state and government. The Commission has an essential role to play: to ensure compliance with treaties, to ensure compliance with deficit reduction trajectories. But if the Commission is the vigilant guardian of the eurozone, it cannot be the economic government, because one cannot both manage and sanction. In that case, one sanctions oneself.

I would also like to say that Spain and Italy have made courageous and remarkable decisions. And France wants to commend the actions of Mario Monti and Mariano Rajoy. They can count on the determined support of France, as well as all their European partners.

But let us know that the eurozone will not emerge solely through institutional mechanisms. We will now need to tackle the substance of our policy. We must clearly change our trade policy. I assure you, there is no question of protectionism. It is simply a matter of reciprocity. Reciprocity is a word that must become a reality in trade negotiations. And, in this regard, Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors, Europe is the most open continent in the world. This will continue, but Europe expects other parts of the world to be open in proportion to what it is itself.

We will need to change our competition policy. The eurozone, the European Union, is a single market; there cannot be a competition analysis on 27 markets or 17 markets, depending on whether one is in the Union or in the eurozone; there is one market, the single market. Therefore, there is one competition, the competition of the entire single market. Europe will need to change its industrial policy to promote the emergence of large European groups, this last theme being linked to that of competition.

Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors,

At the gates of Europe, the Maghreb and the Mashreq are experiencing unprecedented upheavals. The peoples have mobilized in the name of the universal values that are dear to us: freedom, democracy, justice. Our duty is to support these peoples, with friendship and without interference.

Let us refrain from hasty judgments; let us refrain from premature judgments; let us give time to the new leaders of the Maghreb and the Mashreq. Building democracy, France knows, is not an easy task. The challenge of the ongoing democratic transitions is not so much the place of political forces that claim a strong link with Islam. The challenge is that these parties respect the rules and requirements of democracy, which are the acceptance of alternation and respect for minorities. The political minority, minority communities must be respected; it is the richness of the East to maintain this diversity.

Mr. Lemmens, please convey to His Holiness that France does not forget the Christians of the East, wherever they may be. The Christians of the East are one of the riches of the East. They are not alone. France will be determinedly by their side. France is secular, France is democratic, France is republican. France ensures that everyone can live their religious commitment and pass it on to their children. But France wants all religious minorities to be able to do the same in all territories of the world. This is a significant issue that touches the very core of our convictions.

You have also mentioned the Judeo-Christian roots; you know very well, Mr. Lemmens, that this is a subject of great harmony between us. There is no civilization without roots. We will help ensure the success of these young democracies. This is the "Deauville Partnership" and these are the relations we maintain with our new partners. Alain Juppé, whom I want to commend, has just made a successful visit to Tunisia, and next month we will receive the President of Tunisia, a country that France feels so close to, to invent an unprecedented partnership. 2012 will be the year of the refoundation of the Union for the Mediterranean.

2012, a year of hope for several peoples of the Near East, but also a year of all dangers.

In Syria, we cannot accept the fierce repression carried out by the Syrian leaders against their people, repression that is leading the country straight to chaos. And this chaos will benefit extremists of all kinds. Syria belongs to the Syrian people; they must finally be able to freely choose their leaders and decide their destiny. The Arab League has engaged in courageous action. It must continue, and the Security Council, whose mission it is, must provide its support.

We do not want to interfere in Syrian affairs, and no one, more than I, has sincerely tried to reach out to Bashar al-Assad. But at some point, everyone is confronted with reality, and France will not remain silent in the face of the Syrian scandal.

Danger for Lebanon, a country we feel so close to. There have been French soldiers in Lebanon, under a UN mandate, for nearly three decades. But these soldiers serving the UN are there to defend a sovereign and independent Lebanon. Not a subjugated Lebanon. A sovereign and independent Lebanon. And, here too, France's warning is clear. Anyone who attacks a French soldier will immediately face the consequences. We will not abandon Lebanon, but we will not be complicit in the subjugation of Lebanon, whether it comes from outside or from within. France is the friend of all Lebanese, without exception; and how could I mention the necessity of diversity in the East and choose our friends in Lebanon? We are friends of all, of all without exception. But for a free Lebanon, for a sovereign Lebanon, for a Lebanon that is left in peace, not for a Lebanon that one wishes to subjugate.

Danger for Iraq, threatened by the resurgence of religious tensions and terrorism. The world needs a united and diverse Iraq. And it would be a great tragedy for Iraq to explode.

Danger in Yemen, where the long-awaited democratic transition must be carried out in accordance with the commitments made and the resolutions of the Security Council.

Danger, finally, in the unacceptable paralysis of the peace process between the Palestinians and the Israelis. A rapid, credible resumption of negotiations is needed, with a precise timetable and a follow-up mechanism. How can we not understand that the "Arab Springs" make the situation of the Palestinian people even more unacceptable? How can we not understand it!? Everything is changing in the East, and it should be a frozen immobility between Palestinians and Israelis. We need to change the method; the Quartet is a failure. Let us stop with the assumptions of diplomacy. Let us stop masking reality: it is a failure. Let us change the method. We need to broaden the circle of negotiation. We need to remobilize the actors, all the actors who can contribute to resolving the central conflict. France's position is clear. We will never accept that Israel's security is called into question. We say this to everyone. Israel is not alone. The birth of Israel, at the turn of the mid-20th century, is a major political fact in the history of the world, in the aftermath of the tragedy of the Holocaust. Those who threaten Israel's existence must know that we will never accept the disappearance, the questioning of the integrity of this country.

The position of France is clear regarding the Palestinians. They must have access to a democratic, viable, modern state. How many more decades must they wait, having waited so long, when the best condition for the security of Israel is the existence of a Palestinian state?

France took its responsibilities when it came time to vote for the Palestinians' membership in UNESCO. It is a strong choice, a thoughtful choice. How can we deny the Palestinians entry into an organization that puts education and culture at the service of Peace? France does not accept this status quo because this status quo carries so many threats.

Finally, there is the question of Iran and its military nuclear program. The IAEA has revealed the progress made by the Iranian regime in its reckless race towards the nuclear bomb. The military base in Qom is beginning to produce highly enriched uranium. Iranian leaders have lied, not once—Iranian leaders have lied continuously and to everyone.

Allow me to share with you two convictions: the first is that a military intervention would not solve the problem, but would unleash war and chaos in the Middle East. And perhaps, alas, even more. Everything must be done to avoid military intervention. And my second conviction is that time is running out. France will do everything to avoid military intervention, but there is only one solution to avoid it, which is a much stronger, much more decisive sanctions regime, which involves stopping the purchase of Iranian oil by everyone and freezing the assets of the Iranian central bank. Those who do not want to strengthen sanctions against a regime that is leading its country to disaster, with the acquisition of nuclear weapons, will bear the responsibility for the risk of military escalation. Peace requires strengthened sanctions to avoid this risk of a deadly spiral.

Our goal is to stand by the Iranian people, but for that, we must compel their leaders to negotiate seriously before it is too late. And I thank Alain JUPPÉ for all the efforts he is making to achieve global consensus. I say this to our Chinese friends as well as to our Russian friends: help us to guarantee peace in the world. We clearly need you.

We clearly need you. And I choose my words carefully.

Finally, I will conclude with a theme that is dear to me, that is dear to France, which is that of global governance. To say two things: the G20 is only legitimate if the G20 makes decisions.

What makes the strength of the G20 is not simply that it represents 85% of global GDP. What makes the strength of the G20, because it is a small forum, is that the G20 makes decisions—not enough to France's taste—but it makes decisions. Let us not allow the G20 to become paralyzed. And I tell the Mexican presidency that we trust them to have great ambition during their presidency. If the G20 were to meet without a great objective and without making a major decision, the G20 would not survive.

A second remark on global governance: I will not revisit the necessity of UN reform, except to say that France will never renounce its right of veto.

Moreover, I do not know a single country with a veto right that would come forward to say it renounces it. That would be a crazy idea, which no one, by the way, is asking of France, no one. But the Security Council must be expanded.

To those who would like to replace France's veto right with European representation, I say "that makes no sense." Because that would mean that this European veto right would be doomed to paralysis. If we had to wait for everyone in Europe to agree to intervene in Libya, we would still be talking about a Libyan intervention on the ashes of Benghazi. And at the time of the intervention in Iraq, where France, indeed—paying tribute to Jacques CHIRAC—did not intervene, what would have been the position of the so-called European representatives? That makes no sense. But the Security Council must be expanded so that major countries are represented, because they have their place there and so that all continents can be represented.

New methods are needed. I think of the WTO—after all, the Doha round is at an impasse. The Doha negotiations are a failure. How many years must pass before we draw conclusions? And why is it a failure? For a very simple reason, which is that the parameters of the negotiation are wrong. The WTO round is a negotiation cycle between, on one side, poor countries and, on the other, rich countries. This world existed 20 years ago; it no longer exists today. Twenty years ago, one could say "on one side are the poor countries and on the other are the rich countries." Today, there are developed countries, as they say, the poorest countries, and in the middle, developing, emerging countries that are closer to industrialized and rich countries than to poor countries. To embark on a trade negotiation based on the myth of a binary world is a certainty of failure.

I add that I do not believe in these negotiations with 170 or 175 countries, where we sign an agreement on everything and sign an agreement on nothing. Let us allow, within the WTO, for block-to-block negotiations: China with Europe, Japan with the United States, Africa with Europe. Let us change our methods. We are in the 21st century; the rules of the 20th century can no longer function.

So, to conclude, you may find me gloomy. Yet there are reasons for hope. I see them in the development of Africa, which continues to surprise us. This Africa that so many observers and so-called specialists said was doing poorly. Africa, before our eyes, is developing economically and progressing democratically. Dear Abdou DIOUF, this is excellent news. Where is the failure of Africa that we were told about? Many African countries have growth rates that we envy. And the progress of democracy in Africa is undeniable. Good news also comes from the development of the South American continent. Its stability, but also its development around countries like Brazil, which is achieving remarkable results. Let us not forget the discussions on combating climate change. Just because it is out of the news does not mean it should be out of the concerns of state leaders. I say this all the more because the European Union will take its responsibilities—but the share of the European Union in global greenhouse gas emissions is now only 11% of the total and continues to decrease.

Ladies and gentlemen ambassadors, thank you for your attention. I, in turn, make wishes for each of your countries, for each of your leaders, and then I make wishes for you. So what wishes could I make for you?

Well, may the year 2012 see your governments keep you in Paris. Because, after all, are these not the warmest wishes we can make for people we respect and love? And to live and continue to live in the most beautiful capital, allow me to say, in the world?

So, may 2012 see you remain in Paris, before 2013 sees you take a new step in your brilliant careers, so that Paris is indeed your springboard. Happy New Year to all. Thank you.