Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on government and European responses to the economic crisis and the difficulties of the Eurozone, in Toulon on December 1, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

1 December 2011 · Toulon, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the French public in Toulon on December 1, 2011, outlining government and European responses to the ongoing eurozone economic crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone sovereign debt crisis, economic reform, European governance, fiscal responsibility, banking system stability, financial regulation, capitalism reform, French economic policy, truth-telling in governance, G20 leadership, structural reforms, public debt
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,525
93rd percentile
Sentences
324
96th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.75
17th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
59th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 57%56%
  • Geopolitical 21%21%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

324 sentences in 167 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Mr. Mayor of Toulon, dear Hubert,

My dear fellow citizens,

Three years ago, on September 25, 2008, at the worst moment of the financial turmoil that would plunge the global economy into the greatest crisis since the Second World War, it was in this very room that I addressed the French people.

I did not listen to those who advised me to say nothing for fear that by speaking the truth, we would create panic. I was convinced that to save confidence, to avoid fear, we had to tell the French the truth.

This truth, the French were ready to hear.

To tell them the truth was to tell them that France could not remain sheltered from a global crisis.

It was to tell them that this crisis was serious, that it would last, that it would have consequences on growth, on unemployment, on purchasing power.

To tell them the truth was to tell them that the entire banking system was threatened, that their savings deposited in banks were at risk, but that we would not allow any bank to fail, that we would not permit a single French person to lose a single cent of their deposits.

Not a single bank closed its doors, not a single cent of deposits was lost thanks to the banking rescue plan and the guarantees provided by the State.

It was not the bankers who were rescued.

It was not the shareholders of the banks who were protected.

It was the savings of the French people that were saved, as well as their jobs, because the failure of one bank would have led to the failure of all the others, and the entire economy, deprived of credit, would have collapsed.

And it did not cost a single cent to the taxpayer.

Telling the truth to the French was to tell them that the State could not indefinitely finance its current expenditures and its solidarity expenditures through borrowing, because one day, debts must be paid.

Telling the truth to the French was to tell them that the crisis was a structural crisis that required structural responses, that it called for accelerating the pace of reforms, not stopping or slowing it down.

Telling the truth to the French was to tell them that to emerge from the crisis, we would need to work more, not less.

I know that the lives of many French people are more difficult today, after three years of crisis.

I know that despite all the measures that have been taken, many French people have suffered and continue to suffer.

Everyone has had to make efforts, everyone has had to make sacrifices.

But let us take the time to look around us at the situation of European countries that did not timely grasp the extent of the crisis, that did not make the necessary efforts in time. They have been forced to cut wages and pensions and to massively increase taxes.

In 2008, I said that capitalism needed to be reformed. I said that finance needed to be moralized.

The G20 that France initiated helped to restore the confidence that was shaken everywhere.

One can always lament that it did not go fast enough or far enough. But if we look at where we came from and what has been accomplished in the last three years, a true revolution has begun: for the remuneration of traders, for tax havens, for banks, for commodity markets, nothing will be the same as before.

In September 2008, here in Toulon, at the heart of the storm, I outlined a vision: that of a production-oriented capitalism, of regulated globalization, of controlled finance, of sustainable development, of a new role for the State in the economy, of a new European and global governance.

Beyond the urgency that François Fillon's government had to face, with courage and determination which I want to pay tribute to, day after day, to protect the French people, France's policy has resolutely been aligned with this vision for four years. Not a single day have I renounced any of these objectives.

But today, fear has returned.

This fear that destroys confidence.

This fear that paralyzes consumers, that prevents investors from investing, entrepreneurs from undertaking, employers from hiring, bankers from lending.

This fear has a name: it is the fear that France will lose control of its destiny.

The only way to dispel this fear is to tell the truth.

The truth is that the crisis is not over and that there can be no political project that does not stem from a diagnosis of the crisis and its magnitude. Denying the crisis is to deny any prospect for the future.

What is called the sovereign debt crisis that is hitting Europe hard is the same crisis that continues. It is the crisis of private debt that extends into a crisis of public debt. It is the same crisis, which after hitting the banks, now strikes the States.

This crisis affects all major developed countries, regardless of the left or right majorities that have governed them and the policies they have pursued over the past decades.

We must seek the common causes that have led the world into the situation it finds itself in today.

It is in the establishment, starting from the late 1970s, of a globalization without rules other than those that guaranteed the freedom of trade that the origin of the current difficulties lies.

At the end of the 1970s, through a sort of pendulum swing, the ideology of laissez-faire triumphed to the point of making the world forget all the lessons learned from the Great Depression of the 1930s. Financial globalization took hold to artificially compensate for the damage that unregulated globalization was causing in the economies of developed countries.

It was necessary for the surpluses of some to finance the deficits of others.

It was necessary for debt to compensate for the unacceptable decline in the standard of living of households in developed countries.

It was necessary to finance a social model that was collapsing under deficits.

It was inevitable for financial capital to seek profits elsewhere that it could no longer hope for in developed countries.

Thus, a gigantic machine for creating debt was set in motion.

Thus, developed countries sought their salvation in the only path left to them: a headlong rush into debt.

In some countries like France, it was the State that went into debt. Not a single balanced budget since 1974! In other countries like England or Spain, it was households that went into debt for a long time. In others, like the United States, households and the State went into debt at the same time.

The extravagant growth of the financial sector, which has disseminated incredible amounts of debt, has resulted in the financialization of the economy. It has placed it under the exclusive domination of speculative logic and the obsession with the short term. We know the dramatic consequences on industry, on the environment, on inequalities, and on the degradation of the value of work.

As soon as the headlong rush into debt becomes impossible because lenders no longer want to lend, because the immense pyramid of debts, previously concealed by the complexity and sophistication of global finance, appears to everyone as a huge risk, a new economic cycle begins.

This new cycle will be very different from the previous one. The cycle that is emerging will be a cycle of deleveraging that will bring the pendulum of the economy back towards work and production, which developed countries had tended to sacrifice too much.

The transition from a great cycle of debt to a great cycle of deleveraging will be accompanied by an adjustment that all economic policies of developed countries will have to face.

I do not believe it would be economically just, nor morally acceptable, to blame the French for the difficulties we are experiencing.

We are not at the end of the Glorious Thirty. We are not emerging from thirty years of prosperity that need to be corrected for excesses.

We are not emerging from thirty years in which the French would have refused to make the slightest effort to face the competition from emerging countries.

For thirty years, the French have not consumed more than they earn. On the contrary, they save. French households are among the highest savers in the world.

For thirty years, in their vast majority, the French have endured more stress, more tension, more fatigue. They have increasingly struggled to project themselves into the future. I think particularly of the younger generations who are facing greater and greater difficulties in entering the workforce.

This situation has been all the more difficult to bear because for thirty years, the efforts of the French to be more productive have been considerable. They have been courageous.

And above all, for thirty years, those who work and who are proportionally fewer and fewer have seen their incomes heavily burdened by the costs of those who are living longer, of those who are pursuing longer studies, of those who are unemployed, of those whom life's accidents have plunged into distress.

Telling the truth to the French is to tell them that this situation, unsustainable in the long term, is being brutally aggravated by the crisis to the point that it is impossible to continue like this.

That is why pension reform could no longer be postponed and why its timeline had to be accelerated. To contest this reality is to gravely lie to the French. The reform we have implemented, which guarantees the financing of French pensions for the future, was a socially just decision. Allowing retirement at 60 without financing was a socially unjust decision.

Telling the truth to the French is to hide nothing from them about the consequences of the crisis and the efforts it entails for everyone.

If the French feel discomfort when they question their future and that of their children, it is because they feel that their lives are tossed about by crises for which they are not responsible, that they are no longer masters of their future.

To restore to the French the mastery of their future, we must restore to France the mastery of its destiny. And for that, it must fully enter the new economic cycle. It must prepare for it.

There are three ways to respond to the crisis.

The first is to deny it. To explain that it is not serious, that the crisis is just an excuse. This is to lie to the French and to prepare for catastrophes from which France would not recover.

The second is to make the exclusive choice of austerity, of rigor, of deflation. This would be the choice of lowering wages and pensions. This would be the choice to place the entire burden of the crisis on purchasing power. This would be the choice that would pull everything down, a choice that risks plunging the economy into recession and even depression.

There is another possible choice. That of responding to the crisis through work, through effort, and through controlling our spending. It is an adjustment from the top down. It is a choice that preserves the standard of living. Between lowering pensions and working longer, I choose the second solution. Between earning less and working more, I am convinced that the second solution is preferable to the first, that it is fairer and that it will allow us to emerge from the crisis instead of worsening it. This choice of effort, of work, is the policy that the government consistently follows.

In the world as it is, with the challenges we have to meet, with the trends of demographics, retirement at 60 and the 35-hour workweek have been serious mistakes for which we are now paying heavily and which we had to repair.

The crisis is primarily a revealer of our weaknesses. But as long as we know how to draw lessons from it, crises also indicate the way forward for reconstruction and give politics a responsibility and a field of action that is fundamentally unprecedented since the Second World War because everything must be imagined, everything must be reinvented.

We must first again address the urgency, by avoiding becoming a target for speculation by dispelling doubts about our ability to control our debt and repay our obligations. For doubt makes us pay more for our debt.

By reducing our deficits, we diminish the grip that markets have on us, we preserve the mastery of our destiny.

To reduce our deficits, we must eliminate our bad expenditures, those that are unnecessary, those that can be cut without diminishing the quality of public service, those that can be compensated by a reasonable effort in productivity, those that are the result of poor management, of poor oversight, those that have been allowed to drift due to a lack of courage to reform or a failure to anticipate.

For decades, we have spent too much and often poorly. This can no longer continue. The habit that the State had taken of being a counter where it answered yes or no, not to those who needed it most but to those who could protest the most and block the most. This can no longer continue.

We must reduce our current expenditures, being more attentive to the usefulness of public spending. We must continue to reduce the number of public servants while maintaining the rule of not renewing one out of two retirements. We must do this with determination. But also with composure, reasonably, without being swayed by the feverishness and excitement of the markets.

That is why, at the same time that we save, we must continue to encourage work and therefore overtime, preserve tax reliefs, and we must continue to invest, because the key to our future lies in productivity and competitiveness.

France has exceptional assets to face all competitions and all challenges. Of all the major developed countries, it is the one whose institutional system has best withstood the crisis. Thanks to its institutions, it can be governed even when times are tough. It is not by moving to the Sixth Republic, which would in reality be a return to the Fourth, that France will better master its destiny. We have experienced the time of bargaining between parties. The result was impotence, degradation, and confusion. In a world where decisions must be made quickly and with composure, without ideological bias, it is a guilty fantasy that France cannot afford.

When the global economy entered recession, the French social model proved effective in cushioning the shock. It contributed to the economy declining less in France than elsewhere.

But who can think of maintaining it without adapting it to the conditions of our time?

We do not educate, we do not care for people as we did yesterday. Crime is not the same as it was yesterday. Inequalities are not the same. And above all, a new inequality has emerged, one that makes life more difficult for those at the bottom of the ladder compared to a minority that wants to benefit from the system without assuming its share of responsibilities.

We cannot finance our social protection as we did yesterday by solely taxing wages when borders are more open and we must face competition from low-wage countries. The reform of the financing of our social model has become urgent.

We cannot keep the same organization of our social protection as that of the post-war period when those who change jobs, sectors, and professions multiple times throughout their working lives are becoming increasingly numerous.

In the face of the economic and financial storm, having a strong state like France, backed by a long administrative tradition, has proven to be a considerable asset, while a weak state, devoid of any authority, has appeared as one of the main causes that have led many countries to be swept away by the storm.

France has assets that many countries in the world envy. It has a dynamic demographic, a large youth population, talented entrepreneurs, researchers, and engineers, a high-quality, hardworking, well-trained workforce. It has a long industrial and agricultural tradition, skills that have been developed through the work of several generations.

It is not by renouncing our energy independence and shunning nuclear energy, in which France has invested so much intelligence and money for half a century, that it will best leverage its assets.

It is not by choosing a work-sharing policy that has failed everywhere in the world that France will make the best use of its resources.

This path turns its back on progress.

It is work that creates work; it is investment that generates investment.

Working more and better, training more and better, investing massively and better, these are the main levers by which France will align itself with the new economic cycle.

While in France, as in most major developed countries affected by the global crisis, unemployment is rising, we have a duty to seek all solutions to create jobs. The crisis must not make us give up. And just because there is a presidential election does not mean we should wait.

It is now that we must fight step by step, that we must mobilize all intelligence, all goodwill. We will not win the battle for employment without business leaders, without social partners. That is why next January I will invite all social partners to participate in a summit on employment so that everyone can contribute solutions, make proposals. We will need the courage to confront the big questions and to lift the taboos on the barriers to French competitiveness.

On employment, we have not tried everything. When we see unemployment rising, we do not have the right to say that there is nothing we can do, even if not everything depends on us. But in the end, only growth will overcome mass unemployment.

At the beginning of a cycle of debt reduction that carries within it recessionary trends, action in favor of growth must be more vigorous than ever. This crucial moment, where a new model of growth is taking shape, is one that must not be missed.

The triple revolution of digital technology, ecology, and knowledge changes everything. It disrupts modes of production. It shifts growth from material to immaterial, from quantity to quality, from standardization to innovation.

Alongside capital and labor, it gives new importance to these factors of production that are intelligence, knowledge, and imagination. The autonomy of universities, the Grenelle Environment Forum, the research tax credit, the 35 billion euros of future investments in higher education, research, and future technologies prepare this immense revolution. We must persevere.

This is not the time to be discouraged, to retract, to withdraw into ourselves, to take refuge in immobility, in caution, to reject progress.

This is the time to work, to invest, to undertake. This is the time when the state must become an innovator, an entrepreneur, an investor again, where it must lead those who invent, who create, who undertake. OSEO, the Grand Emprunt, the Strategic Investment Fund, these are financing tools for this long-term revolution. We must persevere along this path.

But we will not regain control of our destiny alone. We will not tame finance alone. We will not change the rules of globalization alone. We will not find the path to growth alone.

Everyone must understand that France is so engaged in the world, that its economy is so immersed in the global economy, that there is no difference between domestic policy and foreign policy, between national policy and European policy. Inside and outside, it is one and the same policy that a country like ours must implement to face one and the same crisis that is global.

Telling the truth to the French means telling them that isolation is not a solution, that we do not have the choice between openness and closure because closure would be deadly for our economy, for our jobs, for our standard of living. Closed societies have only one possible fate: decline. Economic, intellectual, moral decline.

It is this lucidity, this acceptance of reality that will allow us to have weight in Europe and in the world and to be able to set the limits that we do not wish to see exceeded.

Thus, we will refuse to erase our borders. They are the condition of our freedom, our democracy, our solidarity.

Thus, we will defend our identity, our culture, our language, our way of life, our social model.

Thus, we will not accept uncontrolled immigration that would ruin our social protection, destabilize our society, disrupt our way of life, and challenge our values. Immigration is fruitful if it is controlled so that those we welcome can be received under the best possible conditions, so that they can share our history, our values, our way of life.

Regularizing all foreigners in an irregular situation is the certainty of creating an uncontrollable pull.

Thus, we cannot tolerate the persistence of dumping, unfair competition, the plundering of our technologies that destroy our factories.

Ultimately, the only way to protect ourselves is to be the architects of a change with others rather than to engage in a solitary adventure that would lead nowhere.

Let us be aware that if we fail to change the rules of the game together, the world risks descending into a "every man for himself" mentality and protectionism, and we will head towards catastrophe, because then we risk retracing step by step the tragic path that the world took in the 1930s.

There is a reality that everyone must understand, that everyone must accept: sovereignty is only exercised with others.

Europe is not less sovereignty, but more sovereignty because it is more capacity to act.

One defends one's sovereignty better with allies than alone. This is the great lesson of the history of the 20th century. Renouncing our place as a permanent member of the Security Council and our right of veto would be nothing less than a mistake. We would not have been able to help the peoples of Libya and Côte d'Ivoire to liberate themselves.

France and Germany, after so many tragedies, have decided to unite their destinies, to look together towards the future. To go back on this strategy would be unforgivable.

History and geography have made Germany and France rivals or partners. By choosing friendship, Chancellor Adenauer and General de Gaulle made a historic choice.

Germany and France united means all of Europe is united and strong. France and Germany disunited means all of Europe is disunited and weakened. I will receive Chancellor Merkel in Paris next Monday, and together we will make proposals to guarantee the future of Europe.

Everyone has their history, everyone has their wounds. When we talk about currency, Germany remembers its history. We must understand it and we must respect it.

Everyone has their institutions, their political culture, their conception of the Nation. One is federal, the other is unitary. We must understand this difference. We must respect it.

France and Germany have chosen convergence. I will never go back on this choice. This does not mean that one wants to be dragged along by the other, nor that both want to renounce their identity until they merge.

The choice of convergence is not one of imitation but one of the lessons learned in common from each other's experience.

The choice of convergence is one of working together, of shared effort to build at the heart of the European economy a zone of stability and trust that will be the engine of European competitiveness. I will do everything to ensure that it is so.

Europe is no longer a choice. It is a necessity. But the crisis has revealed its weaknesses and contradictions. Europe must be rethought. It must be rebuilt.

There is urgency. The world will not wait for Europe. If Europe does not change quickly enough, history will be written without it.

This is the conviction of France and Germany.

Europe needs more solidarity. But more solidarity requires more discipline.

This is the first principle of the rebuilding of Europe.

Because solidarity must not be an encouragement to laxity.

Europe needs more politics. I mean more political responsibility.

Europe without politics, Europe on autopilot that merely blindly applies the rules of competition and free trade is a Europe that cannot face crises. It is an unarmed Europe. It is a Europe that is condemned to suffer. This is not the Europe we want.

Europe needs more democracy. Because Europe is an enterprise that cannot succeed without the peoples. Because if the peoples distrust Europe, Europe will retreat. A more democratic Europe is one where political leaders make decisions.

More politics is the second principle of the rebuilding of Europe.

The rebuilding of Europe is not a march towards more supranationality. It is not the reopening of old quarrels between proponents of Europe of nations and federal Europe.

Europe will be rebuilt by pragmatically drawing lessons from the crisis. The crisis has pushed heads of state and government to assume increasing responsibilities because, in the end, they alone had the democratic legitimacy that allowed them to decide. It is through intergovernmental means that European integration will proceed because Europe will have to make strategic choices, political choices.

Within the Eurozone, we must now decide to move forward without fear towards more decisions made by qualified majority.

Europe open to all winds, Europe that does not protect itself against dumping, Europe that opens its markets without demanding reciprocity from its competitors, Europe that allows products from countries that do not respect social or environmental rules to enter, can no longer continue. Europe must negotiate firmly to defend its commercial interests.

Europe, which enforces the principle of free movement internally and does not control its external borders, cannot continue like this. Schengen must be rethought.

Europe, which tolerates social dumping and tax dumping among its member states, Europe, which allows the subsidies it provides to some of its members to help them catch up with others to be used to lower their charges and taxes to create unfair competition for others, cannot continue like this.

Europe cannot leave its industrial groups at the mercy of all the predators in the world, because it forbids them from grouping together in the name of a false conception of competition. Europe can no longer ignore the absolute necessity of an industrial policy to support our sectors and our exports.

Europe must defend its common agricultural policy because in a world of scarce resources, food security is an essential element of independence.

Europe will have to make crucial choices in the coming weeks.

These choices can no longer be those of the 1980s.

The crisis is an accelerator.

The crisis is a major challenge for Europe. The greatest challenge it has undoubtedly faced since its existence.

Let us not hide it, Europe can be swept away by the crisis if it does not regain its footing, if it does not change.

But within Europe, there is Europe of 27 and there is the Eurozone.

At the heart of the European crisis is the Euro crisis. It is the most serious. It can sweep everything away. What will remain of Europe if the Euro disappears, if the economic heart of Europe collapses?

When it came time to choose the Euro, we were divided between supporters of yes and supporters of no. Each had their reasons, their arguments that were respectable.

But the debate is behind us. The Euro exists. Its disappearance would have dramatic consequences for the French. It would make our debt unmanageable. The collapse of confidence would paralyze everything. The French would become poorer... We do not have the right to allow such a disaster to occur.

Let us take the Euro crisis for what it is: a crisis of credibility, a crisis of trust.

It can only be resolved by restoring credibility, by restoring trust.

If we want the Euro to survive, we have no choice: we must oppose unwavering solidarity to all those who doubt the viability of the Euro and who speculate on its breakup.

It must be absolutely clear that all countries in the Eurozone will be solidary with one another. It must be clear that what was done for Greece, in a very particular context, will not happen again, that no state in the Eurozone will now be defaulted on. It must be absolutely clear that in the future no saver will lose a cent on the repayment of a loan granted to a Eurozone country. It is a matter of trust, and trust conditions everything.

It must be clear that this unwavering solidarity is being worked on tirelessly by all states and all institutions.

This is the purpose of the Eurozone Government that France has wanted and which will bring together heads of state and government to decide together.

This is why France has proposed the creation of a European Monetary Fund that will be the instrument of solidarity for Europe, which will be able to assist countries in difficulty. This Fund will mobilize the necessary resources to provide a bulwark against speculation. We will make it sustainable, strengthen it, and I hope we will allow it to decide by qualified majority.

Naturally, the European Central Bank has a decisive role to play. There are debates about what its statutes allow. I do not want to enter into these debates. The ECB is independent. It will remain so. I am convinced that in the face of the deflationary risk threatening Europe, the Central Bank will act. It is up to it to decide when and with what means. That is its responsibility. No one should doubt that it will assume it, and, by the way, I am pleased that it has already begun to do so.

This unwavering solidarity is not conceivable without stricter discipline. If we want more solidarity, we need more budgetary discipline. We must discuss our budgetary policies together, not so that they are the same everywhere while situations are different, but so that they come closer together instead of drifting apart. Let us examine our budgets together. Let us establish quicker, more automatic, and more severe sanctions for those who do not meet their commitments. Let us strengthen preventive measures so that the deviations we have experienced do not happen again. Each Eurozone country must adopt a golden rule that will enshrine the objective of budgetary balance in its legal order. France must adopt it. Ideally, if everyone acted responsibly, it would be done before the presidential election. If that is not the case, it should be done immediately afterward.

There can be no single currency without converging economies. If the gaps in living standards, productivity, and competitiveness widen between countries, the Euro will sooner or later prove too strong for some, too weak for others, and the Eurozone will break apart.

Convergence must be the watchword of the Eurozone.

This process will necessarily be long and difficult.

Since the beginning of the debt crisis, let us acknowledge it, Europe has disappointed. Not fast enough, not far enough, not strongly enough. I hear these criticisms. Sometimes, I have shared the impatience of observers. But the task was so difficult. The Maastricht Treaty proved imperfect. It provided for preventive mechanisms, but they were quite lacking, sanctions were rarely applied, and there was no emergency instrument.

We had to reinvent everything, rebuild everything, and we rediscovered that sometimes our conceptions of economic policy or monetary union remained different, despite 10 years of common life.

Now, in an extreme situation, after the long journey we have traveled, we must return to the essentials and reaffirm them solemnly. That is why France is advocating with Germany for a new Treaty.

More discipline, more solidarity, more responsibility assumed before the peoples, a true economic government. Such is our vision for the future of the Eurozone and the future reform of the Treaties.

It is so that in the world of tomorrow, Europe can still make its voice heard and keep alive a very ancient idea of civilization that it cherishes above all that France fights.

It is so that in the world of tomorrow, everyone, by developing, contributes to the development of others instead of each seeking to develop at the expense of others that France fights.

It is so that in the world of tomorrow, cooperation prevails over confrontation that France fights.

It is so that in the world of tomorrow, its values, its way of life, its culture are not condemned to disappear that France fights.

It is so that the French do not see everything they have built through hard work, intelligence, and generosity vanish that France fights, that it fights both internally and externally.

This fight, France leads it without arrogance, but tirelessly, with the conviction that in the midst of the worst economic crisis that has ever threatened the world in three-quarters of a century, it carries a hope that must not be extinguished.

Long live the Republic.

Long live France.