Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on government efforts in favor of the Atlantic Shipyards, in Saint-Nazaire on September 5, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

5 September 2008 · Statement on government efforts in favor of the Atlantic Shipyards · Saint-Nazaire, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed workers at the Saint-Nazaire Atlantic Shipyards on September 5, 2008, to outline government efforts to secure the shipyard's future under STX ownership.
Main themes
Atlantic Shipyards future, industrial policy, Alstom rescue and privatization, STX acquisition, shipbuilding heritage, worker welfare, subcontractor victims, Franco-Korean partnership, state intervention in industry, European industrial cooperation
Duration
~20 min
67th percentile
Words
2,453
67th percentile
Sentences
149
80th percentile
Readability
74
99th percentile
Grade
6.9
1st percentile
Syntax
2.69
12th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 65%60%
  • Ceremonial 18%17%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

149 sentences in 24 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Before I speak about your future, which I know is a concern for each of you, I would first like to address the President of the association of victims of the 2003 tragedy. I have not forgotten the day I came as Minister of the Interior. There were all the open coffins, and I know that this has remained and will remain as an event that no one here has forgotten. Whether you are from the shipyards or from a subcontracting company. Those who died under the walkway were not protected because they were subcontractors; they were in the same situation.

I know well that words do not bring back those who have left us. I know well that words do not ease the pain, but I wanted to start my remarks by remembering those of your comrades who died on that walkway, at the bottom of the hold that day. I was there; I have not forgotten. Know that these are not just words of circumstance. How can one forget that?

The transition is difficult, but it is the past, even if it is a painful past. Then there is the future. The older among you know that this is not the first time I have come to the shipyard. I have come several times, sometimes for happy moments, and it was one when you launched the last LNG carrier for Gaz de France that was built here. I do not know how to say it; I do not know if I was the godfather, but I was certainly the one who inaugurated it.

I know what the women and men who work here are capable of. I want to speak to you very frankly, without rhetoric, because I have everything in my head. It is a story I know well. I want to explain how we got here and what we are going to do, and I say this in front of the President of STX, whom I thank for his presence and with whom I just had a working meeting alongside Christine LAGARDE and Luc CHATEL.

The shipyards are primarily the story of Alstom. Alstom is a company that I had to rescue in 2004 when I was Minister of Finance and when no one believed in it anymore.

Alstom, due to poor management at the time, was in a state of near bankruptcy, could no longer find a bank to guarantee its contracts, had no shareholders, and a large part of those who were leading us at the time were in favor of selling Alstom to Siemens in parts. What I am saying is entirely verifiable. No one believed in it anymore. I visited almost all of Alstom's factories; I know all the industrial sites, and since no one wanted to invest in Alstom, I decided, as Minister of Finance at the time, to buy 22% of Alstom's capital. It was in a way a renationalization. I did it because if I had not done it, Alstom would have been finished today, whereas it is one of the most profitable companies in France. At that time, Alstom manufactured three things: rail, energy - there had been a serious error regarding the technology chosen for gas boilers - and ships. We saved Alstom. I left the Ministry of Finance in 2005 against my will; let’s say that at the time I had some explanations with the President of the Republic, who indicated to me that I could not stay, and it is under these conditions, alas, alas because I regret it, that Alstom sold the Chantiers de l'Atlantique. It is a decision I would not have made. So you can say it is easy to say: well, no, it is not that easy; I say it because I believe it. I have always considered that a great country is one that has an industrial policy, and that the basis of industrial policy, if one wants to be a great country, is to be the one that knows how to build cars, manufacture trains, make planes, and build ships. I have always thought that. I have never changed my mind, never.

After Alstom sold, Aker bought, and when Aker had its difficulties - I say this in front of the President of STX - I have nothing to hide because it is the truth; I did everything to find a European solution. We must not tell stories. They know it, and I think that when we are partners, we must speak frankly, and I noticed that neither the Italians nor the Finns wanted to invest as the French state was ready to invest; that is the truth. I found myself quite alone this time, the President of the Republic believing in the future of the shipyards, and when Aker had its difficulties, it was STX that entered the capital of Aker, and then everyone said: this is going to change ownership every two years; where are we being led, what are we going to become? Moreover, they were our Korean friends. Are they not going to take the technology and leave with it?

I prefer to say things because hypocrisy only leads to lies, and lies do not allow for a future.

I have only one word, and I will go to the end. I will explain myself. From that moment on, we began to discuss with STX. It is a large company that has many ships to build in its portfolio, which can bring us a lot, but naturally, I told STX that we, the Chantiers de l'Atlantique, we care about it. Why do we care? Because it took decades to create this industrial memory, this industrial know-how - what the English call "goodwill" - and in a few months, everything can be destroyed. What took years to learn can be undone in a few months. And when the older ones leave, they can no longer pass on to the younger ones; there is nothing left.

I will not let the Chantiers de l'Atlantique fall. I have never wanted them to be abandoned. It will not start today. I therefore told STX: we will prove to you that we care. How to prove it? Of course, there is the signing of agreements. Ah, the agreements! Everyone here can say: ah, yes, it is just a piece of paper! No. There is something better. If we believe in it, we invest. It is under these conditions that I told the government: we must invest; we will take a part of the capital to be a shareholder. What is the best testimony of my confidence in the future of the Chantiers, in the sustainability of high-end, high-technology shipbuilding at the Chantiers de Saint-Nazaire, than to take a part of the capital? As I did, by the way, for Alstom; it did not turn out so badly for them.

These are the conditions under which we signed an agreement with Mr. Kang to take 9% of the capital, plus a right of preemption on the 25% still owned by Alstom. If Alstom were to leave by 2010, I believe, it is the French state that will have bought 34%, because we want to be involved in all strategic decisions, because we believe that here we can build the most efficient ships in the world, be competitive, and because we want to keep this know-how in Saint-Nazaire and in France. So, we will become partners of STX. We will enter the Board of Directors, and we will commit to ensuring that the Chantiers live on.

You may tell me: you signed the agreement in June, and it has not been realized. That is true; I just spoke about it with Mr. KANG because in the meantime, STX's ownership of Aker went from 40% to 92%. They needed to succeed in their takeover bid before implementing the operation.

We will engage with Christine LAGARDE and Luc CHATEL in discussions on the valuation: how much do the 9% cost? We will discuss with Alstom to formalize the right of preemption, and you are therefore in a company where the state will find itself directly or indirectly owning 34%. This is the best proof of my decision to commit sustainably to the Chantiers.

To those who thought we could do better, there are always clever ones; the clever ones talk. The others act. It is a big difference. I do not ask to be believed on the speech; I ask to be believed on what I have done. And that is what I did with Alstom. Ask the colleagues at Alstom if they have fared poorly. By refusing to sell Alstom to Siemens when everyone was asking me to and by renationalizing part of Alstom to better allow Alstom to have an industrial shareholder, which is Bouygues today, and which is one of the companies that has hired the most in France and made the most money. For a company that was doomed in 2004, we must have made some pretty good decisions.

We will do the same for the Chantiers de l'Atlantique. I am aware that there are other issues; I have said this quite often. First, we created in France, did we not, Christine LAGARDE, the most favorable research tax credit system in the world. Because the Chantiers, you will remain competitive; why? How? If we continue to invest. Because if we do not invest, we innovate no more. And we are overtaken by events. I told Mr. KANG: there is now in France the most advantageous tax system for financing research and development. French taxation is no longer an argument. I challenge anyone to find a country in the world that supports research more than France does now. It is an asset for them. There will be other decisions that we will need to make in the future. I do not make any decisions; I do not announce anything. I simply say that we will need to talk about it.

Can we sustainably remain with a yard that builds civilian ships and a yard that builds military ships? This is a real issue. I know very well that among you, not everyone agrees, including among you union representatives. That is normal. It is not such a simple issue. I think we need to reflect on it, work on it, and see what we do in the future. By the way, the first thing the union representatives asked: what about the aircraft carrier? Oh really? The aircraft carrier is not a civilian ship, at least to my knowledge. It is not for cruising, to take retirees; I have nothing against that, by the way. We will have more discussions to hold about the future of the shipyards. I wanted to tell you that. I also add that I asked the minister, Christine LAGARDE, to meet with all the union organizations with Luc CHATEL so that your union representatives have the full signed agreement of the shareholding between STX and us. Of course, I ask the union representatives, and I trust them, for a guarantee of confidentiality because in the competition we are engaged in, it must remain confidential. But there is nothing to hide.

Ladies and Gentlemen, I am convinced that if we fight, not only will we keep the Chantiers de l'Atlantique, but we will also be able to develop them. The state's stake in a private company is a first since Alstom. It has never been done. I had never applied the decree on strategic activities. If we do it, it is because we believe in the future of the Chantiers de l'Atlantique. I think that in the world, we will need more and more high-end cruise ships, high-end LNG carriers. And it would be a weakening for France to let the Chantiers de l'Atlantique fall. In a few weeks, we will be co-owners of your shipyards. It is a major commitment; it is an undeniable turning point in industrial strategy, I mean in industrial voluntarism. I think we owe it to the economic future of France, and we also owe it to the generations of workers who have worked here, who have built a competence, who are respected all over the world.

I add, to conclude, that I told Mr. KANG that I did not agree to meet only on days when there are inaugurations. He indicated to me that there are about ten ships that Saudi Arabia is looking to have built, a billion dollars each. We will fight to bring that here. I know perfectly well that the order book is full for three years. For the workers who build, it is a lot. For the design offices, it is little because for the design offices, they must anticipate and work beforehand. From the moment we are associated with them, we will also fight, in my countless travels, to bring content to the order book. In any case, there is no other solution.

I add, in the agreement, a commitment not to relocate and not to compete with the Chantiers de l'Atlantique, but the best way for this agreement to be respected is for us to be part of the agreement.

Here is what I wanted to say to you. I know that for you, it has not been easy for years. There have been ups and downs, many of them. But that is a reason to appreciate today the decision I am announcing to you. It does not solve all the problems; what solves the problems is having new clients, new ships in the dock, new projects. But with a stable shareholder and the State 100% behind you, we are putting all the chances on our side. I will return to the shipyard, I will come back every year to ensure that what we have decided has been properly implemented. For me, this place symbolizes the industrial will of France. If we were to abandon the shipyards, we would be abandoning something more than just the shipyards; we would be abandoning an industrial will. We must not abandon the steel industry. We must not abandon the shipyards, but we must not abandon Alstom. Please believe that what I am telling you is the expression of a deep conviction. I know that here we do not speak much, we do not like promises, we judge based on results.

Ladies and gentlemen, by coming here, I am making a commitment. I am making a commitment. And I am making a commitment because I know that a decisive part is at stake here.

Thank you for your attention, and I thank Mr. KANG for his presence.

Thank you all.