Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on government efforts regarding the execution of sentences, in Réau (Seine-et-Marne) on September 13, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

13 September 2011 · Inauguration of a new prison facility · Réau prison, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed prison staff and officials at the inauguration of a new detention facility in Réau, Seine-et-Marne, on September 13, 2011.
Main themes
Prison policy reform, sentence execution, prison staff recognition, rule of law, security and firmness, rehabilitation and humanity, secularism in prisons, prison modernization, inmate transport mission, republican values, working conditions for prison staff
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,809
84th percentile
Sentences
186
87th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 56%56%
  • Social 34%33%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

186 sentences in 61 paragraphs

Mr. Minister of Justice, dear Michel MERCIER,

Mr. Deputy Mayor, dear Guy GEOFFROY,

My dear parliamentary friends,

Dear Jean-François COPE,

Dear Christian JACOB,

I am very happy to be with you today to inaugurate this new facility. It has been nearly 40 years since a President of the Republic visited a prison. 40 years! It was time to break this silence, it was time to honor the work of the prison staff and to highlight the importance of their missions for our country.

You are participating in a policy of firmness that I am not afraid to embrace, because it protects society, because it is essential for maintaining the rule of law. It is you, the prison staff, who guarantee to the French people that when justice is served, it is also enforced. There is no justice if justice is not enforced!

To all of you who are engaged in public prison service, I want to express my trust, the recognition of the nation, and the esteem of the French people for the courageous and extremely difficult work that is yours.

Allow me to have a special thought for your colleague who was cowardly attacked in Nancy a few days ago, near her workplace, solely because she was recognized as a prison guard. I also think of your colleague, a guard at the Pontet center, whose car was destroyed by an explosive device. These attacks are unacceptable. They will be punished very severely and they unfortunately illustrate the risks to which you are exposed; our fellow citizens must be made aware of these risks and must draw the conclusion regarding the esteem they should have for the profession that is yours.

Every day you are confronted with an environment where distress, violence, rejection of authority, social misery, and psychological distress prevail. Every day, you must embody firmness, as I have said, without which there is no security, but also humanity, without which we cannot convert those who have flouted the rules to respect them. Every day, you are the guarantors of republican values.

I know that detention sometimes fosters behaviors of withdrawal, community identifications, and renunciation of free will. I am aware of the fears you harbor when you observe among certain inmates the development of sectarianism and rarely well-intentioned proselytism.

We will not allow the great clearance sale of ideologies that undermine the order and secularism to which we are all deeply attached to take root in the courtyards of our prisons. The Republic must never renounce enforcing its values, and the values of the Republic must be respected in prison, perhaps even more so than outside of prison.

The prison career is now recognized for its importance in our society. The prison administration has modernized, and its staff has renewed. More and more young graduates, often women, are joining the ranks of your administration, as evidenced by the latest promotion from the National School of Prison Administration (ENAP), whose students are completing their studies today in Agen and preparing to join the field. I salute them, because I know that right now, we are being received live in Agen.

I know that you work under difficult conditions. In 2009, the government signed an agreement with your trade unions, which I salute, that allowed for significant improvements: greater presence of social workers and psychologists by your side, strengthening of night services in smaller establishments, new provisions for the payment of overtime.

Your status has also evolved significantly, with the creation of new officer grades and the distinction between the supervisory and command bodies. The new "insertion and probation" pathway, dear Michel MERCIER, which is being implemented this year, will complement this system. I hope that the Minister of Justice will continue the dialogue with you on these very important developments.

For a few days now, the Government has entrusted you with a new security mission: you now have the responsibility to transport and escort inmates when they are presented to a judge. This new responsibility, which was previously assigned to police and gendarmerie services, confirms the importance of your role. You are therefore, prison staff, the "third security force" that we have sought to develop in service of the French people.

My visit today should allow the French people to concretely measure the efforts that are yours, the efforts of France to give our prison policy a more humane face and one that is more in line with the demands of a great democracy.

In these places, perhaps more than elsewhere, we must be exemplary. How can we demand respect for others and respect for common rules if we do not know how to enforce them in our prison establishments? How can we protect society if detention inevitably makes inmates even more violent? How can we enforce the law if the prison itself is not a zone of law?

In this area, we have made progress in recent years. This is true in terms of institutions. Since 2008, the General Controller of Places of Deprivation of Liberty has fulfilled an essential function thanks to the determination and vigilance of Jean-Marie DELARUE, whom I have the pleasure of receiving each year since my election and hearing in detail his remarks on his work. I want to tell Jean-Marie DELARUE that I attach great importance to his mission, which he carries out discreetly, with the aim of improving the living conditions of all rather than increasing the number of articles he has in the press. It is in this way, Mr. DELARUE, that you have earned the respect of all the stakeholders in the prison. And it is in this way that the government has listened to you more. Because you have an obsession with the concrete and the reality of life in prison, there is no obsession with media coverage. These are issues too important to be discussed without knowing them.

This is also true in terms of texts, as we have clarified and modernized the rules of prison law. The law of November 24, 2009, Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians, enshrined considerable advances. We have strengthened the respect for the dignity of inmates by enshrining in law the principle of individual cell occupancy, as we have just seen. We have guaranteed the maintenance of family ties during detention. We have developed healthcare in prison, training, and work. Because prison should not be a period of idleness, but a time -- I dare say -- of effort, a time of transformation, as well as an opportunity to reconnect with an activity useful to society.

To give more meaning to the sentence, we have developed measures for adjustment that allow for a gradual reintegration, such as electronic monitoring at the end of the sentence, which allows the convicted person to be placed under electronic bracelet during the last six months of their detention.

Finally, we wanted our prison establishments to have the means to fully participate in the work of Justice. We have multiplied the renovations of buildings and created, since 2007, 6,000 additional detention places, which represents a 10% increase in our prison capacity.

The Réau facility perfectly reflects this effort. Along with the three other penitentiary centers that will open in the coming weeks in Nantes, Lens, and Alençon, it has been designed to promote intelligent detention: its architecture and equipment have been conceived to make the inmate responsible, to lead them to break with their previous way of life and to respect the rules of society. The opening of Réau will help reduce the occupancy rate of establishments in Île-de-France, which is one of the highest in the country - I believe it is 140% - and will thus contribute to a better efficiency of justice.

For effective justice, and I come to this essential question, it is justice whose decisions are followed by effects. This is particularly true when it comes to prison sentences that sanction serious offenses. The French do not understand why court decisions are not executed within a reasonable time. Our magistrates do remarkable work under difficult conditions, but their decisions need to be better enforced.

The sanction must not only be firm, it must also be swift. Because otherwise, it fosters a sense of impunity among offenders and a sense of injustice among the population. Since the beginning of the year, Michel MERCIER has implemented a national plan to reduce the execution times of sentences. We have strengthened the staff of the jurisdictions that have accumulated the most delays.

These efforts are beginning to bear fruit. The number of sentences awaiting execution has been reduced by 15%. Just think, simply because we have the will to do things, since the beginning of the year, in 9 months, the number of non-executed sentences has been reduced by 15%, because the Minister of Justice decided it and implemented a number of measures that allow for these results. But these results, as encouraging as they are, must be pursued and amplified. We must set a new ambition.

I have asked the Prime Minister and the Minister of Justice to present a programming bill regarding the execution of sentences this fall.

To execute sentences pronounced against offenders more quickly and effectively, the penal chain must consist only of strong links: we must strengthen the means of the services for the execution and application of sentences, increase our reception capacities in prison, and improve our tools for assessing dangerousness and providing care in detention.

Our primary objective will be to expand our prison capacity to meet our needs. I want everyone to understand that this is not a question of ideology, it is a question of credibility. We have no complex about a question that concerns the safety of the French people. Let us face reality: today, we are still not able to adequately house the 65,000 people detained in France, nor to ensure the rapid execution of pending sentences, despite the 6,000 places created since my election, and I dare say it because it is the truth.

Statistics prove it, French prison capacity remains lower than that of our European neighbors. It is naive to say otherwise; it is to refuse to look at the situation as it is. Éric CIOTTI, to whom I want to pay tribute, clearly pointed this out in the report he recently submitted to me, and I fully share its conclusions.

To ensure the normal execution of prison sentences, France needs 80,000 detention places. This is a reality that must be faced: it is simply a matter of having the number of prison places we need to house the offenders who have been sanctioned by the justice of the Republic.

This objective of 80,000 detention places will be included in the programming law that will be submitted to the Assemblies in the coming weeks. This represents an unprecedented equipment effort that will be completed in 2017: it will lead us to create 30,000 additional prison places. Given the construction timelines, we must begin this effort today.

We will need to find immediate solutions. I particularly wish that we can quickly open prisons dedicated to those sentenced to short sentences, who do not present particular dangerousness. This category of inmates currently constitutes the majority of incarcerated individuals, and most of the sentences awaiting execution are precisely short sentences. The Minister of Justice will propose, by the end of the year, a list of sites that could accommodate this type of prison facility, including military grounds or buildings left vacant by the Ministry of Defense.

In parallel with the expansion of the prison system, we must also diversify the structures. We cannot continue to confine a repeat offender sentenced to a heavy sentence in the same way as a first-time offender sentenced to a few months in prison.

This is dangerous for the safety of staff and inmates, it contradicts the goal of preventing recidivism, and it is costly for the prison administration, which effectively allocates the same surveillance resources to all inmates.

We also cannot ignore that part of the penal population, let us dare to say it, presents psychiatric disorders. This should not be a taboo subject; it is a reality that you, the prison staff, experience every day, which puts you in serious danger and requires special monitoring.

For all these reasons, we will establish facilities that provide diverse care, some with enhanced security and others more focused on preparation for release.

The second part of this programming law will strengthen our ability to prevent recidivism.

This is an essential subject. We must reassure our fellow citizens. We must guarantee the French people that all individuals under judicial supervision are subject to real and effective monitoring and that they are not released into society without proper oversight.

This is the task assigned to probation and reintegration counselors, who are at the heart of this policy and whom I know are mobilized. They need our support. That is why the Government has asked the General Inspectorate of Finance and the General Inspectorate of Judicial Services to produce a report on the upgrading of resources and the organization of the prison and probation services. The Keeper of the Seals will implement its conclusions.

Preventing recidivism involves better assessing the dangerousness of inmates at every stage of their prison journey, both upon entry and exit from prison. The bill will thus provide for the opening of three new national evaluation centers, which will complement those in Réau and Fresnes. With this system, 1,600 inmates each year will be evaluated by teams composed of prison officers, psychiatrists, and psychologists to be directed to prisons suited to their profiles or to be enrolled in reintegration programs. This is an unprecedented effort. Once someone is sentenced to prison, not everyone should follow the same path.

Regarding the treatment of sexual offenders, let us also stop the taboos, stop the hypocrisies, and look at the situation as it is. The treatment of sexual offenders in detention, before they reach the end of their sentence, is absolutely crucial. We will implement additional resources to ensure that treatment orders are better enforced and to generalize recidivism prevention programs. Treatment orders have so far been handled in a way that is, it seems to me, not effective enough. This is a major issue. A sick person entering prison will not come out cured simply because they have been incarcerated. I know that the question of voluntariness is difficult, but we must also protect society. We cannot treat a sick sexual offender the same way we treat an everyday patient who has not harmed anyone. We cannot apply exactly the same rules in the relationship between patient and doctor. Why? Because there is a third element, which is society, that knows the dangerousness of the offender being released and must be able to demand monitoring, that is, compliance with treatment orders, knowing where this sick person is, and taking measures to protect society. We cannot simply adhere to general principles; that is too easy. Dare I say, it is too cowardly, for you, the staff, for yesterday's victims, and for tomorrow's potential victims. This is a subject that the Keeper of the Seals will debate in Parliament, and I hope that each of us will take our responsibilities. Let it be clear here as well, this is not a left or right issue, it is not a matter of opposition or majority, it is a matter of responsibility. The rights of the patient are very important, but the right of society to protect itself is at least as important. I hope we keep this in mind when we approach the debate in a few weeks.

In the same spirit of efficiency, it is essential that all participants in the criminal justice chain can access relevant information for monitoring offenders, while respecting each party's prerogatives. Let us stop with professional secrecy in this matter; I respect professional secrecy, but when it comes to protecting the physical integrity of staff, everyone must have access to the file that allows them to better understand the person they are supervising. We need to organize the connection of the IT tools of the police, gendarmerie, courts, detention centers, and reintegration and probation services so that we do not repeat the mistake we recently experienced when it was decided to release someone because the last offense was not serious. This last offense was the 22nd, and the previous 21 should have been considered. You know well that there is a history, a life, that must be taken into account. I imagine that when you supervise someone, you do not only look at the last offense they committed, but at the entire history they have had.

The third objective of our programming law: the treatment of juvenile delinquency.

You know the importance I attach to this issue. I wanted, through the law of August 10, 2011, to strengthen the modalities of judgment for the most engaged young delinquents. What have I not heard during the debates accompanying the examination of this law, regarding the alleged will of the Government to ignore the specificity of juvenile justice!

It seems that the more difficult the subject, the more some are obsessed with caricaturing things. No one questions the necessity of an appropriate treatment for young delinquents. I know, dear Dominique BAUDIS, that you will be personally attentive to this as the Defender of Rights. But is it permissible to say some common sense things? What you know is that the juvenile delinquent of 2011 is nothing like the juvenile delinquent of 1945. To say this is not to harm the minor; it is to look at society as it is and not as we would like it to be shown with ideological reasoning. The minor of 2011, let us dare to say the words, is more violent than the minor of 1945. They are younger at their first offense. And to say this is to respect you, the professionals. It takes into account the difficulty of your job, which is much more challenging today than it was in 1945, which does not mean it was easy. This difficulty must be taken into account for judgment, as well as for the execution of sentences.

The quicker a sentence is executed, the more effective it is. This is even truer for a young person who has not yet settled into delinquency. We must therefore act more quickly: minors who are subject to monitoring must be taken care of as soon as the judge's decision is made, and not several weeks later, as is sometimes the case. The law will be amended in this sense, and we will deploy resources to ensure that educational monitoring is immediate. This is in the interest of society, the best way to prevent recidivism.

We will also go further by diversifying the modes of care for minors: the sanction must not only be firm and swift, but it must also allow for the re-learning of the essential values that underpin life in society.

When it was created in 2002 by Dominique PERBEN, the system of closed educational centers was a cultural revolution for the judicial protection of youth. I remember perfectly the countless criticisms directed at closed educational centers. Today, we see that there are no more criticisms. This system is beginning to yield encouraging results, despite a few incidents that remind us that preventing recidivism is a difficult battle.

Just because a few incidents exist does not mean we should throw the baby out with the bathwater. Closed educational centers are suitable tools.

The young people placed in these centers are supervised by a motivated team of educators, teachers, and psychologists. I want to express my admiration for these professionals. I was able to see this again this morning when visiting the center in Combs-la-Ville, which recently opened with the full support of Guy GEOFFROY, whom I thank.

I therefore wish for us to develop this type of structure. I announce that the bill will provide for the opening of 20 new closed educational centers, which represents a 50% increase compared to the 40 that currently exist. Given the reintegration project being developed there, it would be desirable for these centers to accommodate more and more young people sentenced by the courts, alongside young people awaiting judgment.

Diversifying the penal response for minors also means allowing offenders of less serious offenses to perform, for a few months, a "citizen service" within a defense reintegration establishment. This is a proposal that was presented to me by Éric CIOTTI and that the government will adopt.

This period during which the first-time juvenile offender will be subject to strict discipline will do them a world of good; perhaps they would not have become a juvenile delinquent if they had experienced this discipline that will allow them to break the cycle of delinquency. This is the meaning of the bill proposed by Eric CIOTTI, which will be debated soon in Parliament and which has my full support.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Not paying attention to the execution of decisions made by our courts would be to overlook a crucial issue.

The French have high expectations regarding justice. We must meet them.

I hear the criticisms, but I want to emphasize that, contrary to what is said, the resources for justice have been significantly increased, in an extremely difficult budgetary context. Over the past 10 years, the budget for justice has increased by more than 60%! It is never enough, but let us look at the world as it is and the situation we are in.

This is a considerable effort that reflects the importance of your role. Civil servants of the prison administration and judicial protection of youth, clerks, magistrates, each of you, through your decisions and actions, is the guarantor of the primacy of Law over force. Each of you contributes to the proper functioning of Justice, without which there is no freedom or democracy.

I would like you to understand my presence here as the head of state as a way to pay tribute to you, to assure you of society's respect, and to convey the feeling that we all have that it is here, with you, that the Republic will win the battle for the rule of law. You can be proud of your profession, you can be proud of your actions, you can be proud of the career choice you have made. I said earlier for the specialized educators I met, we all admire the choice you have made. You can count on my support as head of state to assist you in this fundamental mission and thus strengthen the bond of trust that unites you with the French people; the battle for the security of the French will also be won here, thanks to you.

Thank you.