Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on his priorities regarding police and the fight against delinquency, in Evry on August 1, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

1 August 2007 · Presidential statement on priorities regarding police and the fight against delinquency · Evry, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed police and security forces in Évry on August 1, 2007, outlining his priorities on public security and the fight against delinquency as President.
Main themes
Fight against delinquency, police and gendarmerie support, zero tolerance for violence, state authority and dignity, juvenile delinquency and impunity, public security policy, police accountability, law enforcement reform, loyalty to security forces
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,805
84th percentile
Sentences
244
93rd percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.67
11th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 57%56%
  • Social 33%33%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

244 sentences in 63 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

First of all, I would like to say that it is something very special for me to be among you, alongside our Minister of the Interior, Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE, in the presence of the elected officials of this department. This is not the first time I have come to Evry, but it is the first time I come here as President of the Republic.

I wanted to place this visit under the theme of loyalty: loyalty that I owe to the women and men of internal security, loyalty to the work we have accomplished together, loyalty to the commitments I made during the presidential campaign.

France can take pride in having, at all times, 150,000 police officers, 100,000 gendarmes, and 250,000 firefighters, both civilian and military, professional or volunteer, who ensure their protection, their safety, and their security.

I know you well. I have been by your side during these years, in your joys, your successes. I have admired your courage, your professionalism in facing the most difficult situations. I have also been with you in those dark moments, which cannot be trivialized, to which no one can become accustomed.

Just a few weeks ago, a young police officer, Reynald CARON, lost his life at the Foire du Trône. Justice, Mr. President, Mr. Prosecutor, will determine the responsibilities. But this violence is no longer tolerable. This violence that leads to the death of a 31-year-old young man, who dedicated his life to serving others, I cannot accept, just as I cannot accept the assassination of Lieutenant Colonel AMBROSSE or the death of Major JOACHIM of the national gendarmerie.

I cannot accept the tragedies that this violence causes in their families, for their wives, their partners, their children... What is the value of my support, so sincerely offered, in the face of unacceptable, irreparable losses for a family?

On what grounds should it be considered normal to strike someone, on the pretext that they are a police officer?

4,711 police officers were injured on duty in 2006: Among them, some of your colleagues, Captain AUBRIOT, Officer AUDIFFREN in Tarterêts, and many others.

I do not accept that representatives of the State are insulted, threatened, or assaulted. I want this violence to be subject to zero tolerance, because it concerns the dignity of these officials, the dignity of the State, because through you, it is the authority of the State that is being undermined, it is the Republic that is being offended.

This gratuitous violence calls only for severity.

While it is legitimate to grant you unwavering support when you are unjustly attacked, I want to remind you that serious offenses committed, compromises, abuses of authority cannot be subject to any leniency. The holders of authority that you are must exercise it with discernment and a sense of responsibility. I am pained when I meet the parents of little Nelson, killed by a police vehicle that did not respect any driving rules outside of any emergency. It is up to you, at all levels of the hierarchy, to be exemplary and irreproachable. When one of you behaves poorly, the entire institution bears the consequences.

I have always ensured this. I know that Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE will do the same, that is to say, in an uncompromising manner.

The prevailing thought told us that nothing could be done against delinquency, that it was violence, that society was like that, that to reduce insecurity and violence, society had to be changed.

We have proven that another policy is possible, that we must stop looking for excuses for delinquents, that we must stop acting as if all the causes of violence are in society and none in the thugs, that we must concentrate police resources on their missions: identifying those who commit offenses, seeking them out, arresting them, and bringing them before justice.

I have been told that we should not create tension, that we should not give a pretext to the rioters, that we must avoid creating conditions for confrontation at all costs. I know this reasoning.

Do we want the police to shy away?

Do we want the police to turn a blind eye?

Do we want the police not to apprehend fraudsters?

Do we want the police to let thugs act freely?

I do not want that.

If we prohibit police officers from pursuing delinquents for fear that an accident might happen to them, what kind of society are we preparing for our children?

Doing nothing because we want peace, practicing a form of naivety where we turn a blind eye to what is happening, prohibiting police officers from intervening to avoid any incident would be an irresponsible policy.

If being a minor excuses everything, if we allow the little thug to become a hero in his neighborhood due to a lack of sanctions that might make those tempted to imitate him think twice, if the little boss, after each offense, returns unpunished to his neighborhood to be welcomed as a hero, it is an insult to the Republic and an injury to his own future. For this impunity will lead the little thug to repeat his actions and serve as an example to others. If we continue like this, society will unravel until the day when self-defense takes hold and the State can no longer act. That will be the negation of the Republic.

Order is the hierarchy of values that is recognized.

Order is the security of persons and property.

Between 1997 and 2001, delinquency increased by 15%. Since then, it has dropped by 13.5%. In 2001, one in four offenders was apprehended. Today, one in three is apprehended. This is not enough yet. But if the strategy we adopted was not the right one - perhaps there are better ones - then what should we say about those that came before? Of course, there is progress to be made. But these figures are indisputable. There are more precise indicators that show that improvements have been made in all areas. I want to pay tribute to you for the effectiveness of your work.

We have implemented many reforms. The programming law for internal security has been scrupulously respected. We have provided significant resources to scientific and technical police. I cannot recommend enough to Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE to abandon this culture of confession, so deeply rooted in the police, to move towards a culture of evidence, through scientific and technical police, which should not be reserved solely for major cases, but should be present in police stations to give you all the means to do your job. I know that much remains to be done, and I know that nothing is more important than respecting the word given. We need a strong State. We must combat public impotence.

But the role of the President of the Republic is to ensure the application of the law and to protect honest people. I have committed to making the restoration of republican authority a priority. Without authority, there can be no possible social life.

I must say that the word authority does not frighten me. Authority is not authoritarianism. Authority is not blind obedience; it is consented obedience. Authority is not fear; it is respect. Authority is not force; it is legitimacy.

But let us stop pretending that the systematic contestation of any form of authority would lead to the improvement of society. Authority is needed, and that authority must assume its responsibilities. That is how it can work. We must respect the law. We must respect the officials responsible for enforcing the law. We must respect the elderly. We must respect women. We must respect children. We must respect the weakest. For that, there must be an authority that enforces the law. And that authority is you.

By denying all forms of authority, by rejecting all manifestations of authority, we risk reinstalling barbarism in our society. By contesting authority, we believed we were emancipating ourselves. The truth is that we have alienated ourselves. I know well that a young person builds themselves by saying no; that is no reason to say yes to them. I know well that a young person builds themselves by contesting the established rule. But if there are no rules, what do they contest? What kind of society are we preparing?

When authority is lacking, it is the most humble, the most vulnerable, those who do not have the means to protect themselves who suffer the most.

When there are no more prohibitions, when there are no more taboos, when there is no more hierarchy of values, when there are no more limits, when there is nothing sacred, then there is no more freedom. Go see in other countries when someone attacks a uniform. It would never occur to anyone. Officials must be respected.

I do not seek to be friends with thugs, I do not seek to be popular among traffickers and fraudsters. I do not seek to be well-regarded by rioters.

I will never equate the victim to whom we owe everything with the delinquent who must answer for the acts of which he is guilty. Perhaps a delinquent was once a victim? In that case, it does not improve their situation to make someone else a victim in turn.

I want to be the President of a France in which all the means of the State will be mobilized to improve the security of the French people.

We must therefore continue the work initiated in the internal security forces. I have asked Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE to prepare a new orientation and programming law for internal security, to strengthen operational achievements, develop the role of new technologies, improve our modes of organization, pool our two forces, and enhance the efficiency of services beyond mere brute performance. These objectives are ambitious. She has all the qualities to fulfill them, with you.

The stakes are vital. Our fellow citizens expect results, results in terms of reducing delinquency. We must particularly curb the rise in violence against individuals and further increase clearance rates.

We need to adopt a new policy to change the current situation in the suburbs. This is a major issue. The State and local authorities have already invested significantly in these territories. What do we see? We see that the situation persists, that the improvements we were expecting have not materialized. The objective is therefore republican: it is the end of ghettos, security, employment, and equal opportunities for all. The method is firmness and solidarity: the fight against gangs and crime, and at the same time, the right to the best education for those who have the will to succeed. The fight against discrimination, and at the same time, work rather than idleness. We must help all those who want to get out. We must make it clear to all those who want to poison the lives of others that society will not let itself be done to.

The international situation, the events in London and Glasgow must prompt us to a very real vigilance in the fight against terrorism. France is not a sanctuary. We must improve our systems. It is in this spirit that I have asked the Minister of the Interior to design a very large plan for the development of video surveillance, both in terms of the installation of cameras in strategic locations and in terms of pooling and utilizing images by the police forces. I was very impressed by how our neighbors were able to apprehend criminals who had planted bombs. Do we have the right to refuse the extraordinary contribution that video surveillance represents for criminal investigations?

I committed during the electoral campaign to provide a response to the problem of repeat offenders before the end of summer 2007. 5% of delinquents account for 50% of delinquency. We cannot tolerate having the same clients coming back under the same conditions for the same offenses. I find no excuse for repeat offenders.

That is why I wanted there to be minimum sentences for repeat offenders.

I had made a commitment to the French people to give justice the means to combat this scourge of recidivism. I have kept that commitment.

Parliament has adopted the bill strengthening the fight against recidivism. The message we are sending to delinquents is clear: prison is now the rule for repeat offenders, and more importantly, they can no longer ignore the minimum sentence that will be imposed on them. I am open to contestation; there may be other solutions, but then let them be presented to us. But in my mind, things are clear: when one is a repeat offender, one must be punished more severely when returning before the same court. It is a republican issue for society.

There was also the question of juvenile justice. Our principles are outdated. It is not about putting minors in prison. It is about putting back on the right path those who stray from it, making them aware as early as possible of what is permitted and what is not.

The 1945 ordinance is a generous and humanistic text. But how can we ignore that the 62 years that have passed since its drafting have rendered it obsolete and perfectly unsuitable for today's juvenile delinquency? It is quite extraordinary not to understand this. It is a completely respectable text, but it is 62 years old. Have young juvenile delinquents not changed in 62 years? Who can say that? Moreover, this is not a question of left or right. Here, beside me, are left-wing officials who are knowledgeable about these issues. There is not a single honest person who can say that things have not changed. This is not a question of the police's perspective or the magistrates' perspective. Everyone is convinced that we cannot sanction a 17-year-old repeat offender in 2007 as we did 62 years ago. Not to mention the considerable feeling of impunity that leads minors to be used today by unscrupulous adults, arguing this impunity.

The law that has just been passed puts an end to this incomprehensible gap between the commission of serious acts and overly light sentences. For the repeat juvenile offender, the excuse of minority is over. Minimum prison sentences will apply to repeat juvenile offenders over the age of 16.

We owe this firmness to the victims, but we also owe it to the police officers who are fed up with arresting the same individuals over and over. I remember, by the way - it was in the Essonne department - that I was told that five young people had been apprehended, the youngest being 13 years old, in a laboratory for making Molotov cocktails. These minors had been placed in police custody for questioning. I speak under the authority of the Prosecutor, who can testify to confirm that what I am saying is accurate. The question was posed to the minors: how was it that they had set up a laboratory? We were all astonished: the oldest, I believe, was 16, and the youngest was 13, and they had set up a laboratory for Molotov cocktails. Really, is that an occupation when you are 13 years old? We asked ourselves: why were there only minors? In the first 24 hours of police custody, we did not have the answer. Then, on the last day of custody, in the final hours, we got the answer. Because it was those we call "big brothers," a term for a thug, who had put minors to make the explosive cocktails, solely because they thought that the minors would remain unpunished.

If the public authorities, the Minister of the Interior, the President of the Republic, the Prime Minister, and parliamentarians, do not draw the consequences of this situation, we leave the officials that you are, who work under our orders and instructions, completely helpless in the face of a situation that no one can pilot or control anymore.

That is why we needed to provide answers. So, we will see, Michèle, does it work? Will it be enough? Will we need to go further, will we need to adapt? We will do it. But what we want is for the cancer of recidivism to be over. You understand, when we see citizens of 20 years old who already have 70 entries in their criminal record, it is a resignation of society to judge them as if nothing had happened. When we see young people, increasingly younger, embarking on this dead end of violence, gratuitous violence, savage violence, and society does not react firmly, it is a failure to assist a person in danger, for the innocent victim on the street, for the police officer or gendarme who will be injured, and even for the guilty party.

Of course, if nothing is said to them... I remember the case of the "gang of barbarians" - can you imagine, already, when one has the idea to name themselves that! Can you realize how lamentable we have become! The alleged leader, a certain FOFANA, 24 years old. When we recovered little ALIMI, he had been tortured on 90% of his body. I ask the question: does one become barbaric to that extent at 23 or 24 years old? Or were there alerts, signals, deviations, at a time when society did not want to respond with enough firmness?

What would have become of all these thugs, all these barbarians, if society, instead of turning a blind eye, had behaved normally and had severely sanctioned the first delinquent behavior? These are still questions I want to pose before the French people. It is my duty to pose them. If, Michèle, we do not pose them, who will do it in our place and who will say it? It is all well and good to have good consciences, it is all well and good to have long digressions about it is not their fault. Oh yes, it is not their fault, but still, at some point, there is someone who does something they should not do. Because in the French Republic, one must behave normally. It is not normal to kidnap an unfortunate young person who has done nothing and to go torture him, after all!

That is not the life we want in our neighborhoods, or to wait for a CRS officer, simply because he is in uniform, to beat him and hit him with a baseball bat, to the head naturally. That is, after all, Mr. Prosecutor, an aggravating circumstance. We can say whatever we want. When I went to see your colleague in the hospital, and I saw his injuries, all to the head, it is not a coincidence. It proves that they hit to hurt, even to kill. Let us say things as they are.

Justice, the police, the security forces, hand in hand, we must provide a response. I do not consider it normal that in certain neighborhoods, you have to send 80 officers to restore order. In a democracy, it should be enough for one or two police officers or gendarmes to arrive and for the mere sight of the uniform to impose enough respect and, why not say it, sometimes fear, for that to be sufficient.

Look at what is happening elsewhere. When, for years, it is considered normal that it is part of the risks of the job to be pelted with stones, the same goes for burned cars. It has been 25 years that this has become a national sport, so we decided to apprehend - even if it is very difficult, Mr. President, because it is very easy to set a car on fire. Generally, those who set fire do not set fire to their own, but to the neighbor's car, as if it amused them. If they want to burn cars, let them burn their own and not the neighbor's.

The day real sanctions are imposed, it will deter those who want to imitate.

Gentlemen, I wanted to tell you this, to tell you from the bottom of my heart, you are doing very useful work. I ask you to do it under the authority of your minister in an exemplary manner, because you are the police of the Republic, a legitimate force that obeys a code of ethics. We do not let ourselves go to anything, not even familiarity, not even the use of the informal "tu," not even having the window open with an arm hanging out. No, that does not happen. It is the police of the Republic. But at the same time, when one of you is hit, insulted, injured, we must be completely by your side.

We must achieve results. You know, the French people trust us, they trust you. But we must achieve results. After all, you chose a profession that is exciting, a profession where there is a bit of stress, a lot of responsibilities. You chose it! You wanted work, you will have it. You wanted responsibilities, we give them to you. But we want results. Yes, but then, I am told that I am putting pressure on you. Oh really? But what do you expect from me? That I say that we do not care whether you have results or not. What do you want me to say? It is not the same to have results or not to have them.

The police are on the ground. I have seen, in particular, that you are fully developing the incident report system, the IT, to know, in each police station, how to use the personnel. You often talk to me about personnel. Personnel, of course, is important, but at the same time I am convinced that we have tremendous productivity gains to achieve.

This is a discussion we will have with the elected officials. I am not convinced that everyone wants their own police station or their own police post. I much prefer that there are fewer police stations, fewer police posts, and more police officers on patrol. On patrol, there are also yellow stripes, not just blue epaulettes. Everyone, the leaders too, on patrol, for supervision, is very important. I know what I am saying. Everyone must be on the ground. I assure you, you will have a tremendous reward. First, because there is a merit bonus that Michèle will distribute. And then, the perception of our fellow citizens regarding the police uniform, the image of the police, will be strengthened.

The image of the police is very good. Be proud of the uniform you wear and of the way people look at you. People trust you. That is the truth. We have done a lot, by the way, to make it so. Keep up the good work. I hope you understand that it really pleased me to come here.

Well, good luck and have a good summer.