Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on hospital reform, in Paris on April 10, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

10 April 2008 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a commission in Paris on April 10, 2008, presenting his response to recommendations on reforming France's public hospital system.
Main themes
Hospital reform, patient-centered care, public hospital service, hospital governance and leadership, coordination of care, aging population and chronic diseases, private clinics and public service, territorial hospital communities, hospital staff, emergency care, demographic change adaptation
Duration
~18 min
59th percentile
Words
2,106
59th percentile
Sentences
134
76th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
9.4
15th percentile
Syntax
2.64
9th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 50%50%
  • Social 34%34%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

134 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Madam Minister,

Mr. Minister,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Six months have passed since the establishment of your commission. During these six months, you have listened, listened a lot. I believe you have conducted over 200 hearings. You have engaged in thorough consultations with stakeholders in public and private hospitalization and their environment. And God knows how important your environment is.

The proposals made by your commission are therefore the result of sustained dialogue. All viewpoints have been expressed in Paris and in the regions. All subjects have been debated without taboo. You have analyzed the situation of public hospitals with clarity. The role of private clinics has been considered without ulterior motives. And the proposals you present to us today are the result of collective work within your commission. All the sensitivities represented have contributed to the proposals. Let each and every one of you be sincerely thanked. This is a useful work not for the executive, but a useful work for our country.

It is therefore a high-quality report, dear Gérard, that you present to us today. I commend the work of the commission. I have a special thought for Professor Gérard CATHELINEAU, a member of your commission, who passed away suddenly on November 15, 2007.

You have made the patient and their expectations the heart of your proposals.

The patient's journey between the city and the hospital, or between the hospital and the structures for the care of disabilities or the elderly, is not coordinated. One could even say simply that it is not managed.

You know these hospital issues have fascinated me for a long time; I myself was President of the Board of Directors of a hospital center for twenty years and I even led the largest merger ever carried out in Île-de-France, then that of the hospitals of Puteaux, Courbevoie, and Neuilly. These are issues that interest me.

The proposal you make on the unique regulation of the continuity of care and emergencies is, in my opinion, essential. You highlight the role that local hospitals play in providing primary care in close collaboration with general practitioners, and I fully share your view that there are private medical practices that can provide a public service. Just because they are private does not mean they do not provide a public service.

More fundamentally, when you say that the hospital has not yet adapted to the aging population and the explosion of chronic diseases it entails, you highlight that there are 15 million people in France who are affected. That is not insignificant.

This is not about condemning the hospital. It is simply about giving it the tools to make this shift before it is too late. Stagnation will kill the hospital. It is a matter of the quality of the service it offers to each of us.

The hospital will need to redeploy its resources towards the care of disabilities and the elderly. The hospital must take its share of the response to demographic changes.

Roselyne, this is both a problem and an opportunity because it will be different from what we did for the judicial map where I asked for the closure of 20 to 25% of establishments. Fortunately for the hospital, we have this transformation. It is both a problem and, at the same time, an opportunity. There are always people who consider that moving on is a decline. I detest this active expression as if those who are in medium or long-term care are not active.

I hope that the territorial hospital communities, which you propose to establish, will play a driving role in these reorganizations. I expect tangible improvements in service for the patient: less waiting in emergencies, faster care for strokes.

Another characteristic of your report is the attachment to the missions of the public hospital service. The hospital is one of the public services that the French hold most dear. We have reason to be proud of our hospitals that treat all diseases of the world without discrimination.

I will not be the one to devalue the hospital. On the contrary, I want to be the one who modernizes it; it is a tremendous asset for our country. I also want us to pay more tribute to hospital staff, and I am fully aware of the malaise they are experiencing.

You show under what conditions a new breath, a new sustainability can be given to the public hospital service.

We need a clarified organization. The hospital needs a leader. I believe I even used this expression when I was in Bordeaux. Saying this does not ignore that there is a dual legitimacy in the hospital - the manager and the physician. But ultimately, the decision must be made by the director, whom you propose to make the president of the management board. The president of the medical commission would be the vice-president. The words do not shock me.

In the hospital, everyone has enough power to say no. No one has enough power to assume a yes. I am ready to go into the details because it is not just the director and the president of the medical commission, the CME. There are the unions, health insurance, local elected officials, rivalries between doctors and between services. Yes, that exists; at least in the one I chaired, it existed. I guarantee you. We must not have known the same ones, then.

These are not malicious rivalries, but when there is a bit of investment to share, there is naturally a rivalry, and then there are the average lengths of stay, the occupancy rates; at the same time, it is difficult to maintain obstetrics without keeping surgery, even within certain services between orthopedic surgery and visceral surgery, there are sometimes debates.

You also suggest centering the board of directors on a control mission by making it a supervisory board with an elected president. This leads to redefining the role of the mayor in the hospital's governing bodies. This is a very difficult subject, and I mostly agree.

There are mayors who completely disregard the hospital, and there are others who are passionate about it. For some, the hospital is just an employer and not a place that provides care. At the same time, not involving the mayor is problematic because he is the only one who has an overall view of public services in his municipality and with whom we can negotiate counterbalances.

You tell us that organization - governance - will not be enough, and I fully agree with you. Moreover, the work of your commission reminds us of the essential: that each hospital can organize itself as it sees fit. This is the French problem; we believe that equality is uniqueness, it is uniformity.

This is why you propose to give public hospitals an ad hoc status that would enshrine this freedom of organization. This specific status would allow for management flexibility. I agree.

Doctors would be offered more flexible and rewarding frameworks for practice. In addition to the current status, the statutory framework would be adjusted to offer remuneration that takes activity into account; this is a revolution. Come on, let's go; I also feel very revolutionary. Finally, listen, we continue to pay doctors who no longer set foot in the hospital and have no activity, who multiply conferences, debates, and trips - at least in the one I knew - and doctors who fight, who are active, who keep the hospital running, without any moment of differentiated recognition. Furthermore, a unique contractual framework, governed by labor law, would be created. These two new frameworks would be accessible to doctors on an optional basis.

I believe that these two proposals - ad hoc status and new frameworks for doctors - are fundamental. I even see them as the seed of the renaissance of the public hospital. These two measures are likely to make the hospital more efficient. And we will need regional health agencies equipped with the necessary skills to monitor the commitments made by establishments in terms of performance. We will need to see who will preside over them? I say, be very careful not to create a new administration if the regional Prefects do not have an essential role. The Prefect is still competent to define a hospital map! If we create a new health Prefect, we will have conflicts between the two. And the inability to negotiate counterbalances. We will discuss this, but they have somewhat disappointed us in their assessment. Because they were supposed to carry the seed of reorganization, they carried nothing at all, not all, but there are still many that have been timid.

The primacy of public service missions is finally reflected in your proposals regarding private hospitalization. It has an unparalleled weight in France. It represents nearly two-thirds of surgeries. You propose to formalize the participation of private clinics in public service missions through a contract with the ARS. You are right; it makes sense.

I support this proposal if it guarantees better access to care, whether in emergencies or regarding excess fees. I know this is not to burden the operation of private clinics but to recognize their utility in terms of public service.

In the end, what could be more obvious? Public service is not a status; it is the exercise of a mission.

I will stop here in reviewing your proposals. There are others that deserved mention. I have retained the most salient.

I hope that the entire report established by your commission will allow us to engage in an ambitious hospital reorganization. This reorganization will allow for the conversion of certain sites. We will need to evaluate the consequences in terms of employment management and skills.

Furthermore, your report must help us define the modalities for returning public hospitals to balance by 2012. Something must happen.

I will have the opportunity, during an upcoming visit, to return to your proposals, to outline the main orientations of the hospital reform. This, dear Roselyne, must be defined in consultation. The main measures that will be retained will be included in a legislative text that you will present before the end of the year.

I hope you understand one thing: I will lead the hospital reform. When I say I, I will take responsibility; you understand well, this time we will not overlook the hospital. There you go, I really want everyone to be convinced, whatever the opposition, I have no choice; I was elected to reform. The hospital has been the great forgotten of all these last years, for a very simple reason: it is the most difficult. It is precisely because it is difficult that we will do it. And I thank you. But let no one think that this work is just another pleasant report because I think they would be disappointed. I will take it into account.

Above all, everyone must understand, we have no choice. We have no choice because there are immense financial impacts, we have no choice because there is immense malaise. In fact, we have no choice; it is because the French have immense expectations of the hospital. Expectation, malaise, financial abyss, add aging on top of that, we have the full package; it would be irresponsible. Moreover, Roselyne, we will do this, but you must plan in the reform that if we make a mistake, we can modify and revisit it calmly. I do not believe in an immobile and definitive reform. You see what I mean?

This reform is monstrous; it is immense; we have done it; we are going for it boldly, but we will not hesitate to revisit certain points if we have made a mistake, or if it is insufficient, or if something has not worked. We need to stop this thing where we fight to the death beforehand, and then we forget everything afterward. There is a problem in France that is not simply about the will to reform; it is also about the management of the reform, which de-dramatizes things. It is not a drama to revisit one, two, three, or four points of a reform because we realize we were wrong, that it is not suitable, that there is a difficulty, that we need to move and do things differently.

I would gladly propose that when we move forward on the text, your group is always constituted to be consulted to evaluate, to help us so that this reform accompanies you with us. There you go, I thank you immensely, and I will have the opportunity to see you again, and I tell you how precious your work will be to us.