Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the reform of the State and territorial administration, in Cahors on April 8, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

8 April 2008 · Reform of the State and territorial administration · Cahors, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed elected officials, prefects, and parliamentarians in Cahors on April 8, 2008, to outline his agenda for state reform and reducing public spending.
Main themes
State reform, public spending reduction, territorial administration, fiscal responsibility, full employment, standard of living, European competitiveness, work valorization, comparison with European neighbors, coherence of reform commitments
Duration
~51 min
94th percentile
Words
6,076
94th percentile
Sentences
380
97th percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
8.4
7th percentile
Syntax
2.68
11th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
14th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 37%36%
  • Economic 35%35%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 5%4%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

380 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen Ministers, dear Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE, dear Eric WOERTH,

Ladies and gentlemen Parliamentarians,

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials,

Ladies and gentlemen Prefects,

Ladies and gentlemen,

During the presidential campaign, I made commitments to the French people. I committed to enhancing the value of work, Mr. Mayor, I forgot to greet you, I apologize. I committed to achieving full employment. I committed to increasing the standard of living. I committed to reducing public spending. I committed to reforming the State. I will not forget any of these commitments. Simply because, beyond the mandate given to me by the French people, these commitments are interconnected and form a coherent whole.

Ladies and gentlemen,

We cannot claim to return to full employment and improve the level of wealth without enhancing the value of work. We cannot enhance the value of work and raise the standard of living without reducing the burden of taxes and controlling our public spending. We cannot control public spending and improve the services provided to citizens without profoundly reforming the organization and functioning of the State. This is not a question of right or left; it is a question of common sense. For twenty-five years, our country has spent each year 20% more than it has in revenue. So, regardless of who the President of the Republic is, regardless of the majority, all are responsible, because I observe that, for thirty years, there has been both left and right. There is a situation. And if each of our families were in this situation, they would not say: I am on the left, I can continue to spend, or I am on the right, I must save. They would say: how do we manage?

Listen, our level of public spending is not an opinion I am giving; it is a reality I am describing. Our level of public spending is an anomaly among developed countries. I will prove it. There is only one country that spends more than we do. Only one. It is Sweden. But rest assured, at the rate we have known in recent years, next year, we will have surpassed it, the only country. If we had the same public spending rate as Germany, which itself is at the average of the Eurozone - I do not observe that Germany is a poorly administered country - we would have 150 billion euros less in public spending. This is a fact; it is not an opinion, it is not a viewpoint. It is a fact. So, I let you imagine the scenario in which 150 billion euros more would be available to the French each year. I ask the French to reflect on this. Do you really think that the Germans and other Europeans are doing worse than us? Do you really think that the Germans live in an ultra-liberal and savage world, they whose half of the ministers are socialists? Do you really think that the Germans do not have public services and do not have social protection, after two terms of Mr. SCHROEDER, who is himself a socialist? Do you think that German companies, German citizens who have remarkable performances in terms of foreign trade, exports, do you think they do not find themselves in terms of competitiveness and purchasing power? We wanted Europe. President MITTERRAND wanted Europe and was right. President CHIRAC wanted Europe and was right. I want Europe through the simplified Treaty. We wanted Europe, we built it, but it is not to find ourselves on its margins, with a public system that is more expensive and less effective than our neighbors. We did not want Europe to have the highest taxes in Europe, or else we should not have made Europe. If we make Europe, both left and right combined, it is precisely because we wanted to harmonize so that our companies are not disadvantaged in competition. What do we call that? We call it a duty of coherence.

I have therefore committed to reducing the level of public spending, and I will do so. But, ladies and gentlemen, in this situation that I am describing to you, which is easily verifiable, what I am saying can be verified. Who among you could stand up and say: very well, I understand. Therefore, we must increase public spending? Who? It is quite fantastic. Who? With what money and with what means? What do we do? We must reduce the level of public spending because there are no other means.

This is not a matter of ideology. Or else it is to believe that all other developed countries are ideologues and that we would be the only ones to be right against everyone. One can believe that; it is not my opinion. Many governments, whether left or right around us, I think of Spain, Mr. ZAPATERO whom I see very regularly, I think of England, not even mentioning Mr. BLAIR, Mr. Gordon BROWN, well, they have pursued reforms that have allowed them to regain control of their public finances. It turns out - it is extraordinary! - that at the same time these countries regained control of their public spending, they had stronger growth and lower unemployment. Fantastic to observe. It is interesting to look at what others are doing.

It is simply a matter of common sense, and I am convinced that the French understand it. Our public system - hold on, it is something. I have been President for eleven months - our public system has generated 1,200 billion euros of debt. This is a reality; it was not done this year. 1,200 billion euros of debt. We will have to repay it. Who here can stand up and say: but no, it does not matter, we can just continue to increase? And the worst part is that we have 1,200 billion euros of debt without performance that is exceptionally better than other countries, neither in terms of life expectancy. It is not true; life expectancy in France is not better than elsewhere. Nor in terms of unemployment. It is true that we have an unemployment rate today that is the lowest in twenty-five years, we are at 7.8 or 7.9. But there are 12 countries out of 27 in Europe that are at 4.5. Nor in terms of poverty; we do not have fewer poor people than elsewhere. Nor in terms of education; all our universities are falling in international rankings. Nor in terms of higher education, nor in terms of research. We have 1,200 billion euros of debt and we spend 150 billion euros more each year than the Germans. We would be entitled to expect exceptionally superior results. We must, however, and I will popularize these figures, reflect on this together.

I would also like to say that in terms of public spending, we have dared everything. We subsidized workers to stop working (that is early retirement). I am sorry; I am against it. We subsidize people to stop working when, very often, these same people want to continue working. It is total incoherence. We tell the French, and we are right, that they must work longer to pay for pensions, and at the same time, we send people into early retirement who only want one thing, which is to continue working. We must dare, and I say this very frankly. I am completely opposed to all these systems that encourage people to retire earlier when we need them to retire later. We increased public employment to lower the unemployment rate (remember, it was the youth jobs), and with that, we had the highest youth unemployment rate in Europe and the lowest employment rate in Europe for those over 50. It is an absolute triumph across the board.

We have given powers to local authorities, ladies and gentlemen elected officials, without reducing the interventions of the State. Fantastic. Since the first decentralization laws of Messrs. MITTERRAND and DEFFERRE, the first wave, at the time of the MAUROY government, there have been others. Listen, between the early 80s and now, there have been 300,000 more public jobs in the State apparatus. Note that at the same time, local authorities increased their jobs by 40% and hospitals by 30%. All this in a Europe we want to build and in a world where there is competition. I am not even talking about the 35-hour workweek. So, not only have we had more public spending, but the consequence of all this is that people have said: work has been devalued since it is not rewarded, and after all, between early retirements and all that, what is the point of working since one could earn as much without working?

But this money is that of the French. This debt is the legacy we leave to our children. We can no longer manage the fruits of the work of the French with such carelessness. It is a moral requirement: every euro of public money must be spent justly.

There are debates in our country, and I do not contest them at all. Some believe that public spending is good for growth. After all, this goes back a long way; it was KEYNES and the entire school that followed: public spending is good for growth. But, ladies and gentlemen, here too I ask you to set aside our ideological convictions. If it were true, we would have the best growth among developed countries since we have the highest public spending. If public spending is good for growth, we should have the best growth since we have the highest spending. However, it turns out that for the past twenty years, we have had rather below-average growth. Public spending is neither good nor bad in itself; it is good when it is effective. So, reform is not less; it is more. It is not less solidarity, fewer civil servants, less school, less treasury in rural areas, I know the department I am addressing; reform is more quality, more added value, more innovation, and ultimately more growth. Because your departments should experience absolute happiness since, for years, we have been continuously increasing public spending. And that is not what is happening.

When I was Minister of Finance in 2004, Michel Camdessus gave me an excellent report. My successor received the report from Michel Pébereau. Two excellent reports that said the same thing: public spending is too high and too ineffective; there are margins, we need to review spending. There are many excellent parliamentary reports on the inefficiency of public spending, and not just from right-wing parliamentarians, but from left-wing and centrist parliamentarians. The Court of Auditors publishes excellent reports every year, which we do not take into account. I say calmly, after the time for diagnosis, the time for action has come. That is what is expected of me. I will not order more reports. We will not set up more commissions. We must make decisions.

That is why I launched the general review of public policies. To identify ineffective spending and to control expenditure. I presented a series of decisions on December 12, then another last Friday. I announce that there will be another modernization Council in May. And we will make new decisions on spending chapters that have not yet been fully analyzed. And we will do as much as there are decisions to be made that will improve public service and free up margins.

Is a higher quality public service possible, at a lower cost? I will take an example, in front of Eric WOERTH, the merger of the taxes of the DGI and the Public Accounting, this should not be an absurd idea since Michel CHARASSE, who is not a great personality of the UMP, tackled it in the early 90s? Strikes. It stopped.

Then Christian SAUTTER, a great personality of the UMP, Christian SAUTTER? He is a socialist. He tried to do it. He was right. Demonstrations, strikes, it stopped.

This reform, Eric decided, it is done. I installed with him a new director of the DGI and Public Accounting. It is quite a strange idea that for fifty years, the officials who collect taxes belong to a different administration from those who calculate them. 80,000 on one side, 60,000 on the other. And even here, we must think about where we are going, depending on whether we go to give our check or whether we go to contest, to discuss, or to ask a question. It is quite extraordinary. One might think there is a single counter. Hold on, there even had to be a competition to move from the DGI administration to the Public Accounting administration. Those who invented this are strong. They may be strong, but we have decided to put an end to it.

These reforms do not cut back on anything. They improve the efficiency of the State. They also create room for maneuver for the remuneration of civil servants who will benefit from the reform. In fact, what is the alternative to this? It is, as usual, to do nothing. We wait. Wait for what? I do not know. But we wait. We continue, and that is the worst. Because doing nothing, when we do not have the means, means not renovating buildings. It means extending the lifespan of public equipment by wearing them out until they break down. It means leaving empty chairs in an unchanged organization. It means freezing salaries. This is what is called rationing, which is imposed on countries that have not managed to reform. But it is then that we call into question the quality of public service that the French deserve. It is then that civil servants see their working conditions deteriorate. We reform because we have understood that any organization modernizes by moving. A company does it for its customers who will otherwise go to the competition; a union does it for its members who will otherwise turn to the most effective in dialogue with management; a State must do it for its citizens; a political party must do it as well.

Some believe that reducing the number of State employees yields small savings. This is what I hear: why do you go to so much trouble for small savings? Well, let's talk about it. When we avoid a recruitment by organizing the service differently, we do not avoid one year of salary, but forty years of salary and twenty years of pensions. For a simple reason, it is that the State does not contribute to social security. The State pays the pensions of its employees. That is a reality. I am sorry to say this. When we hire someone, we hire them for 60 years. A company does not do that. Because there are contributions, and it is our pay-as-you-go pension system that comes into play. The State continues to pay. When it hires someone, it hires them for 40 years plus 20 years of pensions. This is an average, of course. Not replacing one civil servant out of two who retires between 2009 and 2011 means 3.5 billion euros in savings per year, starting in 2011. It is as if, in the end, we were reducing France's debt by 100 billion euros. It is very simple; the payroll of the public service is about 55% of the budget. If I am told that we should not touch the non-replacement of retirees, it means that we should not touch 55% of the budget. There is 15% of the budget for debt service. 55 + 15 equals 70. This means that we must make the savings come from the remaining 30%. This is not a left or right issue. It is a matter of knowing the budget of France and its facts, which are facts. Tomorrow, another President of the Republic will face the same reality if I do nothing. I want to give you figures, not to bore you, but because my duty is to explain to my fellow citizens the situation. The situation is never explained.

The number of State civil servants has therefore increased by 300,000 since 1982. And since 1982, there have been all the decentralization laws.

Since 1982, there have been all the decentralization laws, meaning that the State has had less to do. 300,000 more civil servants. Is it surprising under these conditions that we can identify productivity gains of around 4 to 5% allowing us to do better with fewer civil servants? But who can make the French believe that this is the dismantling of public services? The dismantling of public services, 300,000 more civil servants since 1982 with all the decentralization laws? I indicate to civil servants, who are the first victims of poorly organized work, stacked structures, and complicated procedures, that my ambition is to return to the staffing levels of the public service in 1991. If I manage to implement the non-replacement of one out of two, we will return to the staffing levels of the public service of 1991. Who was the President? François MITTERRAND. I do not remember a France completely disorganized in its public services, except that, in the meantime, the State has less to do today than in 1991, since there have been all the decentralization laws. Civil servants are not opposed to the reform of the State because they are the best placed to know that there is much progress to be made, and the reform of the State is an opportunity for every civil servant: it will bring them professional prospects, better remuneration - I specify to those who tell civil servants: we will increase the number of civil servants, they will have to explain to me how they will better pay more numerous civil servants when we already do not have the means? They will have to say it without laughing... We have designed the tools we need so that each change, each individual situation can be taken into account flexibly. It is natural for civil servants to ask questions; how could it be otherwise? I ask public managers, and at the forefront of them, the ministers, to place civil servants at the heart of the reform of the State and to explain what we are doing.

The State will set an example of reform, but it cannot be the only one to reform. I am thinking here of local authorities. Elected officials, you know, regardless of their political commitment, have the same concern because, in a city, as soon as you are mayor or deputy, senator, president of the general council, you are for everyone. The requests made to a left-wing elected official must resemble those made to a right-wing elected official. But I know that the role of local authorities is essential; it is no less legitimate than that of the State. I know the burden and dedication of our elected officials, but I know that today, too often, everyone does a bit of everything in a jumble of mixed competencies that does not allow for either the best public service or the best control of public spending. There needs to be better clarification of competencies. This is an unavoidable meeting, not just between the State and local authorities, but between local authorities themselves: regions, departments, communities of municipalities, territorial authorities. Dear Michèle ALLIOT-MARIE, we must tackle this issue and move forward. Local authorities will not be able to exempt themselves, along with the State, from this effort at clarification. The free administration of local authorities is not a vain word for me. I will certainly not be the one to dictate to the mayor of Cahors, the president of the general council of Lot, or the president of the Midi-Pyrénées region what they have to do, especially since they are not necessarily the wealthiest local authorities, and so I understand your problems. On the other hand, in all honesty, you are honest men and women, I want to tell you that overall, the grants that the State provides to local authorities will not increase faster than the expenditures that the Government devotes to its policies: education, research, solidarity, defense. It is not possible. I can tell them that when the State reduces its taxes, it cannot continue indefinitely to bear a part of the increase in local taxes. Look at the business tax. We have arrived at an unbelievable system. You increase the business tax - not you specifically, local elected officials - but you know that since the system is capped, businesses do not feel it. Why? We must tell the French because it is the State that pays the difference, and the reality is there: with a business tax decided by elected officials, on a base that is that of businesses (there would be much to say, by the way, about the calculation of the base), but in the end, 40% or 35% of the business tax is paid by the State without anyone knowing it, thus by you.

The State is the taxes of taxpayers, and I think that each of us, within the framework of respecting our differences, can assume this discourse; we cannot continue like this.

As for social policies, they cannot continue to feed the deficit and the debt. Passing on to our children the bill for our health and retirement expenditures via debt, even as the French population ages, is profoundly immoral. We will return to the balance of our social systems again through reform. We reformed special regimes; it should not have been so easy to do since others have not done it. They did not do it, not because they were unwilling, but because it was difficult. I did not do it because I do not like electricians or gas workers; that does not make sense; they are perfectly respectable men and women. But how could we explain to the French that some contributed for 37.5 years while others contributed for 40 years? I know well, there is the debate on hardship; it needs to be had. But finally, in the commercial service of the SNCF, you will have a hard time explaining that it is more difficult than being in a public service or in a local authority in the department of Lot. Everyone can see that it had to be done. The same goes for the question of 41 years; I did not invent it. It was signed in 2003, with the exception that there is a new fact. What is the new fact? I would also like it to be indicated to me; I am the President of the Republic; I am responsible for the fate of our nation. I cannot, on such important issues, ignore all of this. It is all well and good to tell the French: sleep peacefully; we will always spend more. Perfect, but with what results, with what accumulation of deficits?

So, I wanted to come to Cahors because I wanted to salute an absolutely remarkable initiative. And we do not need, Madame la Préfète, to be in a huge department; I am speaking in terms of population; I believe that Lot must have about 150,000 or 145,000 inhabitants, something like that; I do not want to say anything foolish. That is what is extremely interesting; it is that in this department of Lot, you sensed, before the central administrations, that it was necessary to move. And I come to salute the executives and agents who are engaged in this approach. A simple approach aimed at grouping services that work on similar policies. To organize the structures of the State not according to those of the central administrations but according to needs. With the creation of the general directorate of territories, the general directorate of the population, the general directorate of security. In one department, we are talking about around 500 civil servants; it is quite normal that you felt the need not to organize exactly as, perhaps, a department that is dear to me, like the Hauts-de-Seine department. You did this by understanding that more mobility is needed.

Two things are needed. More fungibility so that the credits that are decentralized can be allocated as you see fit. Fungibility is crucial, and more mobility.

I committed on September 19 last in Nantes to maximize the mobility of civil servants, and on December 12, during the first modernization Council, the corresponding decisions were described. After an intense phase of consultation with the trade union organizations, led by Eric Woerth and André Santini, we will examine tomorrow in the Council of Ministers a bill that removes all legal obstacles and establishes the right to mobility for civil servants. I committed to this, and I believe in it a lot because the quality of life of civil servants, the malaise in the public service is real. We must not kid ourselves. There is a real malaise within the public service, within the teaching body. It is not just a malaise that is only about the paycheck; it also relates to working conditions, and mobility is important.

The government has worked well; Parliament will be seized of it by the end of April, and in the field of public service, the promised reform is underway.

During the modernization Council on Friday, we defined the new regional organization of the State. We will only have eight regional directorates. There are about thirty today. As soon as there is a ministry, a central administration, it wants its own correspondence on the ground; we can no longer do that. Thirty regional directorates representing the same State. There will only be eight. The scheme we have defined is innovative; if we made a mistake, we will correct things. But finally, I would cite three of the innovations.

A regional directorate for sustainable development and housing that will correspond to the ministry of sustainable development; it is an administrative revolution that organizes the consideration of sustainable development in all relevant policies. Enough of saying that sustainable development is a priority, a priority in speeches. In reality, there was nothing.

I will then cite the regional business direction that will bring together the services dealing with economic development, consumption, employment, and labor. Businesses, employers, and employees will find there a contact point that gathers complementary skills, particularly to support economic changes. And you know very well, you, the elected officials, that when there is an industrial disaster, there are 25 counters and it’s a race to find out which one is the right one. We needed to bring some coherence to this.

And finally, we have decided to create regional health agencies. This will be a topic, because hospitals are a subject, and I will not shy away from it. It is a subject that fascinates me. The governance of hospitals is a very important issue; it cannot work without a leader, without a facilitator, everyone has the right to say no, no one can say yes. And then there is the hospital map. The regional health agency will bring together the skills in terms of organizing care, both in the community and in hospitals, but also in terms of medical-social establishments. It will be a coherent and comprehensive vision. Thanks to this reform, we will finally move beyond the duality of the State and health insurance. The creation of this agency must not harm the coherence of the State's action. So I tell you, I take my responsibilities; I think it would be a very good idea for the regional prefect to be the president of the supervisory board of the agency. We are not going to create two systems with a new health prefect. If the president of the supervisory board is not the regional prefect, you will have two systems, you will recreate two administrations, whereas the regional prefect must be at the heart of negotiating the maintenance of public services, providing compensations, and finding solutions.

At the departmental level, I have come to tell you that your example will spread throughout the country. Moreover, we have just decided that your organization in the Lot department will be generalized to the Midi-Pyrénées region. I think it is a good idea. If it works in your department, we will try to make it work in the same region rather than looking for another department. I also want to confirm that the role of the prefects is crucial. For me, things are clear; there is a leader in each department, it is the prefect. It is the prefect who must have authority over all administrations. Now, this does not mean that all departmental organizations must be the same. I believe that in the Lot, there are 1,000 foreigners arriving each year, according to what I am told, and that this is due to labor immigration because of the extremely rural nature of your department. Obviously, you can imagine that in Seine-Saint-Denis, the rural vocation is not the same. I am not in favor of all departments being organized in the same way. And I would like us to understand that unity is not uniformity and that equality is not uniformity. Departments do not have the same assets, do not have the same handicaps, and equality is not about giving everyone the same thing; it is about giving more to those who have less or who face more difficulties. Therefore, the unity of the Republic is not about organizing a rural department and an exclusively urban department in the same way. I willingly admit that this is an idea we will have to work on and that is not necessarily spontaneously that of our country, where in our country, spontaneously, we say: you have this, I want that. This is not necessarily the solution. And it is not necessarily how we guarantee equality.

So to conclude, I would like to talk about public service in rural areas. This is an extremely difficult and absolutely crucial subject. Why is it crucial? Because France is the country in Europe with the largest area. And therefore, the issue of land use planning necessarily plays out more in a country like ours than in Estonia. In Estonia, honestly, they do not have the problem of having an air force because the plane would not have time to turn around. It is a country that counts. It is one of our European partners. It is a friend. There is a million inhabitants, but the issue of land use planning in Estonia is not the same as ours. I would even say compared to Great Britain. We have a very large territory; it is a subject that is close to my heart and on which we must reflect. The identical reproduction of the same public service organization in all the cantons of France is the opposite of equality. This leads in rural areas to having in certain structures half an agent, unable to answer users' questions or counters open one day out of five. So yes, the building is there, with the corresponding sign, but it is not a quality public service. The vision that equates public service with structures is not mine. Public service is measured by the users. Rural residents also have the right to excellence. France must take the lead in Europe in terms of digital land use planning; it is the essential question of access to high-speed internet in our territories. The deployment of very high-speed internet can only improve things in the future. I know that recently, the Lot inaugurated the first public video point, thanks to an initiative from the General Council, the ANPE, and France Télécom. This is what we call the virtual counter with the best specialists.

The prefects will play a major role in the reform of the hospital map and in the reform of the military map. Let me explain; our armed forces must ensure the security of France, and I am the head of the armed forces. I am aware that the presence of a garrison creates land use planning. But we cannot tell our armed forces: be efficient for the security of the nation and, at the same time, do land use planning. There are about fifty air bases. We can cross our country with the Mirage 2000-5 in 20 minutes, and believe it or not, out of the fifty air bases, a good half have not seen a single plane in twenty years, not one! Let’s agree that an air base without planes poses a problem. It is like that; I do not criticize anyone. I describe a famous base of alpine hunters in Briançon, whose mission was to prevent the invasion of the Italians. Mission accomplished. I can see the consequences on commerce; I can see the attachment to garrisons, but at the same time, I remind you that the defense budget is the second budget of the nation. This is not a small issue; it is the third behind the debt, let’s say the second excluding debt; we will have to do something. What we will try to do with rural areas and public service is to be imaginative and think about what the best layout of public services in my department is. I take another example; proximity justice is not about having a local court less than a quarter of an hour from home; it is about obtaining a decision from the court within a reasonable time, a decision that is understandable.

I asked Rachida Dati for the reform of the judicial map. I will not hide behind my little finger; it is I who asked her. Since 1958, it has existed. We will eliminate between 20 and 25% of the courts; why? Because we find ourselves with courts with one judge. We cannot continue like this; it is not possible.

So for the hospital map, I think it will be simpler because we will transform some active bed establishments into medium and long-stay beds, which we need a lot given the aging population.

We also have the dramatic issue of palliative care. You know, the unfortunate ones who are seriously ill, whose outcome is certain, who must die with dignity.

And so the prefects will have a role to play because a city that has a problem with its garrison must be guaranteed its court; if there is a problem with its hospital, it must be guaranteed its sub-prefecture. Finally, you see, we must be able to create a network of public services in a department on one condition: there must not be a national scheme because the national scheme is the scheme defined by the central administration that will impose itself on others. This is the certainty of failure. We need to discuss with the actors in the department about the solutions.

I would like to conclude with this word: progress. This force that drives successive generations to build a better world for their children. Progress today must take into account new challenges, sustainable development, improving the standard of living, a modernized public service, but also reducing the deficit. It is my duty to bring France back on the path of progress to reconcile it with success and the great challenges of its time. Our country needs to work more. There is not a country in the world that works less. Not one! And that is why I wanted the tax exemption for overtime. Our country needs change, and I tell the civil servants in the room that we will give them half of the productivity gains generated by our replacements of one departure out of two. That is 1 billion euros per year, by 2011/2012, that we will give in purchasing power to civil servants. You know, I am well aware that what we are doing is difficult, but precisely because it is difficult, we must do it now. Because if we do not do it now, it will be even more difficult to do it later. It is unavoidable. And I would like to thank you, thank the elected officials who have come in a republican manner, and I thank them and thank you as well. We must explain to the French what is happening and what we are doing, and you have understood for me what is happening in this department of Lot; I wanted to congratulate the prefect; it is extremely interesting, and it shows that here, the civil servants of the State are at the forefront of progress. Thank you.