Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on judicial reforms including the creation of "citizen assessors," in Dijon on January 26, 2012.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

26 January 2012 · Dijon, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed magistrates, officials, and citizen assessors in Dijon on January 26, 2012, to mark the launch of the citizen assessors reform in French criminal courts.
Main themes
Citizen assessors reform, judicial democratization, citizen participation in justice, trust between citizens and institutions, criminal justice system, republican values, democratic reform, magistrates and lay judges collaboration, court of appeal experiment, civic responsibility
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,956
75th percentile
Sentences
156
82nd percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 74%74%
  • Social 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Economic 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

156 sentences in 51 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers, dear Michel MERCIER, dear François SAUVADET,

Mr. President of the Court, Mr. Attorney General,

Ladies and gentlemen magistrates,

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials,

Ladies and gentlemen citizen assessors,

Ladies and gentlemen,

My dear compatriots,

I am very happy to be with you today in Dijon. What better symbol than the former Parliament of Burgundy, where justice has been administered for over five centuries, to discuss with you the gradual opening of justice to citizen participation?

As you know, the reform of "citizen assessors" has been experimented with at the Court of Appeal of Dijon since January 1st. It is also being tested at the Court of Appeal of Toulouse.

For nearly a month, several hundred of our compatriots have been drawn from the electoral rolls to serve, as assessors, within the criminal courts. They participate in the judgment of serious offenses, both in first instance and on appeal, and are involved in decisions regarding conditional release that may concern heavily convicted criminals.

I attach the utmost importance to this reform because I am convinced that it will profoundly change the way the French view their justice system.

What have I not heard at the announcement of this project? It was a "populist" idea; it was an attack on magistrates; it was a useless and costly gadget that would do nothing less than paralyze criminal justice.

Let us take stock by asking a few questions: is it populist to want to bring the people closer to the institutions that represent them? I remind you that justice is rendered in the name of the French people. How can one say that the French people would be illegitimate within an institution that makes decisions in their name? Is it unnecessary to want to rebuild the trust between the French and their justice system? Who would dare to say that this question does not arise, that everything is fine? That magistrates do not question their profession and that citizens do not question their justice? Is it implausible to think that the judicial institution, in the face of all the difficulties it encounters, can benefit from citizen participation? Is it so shocking to trust citizens, to trust the French people, to trust their sense of responsibility, their civic sense, their capacity for engagement?

I am convinced that this reform of citizen assessors represents a major democratic advance. You can be proud to be its pioneers.

Magistrates, clerks, lawyers, you are preparing for this change. To all of you, I want to express my gratitude today. 210 assessors have been trained in Dijon and are now capable of fully exercising the role that the Republic has entrusted to them.

The ongoing experiment will be evaluated, which will allow for the generalization of the reform to all courts of appeal by the end of 2013.

I have just spoken with magistrates and citizen assessors. These exchanges reinforce my belief that the introduction of citizen assessors will place justice at the heart of our republican pact. Society has evolved, the relationship of the French with their institution has profoundly changed. The French expect a lot from their judicial institution and do not sufficiently recognize themselves in it.

Therefore, since judicial decisions are rendered in the name of the people, is it not legitimate to enshrine in law that the most significant of these decisions will now be rendered by the people, not simply in the name of the people but by the people, alongside professional magistrates?

This evolution merely continues the movement of democratization of justice that began with the advent of the Republic in our country. For over two centuries, the French have participated in the judgment of the most serious offenses, namely crimes, by sitting on juries in assize courts.

For over two centuries, the French have participated in the juries of assize courts. Has it ever been said that this participation undermines the judicial institution? In truth, it is a precious legacy bequeathed to us by the Revolution: involving citizens in justice, that is what allowed the founders of the Republic to nurture their attachment to democracy and to definitively break with the old regime. For over two centuries, we have preserved this tradition while allowing it to evolve. Since 2000, it has been possible to appeal convictions pronounced by assize courts, and since January 1st of this year, assize courts are required to justify their rulings. Just think, ten years ago, assize courts decided without the possibility of appeal, and just last year, assize courts rendered their decisions without justification! Imagine what it meant to be convicted without knowing the reasoning that led to that conviction.

You all know here that the verdict of a citizen jury is undeniably marked by a seal that inspires the deepest respect among our fellow citizens.

It is obviously legitimate, in a democratic society, for criminal justice to be a subject of debate.

Essential questions are at stake.

It is very understandable that our fellow citizens express demands regarding criminal policy. I often hear these demands. What does the French people say? They ask for greater severity. But let us not lose sight of this: if our compatriots ask for this, it is often because they do not know the subtleties of the judicial organization, because they do not understand certain decisions and sometimes feel that they are not applied with the speed they expect. There is a link between the misunderstanding of certain decisions and the distance between the French and the judicial institution, which explains the unjust judgments that are sometimes made about it. Today, in the context of an unprecedented economic crisis that shakes our traditional benchmarks, the French are wondering if justice hears their concerns. To say this is not to call anyone into question; it is simply to describe a situation that anyone could express in my place, in the same terms.

We must therefore ensure that the questions of the French do not remain unanswered, that their concerns do not gradually lead them to a feeling of distrust, which would be a catastrophe for the judicial institution. You know as well as I do that there is only a step from misunderstanding to rejection. That is why justice must open up.

To say this is not to call into question the competence of those who render justice. I have said it many times, and I want to repeat it forcefully before you: magistrates are competent, hardworking, honest men and women. They have my full trust, my consideration, and my esteem. They work with great professional conscience, constantly concerned with the public good, despite increasingly difficult working conditions. It is more difficult to render justice today than it was 30 years ago.

Involving citizens in the work of justice does not undermine the professionalization of the judicial body. Far from detracting from it, the reform of citizen assessors highlights this professionalization. It will allow the French to better understand the daily functioning of our courts and tribunals.

Justice has much to gain from this: it is an unprecedented opportunity to change the way the French view the judicial institution, to share with them the complexity of the situations that the courts must judge every day. It is an unprecedented opportunity to show our compatriots how seriously justice is rendered in our country. It is the very legitimacy of the decisions rendered by magistrates that will be strengthened.

I have also heard it said that the presence of non-professional jurors would destabilize criminal justice. However, I do not know of any instance where the presence of citizens in assize juries has ever weakened their role. The new assessors with whom I have spoken have all expressed their deep respect for the responsibility entrusted to them by the Republic and the attention with which they have fulfilled it. Similarly, the magistrates I have met have emphasized the seriousness and great awareness with which our fellow citizens have appropriated the terms of the law and approached the cases they had to judge.

I understand that the selection and training of new assessors represent additional workloads for the magistrates and the courts concerned. The presence of citizens inevitably implies an extension of hearing times. That is why, together with the Keeper of the Seals, we wanted to limit this participation to the judgment of the most serious offenses, in order not to overload criminal justice.

This is what led the Government to provide accompanying budgetary measures that we will continue, in terms of magistrate positions and clerk positions. This is precisely why Michel MERCIER organized exceptional recruitment competitions, so that the courts would receive additional staff as early as September. Because a magistrate or a clerk cannot be trained just like that.

Ultimately, it is the link between justice and citizenship that we want to strengthen, and that is why I attach great importance to this reform. I add that in matters of justice, we will continue to pay attention to the issues that concern our fellow citizens and the magistrates. A programming bill relating to the execution of sentences has been adopted in first reading by the National Assembly and will be adopted by the Senate.

Indeed, we must execute sentences more quickly, but also more intelligently, by increasing the number of detention places. Let us state the facts as they are: France needs 80,000 detention places. With 68,000 detainees today and 60,000 places, the institution cannot function normally, and the creation of these 20,000 additional detention places is a priority.

Justice, which is a factor of national cohesion, must ensure that the sentences it pronounces are executed. How do you expect our fellow citizens to understand that 100,000 prison sentences were not executed? How can we explain that a dangerous convict was not properly monitored and treated during their detention, when everyone knows they would regain their freedom sooner or later? These are essential questions.

The efforts made by the Keeper of the Seals and the courts have reduced the number of sentences awaiting execution by 15%. 15,000 sentences have thus been executed, and we will continue. That is why I proposed the vote on this programming law.

Finally, a word on the central question of the independence of justice. I was told: rather than creating citizen assessors, focus on giving more independence to justice. Justice is totally and completely independent; I have ensured that it is so. The constitutional revision of 2008 granted total autonomy to the Superior Council of the Judiciary. I am the head of state who put an end to sixty-five years of presidency, by the president of the Republic, of the most important body of the judiciary!

Those who are so concerned about independence were not shocked to see the president of the Republic, when he was one of their friends, preside over the Superior Council of the Judiciary? That was total independence; that posed no problem... I put an end to that situation. The Superior Council of the Judiciary is now presided over by the First President of the Court of Cassation for the judges of the bench, and for the public prosecutors by the Attorney General of the Court of Cassation. It is no longer the president of the Republic who presides over it.

Why was this not done before? How could such a mix between the executive and judicial powers inspire confidence in the French?

In the same spirit, I wished to extend to the appointment of public prosecutors the consultation of the Superior Council of the Judiciary. The opinions it renders regarding the appointment of public prosecutors, my dear compatriots, have been systematically followed by the Keeper of the Seals and by myself.

But we will go further. I announce to you that, as with judges of the bench, the Superior Council of the Judiciary will be called to render a binding opinion, and no longer just an advisory one, for all appointments to the public prosecutor's office. Understand me well, this means that henceforth, for both judges of the bench and public prosecutors, it is the Superior Council of the Judiciary, which is no longer presided over by the president of the Republic, that will ultimately decide on all appointments. Let no one come to tell me that there is a problem with the independence of justice, or else let them take the time to work on their files.

We must also face reality: in an unprecedented crisis context, we have made a tremendous budgetary effort for justice. Ladies and gentlemen, between 2007 and 2012, the budget of the Ministry of Justice increased by 20%, rising from 6.2 billion euros in 2007 to 7.4 billion euros in 2012. Judicial and clerical positions have been created each year, totaling 450 more judges and 1,200 more clerks, while at the same time I had to impose on the state the non-replacement of one civil servant out of two.

Ladies and gentlemen, judges, I am not saying that this is enough. I ask you, as responsible men and women, to look at the situation of your ministry. For the first time since 1945, state spending decreased last year. The budget for justice has increased by 20%. I have had to eliminate 160,000 civil service jobs since 2007, and there are 450 more judges and 1,200 more clerks.

Let no one come to tell me that justice has not been a priority for the state. I am not saying that you are privileged. This effort is normal: you render more decisions, society is becoming more litigious, and the call to judges is now almost systematic whenever there is a problem. I am fully aware that, in certain jurisdictions, you are facing an explosion of civil and criminal litigation, and that the situation of judges and clerks is still very delicate. We will continue this effort.

My last words will be for the victims. Justice is certainly an institution, but it is not just the business of professionals. We do not work in a closed circle. Justice - and I am thinking particularly of criminal justice - is primarily about the victims.

The stakes are immense, because it is not simply a matter of granting the victim the damages to which they are entitled; it is about acknowledging their suffering and responding to their humiliation. And it is about giving them the feeling that they are at the heart of our concerns.

There is a particularly scandalous form of double punishment that affects a victim, whose first punishment is the offense, the misdemeanor, sometimes the crime, the rape, that they have suffered. But their second punishment is the feeling they may have that society places more importance on the perpetrator than on themselves. I know that this is very difficult for you, the judges, and for the institution. I draw your attention to this point. The trial, whether criminal or correctional, focuses on the perpetrator, their personality, their motivations, their history, in an attempt to understand how a man or woman has come to this point.

The victim, their story, their personality, the fracture represented by the encounter with the crime or offense, must be taken into greater account. I know that I am sometimes criticized for being "compassionate," but I believe that it is not absurd in our society to show a little humanity. It is even necessary, but we must not only show it towards the perpetrator; we must also show it towards the victim.

The victim is not the obstacle to progress; they have things to say, the victim has rights to assert. The victim expects justice to provide reparation; they do not expect vengeance. They expect their pain to be taken into consideration.

I understand that during a correctional hearing with 30, 40, or 50 cases, there is not always time to take this into account. But for the one who is a victim of a crime or offense, for their family, being in court is not a trivial act. Valuing the victim is not showing cheap compassion. The judicial institution is primarily the institution of the victims, and you, the judges, work first and foremost for them.

Other professionals, in prison or elsewhere, will accompany the accused, the convicted, on the necessary path of reintegration. But when the victim leaves the courtroom, they leave with their pain and your decision. And they can find peace if they feel that your decision is just and that you have taken their suffering into account. If they do not have that feeling, they will feel anger and humiliation. That is why the job of a judge is so difficult, not because it is necessary to decide between two truths - that is a professional task that you carry out with much experience and competence - but because it is necessary to show both severity towards the perpetrator and humanity towards the victim. This must be done in the same decision, at the same moment, by men and women overloaded with work and responsibilities.

Ladies and gentlemen, I hope you understand that it is very important for me to be with you in Dijon. I want to tell the citizen assessors that they honor the word citizen, that they give it substance. They are much more observed than they imagine, and soon, everywhere in France, there will be women and men like them who can say: "for the space of one or several days, we were judges. It is a great honor, it is a great responsibility, and it is also a great difficulty." In a few years, the judicial institution will have been considerably strengthened for a simple reason: we are always strengthened when we trust the people. Thank you.