Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on nuclear research and the autonomy of universities, Le Barp (Gironde) on October 14, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

14 October 2010 · Statement on nuclear research and the autonomy of universities · Atomic Energy Commission and Alternative Energies (CEA) facilities, Megajoule laser site, Le Barp, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed scientists and officials at the CEA facility in Le Barp, Gironde, on the 50th anniversary of the laser's invention, to mark progress on the Megajoule Laser project.
Main themes
Nuclear energy and independence, Megajoule Laser project, research and innovation investment, university autonomy, French nuclear deterrent force, CEA and atomic energy history, alternative energies, scientific leadership, civilian nuclear program, energy security, French industrial and technological achievement
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,906
74th percentile
Sentences
130
75th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 31%31%
  • Technological 25%25%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Institutional 11%11%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Environmental 2%2%
  • Not in focus 2%

130 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Madam Minister,

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials, dear Alain JUPPÉ,

Gentlemen university presidents,

Ladies and gentlemen,

This year we celebrate the fiftieth anniversary of the invention of the laser. On this occasion, I wanted to come here, on this "laser road," at the heart of the facilities of the Atomic Energy Commission and Alternative Energies (CEA), to emphasize something that you know perfectly well and that we must convince all the French people of: the future of France and its independence depend on its ability to invest massively in research, to master cutting-edge research, and to capitalize on the applications of research.

What you are developing here with the Megajoule laser is in line with the decisions made by General de GAULLE at the time of the launch of the French military and civil nuclear program. God knows that at the time of this launch, this decision did not have unanimous support. God knows even that the question of nuclear energy is still raised in political debate. I say this as I believe it, as long as I hold these positions, France will continue to invest massively in nuclear energy. Nuclear energy is essential and it does not oppose alternative energies. We must invest in both.

In 1945, when General de GAULLE created the CEA, appointing Frédéric JOLIOT as High Commissioner for Atomic Energy, he launched one of the most ambitious scientific and industrial programs that France has ever known, a program that would lead to the birth of the French nuclear deterrent force. Mastery of nuclear energy marked for our country nothing less than the beginning of a new era. After the disaster of the Second World War, after the weakening of French power throughout the Fourth Republic, France regained its ability to be heard and respected around the world. I would like, when we talk about nuclear energy, not to forget this important element of contemporary French history.

This new independence of France did not rest solely on the nuclear deterrent force: the French nuclear program included a civilian dimension, with the Zoé reactor, our first nuclear reactor. Commissioned in 1948. But it is thanks to this unprecedented research effort that France is now one of the few countries in the world to be perfectly independent in terms of energy, even though it has no natural fossil energy resources. Today, this momentum must not weaken and will not weaken. Those who claim that we can replace nuclear energy with alternative energies are stating an absurdity, and it would be another absurdity to explain that because we invest in nuclear energy, we should not invest in alternative energies.

Thanks to the Megajoule Laser, whose project, dear Alain JUPPÉ, was born in 1995-1996, with the definitive cessation of French nuclear tests. But from the moment you announced with Jacques Chirac that the tests were over, it was necessary to invest in simulations, in what we did in the laboratory and no longer in what we did in the open air or underground. And we are about to have an extraordinary tool, which thus opens access to extreme physics and will allow us to finance and organize considerable scientific progress.

This laser will recreate for a very short time, in a volume of a few cubic millimeters, the same physical conditions of temperature and pressure as those of thermonuclear fusion. It goes without saying that it will be the most powerful in the world. How can one not be impressed by the enormity of the Megajoule Laser? Longer than the Eiffel Tower, taller than the Arc de Triomphe, built with three times more concrete than the Millau Viaduct. It is safe to say that it is a monument of science, here, Mr. President of the Aquitaine Region, here, Mr. Mayor of Bordeaux. And it will be even more so when it contains its 20,000 optics. Imagine the power of two nuclear power plants in a millimeter-sized target!

It is a considerable financial investment, 3 billion, and I also want to highlight the human investment that has made this project a reality. For 10 years, engineers, technicians, and workers have worked tirelessly to make the Megajoule Laser project a reality. I want to thank them, and I have seen the pride of all those who contributed to this historic, exceptional achievement.

The scientific program you are implementing is a considerable challenge for France. You will allow us to sustain our deterrent force for as long as necessary. And you will especially allow us to strengthen French leadership in research in this field.

Let us not forget that while the laser is an American invention, the way was opened by the work of a French Nobel Prize winner on optical pumping. And that the first thermonuclear neutrons produced by a laser were produced at the CEA, at the Military Applications Directorate, at the end of the 1960s, a directorate that I thank for the remarkable presentation it organized this morning.

The work of the Megajoule Laser will contribute to energizing the French industry in the field of high technologies. And for me, it is especially important to bring military applications and civilian research programs closer together. Finally, we understand what the Americans have been practicing for so long. Just as there should not be and must not be a gap between fundamental research and applied research, there should not be a gap between the university and research, there should not be a gap between the university and business, there should not be a gap between military research and civilian research, each nourishing the progress embodied by its own competencies and objectives.

Moreover, by choosing to implant the PETAL laser on the Megajoule Laser, we are paving the way for the exploration of a new form of energy. Thanks to its research, with the ITER and PETAL projects, France is now a leader in the global competition for energy production through fusion.

So this is a major program that you are embarking on here.

What does this prove? That France is still capable of having large-scale scientific and industrial projects. I would like to be understood. We have just emerged from a crisis that is undoubtedly the most significant in a century. A country's response to a crisis is not to withdraw, not to retract, not to lack ambition. A country's response to a crisis is innovation, research, openness, reforms, and projects. That is what is happening here.

Around the Megajoule Laser, with the "Laser Road," you are creating an ecosystem of knowledge. I was in Saclay two weeks ago, with Valérie PECRESSE, whom I thank once again, at the NanoINNOV site, but we see here the "cluster effect," the ripple effect, but who would have said just a few years ago that a competitiveness cluster would be established around this military site? I remember very well when Christian BLANC came to me, I was Minister of Finance, in 2004, to explain how the Spaniards had saved the leather industry, which was suffering from a considerable economic catastrophe. By creating what they called a cluster, bringing together all the small businesses in the same sector, equipping themselves with common communication and marketing networks, combining their skills, they decided to invest in luxury car leather. And I thought, in the end, in France, we have Crolles Grenoble, but we do not have a competitiveness cluster of the same nature. And it was from that moment that we created the sixty competitiveness clusters with tax advantages, with social advantages, but what is very important, I said to Alain JUPPÉ, is that if the competitiveness clusters we have labeled are not competitive, we delabel them. I mean that there is a duty to gather, to create, and even to excel.

Today, thanks to the combined investments of the State, the Region, and Europe, we have here:

- university establishments, since the University of Bordeaux 1, Sciences and Techniques will host researchers from its mixed units, those from the CEA, the CNRS, and the École Polytechnique who have come to use the facilities of the Megajoule Laser;

- innovative companies that have come to establish themselves around this platform;

- a transfer platform, Alpha-nov, which will be tasked with supporting the scientific and technical spin-offs of the Megajoule Laser.

You see, the competitiveness cluster "Laser Road" is exemplary of the policy we want to implement in France. So this policy, I want you to understand that we will develop and strengthen it. I am convinced that the French economy cannot do without a profound transformation of its universities, a profound transformation of its research institutes, a profound transformation of its tax policy.

We have created the research tax credit. I looked at the figures before coming, it is 4 billion euros per year that are refunded to companies that invest in research laboratories in France. France now has the most powerful tax system in favor of research in the world.

I say this to the parliamentarians who are here and whom I thank. I care a lot that we do not touch the research tax credit in the context of the budgetary discussion. For once that a tax system works in France, could we keep it? I remember a number of collaborators from Bercy who came to see me saying: "the research tax credit is catastrophic, we thought it would cost 2 billion, it costs 4 billion!". But I say: "what good news!". So here is a fiscal innovation that works because what we should not see is the cost of 4 billion. What we should see is the investment finally of French and foreign companies in research laboratories in France. And I will even tell you one thing: I hope it can cost more because it shows that we continue to invest in research in France.

Regarding universities, I would like to thank the University Presidents who are here with whom, by the way, I have had several working meetings recently at the Élysée alongside Valérie PECRESSE. Do you realize: your universities Bordeaux 1 and Bordeaux 2 have gained their autonomy since January 1. On January 1 next year, ladies and gentlemen, my dear compatriots, 90% of French universities will be autonomous. Who would have said it, who would have believed it, who could have imagined that in three years, the French university system would voluntarily, magnificently, evolve towards autonomy without drama, without theological quarrel, of course with some strikes, some misunderstandings... we are in France, some occupations... we are in France. But in France, we can say to the whole world, our university system has brilliantly passed the test of its transformation, and students, professors, and researchers should be thanked for that.

I want to pay tribute to the dynamism of President Alain BOUDOU so that the University of Bordeaux 1 can establish itself on the CEA site to host the Center for Intense Lasers and Applications, a research laboratory shared by the University, the CEA, and the CNRS. But it is in everyone's interest, especially the families and students of the region, to have a dynamic university. During my visit to the University of Bordeaux 1 building, I was able to gauge the enthusiasm and expectations of young researchers and doctoral students. It is extremely important that things are moving. But who could imagine that the world of the 21st century is moving at this speed while our university system or our research system remains stagnant? Autonomous universities must now place themselves at the center of this dynamic of knowledge; universities must diversify their sources of income and their partnerships. Just realize: at this very moment, there are 32 university foundations that will allow private sector resources to be attracted to universities. But why deprive ourselves of this? Few people would have bet on such an evolution. I know well that reform is not an end in itself, autonomy is not an end in itself; we also needed the means. For the past three years, Ladies and Gentlemen, universities have seen their operating funds increase by 18%. They had never experienced this before. And fundamentally, I understood why the academic world and the research world had been so resistant to change: because for too long, academics associated reforms with budgetary restrictions, and this created, and it is quite normal, a feeling of retraction. We knew what we had; we were afraid of what we would have. And fundamentally, what we have tried to build is a relationship of trust with French universities. We will provide you with the means you need, which you have never had in the past, but we demand reforms and evolutions in return. This is the win-win partnership. We have chosen the campus operation because there is no fatality: what is the fatality that would suggest that airy, magnificent, ecological, happy, cheerful campuses, that modern university buildings and not cracked ones, that quality sports facilities, that libraries open even on Sundays, all of this should be abroad and not here? Where is this fatality? I was deeply shocked when I heard that for many families, their dreams were to send their children to university in Spain, the United States, or even England. That our young people go to university abroad is an excellent thing, but they must go for the right reasons, not for the wrong reasons, not because they believe that in France one cannot study under good conditions.

So, we have allocated 5 billion euros to the Campus operation; the 10 massive university renovation projects will all have started before the end of this five-year term. There is no fatality; one cannot study well while looking to the future in buildings that barely reflect the present. There is no fatality; here too, the allocation of 475 million euros obtained by the University of Bordeaux is a great success that will help restore coherence to a university and scientific ensemble whose exceptional quality is not sufficiently recognized.

I would also add that in the program of the great loan, 35 billion euros, we will dedicate, following the remarkably chaired work by Alain JUPPÉ and Michel ROCARD, 22 billion for research and for the university. Perhaps these figures, this is what I would like to say in conclusion, may be dizzying, since I am told: "But how will you do it, because there are deficits, because France is in debt?" But, Ladies and Gentlemen, too often in the past we have made the wrong choice. The choice not to have the courage to question operating expenses and to sacrifice investment expenses out of convenience. The question is not whether borrowing is bad; the question is why do we decide to borrow? Borrowing to invest is a loan that prepares for the future, that creates wealth, that creates growth, and that puts France back in international competition.

And you thus understand, the means, the reforms, one with the other, and the refusal of old divides. We are in a new world. We need new ideas. And you researchers, you know better than anyone, the great scientific discoveries have often been marked by the refusal of consensus. If you researchers, you scientists, you academics, only had consensus in mind, then you would be in a single thought, whereas often, the greatest inventions have been made by breaking with that consensus.

Here lies the very great difficulty: to move everyone forward without leaving anyone behind, but to understand that we cannot remain still.

Really, I would like to tell you here, in Aquitaine, Mr. President, in Bordeaux, Mr. Mayor, in front of the academics and researchers, Madam Minister, that there is nothing more exciting for me than to see the capacity with which, regardless of your backgrounds, regardless of your sensitivities, you have managed to engage in the unprecedented modernization movement of our research system and our universities.

We will not stop there; there will be a stage 2 of the modernization of our universities so that the transfer of buildings goes better, faster, so that private partnerships are easier, so that cooperation with local authorities is more fruitful. Let us not oppose each other; they are the same families, the same young people, and the same territory; they need our collaboration and not our opposition. There will be a stage 2 so that university presidents can better assume their role, so that qualified individuals do not feel like they are invited to a side seat when they have their own place fully in the university. This is undoubtedly one of the most exciting projects we have undertaken.

I would also like to pay tribute to those who administer our major research organizations, that they do so with a concern for reform.

I would like to conclude with this: I am not obsessed with reform, but I have the responsibility to lead the 5th largest economy in the world in a world that is changing. Our country cannot remain still; we no longer have the means to wait to decide; we cannot sweep the dust under the rug; we cannot close our eyes to the deficits and delays that are ours. Our duty is to act, to act in the general interest, to act with justice, but to act. Ultimately, I believe that the worst injustice is immobility, the one that consists of maintaining injustices that are, in my eyes, no more legitimate simply because they are old. Thank you.