Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on sustainable development policy, particularly the implementation of the Grenelle Environment Forum, in Orléans on May 20, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

20 May 2008 · Presentation of the Grenelle Environment Forum conclusions and sustainable development policy · Orléans, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed officials and stakeholders in Orléans on May 20, 2008, to outline France's sustainable development policy and progress on implementing the Grenelle Environment Forum agreements.
Main themes
Grenelle Environment Forum implementation, sustainable development policy, ecological taxation and bonus-malus system, environmental protection and biodiversity, carbon cost arbitration, public consultation and democratic openness, behavioral change, nuclear energy parallel, Amazon rainforest protection, political commitment and consistency
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,665
93rd percentile
Sentences
280
94th percentile
Readability
52
70th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.86
29th percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
54th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 38%37%
  • Economic 25%24%
  • Environmental 22%21%
  • Social 6%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 4%

280 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Mr. Deputy Mayor of Orléans, Dear Serge GROUARD,

Mr. President of the General Council, Dear Eric,

Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians,

Ladies and Gentlemen elected officials,

Dear Christine LAGARDE,

Dear Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET,

I am very happy to be here in Orléans to talk to you about an absolutely major subject. It is nothing less than giving our country several decades of advance in sustainable development. What we managed to do several decades ago for nuclear energy, we are going to do for sustainable development.

Almost six months ago, I concluded at the Élysée the first phase of the Grenelle of the Environment, receiving the conclusions on which many of you here have worked hard and reached an agreement. I know how difficult it was for each of you, responsible for associations, business leaders, trade unionists, representatives of local authorities, representatives of NGOs, to accept the necessary compromises for this exercise. At that moment, we all took a risk: the risk of building together. We took the risk of exchanging our points of view - all as respectable as they are different - rather than remaining, each in the role-playing game in which French society has been locked for decades. I want to thank all the actors of the Grenelle for their open-mindedness and their participation.

You know that the word "openness" is dear to my heart. And to those of my own friends who did not always understand that openness was necessary in a country like ours, I respond that it is better to campaign on openness than on closure, on tolerance than on sectarianism, on listening to those who have a different opinion than on refusing to dialogue.

The Grenelle of the Environment has become such a symbol of a successful exercise in the regeneration of public choices, of a break in consultation methods, that everyone now wants to hold their own "Grenelle." The Grenelle of insertion, the Grenelle of the family. This is not a proof, certainly, of the effectiveness of the Grenelle, but it is a sign. The sign that the approach we have launched has allowed everyone to express themselves, to be heard, and to participate in public decision-making. I hold this spirit more than anything. I will not betray it.

If the Grenelle of the Environment were to be redone now, six months later, who would refuse to engage in this path? I know perfectly well that everything remains to be done. But the first decisions taken by public authorities over the past six months have been scrupulously applied to respect the letter and spirit of the Grenelle of the Environment. It is not simply a matter of gestures of goodwill, but the start of a sustainable development policy that states, in advance, everything that must be done, and rigorously does everything that has been said. I tell observers that nothing pleases me more than when they say: the President of the Republic gave a speech that recalls his campaign speeches. I claim this break. Very new in French political life, both right and left, to say the same thing after the election as before and to implement the policy on which I had committed myself beforehand.

During the Grenelle - I can still hear the cries of horror from some of my own advisors - I committed to two things: first, to arbitrate major projects in light of their carbon cost and their impact on biodiversity. I also specified that I wanted a reversal of the burden of proof in environmental matters. A reversal. And that it would therefore be up to the projects, whatever they may be, to prove their neutrality with respect to the environment. This is a considerable change because, until now, environmentally friendly projects are more expensive projects. If we arbitrate solely on the quantitative, we should not be surprised to have so little qualitative. When the question concretely arose about opening a gold mine on the Kaw Mountain in Guyana, we were firm, faithful to our commitments, despite the considerable economic interests of this project. I refused the opening of the gold mine on the Kaw Mountain because I believed it would seriously jeopardize biodiversity in this unique place that is the Amazon rainforest, even if it is in the French Guiana part.

When, with Jean-Louis BORLOO and Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET, we announced our intention to use ecological taxation to modify behaviors, this ambition was met with fear by some, we were going too far, and with skepticism by others, we were not going far enough. And it was the bonus/malus on the purchase of new vehicles: it has been in effect since the beginning of the year, directing French purchases towards the most efficient vehicles in terms of CO2 emissions. Today, I do not hesitate to say that the change in behaviors is prodigious and goes well beyond the financial incentive, which is ultimately quite modest compared to the price of the vehicle. Last month, the five best-selling car models in France were all eligible for the ecological bonus. All of them. Over the past three months, vehicles subject to the ecological malus have decreased by 40%. It is prodigious. The result of this gradual transformation of the French vehicle fleet is that France is now ranked third in Europe in terms of CO2 emissions from vehicles. I tell parliamentarians: it is not about prohibiting, which is always done in France, it is about convincing and encouraging. It works. How do you expect people to buy ecological vehicles before, when they were more expensive than polluting vehicles?

Allow me, finally, to return for a moment to the question of GMOs, which has taken, in recent weeks, a completely irrational turn and to say things plainly, perfectly misplaced and ridiculous. The Grenelle had resulted - I was proud of it - not in a shaky compromise, but in a strong position of balance. We can see that we are in a position of balance when we are criticized from both sides. And on that side, both sides are competing in their criticisms. I had committed to stopping the commercial cultivation of the only GMO authorized until then in France, Monsanto 810, due to the risks it presented. I did it. And I do not intend to receive lessons from an interposed government, unjustly attacked while I invoked the safeguard clause on Monsanto 810. To all those who campaign against GMOs, I want to say that when I had to take my responsibilities, I took them. No one forced me to do it. I did it. It was authorized before. It is no longer today.

On the other hand, I will say things very clearly, we had to transpose a directive adopted long ago, in 2001, under the government of Lionel JOSPIN and under the presidency of Jacques CHIRAC. This directive was adopted. It had to be transposed. The Commission threatened France with daily fines of 300,000 euros. It was not me who had this directive adopted. The French government at the time could have refused this directive. It had all the power to do so. It accepted this directive. When a legitimate government accepts a directive, it cannot be surprised that the European authorities legitimately condemn the country that accepted a directive and refuses to transpose it. That is intellectual dishonesty. If you are against this directive, Ladies and Gentlemen, you say so at the date of the European Council. If you are for it, Ladies and Gentlemen, you are not for it in Brussels and against it in France. You transpose it. I would not be the President of the Republic who would accept that France be condemned to fines of three to four hundred thousand euros per day, simply because a government would not have the courage to transpose a directive that was accepted by its predecessors. When I see the attitude, notably of a number of political forces, today in our country, who accepted the directive and refused to transpose it and who leave it to me to transpose it, I tell myself that, in life, there is the left, there is the right, there is the opposition and the majority, that is normal. But that each of us must be consistent with the decisions we have made in the past. I imagine that at the time, Mr. JOSPIN's government was supported by political forces, and it should not be surprised that today, Mr. FILLON's government transposes a directive that was accepted by the government of its predecessors. I really do not see this as a matter for debate between the left and the right. I see it simply as a matter for debate on consistency, common sense, and why not say it, on honesty. If we are in Europe, we have considerable advantages, but there are rules. I intend for France to respect these rules.

I add that among the several fundamental principles regarding GMOs, it was high time to transpose them into our legislative arsenal. I think of the precautionary principle, I think of transparency, I think of respect for the property of others, whatever convictions one may have. We must respect property rights. I think of the participation of civil society in decisions, I think of the right for each farmer to produce with or without GMOs. Finally, we wanted to strengthen research in biotechnology, because if some existing GMOs present risks, it would be foolish to forbid ourselves from finding, through research, transgenic plants worthy of interest and without risks, either for the environment or for human health.

There you have it, what we are doing. It seems sufficiently important for future generations to not get embroiled in a quarrel that has no reason to be. You know, I told François FILLON this morning, as I tell Jean-Louis BORLOO and Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET, who have all my support, I would have liked the government I appointed not to have to do all this work. If it has to do it, it is because it was not done before. Each passing the "hot potato" to the next, as always. Come on, a little more dust under the carpet and we are sure that with that France will fall behind! That is not my conception of public affairs. I prefer to take on the problems, try to find solutions, honestly, without ideology, without sectarianism, without a system mentality.

I challenge anyone to demonstrate that we have done anything other than rigorously uphold the commitments of the Grenelle of the Environment. With the activation of the safeguard clause, Monsanto 810 has ceased to be cultivated on our territory. It is over. Let no one be mistaken: it has not been easy. But it has been done in accordance with community law. I am convinced that Europe is the future of France. I do not intend to put France in violation of community law. And if, once again, there were a directive whose objects I did not share, I would say so at the European Council table. I would not come back to France to say that it is the fault of others. Believe me, from this point of view, we too, as political leaders, have a lot of progress to make, rather than always pushing the blame onto the Commission or others. The fault comes from political choices that are never assumed. If we have convictions, we fight for our convictions.

Finally, the text resulting from parliamentary debates fully respects the principles of balance adopted during the Grenelle, it will regulate GMOs in the most rigorous and protective manner possible. As soon as this text is adopted, I wish for the High Council of Biotechnologies to be established and to begin issuing its opinions, notably the much-anticipated one on the definition of "non-GMO." I am well aware that it needs to be defined, but to define it, it is better that this High Council be set up, otherwise who will define it? The government will then take - I commit to it - all necessary responsibilities to deduce the necessary provisions. This commitment will be honored. To be completely sincere, I fear that those who contest this text have in fact never accepted the commitments made during the Grenelle of the Environment. That is what is at stake. Of course, we have changed everything. I say this in front of Jérôme BIGNON, my friend, instead of pitting hunters against ecologists, we tried to find a compromise. Instead of pitting farmers against NGOs, we tried to find a compromise. Why? Because France needs everyone and we must lift everyone up rather than exclude ourselves in media frenzies.

For six months, we have established a new governance, the "dialogue at five": the unions, businesses, NGOs, elected officials, and the administration. I do not cite them in order. I say that it is a new way of governing. This has been the success of the Grenelle. It is a completely new way of working. But sustainable development has never meant to me subordinating all societal decisions to the sole criterion of the environment. Sustainable development is development and sustainability. I wanted to break out of this deadlock that opposes growth to environmental preservation. Because if you oppose growth to environmental preservation, you condemn the poorest to remain poor, whether they are countries or individuals. But it was about choosing a new way to develop, growth but sustainable growth. I want to reaffirm that I wish for this "dialogue at five" to become one of the principles of public decision-making in our country, as soon as the question of the representativeness of environmental NGOs can be resolved.

So, I know that this approach, fully shared by Jean-Louis BORLOO and Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET, has been the success of the Grenelle, but I want to pay tribute to Michel BARNIER and the agricultural world who played the game under perfectly exceptional conditions. I specify, moreover, that the first victims of insecticides, in particular, are those who work inside agricultural businesses, and they should not be denounced as guilty; they were interlocutors who played the game perfectly. I also want to say to Jérôme BIGNON that I thank him for presiding over the round table on hunting. These are subjects historically heavy with disputes and confrontations, and thanks to all of you, you have succeeded in something very difficult to achieve in France, which is to restore dialogue. We are surprised that we do not understand each other. If we do not dialogue, how can we understand each other? If we excommunicate each other constantly, how can we understand each other? That is what has been done with the Grenelle of the Environment.

And on the occasion of the constitutional reform, I wish for this new governance in environmental matters to be deeply embedded in our institutions. At the same time as it will integrate a "new environmental pillar," the Economic and Social Council will become an Economic, Social, and Environmental Council. This is the meaning of the constitutional reform project currently before the Assemblies. I intend for the Constitution to provide for an expanded consultation capacity of the new C.E.S.E. for "any text relating to the environment." And I ask the government, following the rules of prior consultation that prevail in social dialogue, that the future C.E.S.E., endowed with its new environmental component, be effectively consulted on all texts related to the environment. When a bill is good, we should never fear submitting it to the opinion and criticism of those who are the experts on this subject. I add that it will do the greatest good for the C.E.S.E. to expand a little to represent the diversity of the nation's living forces. Because in the living forces of the nation, when I see that there are five representatives of associations, while there are hundreds of thousands of associations in our country, I find that a bit short. When I see that in our Council of the living forces of the Nation, there are no NGOs, I find that a bit short. When I see that there are no representatives of young people, I find that a bit short. But I could continue; there is also no representative of the major spiritual currents. After all, they may have things to say. And I can continue; there is also no representative of the military community of our country, who also have a say and who undoubtedly are part of the living forces of the nation.

So, regarding the coming weeks, the Grenelle of the Environment will enter a new crucial phase, I say to the parliamentarians, a legislative phase. This is the essential phase of its appropriation by the national representation. After the opinion of the Economic and Social Council and after final modifications, the bill known as "Grenelle 1," which transcribes into law the commitments of the Grenelle of the Environment, will be adopted by the Council of Ministers at the beginning of June.

As for its final adoption, I wish for the government to set the goal of the first anniversary of the Grenelle of the Environment in the fall. The "Grenelle 1" bill will, moreover, be followed by two major implementing texts that will be submitted to Parliament at the start of the next school year, at the same time as the three-year finance bill for 2009-2011, of which I wish for the Grenelle of the Environment to be one of the major priorities. Thus, all the commitments made can begin to be executed from the beginning of 2009. There is no time to lose.

It is the ecological urgency that commands us today to advance in the fight against climate change, in the fight against the reduction of our biodiversity, in the fight against all forms of pollution. But I want everyone to measure, here, the immense ambition of transforming society and deeply adapting our growth model, of which the Grenelle of the Environment is a bearer. France, for the first time, has decided to set, in law, structuring objectives, binding objectives, clear objectives, precise objectives, not just in the medium term, 2020, but as early as 2012.

France does not consider itself to have an obligation in the preservation of the environment. France considers itself to have an imperative obligation of results. We are no longer in incantation; we are in decision.

France can no longer evade the questions and commitments of the Grenelle. But I will tell you that this Grenelle of the environment and this ecological challenge, well, it is an opportunity, an economic opportunity, a social opportunity, a human opportunity. Reducing our dependence on carbon and fossil fuels is the great challenge that all humanity will face; in a century, there will be no gas, in forty years, there will be no oil. It is time to think about the future. This is not an ideological matter; what are we going to leave to our children? And what are we going to decide with that? The Grenelle of the Environment is our opportunity to get ahead, to turn towards innovation, to become the actors of the next technological revolution that the world will experience. What General de GAULLE did for nuclear energy, we will do for sustainable development without renouncing nuclear energy.

By 2020, if we equip ourselves with an adapted industrial policy, the Grenelle of the Environment can be the source of the creation of 500,000 additional jobs: in construction, where the thermal insulation of existing buildings and the construction of new "low consumption" buildings will lead to the creation of new jobs, as illustrated very well by the Orléans company we just visited. Many jobs will be created in transportation, thanks to the modal shift towards rail or river transport. Listen, we are not going to continue to be the only country in Europe that is constantly crossed by trucks because we are renouncing river transport, because in fact, we are renouncing freight and because we are renouncing maritime highways. So many countries divert truck traffic; it is not for us to recover it.

Through the Grenelle, it is not just about anticipating an inevitable change; it is about acting rather than suffering. France has been able to do this in the past. This legacy allows us to be the most carbon-efficient economy in the entire European Union; well, this time, we will engage in renewable energies, taking on the challenge of a spectacular improvement in the energy efficiency of buildings and organizing a massive modal shift towards rail and river transport. But I say it, I know this will get me into trouble again, but the modernization of freight at SNCF is unavoidable. Because with an average speed of 13 km/h, there may be better to do, regardless of the dedication of the agents. But do not ask me to stand by helplessly as the locks accumulate, the result of decades of immobility in our country; it is not necessary to have Alstom, to know how to build the TGV and high-speed trains to have freight in this situation. I am not looking for trouble and opposition with anyone, but no one will prevent me from describing a reality. I believe in rail freight transport. Just as I believe in the reform of ports. What do you want me to say? A crane operator at the port of Marseille worked 2,000 hours a year, while a crane operator at the port of Barcelona or a crane operator at the port of Antwerp worked 4,000 hours a year (correction of May 27: a crane at the port of Marseille worked 2,000 hours a year, a crane at the port of Barcelona or a crane at the port of Antwerp worked 4,000 hours a year). Well, as a result, out of three containers that enter France, two enter from abroad. Is that normal? As a result, all the major ports in the world are developing their activity, except ours, which are losing it.

Well, I will lead the reform of the ports, and I will do it without weakness because it is in the interest of the French economy; we have been talking about it for a long time, and we are doing it. Our country must reconnect, dear Christine, with a real industrial policy; it will be about defining key technologies, markets, and conquest strategies. We will do this work in connection with industrialists within the framework of the strategic committee for eco-industries that the government will set up as early as this summer. It will be co-chaired by the Minister of State and the Secretary of State for Industry and Consumption.

Such a strategy, I know, will earn me criticism, but only in France is the voluntary attitude of public authorities, who are concerned about the industrial consequences of the structuring policies we are implementing, qualified as dirigisme or colbertism. If I had listened in 2004, when I was Minister of Finance, there would be no more Alstom, and if I had been Minister of Finance, I would never have authorized the sale of Péchiney. I say it as I think. The role of a Minister of Finance, dear Christine, is to be proactive, to direct the economy towards strategic sectors, and to give the necessary push to allow the French economy to be a leader. If General de GAULLE had not wanted nuclear energy, the market would not have created it spontaneously. I believe in the market, but I do not oppose the market to a strategic decision by public authorities. And that does not make me feel dirigiste.

Seizing the opportunities opened by the Grenelle also requires significantly developing the construction of wind turbines; we have visited 6,000 wind turbines. We must build three times more than the current park. So, it is still a major issue to know where and by whom they will be manufactured tomorrow. We cannot be blamed for saying: we are going to triple the number of wind turbines in our country, but we are completely indifferent to knowing where they will be manufactured, what the technology will be, and where the jobs serving this technology will be located. So, I am not unaware that there is a reflection on the considerable initial training work that must be orchestrated so that our young people and French employees have the techniques and know-how when the demand is present. In order to give visibility to the job opportunities arising from the Grenelle, I wish, dear Christine, that by the end of the year, a national event be organized on the theme of new jobs in sustainable development. Sustainable development is not a punishment; it is an opportunity! Sustainable development is not less growth; it is more growth. Sustainable development is not environmentalists against industrialists; it is a whole country that will appropriate the technologies of tomorrow so as not to sacrifice our economic interests today for the future of our planet and therefore, the future of our children. And we will powerfully support research, beyond the competitiveness clusters and the expansion of the research tax credit. An additional 1 billion euros will therefore be dedicated over four years to climate change, future energies and engines, biodiversity, and the impact of the environment on health. Furthermore, two funds will be established and endowed to allow, one, the financing of heat production equipment from renewable sources, and the other, placed with ADEME, to finance the creation of demonstrators of new energy technologies and the fight against climate change.

I finally hear that the State and public authorities play an exemplary role in kickstarting demand for new services and new ecological products. To quickly enable builders of "low consumption" buildings or better yet "positive energy" buildings like the one we just visited, and clean vehicles, as well as suppliers of organic agricultural products or experts in energy assessments, to achieve significant economies of scale, I want the State to be the first to stimulate demand for these products and services. This is what it will do by 2012, thus allowing the growth of these sectors to enable a reduction in their prices. I am told: it costs too much. Of course, since it cannot be amortized in markets. Well, the State will initiate these markets. This will allow prices to drop, to make these products financially viable and competitive.

In a more anecdotal but no less symbolic manner, I have decided to resolutely position the Presidency of the Republic within the framework of sustainable development. By the first anniversary of the Grenelle of the Environment, all energy and waste flows, all consumption and transportation of all personnel at the Élysée must have undergone a thorough analysis in light of sustainable development, followed by an exemplary implementation plan. If the Élysée is not exemplary in this matter, who will be?

The amounts of investment necessary for the community as a whole to comply with the Grenelle of the Environment by 2020 are significant. This is an unprecedented investment program, but we will rethink the modalities of State intervention: from regulation, tax incentives, to budgetary investment and information on the ecological cost of goods and services.

For nearly half of this amount, which constitutes the thermal insulation of existing buildings, it is primarily for the State to encourage, stimulate, and unlock flows of private investment, the profitability of which is largely guaranteed by the energy savings that the work will allow. Here more than elsewhere, it will essentially be for the State to mobilize innovative financing: between homeowners and energy suppliers through energy performance contracts, or even between owners, tenants, and suppliers. In the field of renewable energies, it is through the buyback prices of electricity or heat from renewable sources that the incentives for equipment will be conveyed. Finally, in transportation, whether it concerns urban public transport—I am thinking of the future line B of your tramway, Mr. Mayor—high-speed lines, or the realization of the Seine-Nord-Europe river link, the State will certainly invest again, significantly, but with the effect of triggering and multiplying the investment of other public and private actors.

I will tell you, I will take strong initiatives including in the Paris region. I will not leave passengers hostage to unacceptable situations on outdated RER lines where every day a million passengers are crammed together, helplessly witnessing sterile confrontations and the obsolescence of investments. If the State must take back control, the State will take it back. The priority is not political squabbles. The priority is efficiency. We cannot tell people to use their cars less and, at the same time, stand idly by in the face of sterile oppositions that lead to the absurd refusal to modernize RER lines, which the Paris region, moreover, desperately needs. Decentralization is meant to manage better, not to manage worse. If we manage better with decentralization, we will go further in decentralization. If there are elements where decentralization leads to sterile standoffs between elected officials, the State and public authorities must take their responsibilities so that users are not held hostage by these archaic practices. This is called a country determined to take charge of its problems.

I completely reject the criticisms that would see the Grenelle of the Environment as just a collection of heterogeneous, costly measures doomed to penalize the economy. I believe that the opposite is at play today: a dynamic economy, low in carbon, respectful of the environment, rich in jobs and wealth-creating. France needs to continue investing in public transport, energy savings, sustainable development, to seize the innovations that the 21st century will see emerge.

I also note that the share of energy expenses in the budgets of the poorest households has risen from 10 to 15% since 2001, while, by comparison, it only represents 6% of the budget of the wealthiest households. It is immobility that penalizes the poorest. It is immobility, conservatism that prevents the poorest from getting by. I am particularly thinking of the 800,000 least energy-efficient social housing units. Here too, let us launch a major modernization plan for these social housing units to make them energy-efficient buildings.

This very strong constraint of purchasing power will also be at the heart of the reasoning regarding the establishment of a potential ecological tax. I have set three conditions, and I will ensure they are respected:

- the overall stability of mandatory levies; I will not accept an increase in mandatory levies, not for ideological reasons, because France is in competition and we cannot continue to let jobs and wealth leave. We need investment and we need jobs.

- Strict compensation for households for any new levy. We have 150 billion euros more in levies than the Germans. I do not observe that Germany is under-administered.

- The possibility for consumers to adopt virtuous behaviors that allow them to evade the levy, similar to the functioning of the bonus/malus for vehicles.

It is within this strict framework that our tax policy will be framed, Christine, including the study, before the end of 2008, of the introduction of a "climate-energy contribution" on fossil fuels.

Finally, in the European context, with Jean-Louis Borloo and Nathalie, we will do everything to have the climate-energy package adopted. Europe must lead the global fight for the preservation of our planet.

I want to say solemnly that we will not be naive in the international negotiations that await us. Europe cannot forever be alone in making efforts to influence a phenomenon that concerns the entire planet; otherwise, we will threaten the competitiveness of our companies, particularly industrial ones, located on our territory. France is not ready to accept this, just as France does not find it appropriate to turn this difficulty into allocating free CO2 emission quotas to European companies threatened by this unfair competition. Because then, that is where we give up. In one case, we give up the competitiveness of our companies; in another, we give up the environmental ambition of Europe. I say this as clearly as possible: if a global agreement to reduce greenhouse gas emissions proves impossible, Europe would have, in my eyes, no other option than to unilaterally establish a border adjustment mechanism regarding imports from countries outside the agreement. There is no reason for us to impose measures on business leaders to preserve the environment and to accept importing into Europe, into our markets, products from countries that do not respect any environmental rules. Let things be clear. I want reciprocity, and I do not want naivety. We already have social dumping, fiscal dumping, monetary dumping; I will not accept ecological dumping as well. If others do not understand that the planet is our common good, then we will create a mechanism at our borders. What they do not want to do at home, we will do for ourselves. What I am saying, by the way, dear Eric, I am saying exactly for our farmers. What is the point of imposing traceability rules on our farmers and breeders if, at the same time, Europe were to accept the importation of products from other countries that do not respect any rules of reciprocity? I will not accept this way of doing things. The planet is our common good. It is together that we will preserve it.

Ladies and gentlemen, you have understood that, for me, what happened this morning is very important, that Nathalie Kosciuszko-Morizet and Jean-Louis Borloo have my full support to open a new chapter in the French economy, that of sustainable development.

If I had to say one last thing, ecology and environmental preservation are too important to be left to the sole political forces that have sought to make ecology a political caricature. It is now up to us to take it on, not in words, not in speeches, but in actions. I hope I have been understood well. I will not give up on these projects, nor on all those I undertook during the presidential campaign. Thank you.