Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the banks' respect for their commitments to finance the economy and on the payment of bonuses to traders based on results, in Paris on August 25, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

25 August 2009 · Back-to-school meeting · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed French banking leaders and ministers in Paris on August 25, 2009, announcing new rules on trader bonuses and bank lending obligations following the 2008 financial crisis.
Main themes
Banker bonuses and trader compensation reform, bank lending commitments to the real economy, financial sector regulation and governance, SME financing and equity support, post-financial crisis recovery, transparency and accountability in banking, state aid and sanctions, housing credit, France's leadership on financial reform
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,363
65th percentile
Sentences
140
78th percentile
Readability
57
80th percentile
Grade
9.3
14th percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
38th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 59%57%
  • Institutional 21%21%
  • Geopolitical 13%12%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

140 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

A year ago, we entered one of the worst financial crises in our history. France reacted with determination. France has withstood better than its partners. France is nonetheless facing this year, like all other countries, the recession and unemployment resulting from this international crisis. Our economy needs a strong financial sector, serving the real economy, and not speculation.

Things cannot, must not go back to how they were before. This is a commitment I made to the French people. This is a commitment that will be upheld. It is a matter of morality. It is a crucial issue to ensure financial stability. This was therefore the focus of this first back-to-school meeting, which I wanted to be dedicated to the banking sector.

We addressed two issues: the first concerning the banks' respect for their commitments to finance the economy.

Together with Christine Lagarde and Prime Minister François Fillon, we asked the banks to honor the commitments they made to increase credit to the economy.

We asked them to make a particular effort on housing finance. By the end of the year, credit to households for housing must start to rise again.

We asked them to pay special attention to financing SMEs: the existence of viable businesses must not be jeopardized by cash flow problems. The credit mediator, who is doing an extraordinary job, and the Prefects will ensure this.

For companies that may face equity problems, I asked the banks, all of which accepted, to subscribe, along with insurers and the FSI, to a fund for the consolidation and development of businesses, endowed with 210 million euros.

As for Ms. Lagarde, she will make a proposal to me before the end of September to create a public support window for the equity of small and medium-sized enterprises, in the form, for example, of participatory loans. I do not hide that in the context of our reflections on the great loan, the issue of equity for SMEs is absolutely decisive.

The second topic: the bonuses of traders. I was outraged to see the lessons of the crisis so quickly forgotten by some, even as the crisis is not yet over, even if there have been some good news. This is unacceptable. I have therefore made three decisions:

The first is that the Paris market must be impeccable. I have asked French banks to be exemplary and to accept operational and precise rules that will take effect immediately.

I do not accept the reasoning that says we will wait for others to move before we move. With that, we can wait a long time; no one will move! So France will move ahead of others.

These rules will improve governance, increase transparency, and ensure accountability of the actors. The payment of bonuses will now be partially deferred to take results into account. Two-thirds of the bonuses will be paid in a deferred manner. One-third of the deferred portion of the bonus will be paid in shares of the company where the traders work. And above all, a penalty system will be put in place: if performance does not meet expectations over time, the deferred portion of the bonus will not be paid.

Before today's meeting, bonuses were paid, traders received bonuses, the following year their activities lost money, and it was the taxpayer who paid. From now on, a trader who earns a bonus because in the first year he made profits from his activity will have to wait three years to receive the full bonuses, and if in the two years that follow his activity loses money, the bonus will be applied immediately; he will not receive his bonus. No bonus without a penalty. It is not "you win every time." It is not the taxpayer's responsibility to pay.

No state has adopted rules as precise and as binding as those I have just mentioned.

I note with satisfaction that the CEO of BNP Paribas has indicated that he is ready to apply these new standards as of today, which will allow him to pay only half of the amount provisioned for the first half of the year, turning one billion into 500 million. I ask the Governor of the Bank of France to be particularly vigilant about the implementation of this first measure.

These rules will be strictly monitored. The banking commission will intervene in all banks established in France starting in September to monitor the application of these rules. The results of its investigations will be made fully public.

I also want banks that do not play by the rules to be sanctioned. I announce with Ms. Lagarde another decision. From now on, the French state will not grant any mandates to banks that do not apply the rules regarding trader compensation. Let it be clear, we will not work with banks that do not apply these rules.

The second decision, a set of decisions, is that the control of state aid will be strengthened.

The state has provided funds to banks to encourage them to lend to businesses and households. I will appoint a qualified individual responsible for monitoring the compensation of traders in banks that have received state support in equity. He will have the power to make recommendations on compensation systems and individual payments for the 100 highest-paid traders. If his recommendations are not followed, he will refer the matter to the banking commission, the board of directors of the institution, and, if necessary, the general assembly of shareholders. This individual, this compensation czar, will be Michel Camdessus.

The third decision: France will take an international initiative to increase control over bonuses.

It goes without saying that the issue of bonuses cannot be addressed by France alone. But that is no reason to do nothing. As with tax havens, the most effective long-term action is international. A decisive part will be played in Pittsburgh. France will tell its 19 partners, who represent 85% of global GDP: "Here is not what we are about to do, but what we have decided." And through Christine Lagarde, we will raise awareness among all international public opinions to say that it is possible to change the rules of financial capitalism. And we will arrive in Pittsburgh with the decisions we have already made. And we will put on the table an initiative that will have three components:

First, we want the G20 to adopt the rules of transparency, governance, and accountability that are now those of the Paris market. And starting Sunday in Berlin, with Ms. Lagarde, we will meet Chancellor Merkel and Minister Steinbrück to convince them to move in the same direction as us.

Next, at the G20, we will ask to agree on enhanced sanctions for those who do not play by the rules. I will propose that states no longer grant mandates to banks that do not comply with international rules in this area, as we are doing in France starting today.

Finally, we will likely need to go further and address the issue of limiting the amount of bonuses. And this limitation, everyone understands, can only be international in this case. Because if we decided to limit it simply in France, everyone would leave. I want the G20 to consider several proposals: a global limitation of bonuses distributed as a percentage of the revenues of financing and investment banks, the first proposal; a limitation on the highest bonuses, the second proposal; and the creation in all financial markets of a tax based on distributed bonuses, the proceeds of which would fund deposit guarantee systems, which are called upon in times of crisis.

The issue of bonuses, transparency, and the transfer of responsibility will be an essential question at the Pittsburgh summit. I will be flexible on the modalities but not on the substance. The reform initiated in London will continue. It is non-negotiable. As for France, starting today, Madam Minister, as well as the Governor of the Bank of France, here are the rules that will apply. I also want to thank all the bank leaders who have accepted these rules and who have recognized the importance of implementing them immediately. There cannot be double standards.

Ladies and Gentlemen, thank you. If there are one or two questions, Ms. Lagarde and I will try to answer them willingly.

QUESTION - inaudible.

THE PRESIDENT - It is not me who manages the banks, and I do not have to pass judgment on that, and it depends on the results of each. But I am satisfied with the 50% reduction achieved in a single meeting. These are the commitments made to the Minister and to me, and I expect them to be upheld.

I am also pleased that all our partners have understood that we must now apply the rules and not wait for others. That the battle is not over, I am the first to acknowledge. We live in a global world, and it is not for us to discredit the Paris financial market. But I believe my interlocutors have understood that if French banks had been less reckless than others, had taken fewer risks than others, what applied to subprimes yesterday must apply today to bonuses. And that, ultimately, it might be a competitive argument for the Paris financial market to say that French banks will be reasonable in terms of compensation.

Now, after that, banks must manage themselves; it is not the state's job to manage all banks, even if, for banks that benefit from state funds - isn't that right, Christine - Mr. Camdessus will have a say. Listen, I ask you to investigate this; I believe that in the overall measures we are announcing with Ms. Lagarde, there is not a country in the world that has established a more rigorous system.

So, I will tell you everything. After Pittsburgh, we have committed to reviewing the bankers. And that seems fair to me because we are imposing rules on them that others do not have before Pittsburgh. We will fight in Pittsburgh to ensure that everyone adopts these rules, and we will take stock after Pittsburgh. I will not go back on these rules. But we will take stock of the competitiveness of the Paris market and the rules that their international competitors have decided or not to apply.

I am convinced that France's role is to be proactive and not to suffer. It is too easy, while so many people are suffering, to say, "We will wait for others to move before we move."

Ultimately, look, on tax havens, we could also have waited for others to move. Nothing would have happened. And when I see what is happening with UBS, the Swiss bank that is reporting to the American tax authorities four thousand tax evaders, I find that it is going in the right direction. It proves that we can make things move; there is no reason we cannot succeed.

In any case, regarding France, banks that benefit from public funds will now be subject to the control of a compensation czar who will verify for the hundred highest trader compensations whether they comply with the commitments made and, above all, a penalty system.

Those who make money from their activity should receive a bonus. But if they cause losses through their activity, they should bear the consequences. It is not the taxpayer's responsibility to pay for them.

QUESTION - inaudible.

THE PRESIDENT - The City is already a first step; these are more wishes than decisions. With Christine Lagarde and François Fillon, we wanted decisions, but I will also discuss this with Mr. Brown. However, France's ambition is to show the way, not to suffer. In any case, there is one question that is non-negotiable: it will not go back to how it was before. That is not possible. We will not accept it. It has been difficult enough to avoid catastrophe; it will not restart, I will not accept it.

I can see in your question that you are wondering about the limits of France's action. Of course, you are right; we are in a competitive world. But it is too easy to say we do nothing because others are not moving. That is not how we make things change. We act, we take the lead, and we will bring everyone along.

QUESTION - inaudible.

THE PRESIDENT - I spoke about it with Ms. Lagarde; it is not a secret, in a telephone conversation yesterday, absolutely, there is no reason. You know, it is a difficult crisis, it is a complex crisis, it is a crisis that causes suffering, and people need to feel that we are paying attention to this issue of justice and equity. Once again, the issue is not that people earn a lot of money; I have never been against that. But when they make mistakes, it is not normal that they do not bear the responsibilities. It is unacceptable. It is unacceptable; it cannot be that you win every time. We cannot have found ourselves, six months ago, in the same meeting room where we were on the brink of the abyss and where states avoided collapse and see this happen again.

THE PRESIDENT - Listen, I will talk to Mr. Steinbruck and Mrs. Merkel, but frankly, regarding non-cooperative jurisdictions, speaking under the oversight of Christine Lagarde, I was very pleased that we worked together with Germany. It has been very difficult, I won't hide that from you. But finally, when I see the eagerness of Monaco, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, the Cayman Islands, not to mention Switzerland, to sign the famous twelve conventions. Because, you know that in order not to be a non-cooperative jurisdiction, you must sign twelve tax information exchange agreements. And on Thursday, we will sign it with Switzerland.

QUESTION - inaudible

THE PRESIDENT - I ask for your understanding, but I wanted to keep this meeting on this subject, which is a very difficult and serious issue. I will stick to that, which is already important. And perhaps in the coming days we will have the opportunity to meet again.

Thank you, and I hope you had a good vacation.