Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the challenges and priorities of the G20 and G8, in Paris on January 24, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

24 January 2011 · Press conference on the challenges and priorities of the G20 and G8 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the diplomatic corps and press at the Élysée Palace on January 24, 2011, outlining France's G20 and G8 presidency priorities.
Main themes
G20 and G8 French presidency, reform of international monetary order, global economic power shifts, financial and banking crises, international economic interdependence, journalist safety and hostages, food security and agriculture, labor and employment, Lebanon, Tunisia, and Côte d'Ivoire
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,656
83rd percentile
Sentences
196
89th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
56th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 63%61%
  • Institutional 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Not in focus 4%

196 sentences in 70 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister, dear François,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

For the first time, the diplomatic corps is invited to a press conference, and as this meeting coincides with the season of greetings, I would like to ask you right away, Mr. Nuncio, Ladies and Gentlemen Ambassadors, to convey to your heads of state the warm wishes that France extends to them and, of course, through them, to the peoples they represent.

I would also like to extend my best wishes for 2011 to you, Ladies and Gentlemen of the press and media. A year rich in news, but also, I hope for you, rich in happiness and success.

Everyone will understand that I have a heartfelt thought for your fellow photographer, our compatriot Lucas Mebrouk Dolega, who was mortally wounded while covering events in Tunisia. Today, I think of his family, his loved ones, and all those who cared for him.

Lucas Mebrouk Dolega was fulfilling his duty as a journalist. He was doing nothing other than his job. A difficult, demanding job that required passion and courage. And Lucas lacked neither.

He was well known here at the Élysée, where he often came to work, with the kindness, discretion, and great professionalism that characterized him. He was appreciated by all, and I know that today, many of you have heavy hearts having seen a talented photographer leave us, and I imagine that for you, he was a friend.

I also have a special thought for Hervé Ghesquière and Stéphane Taponier, your two colleagues held hostage in Afghanistan, 391 days in unbearable anxiety. All state services are fully mobilized to secure their release. We will spare no effort to try to end their ordeal as quickly as possible, just as we do for all hostages around the world.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

International news is rich, from Lebanon to Tunisia and Côte d'Ivoire. If you agree, I will address all these issues in the second part of this press conference, and I would like to first focus on the G20 and the G8.

If you agree, I will make a brief introductory statement, then I will answer your questions, and finally, we will open a second part of the press conference on these issues; it seems to me that this is more coherent.

Over the past two months, I have devoted much of my time to consultations. Consulting heads of state and government, of course, but also international organizations, international unions, representatives of businesses, economists, researchers, and former heads of state and government.

From these consultations, I draw the following message: if the G20 wants to remain legitimate, it must remain effective. Our goal is to open up fundamental issues that can no longer wait, so that we can present concrete results to an increasingly impatient public opinion.

Several ministerial meetings will be organized:

- For the G8, foreign ministers will meet to prepare for the Deauville Summit; interior ministers will meet to work on the fight against drug trafficking, particularly cocaine.

- For the G20, finance ministers and central bank governors will be mobilized. But two other ministerial meetings will be scheduled, to which I attach great importance: that of labor and employment ministers and that of agriculture ministers.

Colloquia or seminars will also feed into collective reflection, and I will have the opportunity to visit President Hu Jintao for a first seminar on the reform of the international monetary order in China at the end of March.

The ambition of our presidency is simple: we live in a new world, so we need new ideas.

This new world is primarily marked by an extraordinary change in the balance of global economic powers.

At the end of World War II, that is to say when the world created the UN, the IMF, the World Bank, and the GATT, the United States represented 45% of global GDP. In 1975, when the G7 was created, the United States and Western Europe alone represented two-thirds of global GDP. Since the late 1990s, we have witnessed an extraordinary upheaval of this balance.

China's weight has more than doubled in ten years, from 2000 to 2010, surpassing Japan as the second-largest economy in the world.

By 2050, China could become the largest economy ahead of the United States, India the third, and Brazil the fourth. It is clear that everything created in 1945 was based on balances that are no longer the same today.

We have partially taken these transformations into account, and this is notably what explains the creation of the G20, which represents 85% of global GDP.

The second observation we can make after this change in balance is that we live in a completely interdependent world, increasingly volatile, where imbalances have not only increased in speed but have also increased in magnitude.

This volatility is found everywhere.

In preparing for this press conference, I wanted to count the number of banking crises and financial crises. It is quite extraordinary; over the past 40 years, there have been 125 banking crises, and if we look at the last 40 years, we see that these 125 banking crises have accelerated extraordinarily over the last 20 years. That is to say, not only do imbalances not slow down, but they are becoming more significant and occurring more rapidly.

If we look at international capital movements: since 1990, the world has experienced 42 crises of sudden stops in capital flows. Thus, between 2008 and 2009, capital flows to Asian countries were halved in a matter of weeks, even days. How can countries withstand and manage such instability? It is absolutely impossible.

In foreign exchange markets, the figures are also staggering; they are extraordinary. The daily volume of transactions has exceeded $4 trillion per day. I know that these figures have no meaning for our fellow citizens, but they are realities that must be faced. $4 trillion per day, daily transaction volume, in the foreign exchange market alone, has increased by 20% since 2007, after a 72% increase between 2004 and 2007.

What concerns me here, of course, is a very banal idea that there is instability in the world, but what is less so is to show through figures that this is accelerating at a staggering speed. Therefore, the consequences will become increasingly serious.

But this volatility in foreign exchange markets, in financial crises, in banking crises, is found exactly the same in the energy commodity market: in 2008, oil prices fell from $140 per barrel of Brent to $40 in six months. Divided by three, in six months. I do not think that energy consumption, the needs, were divided by three in six months.

If you look at agricultural commodities, the volatility of agricultural commodity prices has tripled over the last 20 years, and this parallels the increasing financialization of these markets. This is all the more extraordinary as a 70% increase in agricultural production will be needed by 2050 to feed the 9 billion men and women that our planet will have. This is where you see how strong France will be in defending the common agricultural policy, the second-largest agriculture in the world, European agriculture, while the needs for agricultural production must increase by 70% by 2050. This is really not the time to dismantle the common agricultural policy. These figures speak for themselves.

Agricultural prices have started to rise again. At the end of December, the price of agricultural commodities exceeded the peaks reached in 2008. 2008 is not a year I chose at random, as it was the year of the food riots. We are already higher than the peak of 2008.

Finally, the international monetary disorders in which we live have made possible an unprecedented widening of balance of payments imbalances. It is very simple; balance of payments imbalances have doubled since the year 2000.

The third characteristic - I will come to the solutions, but I think it is impossible to try to initiate perspectives for solutions if we do not try to nourish a shared diagnosis with our partners: naturally, if the diagnosis is not shared, it is useless to hope to find common solutions. The third characteristic is global challenges: climate change, development challenges, which require global responses. I remind you and will tirelessly remind you that we have pledged and promised $100 billion per year to developing countries starting in 2020. This is a promise. This is Copenhagen. How to keep this promise, while our countries are experiencing unprecedented budget deficits, without raising the question of innovative financing? This question of innovative financing is, for France, a crucial issue.

The "new" G8 will need to open the public debate at the political level. I was very pleased, particularly in my meeting with President Obama, with the agreement he had for us to talk informally about the Internet at the G8. I want to clarify that this is not at all about wanting to stifle the development of the Internet and its content. The Internet is a progress, that is undeniable. The Internet is a possibility for everyone to have access to universal knowledge, and it would not occur to anyone to stifle this positive development. But the Internet opens, for us as responsible leaders, major subjects for reflection. And the G8 is eight extremely modern economies where the Internet is extremely developed. It is the place to talk about it.

France will organize a Forum with the main operators of the digital economy from G8 countries on the eve of the Deauville Summit. I believe that the time has come now to trust each other and to build a model by adding our skills, by listening to what the major Internet operators have to say, of whom I am sure are deeply responsible and that they listen to what we have to say to find a path for a civilized Internet.

I wanted to give you an overview of the challenges.

Of course, we are not starting from scratch, and our first priority as a presidency is to ensure that the decisions we made during the last five G20 summits are properly implemented.

This is particularly the case for financial regulation.

In less than two years, considerable progress has been made, even if this idea has difficulty resonating in public opinion, which I am well aware of. Nevertheless, it remains valid. New rules on bank capital, hedge funds that are now regulated and were previously unregulated, bank taxes instituted to limit systemic risk, the regulation of bonuses, which today has reached a consensus. I see that Morgan Stanley has announced that from now on, 60% of bonuses paid will be deferred. This is a bit more than we had requested.

On tax havens, long untouchable, since April 2009, 600 tax transparency and information exchange agreements have been signed. Thirteen countries have renounced banking secrecy for tax purposes. And we will have the first evaluations from the Global Forum on national legal frameworks that will allow us to make decisions.

Development will be a second major issue for the G20.

I want our dual presidency to make Africa its priority.

We will focus our efforts on infrastructure. At the Cannes Summit, we will adopt a list of concrete projects, with their financing, that will be launched immediately. The high-level panel responsible for identifying them will be chaired by Mr. Tidiane Thiam, President of the global insurance group Prudential, former Ivorian Minister of Planning and Development. I thank him for accepting this mission.

Third element, innovative financing. I mentioned it a moment ago, France is in favor of a tax on financial transactions. France believes that this tax is moral given the financial crisis we have just gone through, that this tax is useful to deter speculation, I could explain further if you have questions, and that this tax is effective in finding new resources for development. I am well aware that this tax has many enemies or great adversaries in its path. We will try to convince them. We will work with Mr. Melès, Prime Minister of Ethiopia, who has produced an excellent report, and France will assign a mission to a civil society figure to find innovative solutions at the intersection of the private and public sectors. France believes that the tax on financial transactions is the best, but that it cannot alone exhaust the entire question of innovative financing. Therefore, we are ready to discuss other solutions even if this tax - on financial transactions - and in response to your questions I could explain it further, seems to us to be the best formula.

In the area of employment and social issues, social partners will be fully involved in the work of the G20. For the first time, we will organize a Social Summit on the eve of the G20 Summit, alongside a Business Leaders Summit. There is no reason for there to be a Business Leaders Summit and not a Social Summit. And the question for France is how to give more weight to the International Labour Organization in global governance. France wishes for us to reflect on the establishment of a universal social protection floor. This is not a unique social model, which makes no sense, but a floor, and France does not resign itself to the fact that the 8 ILO conventions on fundamental labor rights are not ratified by all G20 members, who are, moreover, for the most part, members of the ILO. If one is a member of an organization, one ratifies the standards produced and adopted by that organization.

Instability of the international monetary order, volatility of commodity prices. The entire year of 2010 was marked by the debate on currencies. Some even spoke of a currency war. The truth is that the instability of the non-international monetary system, we have been living in it since 1971. To say that there is a monetary system is already a serious mistake; there has not been one since 1971.

I have read a lot of things, and allow me to clarify a number of these points. First, France does not wish to return to a fixed exchange rate system. Moreover, there would be a contradiction in wanting to return to a fixed exchange rate system while at the same time denouncing the volatility of the euro, which does not correspond to economic realities. Therefore, the fixed exchange rate system has the characteristic of not adapting to the realities of the economy. France does not wish to call into question the dollar, which plays a prominent role and must be a strong currency, as President Obama often states. France is also not in favor of capital controls. That is the foundation. However, once we have made these three negations, is there a single person in the world who can assert that the international monetary system is functioning well and that there are no problems?

It is not a matter of addressing these questions from an ideological angle but from a pragmatic angle. Our ambition is to converge with our partners on concrete proposals.

Our position is simple; it can be summed up in one sentence: the emergence of new economic powers will inevitably lead to the emergence of new international currencies. This is unavoidable. The ongoing transition can be a factor of instability.

We therefore have a first objective: to improve our cooperation in support of growth. And for that, we will try to reach an agreement with everyone on the indicators that will allow us to analyze persistent imbalances. Before confronting each other on the imbalances, France will try to bring everyone together on the definition of the indicators that will allow us to measure said imbalances. It is fascinating! Everyone blames each other for their imbalances, but there are no rules, no criteria to define what an imbalance is or what a surplus is. So that is our first task, extremely important. I hope that we will have results with the ministers and governors by next February. It will then be up to each state to present the economic policy actions and structural reforms to reduce these imbalances.

Furthermore, we must address a number of very difficult questions.

How to reduce the need for accumulation of reserves? Obviously, when countries have seen their capital drained in a matter of days, they try to protect themselves against this risk by significantly increasing their reserves, thinking: "if something goes wrong, I will have reserves." But this accumulation of unproductive reserves weighs very heavily. It is a costly strategy. We still need to make progress to create new IMF facilities, as the IMF has indeed tried to do. But how to better take into account the systemic nature of certain crises that affect an entire region and would require not a national response but a global and multilateral response?

How to better regulate international capital flows? The framework in which we live today is outdated. The multiplication of recent unilateral measures raises the question of establishing multilateral rules. We will propose to the G20 to develop a code of conduct regarding the management of capital flows. Ultimately, France's conviction is that a reform of the IMF's statutes is desirable so that common rules prevail and that the IMF exercises its oversight in this area. You see, we set criteria that define imbalances, we ask the IMF to analyze these criteria, to monitor the application of these criteria, and we try to bring everyone together in respect of these criteria.

Finally, how to ensure the transition to the internationalization of new currencies? The Special Drawing Rights, if I remember correctly, were created 42 years ago. 42 years after the creation of the Special Drawing Rights, can we agree on the timeline and modalities for the expansion of the Special Drawing Rights to new currencies, such as the Yuan? I was very pleased to see that in the communiqué of discussions between President Obama and President Hu Jintao, the question of integrating the Yuan into the Special Drawing Rights was raised. But it is already immense to raise this question! When France spoke about it a few months ago, first, it sparked many controversies.

These questions are complex. I am certain that we will not solve all the problems in one presidency. But France wants a debate, because the debate can no longer wait.

I announce to you, in terms of organization, that I proposed to Ms. Merkel, who accepted, that Germany co-chair with Mexico, which will hold the G20 presidency in 2012, the working group that will be responsible for the international monetary system.

The second urgent question is the volatility of commodity prices. If we do nothing, we risk food riots in poorer countries and, moreover, a very unfavorable impact on global growth.

Four areas of action:

- We want regulation of financial markets on commodities: for some of them, there are no basic rules against market abuses or price manipulations. Work is underway in the United States and Europe. We need common rules. How can it be explained that it is normal to regulate financial markets, but that we must refrain from any rules on financial derivatives in agriculture? It makes no sense.

- We must improve transparency in physical markets: to provide predictability, we need to know production, consumption, and stock outlooks. We will propose to create a common database, like the one we have on oil, to prevent food crises.

- We need to strengthen our food security system. I am thinking of a code of good conduct to exempt food aid from export restrictions, and the establishment of emergency stocks. It is still extraordinary that food aid funds are forced to buy stocks of raw materials at the highest price! That is to say, not only does speculation create food riots, but aid organizations, to prevent people from dying, are forced to buy at the highest price! This makes no sense and is a recipe for a fantastic explosion in countries and continents where people cannot feed themselves. And it is unacceptable. We must develop agricultural supply; all my European friends must understand this, develop agricultural supply if we want to be able to feed the entire world population. Agriculture ministers have a huge responsibility within the G20.

- Finally, I want us to look at how to put new financial insurance instruments at the service of the poorest countries to protect them from price increases or events affecting harvests. I have just assigned a mission on this point to Pierre Jacquet, the chief economist of the French Development Agency.

I also announce that Mr. Medvedev, President of the Russian Federation, has agreed to invest more specifically, within the framework of the French presidency, on these issues.

A word to conclude, and I apologize for having been perhaps too long: global governance, an extremely vast subject.

We have reformed the IMF, the World Bank, we have created the Financial Stability Board.

I have stated our desire for the IMF to take its full place in monitoring global imbalances, but there is still a lot to be done. The creation of a global environmental organization, the coherence of all agricultural organizations, the action of financial institutions in relation to the fundamental standards of the ILO, the creation of a permanent G20 secretariat to follow up on the implementation of our decisions between two presidencies.

I have asked British Prime Minister David Cameron, who has accepted, to work more specifically on these issues.

You see, this describes a collective French presidency. The agenda and the schedule now have consensus. The solutions do not have consensus, that is certain, but we have made significant progress on the working method and the agenda. We now need to make progress on the solutions.

Ladies and gentlemen, if you will, I will take your questions on the G20! G8 and then, in a second phase, on other foreign policy issues.