Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the challenges and priorities of the G20, in Paris on February 18, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

18 February 2011 · First meeting of G20 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors · Palais de l'Élysée, Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed G20 Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors at the Élysée Palace in Paris on February 18, 2011, outlining France's G20 presidency priorities.
Main themes
G20 presidency priorities, global economic recovery, financial regulation, international policy coordination, global imbalances, Framework for Sustainable Growth, commodity price volatility, international monetary order, Basel III implementation, financial sector reform, bonus regulation, inflation risks
Duration
~22 min
71st percentile
Words
2,675
71st percentile
Sentences
146
80th percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 52%49%
  • Institutional 27%25%
  • Ceremonial 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 8%8%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

146 sentences in 47 paragraphs

Mr. Director General of the IMF,

Mr. President of the World Bank,

Mr. Secretary General of the OECD,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Governors,

Mr. Commissioner,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I wanted to welcome you to the Palais de l'Elysée to express the importance that France attaches to your first meeting of Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors.

I welcome you to France and I wish you the best of success for your work this evening and tomorrow.

As Finance Ministers and Central Bank Governors of G20 countries, representing 85% of global GDP, you have an absolutely essential responsibility.

The G20 has demonstrated its effectiveness during the crisis: by making coordinated decisions, regulating the financial sector, and reviving our economies, we have allowed the world to emerge from the most severe crisis in 60 years.

The G20, I believe, will only retain its legitimacy if it can demonstrate its effectiveness in the global recovery.

It is therefore your responsibility, as well as that of Heads of State and Government, to provide answers to the major questions facing the global economy today.

Since last year, the recovery has taken hold. It is faster than expected. Global growth is uneven across geographical areas, still insufficient to significantly reduce unemployment, but the experience of the crisis has shown us that international coordination is the only path that will allow us to return to a high level of growth. Coordination is a duty. There is no other possible choice.

Our first priority as the G20 presidency will be to implement the decisions already made. I want to commend the work done by previous presidencies, particularly the Korean presidency.

In the area of financial regulation, the G20's record is considerable. But despite the progress we have made, our citizens in all our countries are questioning the reality of our actions. We must be clear: we will no longer accept practices that led us to the crisis to resurface. There can be no going back, as if nothing had happened; no one would forgive us for that. I am particularly thinking of the issue of bonuses. I want all financial centers to apply the decisions made in Pittsburgh, and I want the Financial Stability Board, dear Mario Draghi, to rigorously assess the effective implementation of these principles. I also want the G20 to ensure that we have flawless financial regulation and that all G20 countries implement Basel III, and that a financial sector does not develop in some way outside of regulation.

The other major achievement of the G20 is the coordination of economic policies. If we do nothing, global imbalances will once again widen. So, of course, it is more difficult to find consensus during the recovery period. The temptation to prioritize national interests is great. But I tell you clearly, that would be the death of the G20.

This is the whole issue of the Framework for Sustainable Growth, which must allow us to find ways together to achieve higher growth for the benefit of all.

I hope that your meeting will allow us to make progress on the mandate entrusted to you by Heads of State and Government in Seoul. You will discuss tomorrow the common indicators of imbalances in order to better target the corrective measures that each must take to rebalance growth. This is a topic that is not very technical and is, in truth, very political. We cannot approach it solely from a mechanistic perspective.

I want to avoid your discussions getting bogged down in endless debates about these indicators that would divert us from the essential: that everyone commits and takes measures to achieve a win-win cooperation between countries that are free in their economic policy choices. Everyone is well aware that stagnation and the status quo are completely forbidden to us.

We have set an ambitious agenda for the French presidency. I know that one year is very short. Of course, we will not succeed in everything. But nothing would be worse than refusing to address the real issues that confront us. It is not about defining a new international monetary order in one year, but who can contest that the question of the international monetary order is not an essential question? It is not about solving all the problems of commodity price volatility, but who can contest that this issue is crucial both economically and socially, even if, of course, we do not think of contesting market mechanisms?

But precisely, a market without rules is no longer a market. The market carries within it the definition of rules. Regulating the market is almost to use the same two words. A market without rules is the law of the strongest, where speculation can do whatever it wants. The market carries within it rules that regulate it.

On these issues, I am counting on your mobilization.

Today, finally, we face two risks to growth.

The first risk is inflationary pressures, fueled by rising commodity prices. This is both an economic issue, which could undermine the ongoing recovery, and a social issue, with the risk of food riots and a development issue for the poorest countries.

What we propose is a comprehensive strategy aimed at combating volatility, regulating derivative markets, increasing transparency in physical markets, and strengthening food security tools. The World Bank, dear Robert Zoellick, and the United Nations institutions, dear Ms. Clark, have made very relevant proposals that the G20 must seize.

My conviction is that beyond the immediate measures we can propose, we must rehabilitate the role of farmers in our societies.

The second risk is the volatility of exchange rates and capital flows. Here, it is not about having an ideological view of these issues, and even less about calling into question one or the other. But the reform of the international monetary order can no longer wait. I am pleased that the Chinese government is inviting us to Shenzhen at the end of March to engage in reflection on this subject, as part of a seminar that we wish to be widely open to the academic community as well as to non-G20 states.

I have a conviction that the emergence of new economic powers will inevitably lead to the emergence of new international currencies. The ongoing transition can be a factor of instability.

This is the case in the area of capital flows, which are becoming increasingly volatile, it is the case with foreign exchange reserves, which are reaching exceptional levels, and it is the case with the supply of reserve assets.

I hope that you can work on the rules of the game in all these areas, which implies - this is my conviction - that the IMF has enhanced means and powers of surveillance. This is a central issue that is essential.

I would like to say that at the heart of the proposals of the French Presidency is clearly the ambition to strengthen, I would say to elevate the role of the IMF, because more than ever, the IMF must be the cornerstone of international monetary cooperation. I apologize for saying it this way, but it is an absolutely major issue.

Where will the coordination of monetary policies take place? For a time, it took place within the framework of the G7. I even believe I remember that the G7 was created for that. Can we consider that monetary problems concern only seven countries? That makes no sense.

We have an international body, which is the IMF. It seems to me, if we even compare the composition of the board of directors to the composition of the G20 - the G20 is not twenty, it is twenty plus five, and the IMF, we should be around that, I believe twenty-four - so there is, it seems to me, a basis for what a future organization could be. I do not see, by the way, which country could refuse such an evolution that is perfectly logical.

We cannot say: "we need more coordination among us" and base coordination solely on the G20 meeting once a year. That makes no sense. The G20 must focus on the most fundamental decisions, the arbitrations, certainly, but there is a whole day-to-day work throughout the year.

In this monetary area, what is essential in the eyes of the French presidency is that in 2011, we agree on a work program and some first concrete reforms. An ambition that we share, of course, with Christine Lagarde.

Finally, the G20 must also address development issues, which have been part of our agenda since the Seoul Summit. We have established a high-level panel on infrastructure to act in the long term. The goal for the Cannes Summit will be to identify, with the help of multilateral development banks, infrastructure projects as well as their financing and to commit to implementing them. In the short term, France will ask you to be ready to mobilize to support our Tunisian and Egyptian friends on the path to democracy, economic progress, and social progress. The success of the transformation that Tunisia and Egypt are undertaking would also be the success of the G20.

And finally, there is the question of the resources we will dedicate to development. Almost all our budgets are in deficit while the commitments we have made are considerable. So what do we do? All together, we accumulate deficits but, at the same time, we have made considerable commitments. How do we resolve these contradictions? I cannot imagine that a single country could say it wishes to be unfaithful to its word. But at the same time, I cannot imagine that a single country could tell me that with its deficits, it will do more - I mean more deficits.

So clearly, the question of innovative financing will arise. Clearly. This is not at all an ideological question; it is a question of respecting the word given and being realistic about the state of our budgets. As far as France is concerned, we are convinced that a tiny tax on financial transactions would be both fair, useful, and effective. I know this is a difficult subject, dear Tim, which generates a lot of opposition, and I understand the sharpness of the debates in each country. I understand it perfectly well.

But I would like to make two remarks here. The first: would it not be possible for some to move forward while others continue to reflect? Are we obliged to have as a choice: all, we move forward or no one? Since not everyone agrees, does that mean we condemn ourselves to inefficiency? Is it a tragedy if a few move forward and others continue to reflect? Let us not make it ideological.

Secondly, we, the French, are in favor of a tax on financial transactions. After all, if the crisis we are experiencing has been so severe, it is because finance has not always been free of some reproaches. Saying this does not insult anyone. Is it not fair, is it not understandable, is it not reasonable, reasonable to consider that those who have contributed so much to a crisis of such magnitude contribute a little to the development of the poorest countries that have suffered the most from the crisis? Is it completely unreasonable to say that? I think it is reasonable. I think it is not a question of left or right; I think it is not a question of northern or southern countries; it is just a question of common sense.

So, these are subjects we want to discuss very openly but that we cannot set aside. I remind you that we were all in Copenhagen and that in Copenhagen, we signed papers, we made commitments to the poorest countries. We cannot say: "no, we forgot, it no longer concerns us." No, we have not forgotten.

So we are not starting from scratch in terms of innovative financing. Many of our countries have adopted it. The French presidency received the mandate in Seoul to examine the conclusions of the report from the United Nations high-level group co-chaired by Mr. Mélès, whose work on financing the fight against climate change I want to commend for its high quality. For my part, on behalf of the G20 presidency, I confirmed to Mr. Bill Gates - for which I thank him - a mission on development financing, both on the necessary mobilization of public aid and on the development of innovative financing, so that Bill Gates can present his conclusions to heads of state and government at the Cannes Summit. I had actually mentioned this issue - Tim Geithner and Christine Lagarde will remember - during the lunch I had in Washington with President Obama. And I thought that Bill Gates was indeed a man whose expertise and commitment could reassure all those who support innovative financing and all those who oppose it. I ask that you approach the discussion that Christine Lagarde will launch tomorrow on the subject with an open mind, simply to understand that your meeting here is being watched by tens, hundreds of millions of people around the world who are wondering what you will do, particularly on this issue, and who are asking themselves: "Will they block or will they move forward?" Because there is a new player in the G20 discussions, there are the governors, there are the ministers, there are the institutions, there are the presidents and heads of government, and then there is international public opinion that matters and is watching what we will do.

To implement these priorities, we will also need to adapt global governance to the 21st century. We created the G20. We reformed the IMF and the World Bank. I add that regarding the IMF, the question of its statutes will certainly arise sooner or later, because I do not see how one can say: "The IMF must have more responsibilities, but we will not touch the statutes." That would seem perfectly incomprehensible to me. If we want to give more responsibilities to the IMF, we must be ready to lay the groundwork for a reform of the IMF's statutes that is consistent with these responsibilities, or else these are speeches that correspond to nothing. There is clearly the question of the IMF's statutes. One can say: "We have time, 10 years, 20 years, a century." I believe that if we agree to entrust new responsibilities to the IMF, the question of the IMF's statutes must be resolved. It is not an extraordinarily complicated subject in truth. Understand me, it can be a complicated subject, but if our goal is to make the IMF a regulatory body, the modification of the statutes - I am sure that the IMF has its own proposals and will not hesitate to present them to us, Mr. Director-General.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I know that your agenda is very busy. It is an honor to welcome you to Paris for this first meeting chaired by Christine Lagarde and Christian Noyer. We are counting heavily on your commitment, heavily on your determination to continue along the path that has allowed the G20 to establish itself as the premier forum for economic and financial coordination. But beyond that, it is public opinion and the peoples who expect their leaders to provide answers to the challenges facing the world today.

I will tell you very simply that by choosing a very ambitious agenda, France has chosen the path of caution. It is by choosing an agenda without content and without ambition that France would have chosen the most reckless path, because public opinion around the world feels that the solidity and extent of the recovery is in your hands. You do not have the right to fail, and you do not have the right to be inactive. And we, the presidency, do not have the right to ignore each other's red lines. So, between each other's red lines and the necessity to coordinate, there will be good work. I am sure it will be fruitful, and I thank you.