Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the fight against global warming, particularly through the creation of a carbon tax, in Artemare (Ain) on September 10, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

10 September 2009 · Statement on the fight against global warming and carbon tax · Artemare, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed an audience in Artemare, Ain on September 10, 2009, to announce a carbon tax and outline France's environmental strategy ahead of the Copenhagen climate summit.
Main themes
Carbon tax, climate change, global warming, Grenelle de l'Environnement, sustainable growth, green economy, energy efficiency, renewable energies, nuclear energy, carbon-free infrastructure, social justice and ecology, post-crisis world order
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,290
88th percentile
Sentences
201
89th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
3.03
51st percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
55th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%49%
  • Environmental 22%22%
  • Institutional 16%16%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Social 3%3%
  • Ceremonial 3%2%
  • Technological 1%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

201 sentences in 41 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians and elected officials,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Our world has reached a moment of truth. The global economic crisis we are experiencing is certainly not over yet. But today we must decide whether we want to create a world different from the one that existed before the crisis, a more sustainable world, a more environmentally respectful world, a fairer world. Some already imagine that, with the first signs of stabilization barely appearing, they can act as if the crisis never happened. That would be a very serious mistake. The world will never be the same as before: it is now that we must act to avert the dangers that threaten not only our country but humanity and the entire planet.

For decades, humanity has only concerned itself with nature in order to exploit it better. The legacy of these excesses is now ours to manage. And the most terrible challenge we face is that of climate change. Without corrective action on our part, the ongoing warming threatens to accelerate: between +1.8° and +4° by 2100, with a risk of a new rise in sea level between 18 and 59 cm. It is time to act.

I firmly believe that it is in these moments of great difficulty that the decisions are made that shape the future. From the unprecedented economic crisis we are experiencing, a new world must emerge.

Each of our fellow citizens must feel concerned by this issue. Everyone must understand the righteousness of our ambition. Everyone must be able to find their place in it. For this is not about building a society of degrowth, a society that would deliberately turn its back on progress, that would claim to make us renounce comfort or mobility. We do not have to choose between ecology and the economy. We do not have to choose between justice and prosperity. We must find the paths that lead to a fairer growth because its fruits will be equitably distributed, lower in carbon and truly sustainable, which will not only respect people and the environment but will also be nourished by the dynamics of innovation and green technologies.

Since my election, I have wanted our country to continually stay ahead of the environmental challenges, which I know are inevitable. The Grenelle of the Environment that I proposed and which Jean-Louis BORLOO has been implementing for two years is the symbol and the vector of this effort by France to position itself at the forefront of sustainable growth.

Beyond important measures on biodiversity, sustainable agriculture, or waste recovery, the Grenelle of the Environment was designed as a vast plan to prepare our country for the post-oil economy, for energy efficiency, for the growth of renewable energies in our consumption. More than 400 billion euros of public and private money will be invested by 2020. More than 600,000 jobs are expected. I am convinced that we will create even more.

With the Grenelle of the Environment, France has set itself the goal of reducing energy consumption in buildings and housing by nearly 40% by 2020. Reduced energy consumption means an immediate increase in purchasing power for all. It means breaking our dependence on hydrocarbons, which means that when oil prices rise, the energy bills of the most modest among us can become an unbearable burden of 15% of their income. We have decided to help our fellow citizens equip themselves with solar systems, heat pumps, and wood heating systems. And we have created a zero-interest loan to finance insulation work, available to everyone, up to 30,000 euros over 10 years. In just three months, nearly 25,000 zero-interest eco-loans have already been concluded. This year, we will exceed our initial target of 1.2 billion euros of new work financed in the thermal renovation of housing.

With the Grenelle of the Environment, France has set itself the goal of becoming the world leader in decarbonized energies, by developing renewable energies and relying on French industrial expertise in nuclear energy. In the coming years, we will devote as much money to research in renewable energies as to that in nuclear energy: an additional 200 million euros each year to give our country a technological lead in key sectors of energy storage, marine energies, second-generation biofuels, and solar energy. The recent announcement of the establishment in France of a world leader in solar panels is no coincidence.

Finally, with the Grenelle of the Environment and the recovery plan, France has launched a unique program for the construction of sustainable infrastructure. For the first time since World War II, a canal will be built in France, between the Seine, the North, and Europe. The works on four high-speed lines are about to begin. By 2020, in Paris and in the regions, nearly 2,000 kilometers of new public transport on dedicated lanes will also be supported by the State. Everywhere, for people as well as for goods, it is about creating reliable and regular alternatives to road transport.

After investing in infrastructure, we will also invest massively in rail freight. We need to open new rail highways, finally create the means for high-speed freight, develop rail operators in our major ports, and guarantee freight trains priority circulation paths.

With these commitments, France has carried the ambition of the Grenelle throughout its Presidency of the European Union. It was about negotiating the "climate-energy package": the most formidable plan for reducing CO2 emissions ever adopted. Through this decision, Europe has become the largest laboratory for inventing the "green" technologies of tomorrow. It is because we have set ourselves the first goals like no others that European technologies will be the most advanced tomorrow.

In December, in Copenhagen, the conclusion of a global climate agreement will be at stake. Until then, France intends to continue to advocate tirelessly for all nations of the world to commit voluntarily to reducing their carbon emissions. Our message is simple: we, the Europeans, have drawn the consequences of our responsibility in climate change. We have committed to reducing our emissions by 20% between 2005 and 2020 and we are ready to go further, up to 30% if everyone takes their responsibilities. At the same time, we ask the rest of the world to move in the same direction. The rest of the world means Asia, the United States, and also emerging countries.

In the face of the climate emergency, in the face of the threats posed by our dependence on oil, in the face of the necessity to transform our growth model, it is time for France to profoundly adapt the incentives of its tax system and create a true ecological taxation. As some Nordic countries have successfully done, it is time for France to strengthen the levies on polluting activities, to reduce taxes on production and labor accordingly. It is strange: it took us several centuries of tax policy to arrive at the idea that it is better to tax harmful behaviors to the community rather than those that are beneficial to it. Everyone now agrees on this common-sense idea. For my part, I have decided to put it into practice.

I made this commitment last spring: a new ecological taxation, the carbon tax will be created: it will apply from 2010, on oil, gas, and coal, based on their carbon content, which is the main gas responsible for climate change. This new taxation has only one objective: to encourage households and businesses to gradually change their behaviors to reduce the consumption of fossil energies that emit CO2. This taxation will stimulate energy savings, reduce the country's oil and gas bills as well as those of families, and allow for further development of green technologies.

I indicate that, in this context, electricity will not be affected by the carbon tax. Electricity production emits very little CO2 in France, thanks to our nuclear fleet, hydropower, biomass, but also, increasingly, thanks to new renewable energies. We are the country in Europe with the most renewable energies. What coherence would there be in encouraging the French, on one hand, to equip themselves with electric cars or solar panels, and, on the other hand, to tax them more?

The carbon tax will be universal and paid by all consumers of fossil energies. For the largest CO2 emitters, which represent a large third of national emissions, the European "climate-energy package" has already provided for European harmonization. 1,400 large industrial sites in France will have to drastically reduce their CO2 emissions, -21% by 2020, or risk having to buy very expensive additional emission quotas. For all other CO2 emitters, for households, and for all companies not subject to emission quotas, nothing was planned. It is the carbon tax that will apply to all tomorrow.

To continue reducing our emissions, to engage France on the path of the post-oil era, changing our behaviors has become essential. And it is now achievable: for nearly two years, the car bonus-malus system has demonstrated how a financial incentive, even limited, can profoundly influence the consumption choices of our fellow citizens: sales of clean vehicles represented barely 15% of the market at the end of 2007. By the end of August 2009, vehicles emitting less than 130 grams of CO2 represented 54% of sales. Conversely, the share of sales of high CO2-emitting vehicles fell from 30% to 10% between the end of 2007 and last month. The French are therefore ready to engage in the necessary transformation of their energy consumption, provided that the signals they receive are clear and that the contract offered to them is fair. I want to commit here to the main principles that will govern the introduction of the carbon tax.

First principle: the carbon tax will be introduced gradually. I am aware that the introduction of a new tax, even if ecological, raises strong concerns. The debate of recent weeks has done nothing to clarify matters for our fellow citizens, caught between those who rejected the carbon tax after having accepted it yesterday, and those who demanded that it be created at the highest possible level. That is why I wanted to express myself on this project in which I deeply believe. I believe in the profound virtue of the polluter-pays mechanism. It is also about initiating a resolutely new process, unknown in France, of transferring our taxation from labor and production to polluting activities that we intend to discourage. Such a change requires some reflection and will still need, I am sure, a lot of explanations.

I want to thank in this regard Michel ROCARD, who has agreed to chair a broad reflection process on the carbon tax. The conference of experts has done remarkable work. I have noted that it and Michel ROCARD himself recommended that we take as a reference a contribution valued at 32 euros per ton of CO2. This position, which stems from significant analytical work and broad consultation, has its coherence.

However, on the market where emission quotas are currently traded among large companies, the value of a ton of CO2 has averaged around 17 euros since its creation in February 2008. Who would understand that households and SMEs are taxed on a basis twice as high as that of large companies subject to emission quotas? Responsibly, I have therefore decided that the starting level of this new taxation would be set with reference to the value of CO2 emission quotas on the carbon market. I intend for the introduction of the carbon tax to be a success for our country. That is why I tell all the most ardent defenders of the carbon tax that we would jeopardize the success of this measure by asking our fellow citizens to adapt to a too abrupt evolution of energy prices. For a value of 17 euros per ton of CO2, the carbon tax will already represent a significant effort: nearly 4.5 cents per liter of fuel oil and diesel, 4 cents per liter of gasoline, and about 0.4 cents per kWh of gas.

Furthermore, I have no intention of reducing in any way the ambitions set by the Grenelle of the Environment, those of halving our emissions between 1990 and 2050. I know full well that this objective is the only one consistent with our commitment to limit global warming to 2° by the middle of the century.

Let it be clear that the level of the carbon tax will gradually increase over time. Again, I will not shy away from my responsibilities. We simply need to find the right pace for its ramp-up. In any case, I want to affirm: whatever the future progression of the carbon tax, if ecological taxation increases, its compensation to the French people must also increase, and in the same proportions.

The second principle that I hold particularly dear: the creation of the carbon tax will not increase the levies in our country. This is an absolutely inviolable rule for me. It means that the creation of the carbon tax will be accompanied by a simultaneous and equivalent reduction, or even elimination, of other taxes. The goal of ecological taxation is not to fill the coffers of the State, but to encourage the French people and businesses to change their behaviors. The creation of the carbon tax will therefore be done - I make this very firm commitment here - without harming the purchasing power of the French people and without penalizing the competitiveness of our businesses.

More specifically, I wish that for French households, the creation of the carbon tax is accompanied either by a reduction in income tax for all households that pay it, or by the payment of an equivalent green check for all non-taxable households. And I want each French household to benefit, according to its situation, from either one or the other. I want everyone to have access to this compensation. In the face of a universal problem like climate change, it would be unjust for there to be, on one side, those who pay and, on the other side, those who are helped. Especially since, as everyone knows, the French are far from equal when it comes to energy expenses. These depend very much on the size of the family and its place of residence. The larger the family, the more a vehicle becomes essential in the household, and the larger the housing must be. Similarly, the more a family lives in the countryside, away from urban centers, the more it is necessary to own a vehicle, the rarer it is to have easy access to public transport, and the less frequent it is to have access to natural gas. I have therefore wished, in a spirit of justice, that the compensation for households be differentiated according to family size and whether they live in urban areas where there is public transport, or in rural areas.

In total, for a value of 17 euros per ton of CO2, a household with two children living in an urban area will benefit from a reduction of 112 euros on its first provisional third if it pays income tax, starting next February. If it does not pay it, it will receive, on the same date, a green check of 112 euros.

A household with two children residing in a rural area where there is no public transport will benefit, on the same date, from a tax reduction of 142 euros if it pays income tax. If it does not pay it, it will receive a green check of 142 euros.

Thus, through tax reductions or green checks, nearly 3 billion euros financed by the tax will be returned to households. Of course, each family will bear the carbon tax on its energy consumption, which will encourage them to reduce it. This is the polluter-pays principle. But reducing consumption will be all the easier, as each family will benefit in compensation from a check or a flat-rate tax reduction, so that the carbon tax does not cut into their purchasing power. In the end, those who decide to reduce their energy consumption will therefore be doubly rewarded: they will pay less carbon tax but will receive, as compensation, the same amount as if they had not saved. This is how, through a bonus-malus mechanism, we will empower the French people to change their behaviors to reduce energy consumption and CO2 emissions. The malus is the carbon tax. The bonus is the green check paid to families or the tax reduction of the same amount.

As for businesses, they will benefit in 2010, the year the carbon tax is created, from the elimination of the portion of the business tax that weighs on investment. Our businesses will find in this ambitious reform the compensation for the costs of the carbon tax while they will finally be able to invest without being fiscally penalized. Some sectors, however, have a particularly strong dependence on fuels, such as transport, agriculture, or fishing. I ask the Government to quickly find ways and means, while maintaining the incentive for energy savings of the carbon tax, to prevent it from excessively harming the competitiveness of these sectors. The effectiveness of the fight against climate change will not progress if the carbon tax leads to favoring the importation of agricultural products, seafood, or further disadvantaging French transporters compared to competitors who are less demanding on environmental standards.

And it is in the same spirit that I had adopted, while I had the honor of presiding over the European Council, the possibility of instituting a carbon tax at our borders. It would not be acceptable that at the same time we make efforts to produce and consume clean products, imports come to compete with us thanks to the competitive advantage represented by non-compliance with international commitments regarding the reduction of carbon emissions. Everyone would then lose: the climate and employment in our country. I note that the United States House of Representatives voted a few weeks ago on a text also proposing a carbon tax at the borders. I also note that the World Trade Organization has deemed such a mechanism perfectly compatible with its rules. This is a fight that I will lead. The carbon tax at the borders is the natural complement to the domestic carbon tax. Moreover, the carbon tax at the borders is vital for our industries and our jobs. It first requires the creation of the carbon tax in France. Our fight against pollution and climate change must not be at the expense of our industries.

The third principle: transparency! I want an independent commission to ensure total transparency on the compensations of the carbon tax. You understand, I want clear rules for the compensation of the carbon tax for households and for businesses. I therefore propose the creation of a permanent and independent commission to monitor French ecological taxation. Its mission will be to track the evolution of the revenues from the carbon tax, to identify the respective shares of households and businesses, and to verify compliance with the commitments of 100% compensation for households and businesses. This commission will be composed of independent representatives from civil society, experts, members of environmental defense associations, representatives of the main contributing sectors, and elected officials, who will be chosen equally from the ranks of the opposition and the majority.

The fourth principle: the State will continue to powerfully support households' efforts to reduce their energy consumption and move towards renewable energies. All the incentive measures developed within the framework of the Grenelle de l'Environnement will be maintained and extended. They will be combined with the restitution of the carbon tax to help our fellow citizens invest. I am talking about tax advantages for the acquisition of energy-efficient housing that can be combined with the zero-interest eco-loan for equipment and thermal insulation, the bonus-malus for automobiles, and the super bonus of 5,000 euros for acquiring an electric vehicle.

In the crucial field of transport, technological advances now allow us to foresee the market launch of electric vehicles or plug-in hybrid vehicles in the coming months. Jean-Louis BORLOO will present on September 23 the electric and hybrid vehicle plan that I announced at the last Paris Motor Show. This plan must allow car manufacturers to offer all French people the opportunity to buy an electric or hybrid vehicle at acceptable price conditions, benefiting from the super bonus of 5,000 euros. You see, at the same time that the carbon tax will encourage the French to turn away from fossil fuels, I want our fellow citizens to have all the tools in hand to adapt, to invest, and to reduce their energy bills.

Ladies and gentlemen, the creation of a carbon tax is anything but a trivial decision. It constitutes a carefully considered strategic choice, a major fiscal shift, as well as a decision of utmost economic importance.

The carbon tax is a considerable innovation in taxation. But I insist: the entirety of the revenue, as I have said, will be redistributed to the French people. But it is about committing, finally, to a path that allows us to collect better: on one side, to collect more from activities that cost society, and on the other side, to gradually reduce the levies that weigh on the work of the French people and on economic activity in France. The creation of the carbon tax is, in this regard, the first step of a fiscal revolution, set to unfold over several decades. With the carbon tax, France will give itself new means to rehabilitate work and to strengthen the industrial vocation of our country.

With the investments from the Grenelle de l'Environnement, our country has sought to open and develop all possible alternative solutions in terms of sustainable transport, renewable energies, and energy-efficient and low-carbon housing. By instituting ecological taxation on fossil fuels, we will set in motion the entire mechanism of green growth. Because the carbon tax will encourage our fellow citizens to consume "green," it will offer new, massive, and promising outlets for all our industrialists who will be able to produce "green." With the carbon tax and the measures from the Grenelle de l'Environnement, the State will create the conditions for an explosion of the market for "clean" products in our country. France will be the first country of this size to take this step. It is up to all our industrialists not to miss this opportunity, like the company CIAT that I visited earlier, in the very promising market of heat pumps.

Ladies and gentlemen, the State is taking its responsibilities to create the conditions for a new industrial and technological revolution. In the coming months, I have no doubt that the work of the commission chaired by Alain JUPPE and Michel ROCARD will recommend a new effort in this area. And the State will respond to the industrial challenges of climate change. In return, I expect total mobilization from our businesses: car manufacturers, home equipment designers, energy suppliers, manufacturers of equipment using renewable energies, installers of innovative materials. This is what I ask of French businesses. It is a win-win contract. We encourage and help 62 million French people to reduce their energy consumption and limit their emissions. And we create a huge market for "green" goods and "clean" services that respect the environment. But the State will not do everything. Businesses must also invest heavily in these new sectors, innovate, and propose the solutions expected by our fellow citizens. This is what I expect from French SMEs. This is what I expect from our national champions. I will soon meet at the Élysée the leaders of major French companies, particularly in the energy sector, to discuss their "green" investment projects in France for the coming years.

You see, ladies and gentlemen, ecological taxation is like so many other things: there are those who talk about it, and there are those who do it. For me, it is profoundly a question of responsibility. A question of responsibility towards our children and future generations, as this measure will help to shape a better world for them. A question of responsibility towards the French people today. I gave them my word, two and a half years ago, by signing the ecological pact proposed by Nicolas HULOT, where the creation of a carbon tax was second only to the establishment of a vast ministry of sustainable development, the one currently held by Jean-Louis BORLOO. By signing the ecological pact, I committed, like other candidates, to do what was necessary, if elected, to introduce a strong tax on polluting energies in France. This commitment, I reiterated in the Grenelle de l'Environnement, asking for it to be studied. Two and a half years later, this commitment is about to be implemented, just as I will implement all the other commitments of the Grenelle de l'Environnement.

The situation is too serious to deceive ourselves or to pretend. Throughout my life, I have wanted to rehabilitate politics. Beyond the grand words, rehabilitating politics means believing that there is never any inevitability. It means believing that there is no problem, no matter how great, that a nation like ours cannot resolutely face if it decides to do so. Whether it is about the moralization of global capitalism or climate change. Rehabilitating politics means believing that the words of political leaders must retain meaning. And there is no inevitability that the passage of time, the difficulties of the moment, or the prevailing demagoguery will overcome the most beautiful ideas, the most essential commitments, and the noblest struggles. That is the ethics I carry in my actions. I will not lack courage. That said, I also know that I will need your support from all of you.