Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the future of public television, particularly the prospect of eliminating advertising, in Paris on February 19, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

19 February 2008 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed an audience in Paris on February 19, 2008, outlining his vision for reforming French public television by eliminating advertising.
Main themes
Public television reform, elimination of advertising, public service broadcasting values, culture and education, programming diversity, French creation and heritage, ratings tyranny, democratic hope, funding of public media, civic role of television
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,037
76th percentile
Sentences
149
80th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.25
61st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 48%45%
  • Economic 24%23%
  • Institutional 19%18%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

149 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Welcome to all.

Along with school, television allows for the widest access and transmission of the culture and values of our society. This is what I meant when I suggested last month that we consider the elimination of advertising in public broadcasting. School and television are the two structures through which our society thinks, weaves, and builds itself. And rightly so, the pioneers, the true creators of public television like Claude SANTELLI once referred to themselves as the "new black hussars of the Republic." Not that I want to return to the old days of the first black-and-white television, but there is a touch of Jules FERRY in this story of public television.

For the essential thing is neither advertising nor funding, even if these questions are very important; they are merely means and not ends. This is not a debate that is exclusively about accounting. It is about a great reform. The elimination of advertising in public service is not just a financial issue; it is a question of values and a question of transmission, a question of creation, a question of education.

A question of democratic hope, which our public television must embody, the hope for diversity in programming, in opinions, in talents, in modes of expression.

Hope in French creation, both new and heritage.

Hope in the social virtue of this great tool of popular culture that is public television.

This hope, politicians, I am aware, have often waved, but they have waved it in powerlessness, alas, in the past. Every ten years, governments tend to look into the health of public broadcasting, its organization, its funding. They question the meaning and definition of public service. Every ten years, experts and wise men gather, and they all note that "public service television needs to be reinvented." All the way to the brilliant report by Catherine CLEMENT in 2002, which poetically summarized the ghettoization of culture on France Télévisions with the lovely phrase: "at night, in summer." (I am sorry, that is not mine. How I would have liked it to be mine!) In other words, culture is present on air when the French are asleep or when they are on vacation, regardless of the efforts of all the teams at France Télévisions in recent years, in recent months.

So every ten years, yet another report is produced; yet another editorial shift is announced to France Télévisions, and a year later, we find that after making so many shifts, we have returned to square one.

Let us be clear, I do not want to downplay the efforts made by the teams at France Télévisions to give meaning to public service and to differentiate it from the offerings of private channels. We should rejoice that France 5 has become a great channel of knowledge and learning, that France 2 and France 3 have reconnected, I say reconnected, with the spirit of "dramatics" by broadcasting theater live during prime time - let them be congratulated - and moreover, the public was there, or adaptations of Maupassant. But I know from experience that this effort risks losing momentum as soon as political attention wanes.

Why?

For a simple reason: the advertising constraint. The tyranny of audience at all costs, on a daily basis, what some call "the tyranny of ratings."

Let us not be fooled, regardless of the virtuous declarations of some and others, if we remain in this advertising logic, we will always, and inexorably, lead programmers towards the easiest path. We know this logic well. It is that of private channels (and why blame them in their case?). To attract advertisers, you need a "powerful" media that brings together the widest possible audiences. And to achieve this powerful audience, the most reliable recipe is to flatter. Flatter what? The easiest aspirations.

However, public service, as we must conceive it, should not be about "bread and circuses." I have nothing against games, nor against bread for that matter. In my position, I need to refuse nothing, but still! Moreover, I do not propose to France Télévisions, or Radio France, to give up audience objectives. I say to give up the tyranny of daily ratings, to focus on trends, the lived audience, analyzed each year as a slope. That is something else entirely. Naturally, France Télévisions must always be concerned about the number of its viewers, or Radio France about the number of its listeners, but not in the same way as a private channel, by quarter hour, by minute, by segment. Because public service television is the television of all audiences.

Public service must mark its difference more strongly and strive to "raise the bar" in an audiovisual landscape that natural gravity pulls downwards. It has often been said, since Jean d'ARCY, one of the first directors of French Radio Television, that public audiovisual service must respond to the triptych "inform, educate, entertain," ensuring that it does not separate its missions but rather intertwines them: "It would be a mistake," wrote Jean d'ARCY, "to have purely entertaining programs, dry informational programs, and overly pedagogical instructional programs." Listen, fifty years later, this message remains perfectly relevant; it has not aged a bit, and we must pay tribute to the talent and vision of the early directors of public television, just as I wish to pay tribute to the first artists and directors, the RENAUD-BARRAULT company, Jean VILAR, or the talented directors of the Ecole des Buttes-Chaumont who were the first to tame the television medium to make it a popular art and the realization of the "democratic hope" that I wished for.

Today we must revisit this triptych (inform, educate, entertain). Because more than ever in an ultra-competitive visual universe, public television must elevate, awaken, excite. Excite curiosity, awaken consciousness, elevate the spirit. Public television must be neither boring nor obsequious. It is said that artists are dangerous because they lay bare the truth of human relationships. In this sense, public television must be "dangerous" and bold. It must take risks.

That is why we must salute in advance, and call upon them to manifest themselves right now, the Claude SANTELLI of the 21st century, the Albert LONDRES of the digital age, the authors of the future's Thierry la Fronde...!

The elimination of advertising is not the negation of the public. On the contrary, it is the only way to establish diversity, to counter the bulldozer of certain low-cost American series that have a devastating effect on our programming industry. Because if we have advertising, we need advertisers. To have advertisers, we need ratings. To have ratings, we need programs that attract: low-cost American series...

This is why the end of advertising in public service, and thus the end of the tyranny of daily ratings, will be beneficial.

This reform, the left has dreamed of, Michel ROCARD first. Lionel JOSPIN attempted it, - in vain. My government will make it happen. Really. Resolutely. Because there comes a time when dreams are good, but reality is better.

The elimination of advertising is a means that I consider essential, but the key to the new public service - this is what I told the social partners I met a moment ago - is naturally the content: what programs do we want to develop in public service? What faces do we want to give to the different channels of France Télévisions?

What should our public television of the future look like? Some have said that the channels of France Télévisions, without advertising, should not become so many new "Arte." I know that this comment has left Jérôme CLEMENT and Patrick de CAROLIS perplexed: was it a criticism or a tribute? Is Arte a model or a counter-model? In reality, Arte is, in my eyes, a reference and a beautiful success of public television. Certainly, its audience is modest, but that is an observation before being a judgment: because achieving an audience of 2% for a contemporary music concert brings together more spectators in one evening than SCHUBERT gathered in his lifetime! Moreover, as René MARTIN and his "crazy days" in Nantes show, it is possible to gather a massive and lasting audience around great composers, as long as the event is scripted and editorialized.

So if there should not be four or five "Arte," it is simply because it would be absurd to want to "clone" a channel, absurd to respond to very diverse aspirations with another type of formatting: public service should not be reserved for the most cultured but should meet the expectations of all audiences, without exception. Each and every one should be able to find in public television a response to their own expectations, a response to what they are looking for, or better yet, a response to what they did not know they were looking for: emotions, a vision, a meaning.

It is in this context, where the networks of distribution are multiplying and diversifying, that I believe it is fundamental to profoundly renew the identity and face of public service. It is not for me to tell you whether the "television of the future" consists of large generalist and unifying channels, or the addition of dozens of "niche channels," or even millions of "on-demand" channels that would make each citizen their own program director. My feeling is that there is room for both models...

Two months after the signing, right here, of the Agreements for the development and protection of works on new networks, I have therefore wished to convene a Commission composed of elected officials and audiovisual professionals, to redefine the identity of public audiovisual service, and to reflect on its embodiment in a renewed and adapted program offering.

Regarding this eminent responsibility, which must involve our entire society, I have chosen to entrust the presidency of this Commission to an elected official.

Dear Jean-François, I know that you will be able to lead the work of this team. You will organize a large-scale reflection involving Parliament, the Government, creators, their partners, the teams of France Télévisions, the CSA, and social partners. And you can of course count on the determined support of the Minister of Culture, Christine ALBANEL, who, when the time comes, will have to present, write, and defend the project.

To all of you who are men and women of art, I will not teach you that talent and quality cannot be theorized, let alone decreed.

"Make me good programs and I will make you good television," one might say... Television is an art of execution, even if it is also an industry that involves heavy investments. Therefore, we expect from you precise proposals to define the identity of public service, to propose the new face of the channels and services of the new public television. In short, to lay the conditions for an offering of popular and quality programs.

You will be keen, in your work, to consult, to probe the dreams of the French, to reveal the territories of their true expectations, of their true aspirations to better quench their thirst for knowledge, emotion, and culture. Public television must be a mirror of society, but a mirror that allows us to see and understand the world.

You will submit your conclusions before the end of May, right here. Your work will enable the Government to draft the new specifications for public television.

There you have it, Ladies and Gentlemen, dear Jean-François, this is what I wanted to say to you. I will conclude with this directive, inspired by another director of French Radio Television, Albert OLLIVIER: "For the general public, we need great television. Aim high, and you will touch their hearts."

Ladies and Gentlemen, before your work begins, I wish to state a few principles that will guide your action.

1. First of all, there will be no privatization of France Télévisions.

No channel of the public television service will be privatized. A single channel, whether private or public, made sense and had value in the era of analog scarcity. In the digital age, it is bouquets of channels that have meaning and value. And France Télévisions is a bouquet of channels. Therefore, it is not by cutting off a limb that we will strengthen the quality of the service, whether public or private, but by working to increase the complementarity between the components of a bouquet of channels and services.

2. Next, every euro of advertising revenue lost for public service will be compensated by one euro of public resources. This will be the case in 2009, but also in 2008, depending on the difficulties that France Télévisions may encounter in meeting its advertising objectives following the implementation of this reform. To demonstrate the State's confidence in its public service and to support the necessary investments for the transition to all-digital, I have asked the Government to assess the possibility of providing France Télévisions with a capital endowment as early as 2008. I do not recall any government having done this; it is a gesture of confidence in the sustainability of this great company.

On this subject of financing, dear Jean-François, dear friends, you are not being asked to organize a "Lépine competition of taxation," but to propose new funding that will compensate for the removal of advertising. You will particularly consider the establishment of a "mix of resources," including a contribution from private television channels, which will benefit from the transfer of advertising revenues, as well as a contribution from telecommunications operators, based on the broadest possible base and therefore at the lowest rate. However, we have determined that private radio and the press should not be subject to any new tax, even though these media will partially benefit from the removal of advertising on public service. Their economic situation is indeed more delicate than that of the major television channels, and I hope that the "breath of fresh air" provided by this reform will allow them to better navigate the digital revolution.

Your proposals on financing must naturally be consistent with the recommendations of the new specifications.

3. You will be able to consider two options. The first would be to eliminate all advertising starting January 1, 2009. The second would involve considering this elimination gradually, beginning in 2009 by removing advertising after 8 PM on all France Télévisions channels.

4. The rules governing the relationships between producers and broadcasters must also be modernized: if we need to better finance public service, we must also allow the private sector to be more dynamic by loosening the constraints inherited from another time. This will obviously benefit broadcasters but also, let us not overlook, French production companies, this remarkable network of SMEs that must develop. The time has come to replace the regime of the famous "Tasca decree" with professional agreements negotiated between adult and responsible partners, concerned with properly financing works and effectively exploiting rights. The mission entrusted to David KESSLER and Dominique RICHARD by Christine ALBANEL must quickly resume its work in light of this "new situation." Thus, the advertising constraints on private channels will be eased through the transposition of the European directive "audiovisual media services" (I would like to say to the social partners that the clarity of my private remarks resonates with the clarity of my public statements). This will occur in the first half of 2008.

It is logical that this "new situation" of regulating our audiovisual sector extends to new operators, so that the downstream continues to finance the upstream and so that distribution nourishes creation. This is how our system has functioned for sixty years. The overall assessment is positive in terms of cultural diversity. However, it is necessary, in return for these efforts, that the new audiovisual operators, namely telecommunications companies, have easier and quicker access to works and channels. It would also be fair that those who create content specifically for the new networks can benefit from public aid currently reserved for traditional cinema and television operations.

I therefore wish for the Ministry of Culture and Communication to continue this exercise of modernization and adaptation of our audiovisual regulation, to achieve a balanced compromise among all actors.

You see, ladies and gentlemen, I do not dare to say my dear friends, the task is immense. We have to build two "new alliances." One among all partners in the audiovisual sector in the digital age. And the other, essential, between the Nation and its public television service.

Finally, some may wonder why the President of the Republic is concerned with the reform of public service television. But if there is one subject that concerns the nation as a whole, it is indeed television, and particularly public service television. And I also tell the staff and teams of France Télévisions that the fact that the head of State is engaged in this project is a testimony of confidence, hope, enthusiasm, and consideration. Television is a matter for the Nation, and the matter of the nation is the matter of the head of State.

Lines, coherence, no taboos, a debate that you will organize around our public television, a timeline, resources, imagination, ladies and gentlemen, let’s get to work! France will become passionate about your debate, do not doubt it, and I hope that you will thus understand better that, for me, the choice was very easy: it was the choice between movement, which allows for the creation of new opportunities, and immobility, which breeds bitterness, disappointment, and the disappointed. I do not want immobility for our country, I do not want immobility for public service television, I dream of a great public service television, I dream, dear Jacques CHANCEL, that we become an example for the world by inventing this public service television of the 21st century. I am a bit tired of being given foreign references, that of the BBC. We will all try together, without preconceived notions, to set an example for others. Let me tell you that I will follow, dear Jean-François, your work with great interest. Be as imaginative as possible and believe me that during my term, this reform of public audiovisual, I am fully aware, will remain one of the most important reforms I will have to lead. Thank you.