Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the priorities of health policy and the reform of the healthcare system, in Paris on September 18, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

18 September 2008 · Statement on the priorities of health policy and the reform of the healthcare system · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed French health officials and parliamentarians in Paris on September 18, 2008, outlining government priorities for healthcare reform.
Main themes
Healthcare system reform, health policy priorities, demographic aging and longevity, chronic and emerging diseases, prevention and sports, quality and safety in healthcare, economic dimension of health, genomic medicine, health expenditure, tribute to medical professionals
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,834
90th percentile
Sentences
323
96th percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
9.7
17th percentile
Syntax
2.64
9th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 64%63%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

323 sentences in 62 paragraphs

Madam Minister, Dear Roselyne,

Mr. Minister, Dear Alain,

Mr. President of the General Council,

Ladies and Gentlemen Members of Parliament,

Mr. President of the Association of Mayors, Dear Jacques,

And if you allow me, Dear friends,

Health has become one of the top concerns of the French people. Health has significantly improved since the end of the Second World War. We have gained nearly fifteen years of life expectancy since 1950, fifteen years, which shows that the money invested has been put to good use. Fifteen years of life expectancy since 1950 and the movement continues. The aging of the French population is, moreover, the result of the remarkable improvement in its health status. But health is also a fragile, precarious good, and that is why each of us, when thinking about our own health, worries and concerns arise. My responsibility, that of the Government, is to take into account the expectations of the French people and to do everything possible to try to meet them.

I would first like to remind you of the context in which these expectations are situated and then tell you what priorities I intend to set for the Government's action in this area.

The context. The context is marked by several realities that we must analyze with lucidity.

First, there is an unavoidable demographic reality. The increase in our life expectancy has biological consequences. Longevity is not a disease in itself, of course, but with age, all sorts of diseases can appear that we did not suffer from in the past. Today, we are witnessing the emergence of new cancers, many forms of age-related visual impairment, and Alzheimer's disease.

Our lifestyles are also evolving. Sedentary behavior is on the rise. We have never been so mobile, and yet we have never counted our physical efforts as much. That is why, dear Roselyne, I created the Ministry of Health and Sports. You are well aware that I was particularly keen on this. I did not like the division of "sports and youth," as if sports were only the concern of young people. When I do sports, I see few young people. I see rather people my age trying to maintain themselves. I wanted to combine health and sports because sports is an essential element of health. If we do not elevate sports and physical activity to the rank of our habits, we risk increased danger in the coming decades. It is not enough to say it; we must now implement it. The Ministry of Health and Sports is crucial. Sports is an element of health. The fight against doping and the protection of our athletes' health are part of sports policy. One wonders why it took until François FILLON's government to take this initiative?

We must finally reckon with a sociological reality. Our attitude towards the health sector has changed. I say this in front of the representatives of the various trade unions present here; every day, we are more demanding. Every day, we want more results. Every day, we are less inclined to accept tragedies like that of radiotherapy in Epinal, where we were still, a few months ago, together, Roselyne. We have the right to expect a level of quality and safety for our health that is even better than what we experience when we fly or when we drive our cars. There is an unprecedented demand for quality and safety in health services.

The medical reality is also changing. Thanks to advances in the understanding of the human genome, medicine will increasingly be preventive. It will allow us to determine in advance the predisposition risks of each of us to common diseases.

Moreover, the number and complexity of diseases that medicine faces continue to increase. New treatments are being developed for rare diseases that were once completely unknown. Their cost can exceed 150,000 euros per person per year. And I can imagine what a box of medication that costs more than a nurse's monthly salary represents for her. And I naturally understand that she may wonder, in the face of the explosion of these costs necessitated by research, what the consequences will be?

At the same time, chronic diseases, which affect millions of our fellow citizens, are on the rise. These diseases account for 60 to 70% of health expenditures in all developed countries. We must live, sometimes for our entire lives, with these diseases for which we combat the symptoms but do not cure.

I would like to take this opportunity to pay tribute to the doctors and other health professionals who shape the medical reality of France. You are our pride. A national pride. We are proud of the quality of your training. We are proud of your dedication to serving the sick. And we are proud above all of the adaptability that each of you has demonstrated.

We must finally face an economic reality. Health has become a driver of our economy. It represents 11% of our gross domestic product and nearly two million jobs. The pharmaceutical industries present in our territory contribute nearly six billion euros to our trade balance. Health is a driver of job creation and wealth in our country. Health is an investment for France.

Today, health insurance finances three-quarters of health expenditures. In fifteen or twenty years, the share of health in national wealth could approach 15%. Following the example of other countries, our health expenditures—two hundred billion euros today—will increase by several billion euros by 2025—two hundred billion euros. This is what we are investing in our health. We must ask ourselves whether these additional expenditures will be used wisely? Additional expenditures are inevitable. Will we be able to maintain national solidarity at the level it is today? It is today that we must ask the question, because tomorrow it will be too late.

For our health system to remain solidary, we must take our responsibilities. And I am the first to have to take my responsibilities. I took my responsibilities by creating medical co-payments on January 1st of this year. This did not please everyone, but I bring it up again, not to apologize but to tell the French: look at those who are responsible and who take their responsibilities and those who are irresponsible and refuse to take them. The co-payments are not an idea of Roselyne. I asked her to implement them. Generally, Presidents, not always, were behind the Ministers, especially when they announced good news. When Ministers announced bad news, Presidents were a little further away. I am not behind Roselyne; I am in front.

I spoke about medical co-payments during my electoral campaign. It is not customary to talk about bad news before being elected. I did it. What have I not heard? I observe all the virtuous people who call on me to spend more without having the slightest idea of how to find the money. By creating the co-payments, I was merely anticipating the needs of tomorrow—cancer, Alzheimer's disease, palliative care. I merely reminded that national solidarity must be supported by new resources. And I merely stated an obvious fact: health has a cost, the financing of which must be rethought and equitably distributed.

Those who are against the co-payments are against the financing of the Alzheimer plan. They are against the opening of new palliative care beds. They are against the money that will be given for the cancer plan. If we want to spend more, we must find revenue. And I am truly open to those who want to give me ideas. In any case, I did not come to say that everything is easy and that everything is possible. Besides, if it were easy, others would have done it before me. It is incredible what I should have already done in 500 days that others have not done in 50 years. Now there is no choice. We must decide and we must take responsibility. If we want to preserve a universal and solidary financing of our health expenditures, every action taken must be done in the most economical way possible. 200 billion euros spent on health; we cannot afford to spend money for nothing. The performance of our health system is the guarantee of its sustainability. It is through the constant pursuit of efficiency that we will be able to meet the health demands of the French, while ensuring satisfactory incomes for health professionals, all without destabilizing our economy. Because I cannot increase contributions to raise the cost of employment and increase unemployment. So I want to strengthen France's competitiveness.

Ensuring the financing of health expenditures is a challenge for tomorrow that is being played out today. That is why I want health insurance to return to balance in 2011. To achieve this, we will need the resolute commitment of all. Of all.

And first of all from complementary health insurance, which must contribute to improving the quality of care, managing risk, and controlling expenditure, in the interest of the insured. Negotiations between health insurance and health professionals will now involve complementary organizations, particularly in sectors where they guarantee significant coverage, such as optics and dentistry.

This is also why I want all health professionals, in the community and in hospitals, to be more involved in the medical management of prescriptions. I want health insurance to propose to the validation of the High Authority of Health reference frameworks for good practice in sectors where we observe deep divergences in the use of care, for example in physiotherapy.

Hospitals must also feel responsible for medical management. Similar to what exists for liberal doctors, a national agreement between hospital doctors, health insurance, the State, and hospital federations could lay the foundations for better regulation of hospital prescriptions executed in the community. There is no reason to ask some and not ask others.

Finally, I invite health insurance to intensify the fight against waste, abuse, and fraud. It must rely on new instruments to tackle fraud. A system of minimum penalties will be established starting next year, based on the model currently in place to combat illegal work.

Health policy is a policy whose results are judged years later. I know this, but I do not want to delay the necessary reforms any longer. It is my duty to initiate today the reforms that are necessary to prepare for the future. It is my duty to ensure that tomorrow our children are in the best possible state of health. This is the purpose of the bill "hospitals, patients, health, and territories" that Roselyne BACHELOT will present at the beginning of October, I believe, to the Council of Ministers. This is a major innovation; until now, hospitals have been the great absent from all reforms; this is not by chance; it is because it is difficult. The debate in Parliament will further improve the content of the reform.

The bill will promote a better distribution of primary care services across the territory.

There are more than 200,000 active doctors in our country today. There have never been so many. We have 3.3 active doctors for every 1,000 inhabitants. The OECD average is 3. But I know that the situation will deteriorate until 2025, when the density of doctors will have returned to its 1985 level. But in the meantime, each of us will consult our doctor more often on average. There is therefore an urgent need to act.

The numerus clausus will therefore continue to be gradually raised. But it should be distributed among specialties and regions, based on medical demographics and the needs of the territories. In the future, each region should define its own medical training needs by specialty. The bill introduces this type of regulation; it is a first that I support with all my strength.

National solidarity cannot remain indifferent to the issue of unequal access to healthcare across the territory. So I ask the question: should national solidarity guarantee the same fee to a general practitioner in a fragile rural area or a difficult suburb as to a specialist doctor setting up in an over-equipped urban area? I take my responsibilities: I do not believe so. I will draw the conclusions. The resources of national solidarity must be mobilized with more discernment. It is normal that better conditions, fees, or advantages are granted to a doctor who sets up on the outskirts of Douai than to a doctor who sets up in the city center of Aix-en-Provence. It is not an offense to anyone to say this. I love Aix-en-Provence very much, but I find it harder to find doctors who settle in Douai than in Aix-en-Provence. This must also be taken into account in remuneration.

I reiterate that conventional negotiations are underway, and I expect operational measures by the end of the year to increase the medical supply in the areas that need it most. I do not accept that some of our fellow citizens do not have a medical offer worthy of the name while in other neighborhoods some doctors can no longer make a living due to the high medical density.

To meet the expectations of the French people, cooperation among healthcare professionals is essential. I strongly believe in the role of paramedics, particularly nurses, for primary care. Nurses can perform a whole series of tasks that overload doctors. I think of routine follow-up for people with chronic illnesses. And everyone will benefit: the doctor, who can refocus on qualified acts, and the nurse, who can better take care of the patient. Cooperation is a guarantee of quality care for all. Roselyne BACHELOT's bill will extend the principle of cooperation among healthcare professionals by moving them out of their experimental framework. Experimentation was necessary, but now we will move to generalization.

In reality, cooperation between doctors and nurses is imperative. We have no choice. As medical demographics are about to enter a difficult period, that of nurses, given the measures taken in recent years, should experience a new vigor. With fewer than eight nurses per thousand inhabitants, our country is among the least well-equipped in the OECD. Increasing the density of nurses, along with a more harmonious distribution across the territory, must be the response to the expectations of the French people. Saying this is not just about demographics for the sake of demographics. On the contrary, I see it as a unique opportunity to better organize our healthcare supply.

In this regard, I commend the agreement signed by health insurance and liberal nurses. This agreement establishes, in the very interest of the profession, a regulation of installations. It rebalances the supply of nursing care between areas where professionals are installed in large numbers and those where they are insufficient. Listen, I come here to the region; you have the same rights in this region, in this department of Jura, as those who are in the center of the capital.

Health houses, like the remarkable one I just visited in Bletterans, are the ideal place for cooperation among healthcare professionals. Health houses are the backbone of the healthcare system of tomorrow. They provide a local response. They improve the quality of care through collegiality. They offer professionals satisfactory working conditions. Again, the resources of health insurance will be directed, I say, primarily towards these structures. We want more health houses.

France is lagging behind its European neighbors in organizing primary care. Besides health houses, other organizations exist to strengthen the primary care supply: secondary practices, temporary positions, replacements. I count on the imagination of the conventional partners to accelerate the development of all these solutions. It is not a matter of moving from all "hospital" to all "health house," but of having a palette that allows for diversifying the offer.

We have for too long, I say this as I think, allowed health professions to self-manage their demographics. It is time to act and make choices. If some have difficulty doing so, we will do it for them.

Access to care also raises the question of medical fees. I want all stakeholders - health insurance, doctors, complementary insurance - to define by the end of the year the modalities of an optional sector for surgeons, obstetricians, and anesthetists in sector 2. The optional sector must allow for better regulation of fees than sector 2, accompanied by quality objectives. It must also put an end to certain injustices between practitioners who, for the same qualifications and diplomas, find themselves in extremely different fee situations. Fee freedoms will be better managed by health insurance and complementary insurance, which will allow for better access to care. For this option to be adopted by the greatest number, specific advantages must be associated with it. If the conventional partners cannot reach an agreement on this subject, the State will draw the consequences and act.

Should the fees of doctors who decide to remain in sector 2 be subject to regulation? I am, as you know, very attached to the liberal practice of medicine. We must take into account the exceptional reputation of certain practitioners who bring honor and attractiveness to our healthcare system. However, it seems to me that a form of adapted regulation could be considered. We must provide concrete solutions to the access difficulties to care that the French people encounter.

The second priority I set for our health policy is the safety and quality of care. The primary mission of caregivers, it should be recalled, is to ensure the safety of their patients. I want to establish a regulation of the healthcare system based on quality.

I know well that safety and quality cannot be decreed. The quality and safety of care are first nourished by research. Excellent biomedical research, concerned with its valorization, is the condition for quality medicine. So we will re-examine our model of the university hospital center (CHU). We must ask ourselves whether this model, created in 1958 by Professor Robert DEBRÉ, is still suitable and under what modalities the triple mission of teaching, research, and care of CHUs should be exercised in the future. The autonomy now granted to universities and the reconfiguration of biomedical research create the conditions for the renewal of our university hospitals. I will soon entrust a reflection mission to a commission created on the model of the "Robert DEBRÉ" commission. I expect from this reflection courageous, ambitious, pioneering proposals.

Ladies and gentlemen, you have understood, I will not leave any element of the health sector in the shadows.

The Alzheimer plan and the cancer plan were designed precisely to strengthen the links between biomedical research and care. These plans must accelerate, through research, the dissemination of reliable diagnostics and quality care across the territory. That is why I am personally involved alongside Roselyne BACHELOT in these public health plans.

The progress made possible by research must benefit the greatest number. Best practices must be the subject of continuous training for health professions. The updating of theoretical knowledge only makes sense if it goes hand in hand with a reassessment of medical practices for the benefit of the patient. The "hospital, patients, health, and territories" bill rightly emphasizes the importance of this quality approach.

In hospitals, I want each establishment to carefully analyze the causes of accidents related to the care provided within it. To accelerate the movement, it is necessary that a few simple indicators, such as the mortality rate or infection rate, be made public for each healthcare establishment. I want concrete results.

I have a true ambition for our country: to ensure that in every medical office, in every health house, the quality of care for dominant chronic diseases - I think of hypertension, diabetes, asthma, as well as psychiatric disorders - is prioritized.

The patient must be an active partner in the management of their illness. We cannot expect everything from protocols. I place great hopes in therapeutic education, which allows the patient to better understand their illness and treatment. I want to take this opportunity to commend the president and members of the national health conference, who are present here. They have understood how important therapeutic education is as a determining factor in our state of health.

The third of my priorities for health is prevention. Both professionals and patients, we must move from a purely curative attitude to a culture of prevention. Let us make prevention a new state of mind, a more effective medicine, a less costly medicine.

Only 7% of health expenditures are devoted to prevention. I want the share of prevention to exceed 10% by 2012.

The prevention policy must be the spearhead of the fight against obesity. It is progressing at a rate comparable to that of the United States. There is no need to mock the United States in this regard. The number of obese people in our country is increasing at the same speed as across the Atlantic. In France, obesity affects 17% of adults and 4% of children. The health of our children is at stake. I do not accept that the children of workers are ten times more likely to be obese than the children of executives. We must do everything to combat this scourge. The fight against obesity is not the sole responsibility of doctors or public health actors. It is everyone's business: parents, elected officials, teachers, healthcare professionals, industry, and the media. I call on everyone's responsibility.

I also wish for an ambitious prevention policy to reduce the number of avoidable deaths before the age of 65. Finally, I was surprised to find that our rate of avoidable deaths before 65 is double that of the United Kingdom. There is no need to explain that health there is very poor. I love my country passionately, but I look at it as it is, with its strengths and weaknesses. I expect the second cancer plan, dear Roselyne BACHELOT, to reduce exposure to avoidable risk factors such as alcohol, tobacco, and the environment. In your bill, you are right; we will prohibit the sale of alcohol to minors and pave the way for new courageous measures to address these factors. We know that these factors kill; it is up to us to take our responsibilities and engage in a genuine prevention policy.

To develop prevention, screening must become a habit. We need to extend to other diseases the campaigns organized for breast cancer screening. I want every French person who has questions to receive a reliable answer quickly. There are still too many cases of diagnostic wandering, too many years lost. We can no longer accept this. Pathways and networks must allow for the immediate orientation of the patient to the professional who will make the correct diagnosis.

The hospital reform, stemming from the report of the commission excellently chaired by Gérard LARCHER, whom I thank, is the fourth pillar of our health policy. In Neufchâteau last April, I defined the content of the reform: evolution of governance, the necessity of having a leader in the hospital - it cannot work if there is no leader, someone who decides, who takes responsibility - opening up the recruitment of directors, extending contracts for practitioners, grouping public hospitals within territorial hospital communities, and management flexibility in public procurement or real estate management. The bill incorporates all these measures, and I congratulate Roselyne BACHELOT for that. In France, hospitals account for 64% of healthcare expenditures, compared to less than 50% on average in the OECD. A portion of patients currently treated in hospitals could be cared for in the community or at home. Hospitals must reorganize to prioritize referral care and give substance to real care pathways. Dear Jacques PELISSARD, we suffer too much from the scattering of medical and paramedical resources. In a city of 50,000 inhabitants, it is not uncommon to have up to five lines of radiology or surgery on call each night. Do we have the means to pay for this for the health of the French people? It is medically unnecessary and economically absurd, while we need money to invest in so many priorities. Some hospital sites must be redirected towards the care of the elderly or adults with disabilities. Let no one doubt my determination to carry this reform through to the end.

In order for the hospital to adapt, its organization must gain in efficiency and flexibility. The hospital reform provides new tools to hospital actors. It is up to them to seize them! The new management freedoms of hospitals will necessarily come with greater responsibility. The French disease is not knowing who is responsible. I see the criticisms directed at me. I see many, but not this one. People think I take on too much responsibility. This is just the beginning. In a country where I find that those in charge do not take enough responsibility, one cannot want to be responsible and not assume one's responsibilities. A leader takes on their responsibilities. The French need to know who decides and why. If it works, we continue. If it does not work, we are sanctioned. That is the rule. I want the accounts of hospitals to be subject to certification. With 64% of health insurance, we can perhaps have certified, verified, controlled accounts. I want situations of deficit to no longer be tolerated.

The hospital reform will put doctors back at the heart of the establishment project. Doctors can count on me; the reform will be carried out with them. But I want to be able to count on them, as well as on all hospital staff, whose daily life I am fully aware of the difficulties. I want to reiterate that the 35-hour workweek has profoundly disorganized the French hospital system. And that this has led to the worsening of the working conditions of hospital staff, even if, with Roselyne BACHELOT, as I promised in Dunkirk, almost immediately after my election, we resolved the issue of millions of unpaid overtime hours worked by hospital staff. Not paying them is not my conception of work.

The reform must also support all those who are committed to change. Why not allow hospitals that are balanced, thanks to the efforts of all their staff, to redistribute part of the surpluses? To whom? To the employees, to the hospital staff, and I see no reason why a profit-sharing policy, which I believe so much in the private sector, should not apply in the hospital sector?

It is thanks to the improvement of its productivity that a hospital center generates a surplus. Why not let all responsible actors benefit from it? I am not afraid of words. A profit-sharing policy for medical or paramedical staff seems very appropriate to me in defining a project where responsibility, quality, and safety are three key words in the mindset of our policy.

The management of the health system is my fifth and final priority. Professionals often have an isolated practice. In many cases, each act is performed without connection to the other actors in the health system. The interactions among them are numerous but poorly utilized. Well-managed, they would improve the overall quality of care for individuals. Ignored, they lead to redundancies, lost opportunities, and dysfunctions. It will therefore be up to the future regional health agencies, which will be established in 2009, to create, or even impose, coherence among the actors.

The management of medical emergencies and the continuity of care is emblematic of this state of affairs. What energy has been devoted by prefects, hospitals, and health insurance in this area! With what result? The doubling in fifteen years of the number of emergency visits! Anyone goes to the emergency room any way they want, at any time. We can do better by bringing together the skills of the State and health insurance for greater efficiency. Thanks to the action of the regional health agencies, the number of sectors with incomplete medical on-call tables must decrease. When you are a doctor, you have obligations. On-call duty is part of those obligations.

In reality, I expect the regional health agencies to reconcile the organization of care and the control of spending: better organization to spend less and provide more to patients. I expect the agencies to help equip our country with a high-performing health system, capable of adapting to the realities of increased life expectancy and the challenge of financing. The agencies are the first stone in a broader restructuring of our health system. So I know how difficult the reform that is underway is. And Roselyne BACHELOT can count on my support because I am committed to it with absolute determination. Health is a major concern for the French. It is 200 billion euros. The President of the Republic cannot ignore it. Everyone knows the reforms that are necessary, and everyone has at one time or another given up in the face of difficulty. Ladies and gentlemen, I have come here to this city and this department to tell you that the word "abandonment" is not part of my vocabulary.

Thank you.