Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the project to merge ANPE and UNEDIC, in Mâcon on October 8, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

8 October 2007 · Mâcon, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed officials in Mâcon on October 8, 2007, to announce and explain his plan to merge employment agency ANPE with unemployment insurer UNEDIC.
Main themes
Merger of ANPE and UNEDIC, public employment service reform, job seeker support, administrative simplification, unified compensation and placement, European employment standards, institutional efficiency, single point of contact
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,598
82nd percentile
Sentences
212
90th percentile
Readability
69
97th percentile
Grade
7.7
3rd percentile
Syntax
2.80
22nd percentile
Vocabulary
1.97
7th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 62%58%
  • Social 22%21%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

212 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Mr. Deputy Mayor, dear Gérard Voisin,

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials,

Madam President, Madam THOMAS,

Thank you for your presence,

Mr. Director General, Mr. CHARPY,

We have come with Christine LAGARDE, and things are clear to me: we need to break away from a system that is not efficient enough. This has nothing to do with the dedication of the agents, their skills. This system is not efficient enough. The most vulnerable among our compatriots, in terms of training, are unable to return to employment. Our results, by the way, are not a value judgment. We look and we compare, and if everything were going well, we wouldn't be talking about it.

It is under these conditions that I asked Christine to carry out the merger between ANPE and UNEDIC. I am told that there are single points of contact. It is true, Saône-et-Loire is well advanced in this area, as your Maison de l'Emploi shows. I would like to say two things. First, this shows that it is possible, and that it is not impossible, it is possible. The sites as integrated as here can be counted on the fingers of one hand. That is why I was shown around. Often, single points of contact are sites that host, in one institution, only a few agents from the other. I will put my foot in the dish: it is more for the image of the single point of contact - I am not talking about here - than for reality. That is why we must now remove the obstacles to bring the two separate institutions closer together, which involves a loss of energy. Too much energy wasted, too much time lost. With the merger, we will move to the next level.

We need to be serious, all of us, and we need to speak frankly. We have been talking about this for twenty years. Twenty years. There are not only fools who have talked about this. Both left and right. It has been twenty years. It has been twenty years that the unemployed have been going through a gauntlet. That is the reality. What is very important to understand is that the members of the institutions are not to blame. They are victims of a status that provides for this. So, what should we do? I was not elected to wait another twenty years. I want to put the job seeker at the heart of the system. I do not start from the administrative structures; I want to start from the job seeker.

What I want is an operator that offers a universal and integrated public service for all job seekers, whether they are compensated or not. All of this is not revolutionary in itself.

What I want is for us to finally bring our public employment service up to the best European standards. All the countries that have recently reformed their labor markets and are achieving the best results on the employment front have all chosen to unify the functions of compensation and placement. I say this to job seekers: all of them. It is a common point. It is quite impressive. All those who have succeeded with the best results unify. In other words, the job seeker deals with the same person, who compensates and who looks for a job for them. It is a matter of common sense. Our administrative structures must adapt to the needs of job seekers and not the other way around. The excellence of the public employment service therefore requires the uniqueness of the structures, so that the job seeker no longer has to go from one organization to another to fulfill their various obligations.

The duty of an unemployed person is to look for a job, not to bear the burden of administrative complexity. Therefore, for the public employment service, there must be a single point of contact.

You know, I am doing the same thing with the DGI and Public Accounting. When you want to pay your taxes and ask for explanations, you have to rack your brain to think: where do you submit your declaration? Where do you go to pay your taxes?

This is no longer possible. There is one place, a single point of contact where you are compensated, because you need to live, and where you are helped to find a job. But that is not all. I would like to bring the cultures of ANPE and UNEDIC closer together so that we no longer separate the compensation follow-up and the personalized follow-up of the job seeker.

From this point of view, the merger allows us to go much further than the simple single point of contact. From two juxtaposed service offers in the same place, we will move to an integrated service offer, and that changes everything. What does that mean? It means, I say this to Ms. Ferraro, that in the long term, a single interview will allow for registration, examination of compensation rights, and the development of the projected plan carried out by a versatile agent, instead of two interviews with two distinct agents, even if they are in the same building. This means we will put an end to the duplication of certain support functions. You can be in the same place and have separate support services since you manage different personnel. This means a single approach in the relationship with companies, with a permanent exchange of information between the services. But we want this merger in the interest of job seekers, especially the most disadvantaged, because it will be accompanied by a considerable mobilization of the resources dedicated to them. Each unemployed person will therefore have, in the future, a unique contact person who will ensure their welcome, registration, compensation, and support in the search for a new job. Mr. Bétayeb asked me earlier what this would change concretely for him. Basically, it is what you told me: your thing sounds good, I am ready to join, but what is it going to change? Thanks to the synergies that will allow the merger of the two organizations, the number of advisors in direct contact with job seekers will increase significantly. That is the result of versatility, it is to put the maximum number of people in contact with job seekers. This will allow for intensive, personalized follow-up of the unemployed. The merger will allow for a more equitable treatment of all job seekers because it will also improve the service to those who are not compensated.

Regarding the functioning of this future service, for Ms. Chamoulot, Mr. Jayet, and their colleagues, Christine is negotiating with the social partners. Ms. Thomas and Mr. Charpy can testify to this. Some have managed to build, here in Mâcon, with the State. We will try to do it together for all of France. I do not want to anticipate the results of the negotiations, but allow me to give you a few axes that, I believe, can be interesting. I think first that the merged ANPE and UNEDIC could be overseen by an orientation council. This council, which would be a place for regulating employment policies, would bring together social partners, the leaders of the new organization resulting from the merger, dear Jean-Patrick, representatives of local authorities, particularly at the regional level but also at the local level, because a mayor matters. This orientation council, which I propose Christine submit for discussion, would allow for better involvement of social partners in employment policy. Below this orientation council, we can imagine two structures. UNEDIC, on one side, would be managed by the social partners, who would continue to independently administer the unemployment insurance system and set the terms of compensation, which are still the responsibility of the social partners. This is what we call parity. I hope I do not shock you by saying this, as I want it to continue. On the other side, the new organization that would bring together the ASSEDIC network and that of ANPE. This new organization would be responsible for welcoming, registering, supporting, compensating the unemployed, as well as maintaining the lists, as ANPE does today. For me, it is very important that the social partners continue to play their full role in this whole.

Last proposal: I would like this merged organization to have regional branches. The question of whether these territorial structures will have their own legal status is part of the negotiations that Christine is conducting, Ms. Thomas, Mr. Charpy. I am very attentive. We set lines, we set orientations, then, you see, there is negotiation, there is discussion, we must also allow a little flexibility in the system.

A word on the role of social partners in this new organization. The merger is an opportunity to give a greater place to social partners. I will explain myself. Today, it is quite simple, perhaps I will shock you but I say it as I think: social partners are not involved in employment policies, except for unemployment insurance. Yet it is in the field of employment that the legitimacy of social partners is the strongest. A social partner does not have as their only mission to defend a social achievement. They can have ideas. These ideas can be good, intelligent, as long as we are willing to hear them, listen to them, and retain them. I therefore wish for them to be more involved as social partners within the framework of a unique public employment service. The social partners retain their prerogatives regarding, as I have already said, the determination of compensation rules. But we must go further and see with them how they could participate in the major orientations of employment policy, Madam Thomas, at both the national and regional levels. A union can have ideas on employment policy; this is not shocking, on the contrary. They must be involved. We will discuss all of this. Christine will lead the negotiations; she will do so with all the competence that everyone knows she has, but in any case, the social partners will have a large place and - I will even make a proposal - why not a majority within the board of directors of the future merged organization. A strong proposal that truly reflects the government's openness in this matter. Why not also entrust them with the power to appoint the President?

As for the director general, they could be appointed by the government after consulting the board of directors. It turns out that we are arriving at something that resembles a form of balance. You can see that it is not against the social partners that we will work, it is with them, to put the job seeker at the heart of all this.

So what future for the agents? Everyone has concerns and should be able to express them. The agents who are already employed by ANPE and UNEDIC will retain their current status, their commitment. Furthermore, a common status will be created for new recruits, a status that existing agents can choose to adopt. If you want to keep your status, you keep it. If you want to choose to move to the new common status? Obviously, those we will hire in the new organization will not be told, "you choose either the ANPE status or the UNEDIC status," we will give them a new status. But current agents will either keep theirs, if they wish, or choose the new one.

For me, the goal is above all to be more efficient and more responsive in the service offered to job seekers. That is the objective. What I wish is for the project to allow for the redeployment of additional resources in service of job seekers. So, what are the next steps? To conclude, Christine LAGARDE has just made proposals regarding the merger project of ANPE and UNEDIC. She has initiated a consultation with all social partners concerning the new architecture of the public employment service. This negotiation will continue. The objective I have set for Christine is that a bill be presented to Parliament by the end of this year, for final adoption at the beginning of next year. We do not have time to wait. It is technical, of course, but I hope I have been as clear as possible about our objectives, the modalities, and the framework. I say this to Ms. Thomas as well as to Mr. Cherpy, and to all those who are here, I truly believe that, on these bases, we should be able to find a consensus on a merger that has been under discussion for twenty years. So that job seekers can say, Mr. Betayeb, I arrive and I have a single contact with whom I can discuss my issues regarding compensation, my training issues, my placement issues. Another element, I did not mention it, but I say it to Ms. Jaillet, I believe that for a civil servant, the question of mobility is an essential question. I tell you things as I think them, because life is made of changes and the larger the organization, the more opportunities there are to find other jobs, other professions, other opportunities if the spouse moves, in order to have a more fulfilling professional life. The French administrative reality is: you are at the DGI, you do not have the right to move to the CP. For the quality of life of agents, the new merged organization means that you will be able to choose other jobs, you will have a versatility that will increase the interest of your work. I think it is interesting to open up to others, to other responsibilities, to another culture, and that when the ups and downs of life mean that you have to move, it happens, well it is easier to find a job in a merged and larger organization than in a vertical organization with a smaller base. I believe that, for job seekers, it will be a plus, for agents it will be a plus, for social partners with the proposals we are putting on the table with Christine, it will be a plus. And, once again, this is what has happened in all the countries that have better results than we do. You know, we did not invent the wheel. We are not looking for ideas that do not work. I want ideas that work. When I see that it works for others, I think, well, if they did that, they may have thought it through, why should we do the opposite? It is not to copy, although copying when it works is better than being inspired by what does not work. And I tell the agents, I do not want them to take it as a lack of trust, it is rather to give them the means to be more effective, because the dedication of the agents of ANPE as well as of ASSEDIC is not in question, quite the contrary. For years they have been a bit alone on the front line, trying to place people who had a lot of trouble finding their way. They did it with a great deal of skill and humanity. We will give them the structural, financial, and administrative means to be more effective.

In any case, and I will conclude with this, when I was elected four and a half months ago, I was not elected to guarantee systems that were functioning poorly, but to change them to be more effective. That is indeed what is expected of me. I am not expected to comment on difficulties, but to try to provide solutions to these difficulties. If it were working well, I do not see why we would be dealing with it, but when I look at the statements of various people, everyone says there are difficulties. Well, let’s go for it.

So that agencies like this one are not exceptions but rather the vanguard of what needs to be done.

In service, across from you, you have the same job seekers. I add, it is anecdotal but still, that this will also allow for more significant follow-up for the tiny minority who, in reality, are not looking. It is still a problem. We can have a generous social system only if there is no fraud. And fraud exists. If the one who provides compensation is not the one who does the job search, how do we connect all this? And you can see it well, a lot of job seekers who are desperately searching, who are exasperated to be associated with the few who do not. I have asked, Ms. THOMAS knows well, the social partners to define a valid job offer. I recognize that this is difficult, but we must do it. What is a valid job offer? Let them tell me it is difficult, but if we do not address it, if we do not think about it, and if we do not work on it, there is little chance we will find it. I told the social partners, "define the valid job offer." What is it? And after two refusals of a valid job offer, there must be a sanction. I also told the social partners to think about sanctions. This is the system that Christine and I are trying to implement. I think it is reasonable, I think it is understandable by everyone, and I wanted to illustrate it this way by coming to you. And, Ms. THOMAS can say it, there were many initial reservations. Ms. CHAMOULAUD, there are concerns, I say this to Mr. SAINT PHILIPPOT as well, that there are questions that arise. If I were at ANPE or ASSEDIC, and someone told me: "I want to change the organization," I would have questions. It is never pleasant, I understand that perfectly, that is why I am here. But I truly believe that with the work we are doing, the discussions we are engaging in, this should alleviate fears. When I propose a board of directors where social partners can be in the majority, and that they designate the President, it is a strong testimony of openness. I say: the reasonable job offer, it is you who define it, social partners, it is your job. However, it is not the job of the unions to impose sanctions. I have always said this, Ms. THOMAS, I have always been consistent in this regard, but someone has to do that work. You know, I do not have a double language, I have only one. I deeply believe that what we are doing is right. At the same time, you have seen, I told Christine that there are margins for maneuver. Of course, there is room for negotiation, and I had met with the leaders of the confederated trade unions to tell them what I want to do. Some were in favor, others were against, but I have truly kept the commitments that were made. Now, we have until the end of the year. We are drafting a law, so we are discussing with you. We draft a text, we have it voted, and at the beginning of next year, we go for it. Because even the employment houses - it is something that I am passionate about, the employment houses - it was good, but if it is for the service of the employment house, the service of ANPE, the services of ASSEDIC... There are three levels, instead of having three places. If it is a good idea, where everyone is, we just need to merge. Let’s go all the way, that is what Mr. TESTARD said: it is a step. I do not want to drag him into this, poor thing. Let’s go all the way instead of staying here, in limbo, and in the end, job seekers will have more advisors. Obviously, by combining our forces, we maximize the people.

There are still other things to say. For me, the problem is not to have an appointment in fifteen days. What is very important is that this appointment has meaning. Simply, I sometimes hear: "We need to reduce the waiting time from so long to so long." No, of course, the first appointment must take place quickly. That is certain, no need to invent it, but the content of the appointment is also important. That is what you said, Ms. FERARO, but I also want us to be demanding in this first contact. And at the same time, that the agencies know that if there are fraudsters, we will not hesitate to take our responsibilities.

Thank you all, you understand, for Christine LAGARDE as well as for the government and for me, this is an absolutely essential project. It is not a small matter. I also tell the agents of ANPE as well as ASSEDIC, that they see this as a recognition of their work. If it were not important, I would not commit myself so deeply to the service of this project. For once, we are putting them at the heart, at the center of an employment policy, as assets and not as excuses, not as mere supporters. We are fighting to reduce unemployment sustainably in our country and we are doing it this way. Thank you all, and I also tell the elected officials that it is important for me to involve them in this, because it is a mobilization of everyone. I imagine, Jean-Patrick, that if it had not been for your commitment for me to come here, this would not have happened. Thank you all.