Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the reform of local authorities, in Paris on March 5, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

5 March 2009 · Statement on the reform of local authorities · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a committee on local authority reform in Paris on March 5, 2009, presenting his response to their proposals for modernizing France's territorial organization.
Main themes
Reform of local authorities, territorial organization, decentralization, local democracy, distribution of competencies, local resources, constitutional constraints, elected officials, French identity and territory, Grand Paris, regions and departments, modernization of governance
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,224
62nd percentile
Sentences
82
53rd percentile
Readability
26
10th percentile
Grade
16.0
84th percentile
Syntax
3.32
84th percentile
Vocabulary
2.38
87th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 72%72%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Economic 9%9%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

82 sentences in 39 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Committee for the Reform of Local Authorities,

Prime Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers,

Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The task that I entrusted to you, along with the Government, on October 22 last was not an easy one; we all knew this when we embarked on this exercise, otherwise we would not have deemed it necessary to mobilize personalities of your caliber.

The work of modernizing our territorial organization is difficult, first and foremost because of its very subject matter and the complexity of the issues involved. The structures of local authorities, the distribution of their competencies, the determination of their resources—everything is complicated and everything is interconnected; your report demonstrates this perfectly. I would add, but you know this better than I do, that the constitutional constraints framing the discussion are heavy: a "decisive share" of own resources, the prohibition of one authority overseeing another, the notion of free administration, the constitutional recognition of municipalities, departments, and regions... all these elements significantly complicate any modification of the overall architecture.

The reform is also difficult due to the number and power of the interests at stake, and the conservatisms or habits they generate. It is not an insult to our elected officials to note that each is attached, with perfect good faith, to their level of representation, which they measure daily in terms of its utility and specificity. The whole question is how to take a step back to assess the overall effectiveness of the system and improve it, without denying these realities.

The attachment of many elected officials to the current structures echoes, why hide it, the ambivalence of the aspirations of the French themselves. The French value proximity and adaptation to local realities, while denouncing the waste generated by the layering of structures; the French who favor local democracy, but whose passion for equality limits their real taste for decentralization; the French who define part of their identity in relation to territories, but who are also aware that France is not simply the sum of those territories.

The last difficulty, the last challenge I should say, specific to your work: I wanted, Mr. President, and you fully agreed with me on this point, that personalities from diverse backgrounds, including politically, participate in your reflection. I sincerely and warmly thank Pierre Mauroy and André Vallini for agreeing to participate in this endeavor and for accompanying it to its conclusion, even as they faced contrary pressures. The Republic is honored to count among its servants personalities capable of rising above their partisan affiliations, and this remark applies to all those present here who have loyally participated in this work.

Thanks to your President, who has conducted the debates with the rigor and impartiality we know him for, you have contributed your input with perfect clarity, each member of the committee having been able, if they wished, to share their personal observations or points of disagreement in the report itself.

Of course, you will tell me, you could not agree on everything. Of course, it would serve no purpose to hide it, your divergences concern some of the important elements of the report, such as the Grand Paris or the rapprochement between regions and departments. However, this diversity was a chance, or rather an imperative. Even when you did not agree on a proposal, your internal discussions allowed for a deeper reflection and ultimately better illuminated the public authorities on the issues at stake. And in the end, I note that sixteen out of twenty proposals garnered consensus among you.

For my part, I do not intend to shirk my responsibilities. I deeply believe in this reform for a simple reason: it is essential for the country, and the French are waiting for it. I therefore wish for it to come to fruition.

Our local authorities and their 450,000 volunteers are an invaluable asset for the country. The State cannot solve all problems alone. It needs local democracy to respond to the aspirations of identity, proximity, quality of life, and social cohesion of the French; it needs dynamic local authorities to distribute the economic development of the country in a balanced manner across the territory, respecting its size and diversity.

As Gérard Longuet wrote in his personal observations, "France is a collective project that is not simply the sum of the projects of the territories that compose it. But conversely, it is from the mobilization of local forces that the energy of our country derives." Everyone knows what the history of our country owes to its former regions, provinces, duchies, and other counties, and it is the great merit of decentralization, your great work Mr. Mauroy, that it has allowed these energies to live fully once again.

That is why, now more than ever in these times of crisis, as we see with the recovery plan, it is essential to modernize our local organization, so that it is more effective, more responsive, more democratic, stronger, and correspondingly less complex, less costly, less burdensome. This is what the country needs, and this is what the French want, as everyone has noted the strong support for most of the proposed measures. This is how we will remain true to decentralization.

To this end, far from simplistic postures that consist, for example, of proposing to eliminate a level of local authorities, your committee has made ambitious proposals. They essentially involve:

- confirming the role of municipalities as the basic level of our organization and our local democracy—for this reason invested, but they alone, with a general competence clause—and responding to the need for proximity and identity;

- completing the intercommunal map, as it no longer makes sense for a municipality to manage certain local services alone, and simplifying it considerably by ceasing to create "pays" and organizing the merger, whenever possible, of thousands of intermunicipal syndicates (SIVOM and SIVU) into communities of municipalities, agglomerations, or urban communities. You also propose to encourage the transformation of intercommunalities into full-fledged municipalities;

- encouraging—on a voluntary basis—the merger of departments and regions, as our administrative division, inherited from history, sometimes overlooks certain synergies, and especially some of our regions are clearly too small to carry the dynamic economic policies we need. It is regrettable that this proposal, respectful of democracy and forward-looking, has been so distorted;

- bringing departments and regions closer together by endowing them with the same advisors, which is the best means, and moreover the only one, to rationalize the distribution of competencies, to avoid everyone dealing with everything, to have more coherent policies, and to save on expenditures. In this regard, I want to say that I am in favor of abolishing the general competence clause for departments and regions, the only way to put an end to cross-financing and the entanglement of interventions; but conversely, we must go to the end of the competencies recognized for these authorities, and the State must stop interfering and eliminate all administrative services that duplicate those of the authorities;

- finally, in large urban areas, uniting existing authorities into a single authority, the metropolis, endowed with all the municipal, intermunicipal, and departmental competencies necessary for a coherent handling of the major issues of urban life, particularly housing, transport, and social policy. These metropolises are also essential for structuring the economic life of our country in a balanced manner, complementary to Île-de-France, and in connection with other major European cities that surround us.

On all these points, a wide consultation has already taken place, thanks to the numerous hearings you have conducted, particularly with associations of elected officials; also thanks to the involvement, very early on, of parliamentarians who have fully embraced this spirit of reform and who, in large numbers, have worked and continue to work on the subject. This is the case in the majority, and I particularly want to pay tribute to the valuable role played by Dominique Perben and Jean-Patrick Courtois in ensuring the good coordination of these efforts; but it is also the case for the opposition, which participates in the information mission set up in the Senate by President Larcher.

This consultation must not be interrupted.

Some consensual proposals need to be clarified regarding their modalities. The process of electing future common advisors for departments and regions must be the subject of further work, and the timetable must be discussed with all political formations. I wish for the consultation on the direct universal suffrage election of the deliberative bodies of EPCI with their own taxation to continue, which raises many questions in my view. As for the proposals that are contentious, we must naturally make every effort to convince and broaden the conditions for consensus.

But it is also necessary to move forward; it is the duty of the government, and to decide is the duty of democracy. That is why, starting today, the consultation must be directed towards the implementation of the proposals.

I therefore ask the Prime Minister, in close connection with Parliament, to prepare a text incorporating your proposals by the summer. It could indeed usefully start from the draft you kindly sent me, Mr. President. Four months is a good timeframe to deepen the consensus and develop, on a complex subject, the necessary legislative text.

Financial questions require specific treatment, particularly because they must be addressed in the finance law. Naturally, however, the institutional reform of local authorities and their financing being closely linked, both processes must proceed at the same pace and in parallel.

I note that between the report of your committee and the current working hypotheses of the government, there are a large number of points of consensus: the abolition of the share of the business tax affecting investments, which your report confirms as economically harmful; the principle of full compensation, to the benefit of local authorities, for the loss of revenue that will result for them—I make this solemn commitment; the financing of this compensation through budgetary allocations and by transferring to local authorities economic taxes, such as the minimum contribution on value added or the tax on insurance contracts, while respecting their financial autonomy; maintaining a fiscal link between territories and businesses; the necessity to limit the accumulation of different powers of rates on the same tax base; the delicate question of updating the property tax bases.

But, in terms of local taxation, when we agree on the principles, we have unfortunately only resolved 20% of the difficulties.

On all these points, the government will therefore work taking your proposals into account and in close liaison with Parliament, for a conclusion also by the summer. The objectives are clear and shared: guaranteeing the financial autonomy of local authorities, more responsibility in the evolution of expenditures, less waste, and the essential modernization of local taxation for the vitality of our economy.

The proposal of your committee for a single assembly in the overseas departments and regions will be examined within the framework of the Estates General.

Finally, there remains, and I know Mr. President that you are very attached to it, as is Prefect Canepa, whom I salute, the question of the Grand Paris.

The diagnosis you present, no one can seriously contest it; I believe that no one among you contests it fundamentally: the governance mode of the dense area of the Paris agglomeration is inadequate to the challenges, and it is imperative to find a closer association of the different decision-making levels.

That said, you indicate yourself in your proposal that this subject calls for specific consultation: a convincing effort must clearly be made with the elected officials in place, without ever losing sight of the concerns of the populations; we must take into account the proposals of Christian Blanc regarding planning and infrastructure, the priority for Île-de-France, as well as the results of the work of architects and urban planners who will present their conclusions in the coming days; we must actually agree on a vision, define a project, before selecting an administrative model. We must therefore give ourselves a little more time, even if I will not accept stagnation.

Advancement or regression of local freedoms? Deepening of decentralization or insidious state control? Renewal of local public action or establishment of constraints? I hear the debate that is opening up, I hear the positions of various parties.

Everyone is free to have their own opinions, but I must admit I am sometimes surprised. Because, quite frankly: who can deny that such reforms would give new life to our local democracy? Who can assert that immobility is preferable? Who can doubt that local elected officials would find new means of action? Who can contest that citizens would more clearly identify responsibilities?

Consolidated local democracy £ encouraged local dynamism £ more effective, more responsive local authorities £ simpler and less costly organization £ better consideration of local specificities £ decentralization will indeed emerge strengthened, because it will ultimately be better loved.

I would like to take this opportunity, Madam and gentlemen members of the committee, to warmly thank you for your remarkable work and your commitment. You will understand that these thanks are particularly directed to your President. By entrusting him with this mission, I knew that it would yield ambitious, innovative proposals, not all easy to implement, but which will once again allow France to stay one step ahead.