Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the reform of vocational training, in Alixan on March 3, 2009.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

3 March 2009 · Presentation of the reform of vocational training · Alixan, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed local officials and business leaders in Alixan, Drôme on March 3, 2009, to present his government's reform of France's vocational training system.
Main themes
Vocational training reform, workforce development, social equality in training access, job security, employee skills development, company competitiveness, sustainable construction jobs, OPCA reform, training fund management, social advancement, lifelong learning
Duration
~24 min
74th percentile
Words
2,890
74th percentile
Sentences
157
82nd percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
2.88
32nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 38%38%
  • Social 30%30%
  • Economic 24%24%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

157 sentences in 56 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, members of Parliament,

Mr. President of the Regional Council,

Mr. President of the General Council,

Mr. Mayor,

Thank you for welcoming me here, in your beautiful department of Drôme. It has been a long time since a President of the Republic visited this place.

The reason I wanted to meet with you today is to present the reform of vocational training that we are currently implementing with Christine LAGARDE and Laurent WAUQUIEZ, thanks to the important agreement that the social partners reached on January 7th. This reform is something I committed to during the presidential campaign.

Why place so much importance on vocational training?

For employees, training is the best form of job security. The ability to develop skills throughout one’s life ensures the ability to maintain a quality job or to find a new one if one loses their job. I would like to share the story of a young woman I met a month ago in Châteauroux, who impressed me with her determination. She is 43 years old and has worked her entire life in garment manufacturing. She was laid off due to economic reasons, and it is fair to say that it is not easy to find work in garment manufacturing. Well, instead of giving up, she pursued training in industrial metalworking and found a permanent job in this new sector. For me, this is the symbol of what vocational training can provide: better security and the possibility of a fresh start.

Vocational training is also a guarantee of social advancement, ensuring the ability to progress within one’s company or to access another job that is more rewarding and better paid. Not everyone has a university degree. Not everyone has attended Polytechnique, ENA, or HEC. There is no shame in starting at the bottom of the ladder. The tragedy, however, is to think that one has no other perspective than to remain there for their entire life.

Finally, vocational training is about the competitiveness of our companies. I am addressing the business leaders present in the room. You know well that your main asset is the men and women in your company. If you do not invest in them, if you do not give them a chance, how do you expect to develop, innovate, remain competitive, and win new markets? I just visited the Néopolis center a few kilometers from here, which trains people for sustainable construction jobs. It is a very nice center that teaches young people, employees, and job seekers how to build more energy-efficient, environmentally friendly, and effective buildings. In short, these are training programs focused on the future and in-demand jobs, in the common interest of both employees and companies, who also benefit from them.

Why reform vocational training? Because while we allocate a total of 27 billion euros each year to it, the French system suffers from real shortcomings.

First, the inequalities in access to training are glaring. In fact, the current systems often work in reverse:

- First inequality, the less qualified you are, the less you benefit from vocational training: if you are a manager, you have a one in two chance of accessing it, but only one in seven if you are a worker.

- Second inequality, the smaller your company, the less you benefit from training: an employee in a company with fewer than 10 employees has five times less chance of receiving training than an employee in a company with more than 500 employees.

- Third inequality, if you are unemployed, you have less access to training than if you have a job: 75% of training requests from unemployed individuals do not lead to any training.

- And I am not even mentioning the inequalities based on age, because once you are over 45, you have even less opportunity to train.

Honestly, who can say that this is effective, who can say that this is fair?

The second problem: our training system is unjust. Small businesses pay to train employees of large companies. Thus, nearly 30% of companies, mainly very small enterprises, only finance training without sending their employees to training.

The third problem: the collection of vocational training funds is complex, and its management costs are too high. There are about a hundred approved joint collecting organizations, known as OPCA. It is a compartmentalized system that operates too much on a professional branch logic, while many jobs today are in sales, marketing, human resources, etc., which do not depend on a specific sector. It is a system that does not encourage enough competition in the choice of training providers.

The fourth problem is that information, guidance, and advice for individuals and companies, especially for the smallest ones, are insufficient. In France, there are 45,000 training organizations that prepare for more than 15,000 titles and diplomas. It is an inextricable maze.

Understand me well, this is not about tearing everything down, but about conducting an ambitious reform around five simple objectives:

- Better direct vocational training funds to those who need them most, namely job seekers and low-skilled employees.

- Develop training in small and medium-sized enterprises.

- Integrate young people into the labor market by building on what works, particularly apprenticeship training.

- Improve transparency and funding channels and better evaluate vocational training policies.

- And finally, which is essential in current times, simplify, better inform, better guide, and support employees and job seekers. They should be at the heart of the system instead of suffering from its complexity.

We have defined these objectives collectively. Indeed, at my request, the government established a working group at the beginning of 2008 that brought together the relevant stakeholders, namely the State, the regions, and the social partners, to jointly determine the reform pathways. I would like to pay tribute to the work of this group led by Pierre FERRACCI.

It is indeed based on its conclusions that the government was able to send an orientation document to the regions and social partners at the end of July, proposing the main axes of the reform and inviting the social partners to open negotiations.

Unions and employers reached an agreement on January 7, 2009. And this agreement should be signed unanimously. Its conclusion illustrates the richness of social dialogue since May 2007. Over the past three months, social partners have concluded essential agreements. On vocational training, as I mentioned, but also on unemployment insurance, the personalized redeployment agreement, which allows for support for employees laid off for economic reasons, partial unemployment, and the forward-looking management of jobs and skills. These agreements are negotiated solutions that are provided to employees and companies. And in the harsh economic crisis we are experiencing, it is clear that social dialogue is more necessary than ever.

I reiterated this to the unions and employers when I received them at the Élysée on February 18th. They have their convictions, I have mine. And I fully understand that their role is also to express, if not organize, discontent. But we must never lose sight of the fact that we need to work together to find solutions in the interest of all French people, especially during this period. The agreement that has been reached on vocational training is an excellent illustration of this, and it is now up to the law to give substance to the reform.

I hope that this bill will be submitted to Parliament before mid-April. Until then, I ask Christine LAGARDE and Laurent WAUQUIEZ to continue the consultation on this project with the signatories of the agreement, but also with the regions and, of course, with the parliamentarians. The national representation has always been very involved in vocational training issues, and I want to commend its high-quality work, particularly the report by Jean-Claude CARLE and Bernard SEILLIER (2007), that of Françoise GUÉGOT (2008), and also the one currently being worked on by Jean-Paul ANCIAUX and Claude GOASGUEN. I believe that certain topics lend themselves well to preliminary work with Parliament, such as the oversight of vocational training, simplification, evaluation, and regulation of the training offer.

What does the reform consist of?

The first axis is that the social partners have planned the creation of a fund for securing professional pathways. The objective of this fund is to train job seekers and low-skilled employees, particularly those from the smallest companies. This fund, funded by a portion of employers' mandatory contributions to training, will be endowed with 900 million euros. It will train 500,000 low-skilled employees and 200,000 job seekers each year, meaning those who have so far been excluded from training.

But there needs to be clear governance and good coordination of training and employment policies. As the principle is provided for in the January 7 agreement, the fund's intervention priorities will be set contractually between the State and the social partners and relayed at the regional level.

The second axis is to make funding channels more efficient. We need OPCA with a larger financial base and organized by major sectors of activity, which will allow for economies of scale, better management of collected funds, and professional mobility. I favor raising the minimum collection threshold to 100 million euros. But all this will not happen overnight. A two-year period will be given to OPCA to prepare for their reorganization. After this period, it would be desirable to have ten or fifteen OPCA, instead of the hundred that currently exist. There also needs to be more transparency. The law will therefore provide that OPCA can be audited every three years.

The third axis is the simplification and improvement of training tools.

I am thinking, for example, of the individual training leave. It allows any worker to follow a training course on their initiative, independently of the training courses included in the company's training plan. This leave can last up to a year and allows, if desired, to prepare for and take exams. I want this tool to be fully utilized and expanded, for example, to fund evening classes.

I am also thinking of the individual training right. The social partners created it in 2004. It is 20 hours per year. But nothing was provided in case of termination of the employment contract, and this right was generally lost with dismissal. To remedy this, the social partners have provided that this right can be used during the two years following the termination of the employment contract. In practical terms, an employee who is laid off and has accumulated 100 hours under the individual training right with their former employer—which represents about the equivalent of 1,000 euros—can ask their Pôle emploi advisor to use this right to finance training.

The social partners have also agreed on other advances in their agreement, which the law will seek to incorporate. This includes the simplification of the training plan, the creation of a professional progress assessment, the generalization of the training passport, the development of the validation of acquired experience, and professionalization contracts. All these tools are good tools, serving both employees and companies.

But as I said, knowing about existing training, finding the right one, obtaining it, and securing the corresponding funding is too often an obstacle course.

That is why the fourth axis of the bill is to create a right to information and guidance.

We have a myriad of places where one can get information and meet an advisor: local missions, Pôle emploi, information and orientation centers, chambers of trades, career centers. We will bring coherence to all this by labeling the organizations that participate in professional guidance.

Why not imagine a dedicated call center and an internet portal to explain the systems, catalog the training offers, and direct individuals to the appropriate contacts?

Finally, as provided for by the agreement between the social partners, we will expand the missions of OPCA, particularly in favor of very small and small businesses, so that they know how to send their employees to training and guide them towards suitable training. The OPACIF, which manages individual training leave, will do the same for employees' personal projects and for job seekers, in connection with Pôle emploi.

There are still important topics in the field of consultation to finalize the bill. Discussions are ongoing between the social partners and Christine LAGARDE and Laurent WAUQUIEZ to examine whether we can go further to develop training in very small and small businesses or to strengthen training that has real content in terms of qualification or that allows access to a diploma.

A consultation is also underway with the Association of Regions of France and the regions. It should conclude in the coming days. Vocational training has been one of the first areas of decentralization. The transfer from the State has occurred gradually: apprenticeship in 1983, vocational training for young people in 1993, and for job seekers in 2004. I hear that we should go further. Before going further, it is time and high time to ask the question of results, of the evaluation of these regional policies and of equity between territories. Proposals will be put on the table to make progress in all these areas.

I am also told that we need to clarify responsibilities: the State handles employment, the region handles training for job seekers and young people, and social partners handle training for employees... These arguments actually only reinforce compartmentalization.

It is neither illegitimate nor abnormal for the State, social partners, and regions to all intervene in the field of vocational training. However, it is not normal that the dialogue is so poorly constructed among all these actors. We must be capable, especially in this time of crisis, of building a collective response to the needs in the territories: the evolution of the training offer map, the anticipation of new jobs. I believe it would be useful for regional development plans for training to no longer be the sole document of the regional council but to be partially contracted with the State and for social partners to be involved in its development.

The reform I have just described is structural. It will allow us to modernize our vocational training system deeply and sustainably. However, some changes will take a bit of time. Yet, in the face of the economic crisis, we are racing against the clock. Our responses must be quick and commensurate with the situation.

That is why we are going to create a social investment fund. We agreed on the principle of this fund during the meeting I held on February 18 with social partners, and I ask the Ministers to finalize a draft founding charter to be submitted to the unions and employers as soon as possible. This fund represents a strong commitment from the State, trade union organizations, and employers to invest massively and quickly in policies that promote skills adaptation, retraining, and return to employment. With a budget of 2.5 to 3 billion euros, more than half of which will be provided by the State, this fund will not only support the men and women affected by the crisis but also prepare for the future by getting ready for the jobs of tomorrow.

Of course, each actor will retain full responsibility for their funding. The social investment fund will be a tool for pooling and coordination. It will be managed by a unit that will include the State and social partners.

What will this fund do? Well, for example, it will finance the use of partial activity, which is always preferable to economic layoffs, and it will help improve the incomes of affected employees while also offering them training to prepare for the future. This fund will also finance a 500-euro bonus for precarious employees who have not acquired enough rights to unemployment insurance to be compensated. It will strengthen support for employees facing economic layoffs, through the professional transition contract and the personalized redeployment agreement. It will also contribute to the training of job seekers and maintain their compensation when unemployed individuals participate in long training programs. For all the actions that will allow us to support employees during this crisis and prepare for the future, the social investment fund will be there.

Furthermore, we have with the AFPA a national adult vocational training organization, the largest in Europe. It trains 200,000 people each year on its own.

Certainly, the AFPA must evolve. The State will support it so that it has the means for its development in a competitive framework, particularly by managing its real estate assets. In return, I ask the AFPA to intensify its efforts in favor of job seekers, low-skilled employees, and employees in professional retraining. I say this to the social partners, regional councils, and Pôle Emploi; they must mobilize this instrument.

All actors in vocational training must step up. The State, social partners, and regions. In the face of the crisis, there are two possible behaviors: to stay in one's own corner hoping that it will pass on its own or, on the contrary, to work together to provide concrete solutions to our fellow citizens who are most affected and to reform deeply to eliminate our handicaps. This is the path we have chosen. It is the most difficult one. The one that confronts all conservatisms. But it is the only one that will allow us to progress and therefore the only one worth pursuing.

Thank you.