Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the reforms undertaken in favor of economic growth, employment, and purchasing power, in Paris on March 5, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

5 March 2008 · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed a Paris audience on March 5, 2008, outlining his government's economic reforms targeting growth, employment, and purchasing power amid global financial turbulence.
Main themes
Economic growth and resilience, employment and job creation, purchasing power, TEPA law and overtime reform, 35-hour workweek liberalization, subprime crisis and global shocks, demand-side vs supply-side policy, rehabilitation of work, euro appreciation and monetary dumping, oil and commodity prices, unemployment reduction, standard of living
Duration
~50 min
94th percentile
Words
5,965
94th percentile
Sentences
316
96th percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
9.3
13th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 69%68%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Institutional 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

316 sentences in 61 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

Allow me to express my confidence in our economy's ability to withstand the shock. Of course, we can regret that our growth was not above 2% in 2007: but let us remember that this growth has resisted better than many doomsayers predicted, even as we faced a quadruple shock, the subprime crisis in the United States and the rise of the euro to unprecedented levels. I believe I was one of the first to draw attention to this oddity: that our companies have already faced environmental dumping, fiscal dumping, and social dumping. And it did not seem absolutely essential to me that, in addition, they should face monetary dumping under perfectly unacceptable conditions.

To this, we add a third shock: the price of oil crossing 100 dollars, and as if that were not enough, the rise in commodity prices. And yet, despite this, in 2007, the French economy created more than 300,000 jobs, real jobs, solvent jobs, market jobs, and 320,000 companies, a record, were created. That was the year 2007. Investment is holding up, and unemployment is falling. We will have figures soon that will show an unprecedented level of decline in unemployment in our country. I am not saying that I am satisfied with the situation. I am saying that in an environment that was not, to say the least, conducive, our economy has demonstrated a capacity for resilience that has been strengthened by the measures adopted since last May to support demand. It is not just me saying this, but the IMF and the European Commission, who have been less than gentle in their judgments about the French economy.

So, of course, we will need to go further. I have committed to achieving 5% unemployment by 2012, to catching up on the growth that we are missing.

And to meet these objectives, to achieve them, I have four priorities.

The first: I want to put work back at the heart of our public policies, because without work, there will be no improvement in the standard of living for the French, and without work, there will be no full employment.

And I would like to tell you that when I asked Madame Christine LAGARDE, who did it remarkably, to present the TEPA law this summer, there were countless comments indicating: but what is the French President thinking, everything is fine. July. Why support demand, there is no problem - July. And a great debate at that time, to determine whether it was appropriate to pursue a demand-side policy or a supply-side policy. I would need someone to explain to me the differences and the interest of this theological debate. It was in July. The subprime crisis arrived at the beginning of August, and from the beginning of August, the global economic and financial context turned.

And those same people who reproached us for having initiated, before the crisis, the powerful factor represented by the TEPA law, are now asking me to take measures in favor of purchasing power and therefore of demand policy. Those same people who believed that in July, it was appropriate to pursue a supply-side policy, are surprised that in February-March, we are not pursuing a demand-side policy.

Dear Michel DIDIER, for whom I have friendship and respect, you agree that when it comes to specialists, it is better to precede them than to follow them. I also add that since then, the United States of America has shown the way by doing the same thing as France with just an eight-month delay. What would we have heard if I had not done it? And what did we want to do with this? We wanted to rehabilitate work.

I remember that unbelievable time when, in our country, labor inspectors were sent to the parking lots of your companies to check that executives were not working too much. The extraordinary thing is that we held on.

I also add that I wanted to lighten the straitjacket of the 35-hour workweek, by allowing everyone to negotiate - employers and employees - the number of overtime hours. And in a country where people were told that it was wrong to work more because it took jobs from others - yes, we did find people to say that and they still exist - Notice, what is quite nice is that one can be so wrong and continue to speak. We have completely reversed the logic by exempting overtime from taxes. I do not know if it is demand or supply, what I know is that it is common sense to be able to work more to earn more, and it works.

In the first month, in October, we had 40% of companies with more than 10 employees using it. In the second month, in November, we had 49%, in the third month, in December, we had 55%. Half a million French companies are using tax-exempt overtime. And this translates into a higher standard of living for the French. I know it is very difficult to convince on this subject, but I want to tell the French one thing: that an increase in the standard of living without an increase in work is a lie. There are just under 40% of French employees who have seen their paychecks increase thanks to the overtime law. 40% is not 100%, I know that. But while we are in a country where it was considered that when we increase the minimum wage, we increase purchasing power, I would like to remind you that only 17% of French employees are on the minimum wage. So, when we increase the minimum wage, we leave 83% of French employees behind. With overtime, we have reached 40%, and we are only three months into the results.

I also add that in the meantime, we have made it possible to buy back RTT (reduced working time) and we are pushing French employees to work more. I also add that I will be led to propose strong measures to stop putting people in their fifties into early retirement or unemployment. I tell you this as I think, I will take my responsibilities, but this economic and social sacrifice is no longer acceptable, we do not have enough seniors at work. We do not have enough young people at work. I will challenge all formulas that facilitate the early retirement of people we need to finance our pensions and fund our social protection. Everyone will take their responsibilities, I will naturally take mine, but put yourself in the shoes of the French, we cannot tell them that to pay pensions, they will have to work longer and at the same time, put into retirement or early retirement earlier, men and women who would only want to continue. I say this knowing who I am speaking to, I know that this may pose problems in terms of salary scales, in terms of seniority, but in light of the general interest, it is crucial to increase the amount of work in France. For me, there are two essential issues: the first is the employment of seniors and the second - here too, I will take my responsibilities - is the fact that one can no longer refuse more than two valid job offers if one wants to keep their compensation system. It is a question of justice and it is a question of equity. In the meantime, we have merged the ANPE and the UNEDIC. I also want to pay tribute to our union partners - I am thinking particularly of the CFDT. This merger of ANPE-UNEDIC, we have been talking about it for twenty years, and well, ladies and gentlemen, it is done in nine months, just like the merger between the DGI and public accounting, we have been talking about it for twenty years. There are two socialist ministers who have slightly and momentarily come down from their pedestal, namely Mr. SAUTTER and Mr. CHARASSE on this reform. This reform is done. It is no longer a project, it is a reality. I am fully aware that having a single interlocutor for an unemployed person is essential. Finally, what was this incredible system that made it so that the one who provides compensation is not the one who offers a job? There is a single interlocutor, I have asked the unions to define what a valid offer is, as much as it can be done before the end of March, and from that moment on, I will take and I will ask the government to take its responsibilities. We cannot be in a country where there are 1,900,000 unemployed on one side and 500,000 unfilled job offers on the other, there comes a time when everyone must understand that rights are the counterpart of duties. Unemployed people have the right to compensation, they have the duty to accept a job offer that corresponds to their training or their expected remuneration.

The second priority is really what we have done and it works, we want to invest in the future and free the creative capacities of our companies so that they can grow and prosper.

It is first of all everything we have done for research. Ladies and gentlemen, the research tax credit has been raised to 30%. It is the most advantageous research support system in the world. We have tripled it, we will see the results in 2009, but already a number of companies, I am thinking of Thales for navigation systems, have indicated that while they wanted to relocate their research services to dollar zones, since naturally it is becoming complicated to manufacture in the euro zone and sell in the dollar zone. For anyone who wants to think about economic and monetary issues - naturally if one does not want to think about it, one does not think about it - the French research tax credit is the most powerful lever in the world to support investment in the research of our companies.

In nine months, we have given autonomy to all universities in France, ladies and gentlemen, how long have we been talking about the autonomy of universities? We talked about it, and the graveyard of Ministers of Universities and National Education who have talked about autonomy is filled with all those who were convinced that it had to be done and who could not do it. It is done. All French universities benefit from autonomy. And at the same time, the governance of universities has been changed. There was a President who could decide nothing, this governance has been changed. And we are going to invest 20 billion euros in our universities to have the best universities in the world. It is done.

I saw that I was accused of wanting to change the organization of research in France, that is true, no need to insist, I admit it right away. I want to bring universities closer to research, I want to give more means to researchers.

I want to put an end to this oddity that our best researchers, the youngest, are poached by others because they are paid three times more elsewhere. And this unbelievable system, where an old tattered status means that our best researchers are too old to seek work with us and young enough to be paid handsomely by others, if one thinks that there is nothing to be done, it is that one does not have the same vision of French research.

And I was very happy to see that there were only 200 people in the street yesterday. And this proves that researchers have perfectly understood that they are a priority for us, but I have also said and I will hold: more money and reform. No reform, no more public money. These two go hand in hand, because I was not elected to provide the bottomless pit: always more money, always fewer reforms. Public money and reform in the service of efficiency. I also fully assume the idea that everyone must be evaluated. And that we owe accounts to the French.

I add that the law for the modernization of the economy, on which Christine LAGARDE, Luc CHATEL, and Hervé NOVELLI are working, will be defended in the spring. It will address a number of major issues, we will have the opportunity to talk about it again.

Finally, the third priority: restore seriousness in the management of the State's finances. Listen, I am willing to be responsible for many things, but it has been 30 years since France has presented a budget in deficit. I look, I listen, I hear advice from all sides. You know this proverb: "when I self-examine, I worry, when I compare, I sometimes reassure myself." There is no other way than that of controlling public spending, understand reducing the weight of public spending on our economy. It is not a question of ideology, how to lighten the burden? How to lighten taxation without controlling and reducing our spending? I have seen that again, I am being prosecuted for not having adhered to the non-replacement of one out of two retirements. I explain myself very well. I have looked at the budgets over the last 20 years. No government, whether left or right, has dared to go beyond the non-replacement of 10,000 retirements. Over the last 20 years. What have we done this year? We have not replaced 23,000 retirements. It is certainly insufficient, but it is still a little more than double what the most courageous have done. This does not put me in a position to say that everything is fine, but it puts a number of people in a position of discretion regarding their assessment of this policy.

But I will go further in front of you. If we had wanted to replace one out of every two departures, it would have required between 33,000 and 34,000 non-replacements. Why did I not want that? For a very simple reason: I was elected in May, I obtained a legislative majority in June, we voted on the amending finance law in the summer, so all of this had to be done mid-year, meaning I had to do this even while the reforms had not yet produced their effects, because naturally, it is not about making cuts, it is about reforming to reduce. If you do not reform and you reduce, you create gaps, you cause fragmentation. But naturally, I will meet the objectives, not at all in an ideological spirit but simply because it makes sense. I add that we will continue to involve civil servants in productivity gains and that we will redistribute 50% of the productivity gains in the form of purchasing power. 50% for civil servants, fewer in number, better paid. 50% for reducing France's deficit. It seems to me that this is a fair policy.

Finally, the fourth economic priority for us is solidarity, responsibility on such heavy issues: retirement, health, dependency, hospitals. Once again, Ladies and Gentlemen, I would have been very happy not to find all these issues on my desk. It is said that I want everything, no! Honestly, if the issue of special retirement schemes had been addressed earlier, it would have been excellent news. I observe that the reform of special retirement schemes could not have been that easy since either they did not want to do it, or when they did, they backed down. And nine months later, I stand before you, I have withdrawn no text. We have not backed down on any subject and the reform of special retirement schemes was completed after 9 days of general strike that we endured.

I add, to be perfectly understood, that I want to pay tribute to the union partners, including those who do not share my convictions of course, because when there is a crisis and difficulty, one is very happy to find courageous people, with certainly different opinions but with whom you can dialogue and avoid either the sabotage of public facilities or confrontations. From this point of view, I must say, we discussed with FO, with the CFDT, with the CGT, often in a tough manner, but in a loyal way and allow me to say, responsibly. It is one thing not to agree and they did not agree. I can understand them. It is another to be irresponsible. And as for the railway workers, the gas workers, the electricians, the RATP agents, I fully understand their discontent. It was still a matter of asking them to go from 37 years of contributions to 40! That is no small matter, it was fair, it was equitable, but it was an effort.

Ladies and Gentlemen, I promised it during the campaign, I did it. It seems to me that the French economy has, it seems, not suffered too much from it. And so we will continue in 2008.

We must carry out the reform of hospitals. Hospitals account for 50% of health insurance expenditures. Health insurance has a deficit of six billion. I have looked with great interest at the plans of the last twenty years. There is a major absentee, it is the hospital. So it is not surprising that deficits have continued since we take a supposed price, and do not touch 50% of expenditures. This obviously harms the effectiveness of the strategy.

I have even taken heavy responsibilities. With this story of Alzheimer’s, dreadful! Nearly one million French people are affected by Alzheimer’s. There will be cases in every family in France. 250,000 new cases each year. People who develop Alzheimer’s at 50 or younger, something had to be done! We know nothing about this disease. We needed to invest money. I decided that we would invest one billion five hundred million for a plan that has been unanimously recognized as coherent and, I hope, effective. But, Ladies and Gentlemen, there is a difference with the plan I announced and what has happened in the past. It is that I announced the expenditures and the revenues. I took on the choice of the medical co-payment to put this new money to the service of the fight against Alzheimer’s or to increase the number of beds for those who are in terminal situations and who are nonetheless human beings. I would even say that they are even more human beings who must live knowing that it is over. And so I took on the co-payments because we needed money to implement the Alzheimer’s plan and it seems to me that in doing so I tried to participate in the management of France in a reasonable way. I am told: ah, one should not expose oneself, ah yes, it is easy, but my conception of the role of the President is not one who announces expenditures and forgets revenues. It is one who commits to expenditures but also commits to revenues. It is less easy but it is more honest.

From that moment on, these reforms, we have no choice, we must carry them out. I have also requested and I will carry out the reform of vocational training. Finally, listen, nearly 23 billion euros are committed each year. Who can tell me that the situation today is satisfactory? Ah, it is certain, to do INSEAD when you are a member of an international group and you are already at Bac +22 it is possible! But when you are employed in textiles, in one of our territories in France, and the company closes because the trade is over, and you are 52 years old and need to learn a new trade...

I am not sure that our vocational training system is effective and fair. I want to refocus vocational training funds on our compatriots who must say to themselves, it is not a problem to lose one’s job because society, the State, is there, which will allow me to obtain training to have another job. The tragedy is not losing one’s job, the tragedy is the certainty that having lost one’s job, one cannot find another. That is the logic I want to change in our country. That is it!

And of course, I will also carry out the creation of the fifth risk: the dependency risk. Despite the 800,000 more children each year, a dynamic family policy, the increase in life expectancy means that we will live longer and longer. How will this happen? Who will pay? Who will create the places you will need, one day for yourself and earlier for your parents?

These are not small issues. I was elected to respond, to provide solutions to these major questions that concern medium-sized enterprises as well as all others, because if France does not carry out the reforms, the French economy will not gain the growth point it lacks. And you, business leaders, will not be able to venture into other markets because to venture into European and global markets, one must be assured and strong in one’s national market. Because there is no external conquest that can be built if one does not first feel strong in one’s home market. And I do not know of any company that succeeds magnificently internationally and fails magnificently nationally. It is national success that allows for European conquest or global conquest.

From that moment on, I know you who do not make the headlines of economic newspapers every day, what luck! I withdraw economy, I say the newspapers! You sometimes feel forgotten, what an advantage! And therefore you have a number of specific problems. With Hervé NOVELLI we are well aware of this since I have set myself a goal, to see the emergence of two thousand new companies of five hundred people and more by 2012. I was in Germany two days ago. Our weakness is there! Our weakness is double in a way.

Our large groups are very old. Less than 10% are less than 10 years old, which proves that there are no new ones and our smaller companies have a hard time becoming medium-sized enterprises. That is the heart of our problems.

You have been the origin of several proposals. You continue to be. I would like to say very simply what I think about it. First, it has been a great mistake for French society to turn its back on family capitalism. It has been a great mistake to speak ill of and denounce those of our compatriots who, having means, money, chose to invest it in companies, in factories, in industries. Because when one does not have the chance to have a family entrepreneur or a family shareholder whose name one knows, who has invested his own money, one knows that it is much less convenient to find oneself with a pension fund as an owner whose name one knows only if one knows that it wants returns and that it wants them immediately. Therefore, to turn away from the French economy women and men who wanted to invest in it on the pretext that we hate success was a major strategic error. Because in our departments, we are very happy to have a few families and a few personal entrepreneurs who invest their money to save the company that, without them, would interest no one, and certainly not the pension funds of Scottish widows - against whom I have nothing by the way, but who cannot alone carry the entire French economy.

That is why, and this concerns you very precisely, I had the courage, I believe, to implement the 50% tax shield in 9 months, including CSG. I hear a number of impatiences. Allow me to tell you that since the time I have been hearing this demand, that I see it promised, at least I would have had that. No one will have to promise it anymore since it is done.

I add that I did not hesitate to tackle the issues of ISF, a vast subject. The leaders on the left and the right were unstoppable in salons, at dinners: it must be done, it is obvious, of course, sleep easy, we will do nothing. And they kept their promise regardless of the governments. Allow me to tell you that this has changed since now one can deduct their ISF contribution in very significant proportions if one invests in a company.

I did not want to testify that we should talk about innovative companies because there are enough of them. For me, a company that makes money is necessarily an innovative company. Do not come and tell me, that’s enough, we have already been through this between modern and old economies. The modern economy that said, was one where there were no clients, no buyers, no trades, no products, no distribution networks. Modernity, we raised funds. We saw where that led us, to a speculative bubble that exploded at the same time as those who explained: the future of this economy disappeared into a past from which they will never emerge. We must stop making the distinction between innovative companies. In all sectors, at all sizes, a company is necessarily innovative if it holds its market, if it has clients and if it manages to generate profit. It is not up to the State to say that some are more useful than others. They are all perfectly useful.

You know how much I value industry. But regardless of the sector, this means that all those who pay ISF will be able to invest each year in your company. I see two advantages in this. The first is that it puts money at your disposal. In a country like ours which is very nice, which has one of the most developed banking networks in the world and which I have observed loves to lend money to those who do not need it. -Has that happened to you? Yes, it is true. Me too. I add that this will create a generation of shareholders, that is to say men and women who will invest in a company. I expect a lot from this reform which is extremely useful.

In France, it is much more difficult to grow existing companies than to create them. I believe that we have, more or less, solved the problem of business creation. The figures show it. There are still things to do, but it has progressed enormously. But we have not solved the problem of the growth of these companies.

On the occasion of the merger between OSEO and the Agency for Industrial Innovation, - I did not see what that was doing there, several windows, I wanted only one- We are releasing 300 million euros to finance your medium-sized companies in addition to what is planned.

Thus, we have broken with an innovation policy that exclusively favored large groups or SMEs, because Ivan is right. There was either a policy for TPEs or a policy for large groups and in the middle, medium-sized enterprises were always the forgotten ones.

I asked the European Commission to recognize a category of companies that is intermediate between groups and SMEs, which I mentioned a moment ago. The current community definition of SMEs, limited to 250 employees, leads in a way to equating all companies with more than 250 employees to large groups, excluding medium-sized enterprises from the benefits of policies aimed at supporting them. This is a great misfortune. If you do not create a precise category, you do not create a policy that suits that category because immediately in Bercy they tell you: it costs too much, since everyone is concerned. This is the great advantage of having categories that allow you to target your effort.

In the same way, I wish for companies to be able to retain the benefits of SME status for a limited time, even if one of the criteria is exceeded due to the growth of their turnover, so that we allow them to grow. The goal must be to neutralize the effects of threshold changes that can be a brake on growth!

The entirety of this policy favorable to the development of growth SMEs will constitute a strong priority of the French Presidency of the European Union. I asked Lionel STOLERU, and I thank him, to commit to the "Small Business Act," which is extraordinary. But what American companies can do, why should European companies not have the right to do? I am for competition, I am for openness. But fair competition, not unfair competition. The "Small Business Act" is very important because it will allow medium-sized companies to rely on a French market to conquer foreign markets.

There is of course the issue of business transfers.

This market for transmission/recovery is estimated at 700,000 companies in the next 10 years, across all sizes. I know perfectly well that this is a considerable subject since less than 10% of business transfers in France are family transfers, compared to 58% in Germany, 55% in the Netherlands, and 72% in Italy! If we want to discourage families from investing in business, listen, let’s continue like this!

It is concerning and it is unacceptable.

You know the importance I attach to family capitalism. I told you that a moment ago.

I therefore asked Christine LAGARDE and Hervé NOVELLI, within the framework of the law to modernize the economy this spring, to adopt a number of important measures.

Our taxation regarding transfers must be simple, readable, and stable. Things have been done in recent years, particularly for the increase in the exemption of transfer duties per beneficiary. But we need to go further with a taxation that should not discourage the buyer from taking risks. From my point of view, the least we can do is to allow them to deduct from their income the interest on the loans they have taken out to buy their business. That seems to me to be the basics in this matter.

I also want to reduce the tax cost of buying a business, dear Hervé: is it normal that the buyer has to pay a 5% tax on the value of the business they are buying, even before they have made any profit at all? Today, the applicable tax regime leads to taxing the sales of small businesses, such as SARLs, more heavily, while public limited companies benefit from a more favorable regime. There is no need to put "Equality" on the frontispiece of all our institutions to penalize the SARL compared to the Société Anonyme. I do not think the role of taxation is to produce these legal acrobatics? Hervé, Christine, and I will make very strong proposals. It is pointless to tax a business transfer that is dying. I want to make the French tax authorities understand that it is better to have many transfers that yield less, but that yield more in total, than to prevent the transfer and let businesses die. I admit, this is very complicated, but still, I do not give up on making myself understood, perhaps.

OSEO must be more present to support buyers. I saw the heads of the Caisse des Dépôts yesterday, the President of the Supervisory Board, Deputy Michel BOUVARD, and the Director General. I told them that I would see only advantages in the Caisse des Dépôts behaving like a true French sovereign fund, and that the Caisse des Dépôts should invest, not just in the CAC 40, but also in medium-sized companies, which precisely have the most difficulty finding financing, partners, and shareholders. This will be one of the new directions, at least, that I wish for the Caisse.

Then, ultimately, and to conclude, not everything goes through the law. Ultimately, what am I trying to do? It is to make people love their work again, respect it, and say to themselves: we are not treated the same way if we work hard and if we do nothing.

What I am trying to do is to reconcile the French with success, that those who take a lot of risks are rewarded by earning more money, that is normal, it is just, and it is honest. What is not normal is to be very well paid when one does not take risks. What is not normal is to be very well paid when one has failed. What is normal is when one has wagered their money, wagered their time, and succeeded, that they receive the just reward.

You know, it is not the high salaries that shock me, but high salaries are for great responsibilities. So, when there is a failure, the one who has a great responsibility must assume the consequences; otherwise, there was no reason for them to have a high salary. It is not normal that one is treated the same way when one is on the minimum wage and when one has several million euros in annual remuneration. The level of responsibility and commitment cannot be the same.

Why did I not like golden parachutes? It is not just a question of money; it is a question of principle. Being well paid because one takes great risks, yes. But being well paid with the certainty that one has a parachute at the exit, that is not called taking great risks; it means that the remuneration was not justified. You, the business leaders of medium-sized companies, know perfectly well what I mean.

We will undoubtedly have a difficult debate. I think we need to go much further in terms of profit-sharing and participation; I say this in the clearest and frankest way, a company is the product of the work of all its employees. When I see groups making several billion euros in profits, I rejoice. I rejoice for them, and I rejoice for our country. At the same time, I think it is not unreasonable that not everything goes to the shareholder, and that part goes to the employees. Because the employee has contributed to the creation of wealth in the company. Moreover, it is an element of competitiveness to have employees who say, I work hard, but I too will have the just reward.

The same goes for stock option plans; I find that very good. I simply say that it cannot just be a discussion among members of the same Board of Directors. That more is given to those at the very top is normal, but systematically excluding those at the very bottom is perfectly abnormal.

I have nothing against any specific individual mentioned in the press. But when there is a major disaster in a company, it is not normal that the big boss does not face any consequences, saying the fault is not mine, it is others. That is not my conception of responsibility, that is not my conception of the market economy, that is not the conception of capitalism, that is not the conception of the values that are mine. I want values that are normal. When you work more, you earn more. When you take on more responsibilities, you earn more if you succeed. When you commit, you are valued.

Ladies and gentlemen, we must learn to respect those who succeed and to draw inspiration from them as examples, rather than criticize and hate them. This is how France, which has a long history behind it, can engage with a joyful future. I want to make France a young country, a dynamic country, a country that believes in the future. A country that would not simply tell others, do exactly the opposite of what I do myself. The credibility of the French message is the strength and depth of the reforms we are undertaking; I hope you have understood that.

For me, coming here was a real pleasure. Thank you.