Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the regulation of capitalism, a new international governance, and national identity, in Paris on January 7, 2010.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

7 January 2010 · Paris

Context
Sarkozy addressed the second Symposium on New World and New Capitalism in Paris on January 7, 2010, alongside Portuguese Prime Minister José Sócrates.
Main themes
Regulation of capitalism, new international governance, national identity, post-crisis global economic order, cross-partisan dialogue, European cooperation, refounding political frameworks, tribute to Philippe Séguin, modernization, rejection of ideological divisions
Duration
~34 min
87th percentile
Words
4,123
87th percentile
Sentences
251
93rd percentile
Readability
63
93rd percentile
Grade
8.5
7th percentile
Syntax
2.72
14th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
28th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 39%35%
  • Social 19%17%
  • Geopolitical 14%13%
  • Institutional 14%13%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

251 sentences in 75 paragraphs

Mr. Prime Minister of Portugal, dear José,

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Dear Eric,

Ladies and gentlemen,

Allow me first of all to express my deep sadness at the announcement of the death of Philippe Séguin, First President of the Court of Auditors and former President of the National Assembly.

Philippe Séguin held a central place in our public life for 30 years. He loved ideas, he loved the words that carry them. He defended them passionately and without ever the slightest baseness.

He was born in Tunis. He was the son of a hero who died in combat and a mother who was a schoolteacher. He was the pure product of that Republic of merit that he cherished and which he had placed at the heart of his political thought and action from the very beginning. His love for the Republic was inseparable from his love for France, from his high idea of the State.

Gaullism, with him, retained something alive. The word suited him as a matter of course.

Philippe Séguin had his faults, his weaknesses, his outbursts, but nothing, absolutely nothing of what he said, nothing of what he undertook was mediocre.

He had convictions.

He had a broad perspective.

He had talent.

He was my friend, a very close friend.

We will miss him greatly, and as I speak, I think of his wife, his children, and of course all those who loved him.

I now want to thank Eric Besson for organizing this second session of the Symposium on the new world and new capitalism.

This collective reflection has been initiated at the heart of an unprecedented crisis that heralds the emergence of a new global economic order. This reflection is necessary because everything must be rethought and we need to change our ideas and our behaviors.

I am very happy to be alongside José. He said he was a socialist. I am not, but it turns out that we agree on almost everything. So it is clear that this framework of analysis is no longer suited to the situation. José wants to modernize his country, I want to modernize mine, and when everything seemed to be collapsing, we who are deeply European said to ourselves, "we will not put those on the left on one side and those on the right on the other," but "we will put those who look to the future on one side and those who remain in the past on the other." That is how we made things move, and I am very proud, José, that you are here. For the past two and a half years, I do not recall a point of divergence between us. I do not recall it because the European debate allows us to raise the level a bit compared to national debates that are mired in normal partisan ambitions. José was kind enough to say that it required an open mind to invite him. No! It required an open mind to come. Sectarianism has no place. Why be sectarian with ideas from the last century when we need to invent the ideas of this century? So it is as a friend that I welcome you here, and I share this point of view that is yours. It is not because growth is restarting that we should stop reflecting on the lessons to be learned from what has happened.

When everything changes, when the most reliable reference points fade, when what is most obvious ceases to be so, when it is principles, morality, and representations that are called into question, then we must not only reform, my dear friends, we must refound, and to refound, we cannot do without debate.

We must think together in order to decide together.

There are two categories of people:

- Those who accept to talk, to debate with those who do not share their ideas, their opinions, their beliefs. Moreover, if we only debate among people who agree, the debate will quickly stop. Agree on what? Who can say that things are obvious?

- And then there are those who remain locked in their certainties, their preconceived notions, who prefer to caricature, disqualify, and discredit those who do not agree with them rather than discuss.

José, do you know what would have happened in France at the end of the Second World War if in 1945 every party had not agreed to discuss with the others, if everyone had not agreed to take a step towards the others, if everyone had not agreed to open up to ideas that were not their own? The program of the National Council of Resistance would never have seen the light of day, and we would probably not have known the Glorious Thirty!

What will the world of tomorrow be like? How will Europe, our Europe, find its place in it? How will France maintain its rank? How will we preserve our way of life, our way of thinking, our culture? How will we take into account ideals in the service of a more regulated, fairer, more humane, in short, more civilized world? This is not a matter of left and right. That would be too simple and too caricatural. This concerns 6 billion individuals for the 21st century. We will not solve this problem with the ideologies of the 20th century. These are questions we must answer. Our certainties have shattered, and it would be to misunderstand the deep nature of this crisis to reduce it to a conjunctural accident. This is a first essential point of analysis and debate. From our point of view, the crisis we have experienced is structural; it is not conjunctural.

It is a systemic crisis, the crisis of a globalization, of a finance, of an economy that is insufficiently regulated. And one can be non-socialist and affirm this idea.

Have we already forgotten the gravity of the crisis, have we already forgotten its depth? Have we already forgotten that we avoided the worst only thanks to the absolutely massive intervention of states to prevent collapse? I have the same memory of the Paris Summit, José. Everything was collapsing. And even the central banks were happy to find the states because the markets, the famous markets, no longer believed anyone's word. Except for the states. But I tell you, if the crisis were to restart, the states would no longer be the bulwark they were in the crisis we have just experienced. Because we have used up most of our leeway. And that is why it would be suicidal to stop supporting the recovery.

If we managed to avoid the worst, it is not to go back to how things were before. We do not want things to go back to how they were before. What does that mean?

We do not want any more golden parachutes. I accept high salaries; that does not bother me, but in exchange for a high salary, there must be a high responsibility. If one is guaranteed by a parachute, whether one succeeds or fails, then that is not a high responsibility.

Exorbitant bonuses, put yourself in our place... A year ago, we were asked to intervene to save banks. And I am not specifically talking about French banks, which behaved relatively better than others. A year ago, we were asked to intervene to save banks. Banks that we save with taxpayer money; we had to do it. A year later, we are told, on the other side of the Atlantic, that we must pay bonuses of several billion dollars? Who can understand this and who can accept it? In any case, we will not accept it. And I salute the initiative of the British socialist Prime Minister to tax bonuses with us. But who can accept that? When we make profits with public money, it is normal that these profits are reinvested in equity and not distributed as bonuses.

Moreover, just a year ago, I was told: "But come on, Nicolas, it is impossible to tax those responsible for the crisis." But I do not understand: we easily find the list for bonuses and we find it difficult to find the list for penalties. They should be the same. And we have created in France a system of bonuses and penalties. I thank Christine Lagarde for that. The bonus will be paid over three years. That way, if after a year of profits there are problems, we cut the bonuses that have been paid.

Tax havens, let us think! What is the point, in our countries, in Portugal, in France, elsewhere, of making so-called "prudent" rules, rules for organizing the balance sheet, if at the same time the companies we control in France or Portugal can exempt themselves from any rule by opening subsidiaries in tax havens? It is unacceptable.

Speculation. We want a capitalism of production, not a capitalism of speculation. The extravagant leverage effects, the obsession with short-term profit, and I say it, the monetary disorder that has become unacceptable. We cannot fight, we in Europe, you said it José, to improve the competitiveness of our companies - I say this in front of my friend the Brazilian Foreign Minister, everyone knows the alliance between Brazil and France - we cannot gain competitiveness in our companies in Europe and have a dollar that loses 50% of its value against the euro. Since we manufacture in the euro zone and sell in the dollar zone, it is as if we are giving up selling altogether. I say this in front of Joseph Stiglitz, and you know how close I feel to the United States of America. But it is not possible. The world has become multipolar; the monetary system must be multi-currency. Bretton Woods was in 1945, in the aftermath of the war, in a world where there was one economy: that of the United States, one currency: the dollar, and that is how we organized it. Are we today in the 21st century in the same situation? The answer is no.

A year after the crisis, not everything is resolved, José said. But the progress is considerable. The G20 has been institutionalized, ladies and gentlemen, if the UN system had worked as I wish it would work, we would not have had to create the G20. The G20 is not a power grab. We had to take a place that was not occupied. And as I recognize myself in José Socrates' remarks on the necessity of an economic government for Europe, fundamentally, with the G20, we have created an international economic body. And thanks to the G20, we have been able to move forward. You know very well that I have always thought that the G8 was becoming ridiculous. To leave aside the G5, the G8 inviting, at the end of three days of debates, 5 small countries: China, India, South Africa, and a few others, Mexico, Brazil, to come and debate with us. Who can think that we can settle the world's affairs without Brazil and without India? It is not just unfair; it is absurd. Who can think that we can settle the world's affairs without a single African country? It is shocking that it took so long to reach this result. But today we at least have the G20.

I do not share the analysis of all those who spoke about Copenhagen, where I was with José.

Copenhagen is an incomplete revolution, but it is the beginning of a revolution.

The judgment on Kyoto was unanimous. But Kyoto is 35 countries committing. Copenhagen is 192 countries committing. And if we had not ratified the Copenhagen agreement, we would have left the United States and China outside of any rules. So it is progressing.

Of course, there are questions that have not been resolved. The World Environment Organization, the carbon tax at the borders, but, José, I hope that with your support, we will obtain in Europe a carbon tax at the borders of Europe. Because I will not be one of those who will accept that we impose strong and justified environmental constraints on our industrialists while continuing to import into Europe products made by countries that do not respect any environmental rules. It is profoundly unjust! This is a point we are discussing with my Brazilian friends and President Lula - for whom, you know, I have much admiration and friendship. I am against protectionism, for free trade, but fair trade! Listen, if we impose taxes and constraints on our steel manufacturers, on our steel industry, while continuing to bring in steel from China, and if China does not apply the same environmental rules as we do, first we will not protect the planet, and secondly, we will create unemployment in Europe. That is not the goal.

I said it at the ILO and at the United Nations General Assembly, France wishes for the major emerging countries to be associated with global governance. But when are we finally going to put the reform of the United Nations Security Council on the table! What are we waiting for? We are in 2010, it has been 10 years since we entered the 21st century, it is perhaps time to equip ourselves with the institutions of the 21st century and not those of the 20th! And everyone knows that the solutions are easy: we need to implement a provisional reform. No permanent African member on the Security Council, with 1 billion inhabitants, India is not a permanent member, not a single permanent member from the South American continent, wiped off the map! Finally, who can think that this can hold? Who can think that this is simply reasonable? We must therefore expand the number of members of the Security Council, the permanent members, and have the wisdom to think that each continent will have its own organizational rules to define those who will represent them within the Security Council. For some, it will be election, for others, it will be a rotating system, for others, there may be a usual ticket. For example, for Asia, I would be surprised if one could say that one represents Asia without having China and India. But, for goodness' sake, let us decide! What are we waiting for? To be in the 22nd century? For nothing to happen at the UN? It is now that we must decide, and 2010 is the year in which we must make decisions.

I add that we cannot claim to govern the world solely based on the laws of commerce. That is a mistake. Everything must be done to prevent the return of protectionism. Here too, we must learn the lessons from the great crises of the past.

Openness is only possible if this openness is done in a fair and equitable manner. Everyone must feel that the openness is not to their detriment and that they are reasonably protected by fair competition.

The surest way to kill free trade is to make it a religion. It is to not face reality, it is to pretend not to see the distortions of competition, the various forms of dumping. Allowing our cinema to disappear in the name of untainted competition is a cultural renunciation. Allowing our agriculture or our industry to disappear would also be an economic and cultural impoverishment.

We are at the heart of the debate on identity that I wanted in France and that Eric BESSON is leading with great intelligence. In order for identity tensions and the anxiety caused by the feeling of excessive precariousness not to prevail over the spirit of openness, the world must not be governed solely by trade law and by the logic of the market. What France proposes is that health law, environmental law, and fundamental social rights be placed on an equal footing with trade law through the system of preliminary questions.

I do not understand: we have an International Labour Organization, which has established 8 standards - standards, not laws, standards. Why not decide that the member countries of the ILO, roughly those who are members of the United Nations, decide that a country that does not respect the 8 fundamental social standards no longer has access to IMF funding? I am not saying that there should be a single social model. In the standards, for example, we do not allow child labor, we do not allow prisoners to work, there is equality between women's rights and human rights. It is simple, they are the same who are members of the same organizations, and what if all of a sudden we respected the rules we adopt in one organization and in the other? We are members of the FAO, we say "we must develop agriculture" and we are members of the WTO, we say "we must kill part of agriculture." Who can understand this logic? Who can accept it? No one. No one.

Financial disorder poses a latent threat as behavioral and thought habits are hard to break. And I say this as clearly as possible: we will not be silent in the face of the behavior of certain States that do not respect the rules set by the G20, particularly regarding accounting standards. At the G20, we decided, now we must apply.

As for monetary disorder, I have mentioned it briefly, it is a very large project that will need to be opened.

Finally, I would like to share a double conviction.

The first is that it is not time to take stock of the difficulties that may hinder change, it is time to act. As José said, the role of a statesman is not simply to attend conferences to say what should be done, because the people watching us say: "Oh really, that's nice, why don't you do it since it should be done?" The conditional may be the time of the intellectual, the conditional cannot be the time of the statesman. If he says it, he must do it; if he thinks it, he must say it.

And of course, that is what we have tried to do. I will fight for commitments to be kept.

And I wish that France leads the movement, and does not simply follow it.

When the bonus issue arose, a large part of my own friends told me, - while I was on vacation in August, - "Oh please, don't make mistakes, think of competition, if you make national decisions, the traders will leave." Frankly, when I see the balance sheet, there are some I was not ready to retain. I thought, in the end, what credibility does France have at the table of international summits if I ask others to do what we were not capable of doing? With Christine LAGARDE, Prime Minister François FILLON, we decided as early as August last year to create national legislation. And we went to the Pittsburgh Summit saying "here, we are not telling you what should be done, but what we have done." And others followed us. And that is the whole problem of Europe as well. Too much of a follower, waiting for others to act. As others also wait for what we do, we can wait a long time. We must act, and the movement will begin.

That is how France will remain true to itself.

And then one last conviction: not only will Nations not disappear, but they will play a greater role in the global economy. This is an idea I would like to fight for in this year 2010.

In the crisis, Nations have regained their protective role. It is very curious, some companies and some banks claimed they no longer had a nationality. Global banks, global companies, it is curious. When the wind blew harder, they spontaneously rediscovered their national roots. It is curious, when it comes to sharing profits, we are global; when there are problems, we easily find the national counter to avoid bankruptcy. There, we were no longer in the stateless company.

Not one made a mistake about which counter to approach.

Not one knocked on the wrong door.

José, you spoke of the State, I could join you. I want to talk about the Nation.

It is as if the crisis revealed the nationalities that globalization seemed to condemn.

It is as if the crisis highlighted that the social pact and the civic pact are closely linked to the Nation. There is no social pact and civic pact without the Nation.

This means that between the new global governance that is being established, the Europe that is being built - and I share your point of view, José, that we must move towards more Europe - the great metropolises that we also need, the Nation still has its place because it carries values, culture, identity, and diversity is a driver of progress. But if diversity is a driver of progress, do not flee from identity, for without identity there is no diversity. How strange it is this debate where everyone agrees on diversity and where so many fear identity. "Identity is not a pathology," said Lévi-Strauss.

There is no diversity without identity. And identity is of course linked to the Nation. Uniformity has no future, and I would like to share this conviction that competitive advantage is forged by making the best of oneself, not by imitating others. That is competitive advantage; it is not in the pale imitation of a supposed model. It is in the ability to give the best of oneself.

All the more reason for us to discuss our identity. Our place in the world tomorrow will depend on the confidence we have in ourselves, in the values that unite us, in our culture, in our ability to shape a common future.

Will we be able to promote an open, generous idea of the Nation, and share its sovereignty because we will know how to assume our identity, because we will be proud enough not to fear losing it by opening ourselves to others? It is those who have a strong identity who are not afraid to open up to others. It is those who have a weak identity who tremble at the thought of opening up. The debate on identity is crucial; with a strong identity, one is not afraid of others; with a fragile identity, one fears everything that seems different.

This is the question facing France, an old Nation built by the constantly renewed will of so many generations over the centuries.

This is the question facing all the Nations of the world, exposed as in every period of crisis, to the temptation of national selfishness.

This means that the debate on national identity is not a debate turned towards the past but a debate turned towards the future, towards the construction of the world to come. The world to come is the affair of strong identities that will understand and respect each other. It is not a flattened world where everyone will lose their identity, their culture, their values, their personal identity.

This means that the debate on national identity is not the prelude to a retreat, to a closure, but that it is, on the contrary, the condition for openness. But how can so many intelligent people not understand this!

Yesterday, our values, our social model, which is so linked to our identity, seemed doomed to be increasingly out of step with the march of the world.

Today, they are appearing more and more in line with the expectations of the peoples, with the necessities of the time, with this need that is expressed everywhere for a moral demand and a new humanism.

The debate on our identity is a debate to be at the rendezvous of the history that is being written.

It is not only a question of immigration, of course, it is not only a question of religion naturally. It is a question of language, of culture, of art, of science, of education, of society, of economy. It is fundamentally a question of civilization.

The strength of our identity is our greatest asset in the face of the challenges of the 21st century.

So this debate, it is very wrong to think that we are going to stop it. On the contrary, we will continue it, enrich it, amplify it, so that for every French person the words "Nation" and "Republic" regain all their meaning, for everyone, regardless of their origin, regardless of the neighborhood they live in, regardless of the social background they were born into. Because that is how we will be strong, that is how we will be prosperous, that is how we will be united.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Long live France,

Long live the Republic.