Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the rehabilitation of work, particularly through the increase of salaries, participation, and profit-sharing, in Verberie on May 26, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

26 May 2008 · Verberie, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed an audience in Verberie, Oise on May 26, 2008, to outline his government's agenda on wages, profit-sharing, and the value of work.
Main themes
Rehabilitation of work, profit-sharing and participation, salary increases, purchasing power, vocational training reform, senior employment, social protection sustainability, active solidarity income, economic modernization, competition and consumer prices, university and education reform, unemployment reduction
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,060
86th percentile
Sentences
243
93rd percentile
Readability
58
84th percentile
Grade
9.2
13th percentile
Syntax
2.74
16th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 63%62%
  • Social 20%19%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

243 sentences in 70 paragraphs

Gentlemen Ministers, Dear Xavier BERTRAND, dear Eric WOERTH,

Gentlemen Deputies and Senators,

Mr. President of the Regional Council,

Mr. President of the General Council,

Ladies and Gentlemen Mayors and General Councilors,

My dear friends,

Thank you very much for welcoming me here in Oise and for giving me the opportunity to speak about a project that is absolutely fundamental for French society as it concerns both profit-sharing, participation, and salaries. The word salary should not be taboo in the French political debate.

I say this to Eric WOERTH, Philippe MARINI, and Jean-François MANCEL; they are fortunate to be elected representatives of this department of Oise, which I admire for its vitality. I just visited a company a few kilometers from here that has exemplarily implemented a profit-sharing system for the benefit of its employees.

As you know, my absolute priority, and therefore the priority of the Government, is to put work back at the heart of our system of values. Nothing is more important than rehabilitating work because it is the key to the success of our economic and social policies. We cannot build an economic policy on the devaluation of work. We cannot build a social policy on the devaluation of work:

- more work means more wealth;

- more work means more jobs and therefore more purchasing power;

- more work, as Xavier BERTRAND would say better than I, guarantees the funding of our social protection. By working more, we will have more revenue to fund our social protection and better protect the French people. Because if we work less and spend more, I wonder what will remain, in a few years, of our social protection system. There are many candidates to advocate for increased spending, but few to address the issue of the sustainability of our social protection and therefore the sustainability of its funding.

I would like everyone to be convinced that the government's policy is aimed at this objective, the rehabilitation of work.

That is why we want a more efficient educational and university system. I want the best universities in the world for France, not the worst. I want us to have high schools where you are proud to enroll your children and that they then have the opportunity to pursue higher education that will provide them with a good education and therefore a job.

It is because we want to rehabilitate work that we will reform vocational training. I do not want to visit a company, like the one I just visited, where I am told: "we want to create jobs but we have a recruitment problem because for the jobs we need, we do not have the right training."

In a country where there are still 1,900,000 unemployed, even if it is the lowest level in 25 years, there cannot be 500,000 unfilled job offers. That is why we will redirect vocational training towards those who need it most, namely the least qualified employees and job seekers.

It is also because I believe in the value of work that I have made the employment of seniors a priority. Who can accept that in a country like ours, 60%, I say 60%, of the 55-64 age group is sidelined from employment, while these people have purchasing power issues and want to work? It is not normal to tell all these employees: "leave the company, you cost too much." It is not their fault if they are, by chance, 53 years old!

It is indeed to rehabilitate the value of work that I have asked the government, and Laurent WAUQUIEZ is taking care of it, that it should no longer be possible to refuse two reasonable job offers. It is normal in a country like ours that there are rights and duties. The vast majority of unemployed people want to find a job, but if there is a minority that does not want to work, it is not up to the community to pay for them.

It is to rehabilitate work that I will implement the active solidarity income, so that in France, assistance never pays more than work.

I will go even further; the bill for the modernization of the economy that parliamentarians are currently examining is also about the rehabilitation of work. French employees should not pay more for their products than elsewhere, simply because there is not enough competition in our country. I say this to the mayors, deputies, and senators who are here; I know that this may create concerns for small businesses. But, my dear friends, given how long small businesses in city centers have been suffering, you cannot explain to me that they are suffering because consumers pay more than elsewhere. If the Galland law and the law on commercial urban planning had produced good results for city center businesses, we would know it. If things were going well, I would understand being told "Don't change anything." But city center businesses are struggling to survive, our city peripheries look like a contest of ugliness, and French consumers are paying more than elsewhere, so it is clear that it is not working. And we would want to keep this, to change nothing?

We will introduce competition because we do not accept that a number of groups divide the French market to each have their zone of influence and charge consumers more.

French employees are indeed well treated: lower salaries than elsewhere because the charges are higher and higher prices than elsewhere due to a lack of competition. I do not accept this reality, and if necessary, I will tirelessly explain things to make it clear that it is impossible to leave the situation unchanged.

Encouraging competition in price-setting between suppliers and distributors is the policy we are pursuing. Do you know that in France, when a supplier offers a good price to a distributor, the latter cannot pass it on to the final price paid by the consumer? It is simply absurd! I am fighting to allow that in 2008 in France, a distributor and a supplier can freely negotiate prices. Is this such a novelty? Is this such modernity? This is called a market economy. I do not want French employees and French consumers to bear the disadvantages without enjoying the benefits.

It is true, we want to introduce more competition among large retailers. This is not at all about multiplying supermarkets or hypermarkets in our cities. It is about diversifying brands because abuses of dominant positions are unacceptable. The other day, I was in a city where all the large retailers were from the same group. Is that just coincidence? Well, chance does not do things well. And it will do the greatest good for the brands of this group to see brands from another group established. This is called competition in the service of the consumer. And that is what we want.

Furthermore, we have talked a lot about this issue of the 1,000 square meter threshold. The government is ready to complement the project as long as, I say this to the ministers, it remains consistent with the spirit of the reform. Parliamentarians have very good suggestions to improve things. We will examine them. But I want to assure you of one thing, I am determined to go to the end of the fight against rising prices. You know, when I believe in something, I work hard to convince because I know we will be judged on our results. I am the President of the Republic; I must not bow to all corporatism and all immobility. I must think of only one thing: the French people, all the French people.

I repeat, we will be judged on our results. And we already have these results: our growth in 2007 is 2.2%. Certainly, this is not enough. But when I think that all the experts predicted it would be 1.6% or 1.7%! It is curious; there have been more articles predicting catastrophe than highlighting success. And in the first quarter of this year, growth is 0.64%. Yet we were predicted a catastrophe. As for our results on employment, no one thought they were possible just a year ago: the unemployment rate has fallen to 7.5%; 330,000 jobs were created in 2007, making it one of the five best years since 1974. So I am told "you had nothing to do with it." Very well. But if the figures had been bad, would the same have been said? It does not matter. What matters is that it works and that we will continue to encourage people to work more to earn more, to create wealth, to create growth, to create jobs.

It is for work to pay that I wanted the monetization of RTT days and time savings accounts. That is why we decided on reductions for overtime. 59% of French companies have resorted to overtime. I have heard that it is not working. What would it be if it were working? 59% of companies in 5 months of application. Today, you can go to all the companies in France and ask people "Do you know this system? Have you used it?" Nearly 60% have already done so. Who would have thought this possible in a country plagued, infected by this false idea of sharing working time? Mind you, it was time to end the ideology of the 35-hour workweek, since some were already moving towards a 32-hour workweek. What a lack of ambition. Why 32 hours? After all, we could do 28, 25, 22 hours or nothing at all. And with that, things would certainly go better; we would pay our pensions, we would pay our hospitals, we would pay our public services, we would pay for our children's education. Our merit is to put an end to this single thought.

In the same way, I repeat, I will not accept any challenge to the weekly working hours. There is a weekly working time; it is a social achievement, we will not touch it. But we will remove all the locks that prevent those who want to work more to earn more from being able to do so. I am thinking of these ceilings, these thresholds, these quotas that unnecessarily restrict the maneuvering margins that companies and employees need to organize themselves. We want to give freedom to business leaders and employee representatives to decide together, as closely as possible to the realities of their company's life. We do not force anyone; we open the field of possibilities for and through social dialogue. What is lacking in French society is the possibility to choose, the freedom to choose.

I also want to address the issue of the distribution of the fruits of collective effort. This is not a taboo subject. It is not normal that in a company, employees who work hard, who ensure its success, are not associated with the fruits of its growth. I am for a market economy, everyone knows that, but the question of profit-sharing, not work-sharing, is a legitimate question.

This question is not new. General de GAULLE, forty years ago, said: "As soon as people come together for a common economic purpose, for example, to run an industry, bringing either the necessary capital, or the capacity for direction, management, and technique, or labor, it is important that all form a society, a society where everyone has an interest in its yield and good functioning, and a direct interest."

I subscribe to each of these words. I subscribe to the societal project they outline. I subscribe to this vision that is not antagonistic but reconciled regarding the link between work and capital.

From this vision of the General was born profit-sharing, it is the famous ordinance of January 7, 1959. From this vision of the General was also born participation, it is the ordinance of August 17, 1967.

What is the situation today?

Participation is mandatory in companies with more than 50 employees. Profit-sharing, on the other hand, is optional, its amount is not fixed, and it is based on criteria freely negotiated between management and employee representatives.

The amounts distributed are far from negligible. In 2005, the last year for which we have definitive figures, 7 billion euros were distributed under participation to 4.9 million employees, which amounts to an average of 1,440 euros per employee. As for profit-sharing, it is of the same order of magnitude: 6 billion euros distributed, 4.2 million beneficiaries, an average bonus of 1,400 euros per employee.

These results are good, but I believe we can do much more. Indeed, when we look at companies with fewer than 50 employees, where more than 40% of the French work, we find that fewer than one in ten workers has a profit-sharing agreement. I find this to be a real inequality.

Our objectives are simple:

- that companies distribute more to their employees;

- that employees of small and very small businesses, who are often excluded from profit-sharing mechanisms, are now included;

- that we trust employees and let them choose how to use the amounts allocated to them.

I wish for us to focus our efforts on profit-sharing, as it is a flexible and effective tool. The government cannot increase salaries on behalf of business leaders. But through profit-sharing, in addition to overtime and price reductions, we will address the issue of purchasing power.

What are we going to do?

By summer, the government will adopt a bill in the Council of Ministers, which will be debated in Parliament at the start of the new session:

- Companies that did not have a profit-sharing agreement until now and that negotiate one will benefit from a tax credit of 20% on the total bonuses paid to employees for the three years of their agreement. Specifically, if you pay 1,000 euros in bonuses to your employees, you will receive a tax credit of 200 euros. This is a simple and extremely powerful tool to encourage profit-sharing: if you want to pay less tax, then give more profit-sharing. It is clear, it is simple, and it concerns all companies.

- For companies that already have an agreement, we will encourage them to renegotiate to make it more advantageous. Thus, each company that, through a new agreement, pays more to its employees than before will benefit from a tax credit of 20% on the surplus profit-sharing distributed, for three years of the agreement. Specifically, if on average you paid 1,000 euros before and you pay 1,500 euros tomorrow, your tax credit will be 100 euros.

And this dynamic must start without delay. That is why the government will give all companies that renegotiate or negotiate a profit-sharing agreement for the first time before the end of the first half of 2009 the opportunity to pay a bonus in 2009 based on their 2008 results.

You see, this is a powerful measure, a simple measure that is effective immediately.

The goal is for the amounts distributed to employees under profit-sharing to increase by 20% per year. This means a doubling in four years. I have already said that this doubling is my objective. Because it is no more tiring to be ambitious than not to be. But when you are ambitious, you have a chance to achieve your goal.

And we will meet at the halfway point to see if we are aligned with our objectives. These objectives assume that SMEs fully engage in profit-sharing. If that is not the case, then, I prefer to say it, we will consider implementing a specific and mandatory system for SMEs that have not entered into a profit-sharing agreement.

Ladies and gentlemen, this is a vision of society. The competitiveness of French companies depends on the trust of employees in their companies; it depends on the quality of life of employees in the company. If French employees are convinced that by working more, they receive a fair reward, then our companies will be more competitive. We should not oppose profit-sharing and competitiveness; on the contrary.

My third objective is to give each employee the freedom to use the bonuses distributed as they see fit. This is a very important point in my eyes.

Today, employees who have profit-sharing see their funds locked for five years. And we say, "it's good for them." Allow me this reflection: employees are perfectly capable of judging for themselves what is good for them. I propose that we let them decide rather than wanting to forcefully do it for them. Today, the law provides for nine cases of early release of profit-sharing, such as the birth of a third child. Because it doesn't cost much to have a first or second child? One wonders why the State must legislate so that an employee can use money that belongs to them.

Every year, at the time when profit-sharing bonuses are allocated, employees should be able to decide how they want to use them. Either the employee wants this money to be available immediately in a logic of immediate purchasing power, or they prefer it to be locked away and saved for future needs. If the amounts are used immediately, they will be subject, like profit-sharing today, to income tax. If the amounts are saved, they will be exempt from income tax. But everyone will be free to make their decision; it is not the State that will choose for them. This, it seems to me, is the idea we can have of responsibility in our society. It is clear, it is very simple, and it can be explained in two sentences.

And to all those who think that this is a blow to employee savings and employee shareholding, I want to say that they are mistaken. I would point out that the two operations for the early release of profit-sharing stocks did not prevent the continued growth of employee savings.

Finally, I would like to conclude by addressing the issue of salaries. Yes, the President of the Republic must be able to express himself on salaries, even in a market economy.

When it comes to compensating executive managers, I notice that this concerns many boards of directors. I do not criticize it. It is important that executive managers are compensated appropriately. Even if, here and there, some excesses have been committed.

But it is unacceptable to treat lightly, whether in sectors or companies, the issue of the evolution of employee compensation. In this matter, I do not want to stigmatize anyone. Everyone, the State as well as social partners, has long indulged in a system that is completely disempowering. On one side, governments gave significant "boosts" to the minimum wage, with all the political benefits they believed they would gain from such an operation... On the other side, and this is directly related to the State's actions, social partners felt exempt from their responsibility to negotiate salaries dynamically.

In fact, the salary policy in France for years has been the boost to the minimum wage under the worst conditions, that is to say, a decision that is neither social nor economic and is entirely political. At the same time, the State doing what it should not have done, companies and social partners did not do what they were supposed to do, which is to negotiate salaries.

The result, we know it, and everyone can verify it for themselves. The proportion of employees paid at the minimum wage has increased massively. As for salary dynamics, I am talking about salary negotiation, it has been broken, and the 35-hour workweek has further aggravated the situation.

I want to break with this system because I cannot accept that nearly one in seven employees has their remuneration set by decree, with no prospect of evolution.

Specifically, what we are going to do is based on two principles.

The first is that the government should not distort salary negotiations, let alone substitute itself for salary negotiators. Its decision on the minimum wage will henceforth be informed by a commission of experts that will have to make annual proposals for the revaluation of the minimum wage based on economic circumstances. This will be an economic decision and no longer a political decision. The government may choose not to follow this recommendation, but in that case, it will have to explain itself. Of course, the current legal rules for indexing will continue to apply. Finally, to give more visibility to companies and sectors in their salary negotiations, we will move the date of minimum wage revaluation from July 1 to January 1. Given the time required for consultation and the passage of the law, this provision will apply on January 1, 2010.

The second principle is that in terms of salary negotiations, we want the law to be respected, in its letter and in its spirit.

Respect for the letter of the law first. About a quarter of companies subject to the obligation of annual salary negotiation do not comply with this obligation. This is not acceptable. Of course, the imperatives of competitiveness for companies are very important. No one is asking a struggling company to massively increase salaries. But starting an annual salary negotiation is the least an employer owes to their employees. It is still shocking that every year a board of directors decides on stock options or executive compensation, but does not care about the employees at the bottom of the ladder. Discussing does not mean concluding. But if we do not discuss, we have little chance of reaching an agreement.

Therefore, companies that do not comply with their obligation to negotiate salaries annually will see their charge reductions decreased by 10%. Why? Because the State pays 21 billion euros in charge reductions every year; this gives it the right to express its opinion on a number of matters.

Respect for the spirit of the law next. Today, a number of sectors still have minimum wages below the minimum wage. This is not formally contrary to the law, since the minimum wage applies to the employees concerned. But this situation leads to minimum wage increases breaking the salary dynamics. This is why I have proposed that the reductions be decreased in these sectors in proportion to the gap between the minimum wage and the sector's minimum wages.

I would prefer that the government not have to apply this measure to avoid penalizing entire sectors. This is why we will give these sectors a deadline to adapt. But if, in 2010, we find that sector negotiators have not understood the message, then sanctions will apply. No one is taken by surprise. The deadline is set, and the consequences, in case of difficulties, are predictable.

I will tell you one thing: we are changing France, we are reforming it, but we must do so in a spirit of justice and equity. It cannot always be for the same people. It cannot be one-sided. I believe in merit, I believe in work, I believe in effort, and I believe in reward, but I also believe in responsibility. I believe in rights and duties. No one should be exempt from this. Life is not easy for anyone. It is not easy at the bottom of the ladder. And if at the bottom of the ladder we see that at the top, people are exempt from the rules at the bottom, it cannot work. Therefore, it is my duty to ask the government to implement this policy.

Xavier BERTRAND, Christine LAGARDE, and Laurent WAUQUIEZ will quickly open consultations with social partners. I ask them to examine with the utmost attention all the observations, criticisms, and suggestions they will make. I wish for the bill to be presented to the Council of Ministers before summer and to be adopted by Parliament by autumn at the latest for these provisions to take effect in 2009. The French expect results from us; we will deliver those results.

I apologize for being lengthy, ladies and gentlemen, but I wanted to tell you that what we are discussing this morning is crucial. It is simply the idea I have of France and the possibility for each of our compatriots to receive a fair reward for their work, their efforts, and their merit. This is called building a just society where everyone can be lifted up and where we definitively renounce leveling down. Thank you.