Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the renewal of Alstom and on efforts in favor of an industrial policy, La Rochelle, February 5, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

5 February 2008 · Inauguration of the Alstom High-Speed Train (AGV) · La Rochelle, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed guests at the inauguration of Alstom's AGV high-speed train in La Rochelle on February 5, 2008, defending French industrial policy.
Main themes
Alstom renewal and recovery, French industrial policy, high-speed rail and AGV inauguration, state intervention in industry, competition policy and European industrial strategy, entrepreneurial capitalism, climate and energy transition, public-private partnership, globalization and economic voluntarism
Duration
~26 min
76th percentile
Words
3,077
76th percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.84
27th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
24th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 82%82%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

159 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Mr. Minister,

Dear Patrick KRON,

I have a very special emotion to be here today, the day Alstom inaugurates the High-Speed Train, the most modern and high-performing train in the world and the new technological benchmark for high-speed rail.

The inauguration of the AGV today demonstrates that Alstom, even in the worst moments, never sacrificed research and development to the urgencies of the moment. And that Alstom never forgot that its true strength lay in its technology.

This launch of the AGV also marks, in my opinion, the culmination of Alstom's renewal. A renewal that comes after a terrible crisis in 2004, which threatened the very existence of the company.

This renewal is above all your work, the work of Alstom's employees and the work of Alstom's subcontractors who trusted their new management after having been so disappointed - rightly so - by the previous one. It is the work of Patrick KRON. I can bear witness. The president of Alstom fought for Alstom when no one believed in it anymore. And the President of Alstom at the time did not come to see the Minister of Finance that I was to secure his position, but to ask the Minister of Finance to help him save a company in which he believed. And then, I think we can particularly commend this morning Patrick KRON for the courage and intelligence he has shown.

Alstom is also something else, and I say this to my own elected political friends who have not always understood me when in 2004, I partially renationalized Alstom by buying 22% of the company's capital. It is not the role of a Minister of Finance to sit idly by with arms crossed watching things happen. I believe in the market, I believe in competition, I believe in globalization, but I also believe in voluntarism. A great country must develop a real industrial policy. Alstom was about energy and transport and ships - which I regret once again.

A Minister of Finance, a President of the Republic must commit to serving the economy. This is not interference. But I still have not digested the way Péchiney disappeared from the French industrial landscape because we did not have the courage, at one point, to say that France needs a chemical industry. As a result, Péchiney went to Canada.

One can be perfectly liberal and have an industrial political will. This is not contradictory. And then, there is competition. I do not oppose industry to competition. Competition is a stimulant and monopoly is a danger. But an effective competition policy must look at what the landscape of an industry should be in the medium term. We did not accept that the commission, at one point, had the temptation to dismantle Alstom in favor of one of Alstom's major competitors, Siemens. And it was a famous battle to convince them. I say one thing: I did not want the merger between Siemens and Alstom because this merger was based on the dismantling of Alstom and not on the construction of a large European group, which could have been conceived at one point. And let us stop presenting competition as the impossibility of having an industrial strategy. Competition must be fair and not unfair. And we knew perfectly well that Alstom's problems stemmed from a serious error in gas turbine technology. Because when you buy a new technology at a gold price and it does not work, it is not good for the company. And the employees and workers were not to blame. This is how we were able to save this company.

Alstom's fortune today is to produce a means of transport essential for the 21st century. The two competitors of the High-Speed Train, the airplane and the road, are facing rising oil prices and the obligation to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. The TGV is becoming a key element of a development strategy for emerging countries, and I am very happy that a company like ALSTOM has been able to find a great French industrial partner. It is certainly not because Martin BOUYGUES has been my friend for a long time that I will refrain from saying all the good I think of his actions. I know it is a great classic in politics to speak ill of one's friends and well of one's adversaries.

I am very happy that in France there are people who have resources and who put these resources at the service of industry, rather than placing them abroad for their own cause. And we absolutely must reconcile the French with family capitalism, with entrepreneurial capitalism, otherwise we will not be able to keep factories, industries, and companies in France. I was very pleased that the 22% of the State was sold to a great private industrialist who has become the reference shareholder of ALSTOM. This is all the better for this company, because the State has no vocation to remain the owner of your company, even partially, and it is a serious mistake to criticize those in France who have resources and put them at the service of industry and business.

For the employees, the teams at ALSTOM, it is still better to have a reference shareholder who is a great industrialist than to have simply a pension fund whose origins and thoughts are not always known. I want to say that the work that has been done here is solid work. I have nothing against pension funds, but the advantage, when you talk with your shareholder, is that you know who he is and what he does and that he will support the dynamism and ambition of the company, because we have and we must have a lot of ambition for your company.

What pleases me about this morning's inauguration is that it shows that ALSTOM wants to maintain its leadership by keeping its technological edge. One must always be one step ahead, and it is not because one has won today's battle that one will win tomorrow's. It is surprising, by the way, that for a quarter of a century Europe and Japan were the only parts of the world interested in high-speed rail. And then, in recent months, this has changed. Yes, we fought, Patrick, for you to have the TGV in Morocco, and it is an unprecedented economic and political fact that the first TGV in an African country will be from ALSTOM. It is an unprecedented fact that we are beginning to open markets in South America. We will continue to support you and do so with all our strength.

Regarding competition, I would like to say one thing, so that the situation is also clear. ALSTOM and France do not refuse competition, but I will not accept that some of ALSTOM's competitors come to France to participate in tenders while in their home markets they have captive markets that are negotiated bilaterally. BOMBARDIER is a large company with high-quality people. BOMBARDIER does not need a monopoly in Canada to compete in other markets. In any case, let things be clear: if BOMBARDIER wants to compete in tenders in FRANCE, it is welcome, but in that case, I ask that ALSTOM also be welcome to compete in CANADA. Competition is reciprocity; if there is no reciprocity, we will draw all the consequences. And I say this to the managers of the local authorities who are here. Also take reciprocity into account when you make tenders. So I know that Italy has already ordered the AGV. ITALY was right; I hope that CHINA will do the same, especially for the Beijing-Shanghai line on which we are working. I have no complex about putting the State at the service of ALSTOM's commercial power, dear Dominique BUSSEREAU, because these large markets are often negotiated with state authorities or large public enterprises. Our competitors do it; we would be foolish to have the naivety not to do it. Moreover, the contracts we have signed in the past 8 months represent more than 1,100 secured jobs for years for ALSTOM Transport and its subcontractors.

So I know that behind ALSTOM and its success, there is a worrying situation for industry in France. First, I want to reiterate how much it is a mistake not to imagine that currency matters in a commercial strategy. If we want to continue producing in the eurozone, our industrialists must not be penalized by a too-strong euro. If it bothers anyone that I say the euro is too strong, then I will say that the dollar is too weak. It changes nothing, but if it can be more diplomatic, I will gladly do so. But if we want to continue producing in the eurozone, it is pointless to lose competitiveness with a currency that is at historical levels compared to the currencies of our major competitors.

I know that others manage with this strong euro, but that is no reason to be penalized. We already have fiscal dumping, social dumping, and environmental dumping. There is no need to add monetary dumping.

I also believe that we must engage in the training of people in this matter. We have said so many times in every tone that industry in France was finished, that the future was in services, that we are now seeing the result: scientific and technical vocations are drying up. We cannot let French competence in sciences and techniques continue to wither day by day. We must reverse this trend.

To one of my friends who told me during the electoral campaign: "Why are you going to factories? There are many more people in offices. Go to services." I pointed out this argument that I believe in, which is that the French have a lot of common sense and know very well that the day we close all the factories, there will be no place left for services and that the workers in the factories will be the first to go. It is after that the others follow. In any case, I do not intend to visit centers with everyone in white coats, which are so efficient that there is only one: the one that is shown to the President of the Republic. I want to see the factories and the everyday offices. Because it is these offices, and these factories, that need to be defended and supported.

We must therefore instill in the minds, especially those of students and high schoolers, a simple message: industry is not finished; industry is essential to the economy of a wealthy country as much as to that of an emerging country; industry is the engine of productivity progress in a society. France will have an industry in 2020, in 2040, and in 2060.

I went to Gandrange yesterday. I see a torrent of comments. Specialists in laissez-faire. They believe in nothing, so they do nothing. It is quite logical. How do you expect me to let such a thing happen? The world lacks steel. The price of steel is rising. It is the role of the President of the Republic, when one wants to close a steel mill, to ask whether there is not something to be done to keep it open, especially in a region, dear to Gérard LONGUET, Lorraine, which has suffered so much from the reconversion of mining and the restructuring of the steel industry. What did we explain to Lorraine in the 60s and 70s? That there was no longer a need for steelmaking and that we would no longer need steel. As a result, we look foolish today when the world is underproducing steel capacity. It is not my role to accept without doing anything that we reduce our steel production capacity while the cost of steel is rising in the world. I therefore prefer, in Gandrange, that the State invests in training people or in purchases that will allow for investment and modernization of the plant rather than investing to force 52-year-olds to stay at home, depressed and doing nothing.

I want to put the State's money at the service of an offensive strategy and not a defensive strategy. I want to enable people to work more, not to be forced to stay at home because we are financing an expensive social plan that ultimately leads to the depression of an entire generation and an entire region. This is not my conception of an economic policy. I will do this every time I think that a factory, a company, a site has a future. We cannot save everyone.

Even when we are going to close, I think of Toul with Michelin, which is an extraordinary company. There is undoubtedly a problem with the mid-quality tires that are being manufactured. So, at that moment, I prefer that we put the money, I say this to the elected officials, not to finance an expensive social program but to invest in industrial revitalization, to create jobs, to help new projects, and for France to once again become a welcoming country for work.

What do you want me to say? In 2008, it is abnormal to question whether we should work on Sundays. What is the point of being the country that receives the most tourists in the world and having our shops closed on Sundays in our major cities? If you go to the Champs-Élysées, it is extraordinary: on the right sidewalk, you are allowed to work on Sundays, on the left sidewalk, you are not allowed. Try to find a technician to explain that on the right it was a tourist area and on the left it was not. Frankly, to qualify the right and the left, I would have done something else.

We must reward work, we must reconcile France with work. And finally, I would like to conclude with this, ALSTOM gives us the example of research and development.

I wished that we make in 2007, I choose my words carefully, a historic effort for the research and development of companies. We raised the research tax credit to 30% of R&D expenses, we tripled the credit. And I assert that now France has the most favorable regime in the world in terms of research and development. With this, we have made French universities autonomous and with this, we will be able to build a research and development apparatus at the service of French industry that is absolutely unprecedented. I add that the challenges are immense. Our taxation must become more favorable to industry. France has production taxes three times heavier than the eurozone average. How can this continue? When I think that some tell me: "Oh, we shouldn't change too much." Oh really, but if we don't change too much, we will die, that's the theorem, that's the alternative: change to be competitive or die because we are no longer competitive. So how do we want to keep our factories if we tax them so much?

So we will reform the business tax this year to lighten the burden on industry, or even better, to take into account the financial health of the sites. I know this is a difficult reform because the business tax is an important resource for local authorities. But if I am here, in the position that is mine, it is not to only make the easy reforms. And it is not because industry weighs less than before in national wealth that we should not take care of it. Otherwise, we trigger a vicious circle: the less industry there is, the less we take care of it, and the less we take care of it, the less industry there is. And in the end, it is the death of the economy of a great country.

And to conclude, I believe we need to find financing, Patrick, that is more suitable, more appropriate for industry. And the Caisse des Dépôts must mobilize to raise funds and invest in small and medium-sized enterprises. And rather than letting fortunes leave France, I wanted to mobilize the wealth tax for investment in SMEs, particularly innovative SMEs. And I want to push our banking system, which is in great need, and financial system to innovate a bit in financing businesses. It seems much wiser to me that our banks focus more on investing in innovative projects than on managing trading rooms, which are nothing more than places for speculation on stock prices, currency prices, or commodity prices. And in the end, we see the result, it is hardly brilliant. I am talking about the international financial system because with the mutualization of risks, new securitization products, and the lack of transparency, it is the work of workers, it is the work of engineers that is being undermined because a number of players speculate in more or less transparent ways.

What we expect from a financial system is that it ensures the reward for the entrepreneur and not for speculators. And I find it very curious that there are so many entrepreneurs who have difficulty raising funds while we see so many speculators during speculative bubbles who have no difficulty buying anything for I don't know who, at any price. And ultimately, every ten years, we find ourselves with a speculative bubble, whether in real estate, in Spain, or on the Internet. Well, it is not the role of a financial system to ensure the reward for speculation when we have so many projects, so many technologies, so many ways to be innovative and to support for employment and for the future of the French economy projects that seem to me much more productive.

You see, as far as the government is concerned, the line is simple: do everything to free up the forces of labor in France, let people work, allow discussions to take place in the company about the duration of working time. Allow people to earn more by working more. Allow people to combine a pension and a job. Allow people to retire later if they have purchasing power needs. Allow you, the entrepreneurs, to have more flexibility, to be more competitive.

And finally, you understood, being here with the AGV and the whole team that I want to congratulate for this remarkable work, is fundamentally being with people who love their work, who love their company, who are proud of their company and their work. Ultimately, thanks to people like you, the French economy has beautiful days ahead. Thank you.