Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the role of the Court of Auditors, in Paris on November 5, 2007.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

5 November 2007 · Commemoration of the bicentenary of the Court of Auditors · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed the Court of Auditors in Paris on November 5, 2007, marking the institution's bicentennial and calling for a revolution in public financial accountability.
Main themes
Role and authority of the Court of Auditors, accountability of public finances, moral and intellectual revolution in public management, transparency and certification of accounts, responsibility of public officials, reform of state institutions, civic duty and taxation, fight against impunity and waste, presidential leadership by example, dignity and honor of civil servants
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,542
68th percentile
Sentences
137
77th percentile
Readability
55
78th percentile
Grade
10.0
21st percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
40th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 72%72%
  • Economic 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

137 sentences in 100 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Court,

Mr. Attorney General,

Ladies and Gentlemen Councillors,

Ladies and Gentlemen Auditors,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Thank you for your warm welcome.

Thank you, dear Philippe Séguin, for your kind words.

I am pleased to be among you to commemorate the creation of the Court of Auditors and to celebrate its two hundredth anniversary.

I wanted to pay tribute to your institution, which has served the State continuously for two hundred years despite the vicissitudes of History, by my presence at such a solemn moment.

I wanted to honor the work and sense of duty of its magistrates and all those who assist them in fulfilling their mission.

This mission is to ensure that citizens' trust in the State can be preserved.

This mission is to uphold an ethics, a republican ethics, an ethics of public service.

For the control of public accounts is not just a technical requirement; it is primarily a moral requirement.

Public money is the money of all; it is the money earned through hard work, effort, and the struggles of each individual.

This money is doubly sacred.

It is sacred because it is taken from workers and savers, because it is the sacrifice demanded of each person for the Republic to thrive, because paying taxes is the civic act through which solidarity ceases to be a pious wish and becomes a reality.

Public money is also sacred because needs are always greater than resources, because there is too much distress, misery, and suffering to alleviate, because there are too many injustices to rectify, because there are too many inequalities to correct, and too few means for a single cent to be wasted, for a single cent to be diverted.

When public money is wasted or diverted, it is as much that will be lacking to help those who need it most, those who are the most vulnerable, those whom life's accidents have broken.

For too long, we have regarded the waste and diversion of public money with a certain lightness.

For too long, the investigations, reports, and observations of the Court of Auditors have gone without consequence.

For too long, we have considered that a lack of rigor in managing public funds was not so serious—because public money was not the money of all, but the money of no one.

For too long, we have thought that the nature of public money was to be spent without counting, that it was inherent to public service that its effectiveness could not be measured, and that while we should hold the accountant accountable, it was not legitimate to hold the authorizing officer accountable.

I take this opportunity to express before you today that this era is over.

Our State needs an intellectual and moral revolution.

The intellectual revolution for me is that of certification, which compels transparency and sincerity in accounts, and that of evaluation, which obliges everyone to care about the consequences of their decisions and the results of their actions.

The moral revolution for me is that of responsibility. The moral revolution for me is the greatest severity for those who commit faults, it is the end of the feeling of impunity for fraudsters, it is, at the same time, the reward for merit and well-done work.

Nothing is more immoral and demoralizing than this confusion of minds and values that places good and evil, honesty and dishonesty, competence and incompetence on the same level.

Nothing is more immoral, more demoralizing than this ordinary negligence in managing public funds that discourages goodwill and destroys the consent to taxation.

We need a revolution in minds and behaviors.

This revolution has become urgent after so much laxity.

The French desire this revolution.

It has begun with the new budgetary procedure.

It has begun with the certification of public accounts.

But this revolution is too slow.

This revolution does not go far enough.

This revolution, I will ensure goes all the way, that it goes quickly, that it goes as far as possible.

It is in this spirit that I wanted the Presidency of the Republic to set an example.

The budget of the Élysée was not subject to the control of the Court of Auditors. From now on, it will be.

The salary of the President of the Republic was set at discretion. From now on, it will be set by law, in full transparency.

The reform commission for institutions, chaired by Édouard Balladur, proposes that all constitutional powers be subject to the control of the Court. I will adopt this proposal because we need democracy to be irreproachable and because opacity always breeds suspicion and discredit.

Let me be clear: this is not about casting suspicion on the vast majority of civil servants, on their honesty, on their competence, on their dedication. On the contrary, it is about restoring their dignity, making them above suspicion, preserving their honor.

I have often had the opportunity to say that I do not like the way civil servants are spoken of in my country and that it is profoundly unjust to hold them responsible for the dysfunctions of the State, its immobility, its waste, which are attributable only to faults, behaviors, and political choices.

As it is profoundly unjust to make all civil servants bear the weight of the faults and errors of a few among them.

It is this injustice that I want to combat.

Stricter control, more systematic evaluation, a more clearly defined responsibility to which no one should be exempted, will not only allow us to save money to reduce our deficits and our debt, but also to restore the prestige of our public service and to restore the authority of the State, which suffers from all the faults and errors that have been committed in its name.

Waste and fraud destroy civic spirit and citizens' trust in the State and in those who serve it.

Less waste, less fraud will mean more civic spirit, greater trust in the Republic and in democracy, and more respect for civil servants.

The fight against fraud, I want it to be a priority. I promised the French this. This promise will be kept.

Every head of a public service, of an administration, will have to present a plan to combat fraud.

I will hold each Minister, each Director of central administration, each head of a public establishment accountable for the results achieved. I want everyone to feel concerned, involved, responsible. I want everyone to know that they will be judged on this criterion as well.

I repeat: it is not only the organization and procedures that must be reformed to resolve the crisis of our democracy and for our State and our public service to regain the trust of citizens. It is the very principles of our public management that must be restructured.

This intellectual and moral revolution, you are meant to be the armed wing of it.

I am convinced that we will resolve nothing, that we will not clean up the situation of our public finances, that we will not sustainably reduce our deficits and our debt through austerity policies.

To those who believe only in the virtue of sacrificial policies, I want to say that the French have been making considerable sacrifices in vain for 25 years.

To those who want to prioritize deficit reduction instead of prioritizing reforms, I want to say that they confuse consequences and causes and that it is reforms that reduce deficits.

To those who demand accounting policies, I say that France needs economic policies, not accounting policies. I tell them that the accounting rationing of spending and disorder in the State increases waste and burdens deficits instead of reducing them.

I tell them that rationing is a bad policy and that the good policy is to seek to increase the efficiency of spending. It is for the State to consume less but to invest more.

It is for public spending to be more future-oriented and less past-oriented.

It must be the role of the Court of Auditors to help the State spend better.

It must be the role of the Court of Auditors to illuminate public choices so that public spending is always more effective.

In a few decades, the Court of Auditors has changed a lot. Under the impetus of your predecessors and even more so under yours, Mr. President, dear Philippe Séguin, it has become more responsive, more operational. I point to the speed and efficiency with which it has met the challenge of certification.

We are no longer in an era where each magistrate of the Court worked as if they belonged to a liberal profession.

The time is no longer when magistrates bought their positions and passed them on to their children.

The time is no longer when the senior advisers came in teams once a month to collect their bundles, which they would sift through at home at their leisure.

The Court is now a modern institution that concentrates the greatest skills and the most diverse and remarkable talents. Its jurisdictional status and its collegiality give it a precious independence for the fulfillment of all its missions.

I am aware of the recurring debates surrounding its role. I know the ongoing challenges to its status, its independence, and its positioning. One day, there are calls to split it in two, separating the jurisdictional dimension from the functions of expertise, evaluation, and certification. Another day, there are proposals to create competitors, to multiply evaluation bodies. Another time, there are suggestions that it could be abolished or have part of its missions removed.

As far as I am concerned, I consider these debates to be closed, that the members of the Court will continue to be magistrates, and that neither its independence nor its positioning nor its missions should be called into question.

The Court will retain its status and its unity. It will continue to assist Parliament in its mission of controlling the executive.

You sent me, Mr. President, a draft text aimed at reforming the Court of Budgetary and Financial Discipline, and I thank you for the stimulating and innovative proposals it contains.

Know that they go in the right direction in my eyes. I approve of the principles and the main lines. They will feed into a broader reform that I have asked the government to work on. It will address both the principles of our public accounting, the control and accountability of authorizing officers, the legality control, and the powers and organization of financial jurisdictions.

You will naturally be associated with these reflections when the time comes.

You can sense, after so many changes, so many evolutions, of which the new budgetary procedure is not the least, the necessity to reassess everything, to find a coherence that cannot be achieved either by returning to tradition or by starting from scratch. We need to refound the Court of Auditors based on what history and experience have left us that is most solid.

The message I want to convey today is simple.

I do not want to diminish the independence of the Court of Auditors; I want to preserve it.

I do not want to reduce the prerogatives of the Court of Auditors; I want to increase them.

I do not want to diminish the competencies of the Court of Auditors; I want to enhance them.

I do not want it to have less power; I want it to have more.

I do not want to weaken its resources; I want to strengthen them.

I want the Court to remain a jurisdiction because that is its strength and originality, and at the same time, to become the great auditing and evaluation body for public policies that our State needs.

The urgency, it seems to me, is primarily material.

Such a function requires resources. Can we imagine large private sector audit firms where auditors would have no assistants, where each would have to resolve all their material problems themselves, to perform secretarial tasks?

The least we can say is that the conditions under which the magistrates of the Court work do not favor their effectiveness and that from this point of view, we are still caught between modernity and ancient times. The Court has innovated in its recruitment to meet the challenge of certification. It will likely need to innovate further.

I invite you, Mr. President, to engage in a collective reflection on what the powers, resources, and organization necessary for this great public audit body that France needs could be, so that it can emerge and function without diminishing what makes the strength of the institution you preside over, but rather amplifying it. I hope you will share your conclusions with me within three months.

The future of the Court of Auditors is not behind it. It is ahead of it. The Court has a history. It is the heir to institutions that are much older—because our kings already felt the need to have public money controlled. One does not belong to such an institution without undoubtedly feeling a secret pride in being the heir to such a long tradition, and without each person being carried by this tradition to the highest demands of themselves, as they naturally feel the duty to prove themselves worthy of it.

But endlessly repeating the past cannot serve as a project.

I have not come to invite you to repeat the past but to invent the future.

I have come to invite you to make this bicentennial not a simple commemoration but the starting point of a renaissance.

I have come to invite you to break with the habits, behaviors, and routines of the past.

I have come to invite you to audacity.

For it is audacity that we need to carry out the reforms that your reports have long shown to be necessary.

It is audacity that we need to modernize our administration, to innovate, to make the State once again the lever of change, the main agent of progress that it has so often been in our history, and not a factor of immobility and conservatism that it has ultimately become.

Be audacious, and you will have the means that this audacity calls for. I commit to that.

Be audacious, and you will become the driving force of an unprecedented administrative revolution.

The Court of Auditors is two hundred years old. It is a fine age for an institution in a country that has, in the same period, experienced eight Constitutions, including two Empires, two monarchies, and four Republics, not to mention the Vichy regime.

This longevity is due to the quality of the men and women who have served it, to their high intellectual and moral values, to their passion for the public good. They have made it indispensable to the State. In the circumstances we find ourselves in, it is, in my eyes, more necessary than ever.

I have come to express my confidence.

The Court of Auditors is two hundred years old and still has a tremendous task to accomplish.

It is two hundred years old and is beginning a new youth.

It is two hundred years old and has the whole future ahead of it.

We will build it together. Thank you.