Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the safety and sustainability of the nuclear sector, in Fessenheim (Haut-Rhin) on February 9, 2012.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

9 February 2012 · Fessenheim power plant, Fessenheim, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed workers at the Fessenheim nuclear plant on February 9, 2012, to defend nuclear energy policy, safety standards, and oppose politically motivated plant closures.
Main themes
Nuclear energy policy, safety of nuclear power plants, Fessenheim power plant, energy independence, CO2 emissions reduction, nuclear regulatory oversight, ASN authority, workers' contributions, political debate on nuclear energy, jobs in nuclear sector, energy competitiveness
Duration
~30 min
82nd percentile
Words
3,605
82nd percentile
Sentences
182
87th percentile
Readability
46
51st percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.93
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.35
83rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 41%41%
  • Environmental 23%23%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Not in focus 1%

182 sentences in 89 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

The reason I wanted to come here today to the Fessenheim power plant is primarily to pay tribute to your work.

Every day, all of you, engineers, technicians, workers, whether employed by EDF or its industrial partners, contribute to providing France with the electricity that our fellow citizens need to live, to light their homes, to heat them. In these days of extreme cold, I can tell you that the French people are grateful for your work and the mobilization you demonstrate.

You produce the electricity that our businesses need to create, to develop, to produce.

Every day, here in Fessenheim, you ensure safe and affordable electricity.

I came to Fessenheim to witness firsthand the considerable investments that have already been made to allow this power plant to continue producing electricity for the French people.

It is also to express my determination to strengthen safety, which is inseparable from the choice of nuclear energy.

It is to reaffirm before you my confidence in our fleet of nuclear power plants, thanks to your expertise and commitment.

A political debate has arisen in our country regarding the relevance of the choice of nuclear energy. It is my duty to defend the place of nuclear energy in our energy policy. This choice of nuclear energy has been made by all my predecessors since General de Gaulle.

To deviate from it is to seriously endanger the entire structure.

To deviate from it, to move away from nuclear energy, is to jeopardize France's exceptional results in reducing CO2 emissions.

The debate on nuclear energy is essential for the future of our country; it directly affects you.

The two reactors at Fessenheim are at the forefront of the list of 24 reactors that some would like to close forcibly, to the detriment of jobs in the nuclear sector, to the detriment of the competitiveness of our industry, to the detriment of our energy independence. I will never accept the closure of the Fessenheim power plant for political reasons, for political calculations that have nothing to do with energy or safety.

I tell you this with the same strength: if there were the slightest doubt about the safety of the plant, if independent authorities had pointed out any weakness in the plant, I would not have hesitated for a second to ask EDF to close Fessenheim. The independent authorities, both during the ten-year inspection and the post-Fukushima inspection, have declared that Reactor No. 1 is perfectly safe. Wanting to close Fessenheim is a scandal because it sacrifices your jobs to political ulterior motives that should not be mentioned when it comes to the future of France's energy policy.

France has always placed the absolute requirement for the highest level of safety at the forefront of its nuclear energy development priorities.

On safety, no compromise is possible. But I ask those who are watching us, the media present here, to reflect. If there were the slightest doubt about the safety of our plants, do you believe that those who work in these plants, whose families live next to the plants, would be so attached to the plants if they thought they were unsafe? The first people concerned about the safety of a plant are the employees who work there.

To ensure the safety of its nuclear fleet, France has established an organization that is a global reference and is based on a few simple principles: the responsibility of operators, independence and transparency of the regulatory body, excellence of technical expertise.

The responsibility for safety primarily lies with the operators. I know that every day, here in Fessenheim as in every nuclear power plant in our territory, safety is at the heart of your work and concerns.

Safety is overseen by a regulatory body that is both independent and transparent, the Nuclear Safety Authority. Parliament passed the law on transparency and nuclear safety in 2006; Mr. Jospin's government was unable to bring this law to fruition. This law established the ASN as an independent administrative authority. This means that it operates free from political interference. It makes its decisions collegially, relying on technical and scientific expertise recognized worldwide. The results of its inspections and its decisions are public and can be consulted by all French citizens.

The ASN can shut down a reactor at any time if it believes that its safety is at risk. The ASN, I say to my fellow citizens, conducts 700 inspections each year in French nuclear facilities, 700, to check the compliance of the facilities and prescribe measures to improve their safety.

In addition to this continuous oversight, each reactor in France undergoes a complete safety review every ten years. This is what you are currently experiencing in Fessenheim. It is the ASN, and it alone, that has the power to decide on the extension of a reactor's operation for an additional ten years. In Fessenheim, the authorization for Reactor 1 to operate for another 10 years was granted six months ago, and you are awaiting the ASN's decision regarding the second reactor.

I wanted to see firsthand, by visiting the plant, the massive investments that have been made in Fessenheim. Over the past five years, 600 million euros have been invested to improve the safety of your plant.

All of the steam generators have been replaced, and the facilities have been reinforced to address seismic and flooding risks.

Among the requirements set by the ASN following the last review is the reinforcement of the foundation of Reactor No. 1. This reinforcement, dear Nathalie Kosciusko-Morizet, dear Eric Besson, will be completed by June 30, 2013, representing an investment of 15 million euros. This shows how much we believe in the future of Fessenheim.

Meeting the highest safety standards also requires that we be able to adapt to new risk factors when they are identified. That is why, in the days following the Fukushima accident, I asked the ASN to conduct a specific assessment to draw lessons from this accident regarding the French nuclear fleet. In Fessenheim, as in all plants, not only did you have the ten-year analysis, reactor by reactor, but you also had the post-Fukushima inspection.

We were the first country in the world to do this. We defined an extremely broad set of requirements, including all nuclear facilities (not just the power plants), as well as human, social, and organizational factors (notably to take subcontracting into account).

Following these additional evaluations, the ASN issued a safety opinion on January 3. This opinion is absolutely fundamental.

The ASN states, the ASN says: "The plants in the French nuclear fleet present a level of safety that allows them to continue operating." All of them, without exception, including Fessenheim. All the plants are safe.

This is what the independent French Nuclear Safety Authority, based on globally recognized technical expertise, says.

The ASN has also determined that it is necessary to increase, beyond the existing safety margins, the robustness of the facilities in the face of extreme situations. This will allow us to implement a backup diesel generator, to identify an alternative source of cooling water supply, and to create a "nuclear rapid response force," meaning specialized teams and equipment that can intervene in less than 24 hours, in addition to everything that already exists.

For the entire French nuclear fleet, these safety enhancement works will represent an investment of around ten billion euros, half of which is already included, which is 5 billion in EDF's investment program. I have asked the ministers responsible for nuclear safety to prepare a report by next September on the complete, absolutely integral implementation of the ASN's requirements.

I will fully follow the recommendations of the ASN. I want to be frank with you: if a plant had to be closed because its safety is at stake, I would not hesitate for a minute to do so, regardless of the financial consequences for the operator.

However, without prejudging the upcoming conclusions regarding Reactor No. 2 of Fessenheim, none, I repeat, none of the successive audits conducted here by the ASN recommend closing this plant.

I find it completely irresponsible to want to close such an important plant for Alsace, Mr. President Richert, depriving hundreds of workers of their jobs, simply to try to garner a few votes on the political stage that cannot be obtained otherwise. I want to tell you, this is irresponsible and deeply shocking.

It is absurd to decide a priori, a priori, without technical expertise, to arbitrarily close 24 reactors, starting with the two reactors of the Fessenheim power plant.

This plant will not close because if a plant must be closed, it is for safety reasons, not solely for ideological or political transaction motives. That would be profoundly contrary to the interest of France!

Ladies and Gentlemen, energy policy shapes the future of our country.

For 60 years, France has taken the necessary steps to ensure its independence in electricity supply, through the development of hydroelectric power and then the development of nuclear energy.

The major political parties built a consensus around the development of this energy. General de Gaulle defined the foundations of scientific and industrial organization.

Georges Pompidou and Valéry Giscard d'Estaing defined the construction program for the current fleet. And the construction program for the current fleet was implemented for more than two-thirds under François Mitterrand's mandates.

I am surprised that those who claim his legacy today so lightly seek to undermine it.

Of course, no policy is immutable, and all political debates are legitimate. Stagnation would be synonymous with decline.

But for my part, I wish to change policies that do not work and not to call into question policies that do work.

With the realization of the nuclear power fleet, our predecessors have bequeathed to us a heritage that is a competitive asset for our country, allowing us to be independent.

This fleet allows us to have electricity that is twice as cheap as in Germany for consumers and 33% cheaper for businesses. Why should I undervalue what we have received? This fleet allows our country to free itself from rare fossil resources that emit CO2 in electricity production. Our fleet depends on them only to the extent of 9%, compared to 60% in Germany. Germany emits every year, listen to the figure: 300 million tons of CO2 for electricity production. France emits 30 million tons each year. 300 on one side of the border, 30 on the other, and we should give up the nuclear fleet that allows us to achieve this?

Why would we want to call into question what is an advantage for our country, an asset in economic terms and an asset in environmental terms?

The reasons that led to the construction of our nuclear fleet, namely the need to reduce our imports of fossil resources, are these reasons no longer relevant? Have we found oil and gas in Alsace? That information has not reached my desk!

Do we currently have production means that could replace our current fleet in the coming years?

At what costs? And with what consequences?

The Court of Auditors, perfectly independent, has conducted, at the government's request, remarkable work to evaluate and measure exhaustively the costs of the nuclear power sector.

The Court of Auditors confirmed that all long-term liabilities were indeed taken into account by the operators, and that there were no "hidden costs" as some so-called environmentalists claimed. Hidden costs of nuclear energy do not exist. The Court of Auditors has dismissed this bad faith argument.

There are uncertainties regarding the amount of certain long-term liabilities. But the Court recognized that these uncertainties would have a limited impact on the cost of nuclear energy production.

Thus, if we were to consider the highest estimate of the costs of nuclear waste storage, the increase in production costs, compared to what is currently accounted for, would be 1%, - 1%!

I have asked the Minister of Energy to continue evaluating the dismantling estimates and to establish the final estimate for the waste storage center before the end of the year. This will gradually reduce uncertainties.

I would like to add that these long-term liabilities, whether related to the decommissioning of power plants or the management of radioactive waste, correspond to investments that must be made in any case, regardless of the decisions made regarding the lifespan of the plants. Their amounts cannot therefore be used to favor an early shutdown of the reactors. On the contrary, we have an interest in amortizing these fixed costs over reasonable operating periods.

Finally, the Court has fully confirmed the assessment of the operating expenses of the current fleet and examined the investment projections for the future.

EDF has planned a program of 55 billion euros in investments across its entire fleet, Mr. President PROGLIO, over the next 15 years, in order to modernize the fleet and improve its safety.

As a result, there will be an increase in the annual investment level for EDF, which will rise from 1.7 billion euros to 3.7 billion euros.

Taking into account all these future investments, the operating cost of a plant like Fessenheim is estimated at 33 euros per megawatt-hour. Well, I assert it and I challenge anyone to contest these figures: no, I say again, no substitute energy today, and none in the coming decades, will produce electricity at a lower cost than the Fessenheim plant.

To compensate for the closure of the two reactors like those at Fessenheim, which today represent 70% of the electricity consumed in Alsace, Mr. President RICHERT, it would require an additional 400 million euros to purchase electricity on the European market that we would no longer be able to produce. 400 million euros to finance a political agreement behind the backs of the workers in the nuclear sector.

This additional cost would rise, hold on tight, to 700 million euros per year if the substitute electricity—if we closed Fessenheim—were wind-generated. And to have the equivalent of the two reactors at Fessenheim, hold on tight, we would need to cover Alsace with 2,500 wind turbines. 700 million euros spent in pure loss, plus 2,500 wind turbines in your landscape. That is what it would cost to close Fessenheim, nothing for you to continue having electricity in Alsace.

If we were to replace the Fessenheim plant with a gas plant—I wanted to study all the options—it would require 500 million euros in gas imports per year, half a billion euros, which would worsen our trade balance—as if it needed it—and increase our dependence on gas and oil.

The closure of the Fessenheim reactors means the loss of jobs for 1,000 people, EDF employees and contractors! The consequences are dramatic for a region.

What should we prefer, to provide jobs for our industry by investing in our production fleet or to buy gas abroad every year? What a beautiful alternative. We would go write a check to buy half a billion euros worth of gas and, naturally, the 1,000 jobs lost here would increase the numbers at Pôle emploi, which really does not need it, given the crisis and unemployment we are experiencing.

If you extend, my dear compatriots, this reasoning, valid for the two reactors at Fessenheim, to the 24 units that some are considering closing, you will measure the catastrophic effects of such a decision.

That would then impose 10 billion euros in annual costs on the French economy.

That would destroy between 100,000 and 150,000 jobs due to the increased cost of electricity, which would lower the competitiveness of our companies in France, which need cheap electricity to be competitive.

Our trade balance would be worsened by 5 to 8 billion euros per year due to fossil fuel imports.

Our energy independence would be jeopardized.

And the entire nuclear sector, comprising 240,000 direct and indirect jobs, would be weakened. I add that we would then have fun trying to convince others to buy the nuclear plants we manufacture and that we would close here.

I wish good luck to all those who will go to India and China to propose our nuclear plants with the fine example of closing the same plants in France. That is to say, it would not be good for France, but it would be good for China or India.

Ladies and gentlemen, that would be a catastrophic choice.

The energy policy we are implementing is quite different. Regarding the current fleet, we will improve its safety, we will extend its lifespan. This is the solution that has been chosen by all countries that have plants of the same type as ours.

I add that when we say that Fessenheim is the oldest, yes, it was opened in 1977, but Fessenheim is much younger than the plants in Switzerland or the plants in the United States.

The average age of French reactors is 26 years, while it is 35 years for the American reactor fleet. And in this country, America, half of the 104 reactors in the fleet have already received authorization to operate for up to 60 years. EDF is studying with the ASN the conditions for extending our plants beyond 40 years.

These extension investments also generate a significant workload across the entire French nuclear sector. When, this year, you replaced the three steam generators of reactor number 2 at Fessenheim, that is as much work that was entrusted to the workers at the AREVA plant in Saint-Marcel. This year, it is an order of 1.1 billion euros for the supply of 32 steam generators that has been placed by EDF with AREVA.

It is our goal to enable, alongside nuclear energy, the development of renewable energies.

The United Kingdom has initiated a process to purchase third-generation reactors. 16 European countries are making the same choices as we are. We are not only investing in the nuclear sector, we are investing in all forms of energy, including renewable energies.

One euro for the development of nuclear energy, one euro for the development of renewable energies.

For nuclear, there will be the fourth generation ASTRID, there will be the JULES HOROWITZ research reactor, but our energy mix, our priority, is the reduction of fossil fuels. This is extremely important. We are acting on three levers: the nuclear sector, which I have mentioned, renewable energies, and energy efficiency. Nathalie KOSCIUSKO-MORIZET is accustomed to saying, rightly, that the best source of energy is energy savings. We have made a considerable effort on housing, which represents 43% of our national energy consumption.

For renewable energies, we have launched a call for tenders for 3,000 megawatts of offshore wind capacity that will be announced in the coming months. We are making considerable efforts for biomass and biogas.

The pace of development of renewable energies must be sustainable. Because the French must know that every time we make an effort for renewable energies, we increase the cost of electricity, because wind, photovoltaics, all renewable energies are more expensive than nuclear. I will also have the opportunity next week to visit Photowatt with the ministers, because thanks to EDF, we will present an industrial recovery plan for the employees of Photowatt.

In summary, my dear compatriots, France is not choosing total nuclear energy. France is choosing nuclear energy because we have a considerable lead. We will not close our reactors; we are working on the third generation and already on the fourth generation. At the same time, we are telling the French: "save energy, especially for your homes." This includes all the zero-interest loan systems to allow us to consume less energy in our homes.

Finally, we are developing renewable energies but at a sustainable pace. If tomorrow the price of electricity were to double in France, what would we say about purchasing power? And what would we say about the competitiveness of our companies?

So I say to the workers and employees of this plant, frankly, I would have preferred not to come to give this speech, because it would have proven that you were not threatened. But I can imagine what my state of mind would be if I were an employee of Fessenheim; it has been a year that I have been hearing people, whom I do not know, talk about my job, my future, making promises about what allows me to support my family, announcing the closure, without even having the courage to come meet the workers to say to them, "here is why I am going to close you."

And I can imagine for you, I can imagine it very well, regardless of your commitments, your sensitivities, the feeling that may be yours: do they not mock us? Do they know how things are on the ground? Do they realize that for us, this is our job, this is our livelihood, this is our salary? Do they know that we have chosen the nuclear sector because we believe it is a choice for the future? Do they realize that, worldwide, we are envied for this sector? Why do we want to sacrifice ourselves? On the altar of whom? On the altar of what? Do we really believe that we will restore the trust of the French in public speech with such behavior?

That we have differences is normal; it is democracy. But is there not enough that is going wrong in France to debate the things that are going wrong and that we need to improve, rather than to destroy the things that are going well and that we should not touch?

France's nuclear policy is an asset for France. We must not touch it.

Thank you.