Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the terrorist attacks against Christians in the Near and Middle East and the respect for religions in France and around the world, in Paris on January 7, 2011.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

7 January 2011 · Statement on the terrorist attacks against Christians in the Near and Middle East and respect for religions · Paris, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed French religious leaders at the Élysée Palace on January 7, 2011, condemning recent terrorist attacks targeting Christians in Egypt and Iraq.
Main themes
Terrorist attacks on Christians, Coptic community in Egypt, religious persecution in the Middle East, freedom of conscience, interfaith solidarity, martyrdom, condemnation of terrorism, France's diplomatic response, Baghdad church massacre, protection of religious minorities
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,844
73rd percentile
Sentences
150
81st percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
10.6
27th percentile
Syntax
2.83
25th percentile
Vocabulary
2.30
74th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 46%39%
  • Ceremonial 25%21%
  • Geopolitical 15%13%
  • Institutional 13%11%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 16%

150 sentences in 107 paragraphs

Mr. Cardinal,

Mr. Metropolitan,

Mr. Chief Rabbi,

Mr. President of the Consistoire Israélite de France,

Mr. Pastor,

Mr. President of the Muslim Faith,

Mr. Rector of the Mosque of Paris,

Mr. President of the Buddhist Union of France,

Excellencies,

Gentlemen representatives of the Eastern churches in France,

Madam Minister of State,

Mr. Minister,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

And if you will allow me, my dear friends,

One week ago today, women and men, who just moments before had been prostrated in prayer, were brutally murdered, their bodies torn apart by the shrapnel of a deadly bomb.

This was in Alexandria, on the night of December 31, in front of the Church of All Saints.

These women and men, sometimes accompanied by their children, were spiritually preparing for one of the main celebrations of the Christian world, Christmas.

A celebration that the Orthodox calendar marks thirteen days later than our Gregorian calendar.

Even as we entered the new year, they were living the Advent.

Today, on the date of Coptic Christmas, these men and women should have gathered with their families in this now bloodstained church to celebrate the Nativity.

I have, believe me, at this very moment, a very painful thought for their memory, to which I wish to pay a final tribute before you.

They were preparing to celebrate the birth of Christ; the fury of a suicide bomber condemned them to death.

They had just received and given Peace; they were killed with a weapon of War.

Their crime?

Practicing their religion.

Their crime?

Celebrating the birth of a "Savior" who for some is not the Messiah and for others is not the Prophet.

Their crime?

Belonging to a religious minority. A very ancient minority, a minority that piously preserves the memory of early Christianity, a vibrant and still clandestine Christianity. The Christianity of the Acts of the Apostles, of the Letters and Epistles. A minority that for nearly two thousand years has contributed to the immense cultural and human wealth of a country that is itself millennia old. A country where, for the first time in the History of Humanity, the idea of Monotheism appeared thirty-three centuries ago. A very beautiful, a very great country: Egypt.

This minority is, of course, the Coptic community, which derives its very name from its country, Egypt. A community whose representatives I wish to greet today, here at the Elysée, for this ceremony of wishes, sadly overshadowed by these tragedies.

A community to which I want to extend not only my personal condolences but the condolences of France.

France was deeply moved by this horrific tragedy on the evening of our New Year's Eve, but France is also worried because the massacre in Alexandria is unfortunately not an isolated act.

Equally monstrous events have sown, in recent weeks, consternation in the Middle East. The day before the Alexandria attack, on December 30, a dozen bombs placed in front of Christian homes in Baghdad spread death and terror.

In the same city two months earlier, an Al-Qaeda commando stormed the Syriac Cathedral in Baghdad and exterminated, there are no other words, sometimes with knives, more than fifty people. The victims, in this case, were preparing to celebrate All Saints' Day; they were mostly women and children. It seems that each time the liturgical calendar has been carefully consulted by the terrorists. It is not enough for them to kill worshippers; it is also necessary that these worshippers be barbarically murdered on festive days.

Each of the religions you represent here has its martyrs, and each venerates or celebrates them according to its rites.

In each of the religions you represent here, women and men have sacrificed their lives to defend their faith and thus their freedom to believe, for it is a freedom.

Each of the religions you represent has its martyrs, has been persecuted, and too often, alas, has been persecuted by perverting its name, I mean the name of your religion.

If I could, here, use the word martyr, then I would say that the martyrs of Alexandria or Baghdad are not solely Coptic, Syriac, or Maronite martyrs.

They are collectively our martyrs.

They are the martyrs of freedom of conscience.

The French do not accept, France will never accept that innocent people in prayer can be targeted by delirious and barbaric terrorism.

On behalf of France, I condemn these crimes with the utmost firmness, and France will continue to condemn these crimes from every platform that international law and its standing in the world provide. The Minister of State, Minister of Foreign Affairs will ensure this in the name of French diplomacy.

No human being can accept that one human being massacres another for what he is or for what he believes, which is the same thing. To attack an innocent life is to attack all of Humanity.

Thus, in the face of this unleashing of blind but diabolically orchestrated violence, I say it with emotion and firmness, on this morning of a special day for the Coptic community, turning to the representative of the Coptic Patriarchate of Alexandria, dear Father Lucas Guirguis, to assure him, in your name and well beyond this place, of our solidarity: in the church of Alexandria, it is all of Humanity that has been struck; it is Human Civilization that has been challenged.

Yes, the fate of Christians in the East concerns us all because it symbolizes, well beyond Christians and well beyond the East, the stakes of the globalized world in which we have entered irreversibly.

France is moved, France is worried. However, France does not merely lament; it acts.

The day after the October 31 attack on the Syriac church in Baghdad, the government organized the reception of one hundred and fifty Iraqi Christians injured in the attack. France had not waited for these tragedies to provide assistance to Christians in the East. As early as 2007, the French government had allowed men and women directly threatened to leave Iraq. More than a thousand benefited from this.

But—because there is a but—we must be careful; we cannot also accept and therefore facilitate what increasingly resembles—I use a strong word—a particularly perverse plan of cleansing the Middle East, of religious cleansing. In Iraq as in Egypt, Christians of the East are at home, and for the most part, they have been for 2000 years.

We cannot accept that this diversity, human, cultural, and religious, which is the norm in France, in Europe, and in most Western countries, disappears from this part of the world. The rights that are guaranteed to all religions in our country must be reciprocally guaranteed in other countries.

Each State, each civilization, each society has its laws, its principles, and its rules of communal life, but there are also universal principles to which the vast majority of the world's States have subscribed. These principles guarantee, as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights of 1966 does, the right to freedom of thought, the right to freedom of conscience, the right to freedom of religion.

Yet, in Pakistan, a mother has recently been sentenced to death.

Why? She is poor, she is Christian, she is a former untouchable.

Her name: Asia BIBI.

Her crime? Drinking from her neighbor's glass, which was seen as an impure act, a blasphemy.

Yes, there is a blasphemy law in Pakistan. This woman, Asia BIBI, has therefore been condemned. Voices have been raised in her own country to denounce this condemnation. These voices have paid dearly. But Asia BIBI's head has been put at a price by extremists.

If she is released, she risks death. France is concerned about this.

The Muslim community in France itself is, I know, the first horrified by the crimes committed in the name of Islam.

I want to personally thank Rector BOUBAKEUR for the very clear, very firm, and very kind words he spoke following the Alexandria attack.

But I also want to commend the initiative of the French Council of the Muslim Faith and its President Mohamed MOUSSAOUI, who sent a delegation to attend the Coptic Christmas mass in a sign of solidarity. A mass that was also attended by the Minister of the Interior.

The unanimous reactions in the Muslim world—including from governments or movements whose moderation is not always their main characteristic—testify to the absolutely massive rejection of these cowardly, barbaric attacks, which also aim, let us not be blind, to destabilize the countries where they occur.

Religion, tradition, the history of the Muslim world shows that it has always tolerated, sometimes even welcomed and protected those whom the Quran itself calls "the people of the book."

Should we remind ourselves that this Muslim world welcomed and protected Jews and Marranos fleeing a Europe under the formidable shadow of the Inquisition?

Not far from us, it is not useless to mention, especially in the current circumstances, the noble gesture of Emir ABDELKADER coming to the aid of the Maronite Christians of Damascus.

The results of a survey published the day before yesterday in a major evening newspaper, which shows that too large a third of the French and Germans surveyed consider Muslims a threat, concerns me and can only concern men and women of good will.

If such a religion is irrationally perceived, in our country, as a threat, we must combat this irrational reaction through mutual knowledge and understanding of the Other.

Islam has nothing to do with the hideous face of these God-crazed individuals who kill both Christians and Jews, Sunnis and Shiites. Fundamentalist terrorism also kills Muslims.

We know this well. You know this perfectly well, you men of faith and sincerity, but we must say it tirelessly if we do not want Western opinions, sincerely moved by this massacre of innocents, to lock themselves in distrust, in fear, and thus in amalgamation.

The threats that targeted Coptic churches in France a few days ago are unacceptable, and the government takes them very seriously. A security arrangement has been made so that the celebrations of Coptic Christmas, which concern several tens of thousands of faithful, can take place in the peace and serenity that are essential.

What applies to Coptic Christmas today obviously applies to all places of worship located on the territory and thus under the protection of the Republic.

Without, fortunately, going as far as the tragic events I have just alluded to, each time a cemetery is desecrated, each time a synagogue is violated, when a mosque or a church is the object of acts of vandalism or insults, the perpetrators of these acts will be sought, they will be judged, they will be punished. And I want to say here, how scandalized I am, to our friends and compatriots who are Muslims, by the degrading acts that took place last Sunday on the construction site of the mosque in Nogent-le-Rotrou. These acts, and I commit to this, will not go unpunished.

I will be very clear here about the principles and remind you of the Law, French Law, the Law that must be respected if one wishes to live freely on our soil, whether one is French or foreign.

The principle can be understood by all: everyone must be able, in France, to pray to the God of their choice, the very one they invoke in the secrecy of their innermost being, whether he is that of their ancestors or the one they have chosen through conversion.

Everyone must be able, in France, to pray in peace, security, and dignity. Prayer does not make noise, prayer does not offend, prayer does not aggress anyone.

Everyone must obviously have the right, in France, not to pray.

Everyone obviously has the right, in France, to proclaim that they have "neither God nor Master."

Everyone obviously has the right in France to profess the famous masters of suspicion, those famous thinkers like Nietzsche, Marx, or Freud, who shook many certainties and sometimes undermined convictions that were thought to be solid.

Everyone has the right in France to lose faith, to find it, or to rediscover it.

But beware, if the freedom of worship and thus the freedom of conscience are simply threatened, it is the very edifice of the Republic that wavers.

The freedom of worship and its immediate corollary, the freedom of conscience, are, just like freedom of expression and freedom of opinion, consubstantial to Democracy.

No one in France will attack it without finding before them the State and the French People themselves.

My conception of secularism is simple. It can be, I believe, accepted and understood by all:

A secular Republic ensures to each, in respect of absolute neutrality, the right to practice their faith, the right to believe, the right not to believe.

A secular Republic ensures to each faith and each believer the security without which it is impossible to fully live their faith.

A secular Republic maintains a permanent dialogue with the religions practiced on its soil in order to hear them, and sometimes, why not, to listen to them.

As if religions had nothing to tell us about the world in which we live?

As if religions had nothing to say about the society we are building?

No religion will ever dictate its conduct to the Republic, but in what way would the Republic be threatened by hearing what scholars, philosophers, and sociologists might have to say to it? This idea would not occur to anyone. So why this desire to exclude from the simple public debate those who seek an answer in divine transcendence?

How can one rightly demand dialogue at all levels of society and decide that believers must be confined to their churches, synagogues, temples, and mosques, only to be allowed to emerge as indistinguishable citizens?

Who can claim that one cannot be both at the same time?

The Republic intervenes only when practices, often wrongly presented as religious, infringe upon other democratic principles such as simple human dignity and that of women in particular. Dignity, equality between men and women, principles on which we will never compromise.

The Republic cannot accept that a religion occupies public space without its authorization. But at the same time, the Republic implies that it keeps its promises by allowing everyone to pray in dignified places.

The Republic protects religions and the exercise of worship with its laws and authority, but let us be very clear again, the Republic will never allow any religion, whatever it may be, to impose its law upon it.

I must be the guarantor of this just, secular, and protective Republic.

I must be the bulwark of this Republic.

The relationship between the State and religions is framed by a law that is over a century old. The law of 1905. No one contests it, even if some of our fellow citizens, in the three departments of Alsace and Moselle, live, for historical reasons, within a different framework. However, one must not confuse the law of 1905 with the anti-religious laws of 1793. Aristide Briand is not Chaumette.

The Republic does not have to wage some kind of war against God and against believers.

But since we are talking about the law, I want to refer here to our criminal law, which qualifies as aggravating circumstances a crime or offense motivated by the victim's belonging to a particular religion.

I repeat: I will never tolerate that in France, one can impunely attack an individual or groups of individuals because -- if we can call that a reason, let us not be too lenient -- of their religious convictions or the practice of the faith of the one who is victimized.

All the faithful you represent here, and I particularly address the representatives in France of the Eastern Churches due to the particular context that is ours, are placed under the protection of the French Republic, without distinction.

I sincerely wish that this ceremony of wishes could take place in a different climate, more serene, more peaceful, less solemn, as we were used to. But the gravity of the international situation and the threats it seems to pose to some of our fellow citizens have compelled me to make this clarification today before you.

This does not prevent me from extending to each of you and to the faithful you represent my best wishes for this new year.

May 2011 renew for you the joys that your priesthoods bring you.

May it give you peace, the peace of reflection, sometimes the peace of contemplation.

May it give you the strength and energy of this service to others that is at the very heart of your lives.

On this January 7, Christmas Day for the Copts, allow me to turn one last time to all the representatives of the Christians of the East who have honored us with their presence, to wish them, beyond mourning, beyond pain, and beyond sorrow, a very beautiful Christmas.

There is no other day, among all the Christians of the East or elsewhere, that can carry more towards hope.

Thank you.