Statement by Mr. Nicolas Sarkozy, President of the Republic, on the White Paper on Defense and National Security, Nuclear Deterrence, and Nuclear Non-Proliferation, in Cherbourg on March 21, 2008.

France Nicolas Sarkozy · President of France

21 March 2008 · Presentation of the White Paper on Defence and National Security · Cherbourg, France

Context
Sarkozy addressed workers, military personnel, and officials in Cherbourg on March 21, 2008, to present France's new White Paper on Defense and National Security and honor the launch of the submarine Le Terrible.
Main themes
Nuclear deterrence, White Paper on Defense and National Security, French strategic submarine fleet, nuclear non-proliferation, national security strategy, terrorism and new threats, European peace and Atlantic Alliance, defense budget and military modernization, tribute to fallen soldiers, French military pride and capability
Duration
~28 min
80th percentile
Words
3,377
80th percentile
Sentences
188
88th percentile
Readability
46
52nd percentile
Grade
11.3
36th percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 66%64%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Economic 5%5%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

188 sentences in 72 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

Mr. President, thank you for the remarkable work you have undertaken,

Mr. Minister, dear Hervé MORIN,

Mr. Minister, dear Jean-Marie BOCKEL,

Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians,

Mr. Mayor,

My general, I do not know why I say, My general, there must be several,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

It is a great pride for me to be here among you in Cherbourg, to salute all those who have built the Terrible, the fourth and last born of our strategic fleet. Right here, in 1967, General de Gaulle came to pay tribute to those of your colleagues who had built the Redoutable. Like your predecessors, you can be proud of this submarine, a symbol of high technology and France's determination to maintain control of its destiny. Very few countries in the world have the capacity to achieve such an industrial and technological feat. It took decades of learning to master such know-how, which some of our partners have struggled to rebuild after neglecting it. I want to tell you today how proud France is of you. I have come in its name to pay tribute to your work and your great skills.

Our nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines are an essential component of our nuclear deterrent capability. We owe it to the workers, technicians, engineers, military personnel, researchers, both military and civilian. I have come to tell you that maintaining, at the highest level, the skills necessary for deterrence is a fundamental objective for our security.

I wish to honor the memory of the eleven Frenchmen who died in the Karachi attack on May 8, 2002, your colleagues, your friends, your husbands, your fathers. I know that their loved ones are among us; I have informed them that I will meet with them in the next fifteen days at the Élysée, accompanied by the Minister of Defense, to provide an update on the progress of the investigation. I want to express my compassion to them. The Nation has not forgotten them and will not forget them.

I know the dedication and courage shown by all those who face danger to ensure our security and peace, in Europe and around the world. I want to tell them, on behalf of all the French, my support and my gratitude. France is proud of its soldiers; France trusts them.

The national tribute we paid last Monday to the fighters of the First World War reminded us, if it were needed, that in the past Europe has been a battlefield, let’s be clear, a field of ruins. It was between European states that most of the major conflicts were played out. Thanks to European construction and the Atlantic Alliance, we have built a Europe of peace. And never in history has our national security been so closely linked to that of our allies and European partners. Our common destiny is that of the European Union and beyond that of all nations that share our values: peace, freedoms, fraternity, the defense of the equal and irreducible dignity of men, regardless of their origins, beliefs, or the color of their skin.

But peace is never guaranteed. Mass terrorism has shown us this. Today we are faced with the assertion of new powers, new ambitions, new threats, and therefore new rivalries. Added to this are the risks arising from competition for access to raw materials and energy, the diversion of technologies for aggressive purposes, and, of course, climate change. In this interdependent world, our interests have no borders, even if they still have a geography.

The world has changed since the White Paper of 1994, which drew conclusions from the end of the Cold War and the Gulf War. The world is different, more unstable, more changeable, more complex. This does not mean that it is necessarily more dangerous; it means that it is less predictable than before. Our vulnerabilities have therefore changed, and our strategy must be re-examined accordingly. I do not want, because I do not have the right, for France, as it has too often done in the past, to prepare for the last war or to find itself disarmed in the face of a strategic surprise.

I have the responsibility to ensure that our armed forces are always able to face the threats to the Nation. I want to pursue the defense policy that France needs, not the defense policy of habits or old certainties. That is why I have requested the preparation of a new "White Paper on Defense and National Security," and not just on defense. Because now, the security of the French can be at stake as much far from our borders as within our territory.

For the same reason, I want us to be able to address all issues head-on. I owe transparency, I owe the truth to our armed forces; I owe transparency, I owe the truth to all the French.

The truth is this: I found, upon my arrival, a financial situation more than difficult: to achieve the 2015 army model, it would have required, according to the financial outlook for Defense, an increase of 6 billion euros per year in its equipment budget, a 40% increase. Who can tell me that this objective is even remotely credible?

These financial prospects represent a wall, incompatible with the commitment I made to the French and to our European partners, to restore the finances of the Nation, which has been in deficit for more than twenty-five years.

I do not intend to continue the methods of the past, those that have led to placing me in this situation, because everyone finds themselves losing: the national community, which has the legitimate concern that its defense and security needs are adequately covered; the head of state, the government, the Parliament, who are faced with the necessity of painful reorientations; and above all, first and foremost, the armed forces, which must constantly lament the delays in major armament programs, with their corollaries: aging equipment and skyrocketing maintenance costs. I refuse to be presented with a fait accompli and to resign myself to having no room for maneuver. The duty of every administration, civilian and military, is to do everything to preserve the President's room for maneuver and the government's freedom of action. The duty of every political leader is to create room for maneuver to fully exercise their decision-making capacity.

I have chosen to build the future with a few simple markers: our strategy, our ambitions, our alliances, the European objective. And one principle, also simple: I absolutely exclude lowering our guard. The defense budget is the second largest budget of the State. It will remain so; it will not decrease; I have already committed to this, and I renew this commitment solemnly. But I will propose the choices, too long obscured, that will reconcile the protection of the French, the independence of the country, and its financial sovereignty.

To guide the military effort of the country, I will not rely on analyses that are fifteen years old. I have requested a White Paper for the beginning of the 21st century, which proposes a comprehensive concept of national defense and security for our country and its interests, looking ahead to the next 15 years. Based on the major functions that our armed forces must assume, the Commission must formulate clear orientations that will allow us, with the Minister of Defense, to make strategic and political choices.

The 2015 army model has been recognized as obsolete by the White Paper Commission. Everyone knows that, moreover, this model was unrealistic; it was not said to the French, well, I am telling them. I therefore refuse to start from this army model, simply to note renunciations. It is futile to indefinitely pursue unattainable models. Just as it is futile to claim to build a relevant model by merely settling for the degradation of outdated models. Moreover, can there be an immutable army model for the defense of our country? When threats change, when our strategy evolves, is it not normal that our military effort is renewed as well?

To ensure the protection of the French, their defense tool must be as operational and effective as possible. I will draw all conclusions with the utmost realism. We will carry out the reforms. This is the mandate given to me by the French. This exemplary process of reform and rationalization, which Hervé Morin has already initiated, will be carried out entirely for the benefit of the defense tool and those who serve it.

So that we can prepare it constructively and without taboos, I have chosen to open the reflection.

The White Paper Commission - chaired by Jean-Claude Mallet - is composed of personalities from very diverse backgrounds. Parliament is closely associated with it, from the outset and at every stage of the reflection. The Senate and National Assembly Commissions will be consulted on the draft White Paper. The White Paper will be presented by the Prime Minister to the national representation. I would have liked to do it myself as Chief of the Armed Forces, but for now, the Constitution prohibits me from doing so. I hope that the next revision of the Constitution will correct what has become an anomaly and more generally strengthen the prerogatives of Parliament, particularly regarding everything that touches on our national defense effort. There will need to be as much debate as necessary. Parliament will express its views on the choices I will make, with the Prime Minister and the ministers, since, at the end of the work, a new military programming law will be submitted to Parliament.

I will render my decisions at the appropriate time and explain them to the Nation. You can be assured that I will assume all my responsibilities, for what worries the most is not the prospect of choices, but the absence of decision. Choices will be made, so that the defense policy is the most useful, the most relevant, in service of a great ambition for France and for Europe.

My first duty as head of state and head of the armed forces is to ensure that, in all circumstances, France, its territory, its people, its republican institutions, are secure. And that, in all circumstances, our national independence and our autonomy of decision are preserved.

Nuclear deterrence is the ultimate guarantee of this. Recognizing this reality is the heavy responsibility of every President of the Republic. I wish today to share with you my thoughts on this subject.

Of course, looking ahead to the White Paper, that is to say, 15 years, France no longer runs the risk of invasion. However, other threats weigh on our security. Some nuclear arsenals continue to grow. Nuclear proliferation, biological proliferation, chemical proliferation continues, as does that of ballistic and cruise missiles.

Everyone must be aware today that nuclear missiles from powers, even distant ones, can reach Europe in less than half an hour. Today, only great powers have such means. But other countries, in Asia or the Middle East, are rapidly developing ballistic capabilities.

I am thinking particularly of Iran. Iran is increasing the range of its missiles, while serious suspicions hang over its nuclear program. It is indeed the security of Europe that is at stake.

In the face of proliferation, the international community must be united and resolute; the international community must be resolute. Because we want peace, we must be unwavering with those who violate international norms. But all those who respect them have the right to just access to nuclear energy for peaceful purposes.

But we must also be ready to face other risks than proliferation. The imagination of our potential aggressors is limitless in exploiting the vulnerabilities of Western societies. And tomorrow, technological advances may create new threats.

That is why we hold on to our nuclear deterrence. It is strictly defensive. The use of nuclear weapons would only be conceivable in extreme circumstances of legitimate defense, a right enshrined in the United Nations Charter.

Our nuclear deterrence protects us from any state-originating aggression against our vital interests - wherever it comes from and in whatever form. These include, of course, the constitutive elements of our identity and existence as a nation-state, as well as the free exercise of our sovereignty. My responsibility, as Head of State, is to assess its limits at all times, for in a changing world, those limits cannot be fixed.

Anyone who threatens to attack our vital interests would expose themselves to a severe response from France, resulting in unacceptable damage to them, out of proportion to their objectives. It would then be primarily the centers of political, economic, and military power that would be targeted.

We cannot exclude the possibility that an adversary may misinterpret the delineation of our vital interests, or our determination to safeguard them. In the context of deterrence, it would then be possible to issue a nuclear warning, which would signify our resolve. It would be intended to restore deterrence.

For deterrence to be credible, the head of state must have a wide range of options in the face of threats. Our nuclear forces have been adapted accordingly. They will continue to be adapted. The M51 intercontinental missile, which the Terrible will carry as soon as it enters service in 2010, and the ASMPA missile that the Rafale will carry starting this year, respond to the risk analysis outlined in the White Paper.

I am also convinced that it is essential to maintain two nuclear components, one oceanic and one airborne. Indeed, their respective characteristics, particularly in terms of range and precision, make them complementary. To face any surprise, the head of state must be able to rely on them at all times.

In order to preserve our freedom of action, missile defense capabilities against a limited strike could be a useful complement to nuclear deterrence, without of course substituting for it. Let us not lose sight of the fact that missile defense will never be effective enough to safeguard our vital interests. On this issue, France has chosen a pragmatic approach. It is in this spirit that we participate in collective work within the framework of the Atlantic Alliance - dear Hervé MORIN. We have solid technical expertise in this area, which could be put to good use when the time comes.

Ensuring the security of the Nation comes at a significant cost. Each year, nuclear deterrence costs the French people half of the budget for justice or for transportation. This cost must, of course, be controlled as much as possible, in the financial context I mentioned earlier. But I am determined to bear this cost. It is neither a matter of prestige nor a question of rank; it is simply the life insurance of the Nation.

Our deterrence also takes into account the evolution of the world, our alliances, and European construction.

With the United Kingdom, we have made a major decision; we have noted that there is no situation in which the vital interests of one would be threatened without the interests of the other being threatened as well.

As for the Atlantic Alliance, its security also relies on nuclear deterrence. British and French nuclear forces contribute to this. This has been part of the strategic concept of the Alliance since 1974 and remains relevant today. I say this to all our allies: France is and will remain faithful to its commitments under Article V of the North Atlantic Treaty.

Regarding Europe, it is a fact that French nuclear forces, by their mere existence, are a key element of its security. An aggressor contemplating a challenge to Europe must be aware of this.

Let us draw all the logical consequences together: I propose to engage in an open dialogue with those of our European partners who wish to discuss the role of deterrence and its contribution to our common security.

Our commitment to the security of our European partners is the natural expression of our ever-closer union. The Lisbon Treaty marks, in this regard, a historic advance.

I would now like to address disarmament. This is a subject I wish to approach with realism and clarity. When international security improves, France draws the necessary conclusions. It did so with the end of the Cold War.

Rather than making speeches and promises without translating them into action, France acts. It respects its international commitments, particularly the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons. It has today an exemplary record, unique in the world, in terms of nuclear disarmament. France, the first state, along with the United Kingdom, to have signed and ratified the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty; France, the first state to have decided to close and dismantle its facilities for the production of fissile materials for explosive purposes; France, the only state to have transparently dismantled its nuclear test site located in the Pacific; France, the only state to have dismantled its ground-to-ground nuclear missiles; France, the only state to have voluntarily reduced the number of its nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines by one third.

France has never participated in the arms race. France has never developed all the types of weapons that its technological capabilities would have allowed it to design. France applies a principle, that of strict sufficiency: it maintains its arsenal at the lowest possible level, compatible with the strategic context. This is a principle to which I am committed. I requested, upon taking office, that this strict sufficiency be reassessed.

This has led me to decide on a new disarmament measure: for the airborne component, the number of nuclear weapons, missiles, and aircraft will be reduced by one third.

I have also decided that France could and should be transparent about its nuclear arsenal, as no one in the world has yet done.

After this reduction, our arsenal will comprise fewer than 300 nuclear warheads. This is half the maximum number of warheads we had during the Cold War.

By providing this information, France is fully transparent because it has no other weapons than those in its operational stocks.

Furthermore, I confirm that none of our weapons is targeted against anyone.

Finally, I have decided to invite international experts to come and verify the dismantling of our military fissile material production facilities in Pierrelatte and Marcoule.

But let us not be naive; the very foundation of collective security and disarmament is reciprocity.

Today in the world, eight states have declared that they have conducted nuclear tests. Well, I propose to the international community an action plan on which I call upon nuclear powers to commit resolutely, by the time of the NPT conference in 2010.

I invite all countries to ratify the Comprehensive Nuclear-Test-Ban Treaty, starting with China and the United States, who signed it in 1996. It is time to ratify it.

I urge nuclear powers to dismantle all their nuclear test sites, transparently and open to the international community.

I propose to immediately launch negotiations on a treaty banning the production of fissile materials for nuclear weapons and to establish an immediate moratorium on the production of these materials.

I invite the five nuclear powers recognized by the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons to agree on transparency measures.

I propose the opening of negotiations on a treaty banning short- and intermediate-range ground-to-ground missiles.

I call on everyone to adhere to and implement the Hague Code of Conduct against the proliferation of ballistic missiles, as France has done.

In parallel, it is in all other areas of disarmament that the international community must mobilize. Here too, France will contribute.

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I have come to deliver a simple message to the Nation: its security will be assured in the face of the threats of the world, and France will play its full role in the defense of peace and its values. I want France to have an ambition worthy of its history.

This requires being clear-eyed about the realities and strategic choices.

This requires having the courage to make the necessary decisions. You can count on me to do so.

Above all, this requires being clear and firm about what is essential. And the essential is the safeguarding of France's vital interests.

I stand here, in Cherbourg, as the guarantor of that. France will not let its guard down. Thank you.