Intervention of the President of the Government at the Delphi Economic Forum in Athens

Spain Pedro Sánchez · Prime Minister of Spain

10 May 2021 · Delphi Economic Forum · Athens, Greece

Context
Sánchez spoke at the Delphi Economic Forum in Athens on May 10, 2021, addressing EU pandemic coordination, the digital vaccination certificate, and global vaccine access.
Main themes
EU digital COVID vaccination certificate, European coordination and unity, pandemic crisis management lessons, strategic autonomy, global vaccine access and patents, technology transfer, European Health Agency, third-country travel recommendations, vaccine distribution
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,052
76th percentile
Sentences
147
80th percentile
Readability
45
47th percentile
Grade
12.1
46th percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
31st percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 26%25%
  • Economic 25%24%
  • Ceremonial 18%18%
  • Geopolitical 16%16%
  • Social 15%14%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

147 sentences in 73 paragraphs

P.- Yes, perhaps I can ask you. The European Parliament insists that, well, they want this certificate to go further. The Council asks that it be ready as soon as possible, so that it is as comprehensive as possible, so that people know what they can do with this certificate in great detail, is this the approach?

President.- Well, first of all, let me thank Kyriakos and the Delphi Economic Forum for inviting me, Prime Minister, Commissioner, Minister.

Well, it is a pleasure and I thank you for being here. I agree with Kyriakos, well, there is a trilogue and the important thing is to reach an agreement in June, because we need to be able to create a safe space to ensure European mobility. In my opinion, and to add a little more to what Kyriakos has said, the important thing is that we learn a lesson from this crisis. At the beginning of this crisis, the management by the European Union was not sufficient. There was a lack of information, data, and information exchange among the Member States.

We did not know exactly how the pandemic was evolving, especially at the beginning, during the first months, and I believe that this digital vaccination certificate will also improve our coordination and cooperation against the virus. I think we are about to take a very important step with this certificate, and I believe that these ideas that the Commission has put forward, for example, in the case of the European Health Agency, and by the way, Barcelona would be a great headquarters, eh, Commissioner, I throw this idea out from here.

This is part of one of the lessons we need to learn in order to apply these conclusions and for future pandemics, well, to have better crisis management.

(KYRIAKOS INTERVENES)

And also Kyriakos, there is another issue because we are talking about this vaccination certificate, but the Commission is also reviewing the recommendation for third countries, countries outside the European Union. And I think it is very important that we maintain unity among the Member States to provide a unified response. Unique recommendations towards third countries that are not part of the European Union.

(KYRIAKOS INTERVENES)

Yes, moreover, it is something that has to be consistent with what the certificate is, there has to be a review of the recommendations for third countries and the digital vaccination certificate. So it is something that the Commission has to propose.

(KYRIAKOS INTERVENES)

P.- And that is something we have already learned. This is one of the lessons we learned from the crisis, when there are new competencies that should be community competencies, well, better management is also needed, not only of travel within the borders of the European Union, but also from outside. Mr. Sánchez, President, is there anything else you would like to comment on? Because this coordination you were talking about, well, has yielded diverse results throughout this year. In what other area should the European Union adopt more coordinated decisions?

President.- In many areas, in many areas. I believe that strategic autonomy is one of the lessons we have learned; we all remember the precariousness, the lack of materials, of basic elements for production, at the beginning, right?

I also want to congratulate Kyriakos because he was one of the first European leaders to state in an article that vaccines must be a global public good.

Now we have this debate around patents; what is going to be done, what is the European Union going to do after the statement from the U.S. government a few days ago regarding patents? I also support this approach. I think we should ask the U.S. government to export the vaccines they are not using. In the European Union, we are exporting more than 130 million doses of vaccines, but it is not enough, it is not enough.

We have to raise the issue of patents, and I think this is important too. Not only from the point of view of access but also from the point of view of technology transfer to strengthen the capacity to produce those vaccines and also to accelerate the distribution of vaccines worldwide.

So this lesson of universal access to vaccines will be one of the main lessons, one of the main debates we will face this year.

P.- There is something that interests me quite a bit, and that has to do with how governments have been able to manage this crisis, and that will be evaluated by citizens when they go to the polls. Is there anything that they have been able to learn from each other, well, from the management of the crisis?

President.- Yes, in my case, well, the capacity for testing in Greece, and that was evident, especially at the beginning of the pandemic, so that is something that I think marked the difference between the situation in Greece and other governments and other states.

(KYRIAKOS INTERVENES)

President.- It is a difficult decision, with great uncertainty, because even in the scientific field, not much was known about the virus, especially at the beginning of the pandemic.

I believe that one of the main lessons we need to draw from this crisis is the need to strengthen our healthcare system, especially primary care.

I don’t know if the same happens in Greece, but in the case of Spain, over the last two decades, regional governments built hospitals, which is very good and important, but it is also very important and necessary to strengthen primary care. It is crucial to be able to prevent health crises like the one we are currently experiencing.

P.- We have learned many lessons, and it is clear that now, well, there is the issue of lockdowns, which obviously carry an economic cost. As you know, we already saw it in the fall of GDP last year.

We have seen it in other indicators, such as other indicators from international organizations, such as in Spain, an increase in unemployment, especially among the youth.

President.- How can we prevent this generation from paying the highest price? Well, this is the main challenge we have ahead, the youth and also women. Young people, women are the social groups that have been most affected by this crisis. As is usually the case.

In my opinion, what we need to do now in the European Union is to rethink, rethink our vocational training system to, well, provide skills and abilities to these people, right?, because there is going to be a brutal change in the labor landscape.

There will be two very important transformations: the digital and the ecological.

And well, that is why in the design we have made in the Spanish Government regarding the Recovery and Resilience Fund, human capital, vocational training, the change and modernization of our educational system, also of universities, is one of the main pillars, because obviously we have to provide skills and competencies and new competencies to these people, because there will be new jobs and we have to create opportunities for young people.

QUESTION.- The National Recovery and Resilience Plan, which you refer to by simplifying a lot, consists of reducing dependence on the services sector and developing the green and digital sectors.

How is that recovery plan going to transform the Spanish economy? Because what you have described was a challenge that already existed before the pandemic.

President.- Well, the Spanish plan has about 210 lines of investments, reforms. So we are starting a period of great transformation in Spain, right?, a transformation of great depth due to this plan.

We are talking about 140 billion euros for the next six years. 40 percent of this amount will focus on ecological transformation, 30 percent on digital transformation, 10 percent on what will be investment in human capital, and 7 percent on R&D and science investments. I believe it is a very specific plan in which we propose very specific reforms, very specific measures, which are also very ambitious, and I think it is a great opportunity to really transform the Spanish economy, modernize it.

The impact on our economy, according to the calculations we have made, would be about two points more in terms of GDP.

P.- Per year?

President.- No. I am talking about an increase of two points over the next six years, and we would be talking about about 300,000 new jobs linked to these public investments.

(KYRIAKOS INTERVENES)

P.- Well, concessions had to be made in some areas, and the Chancellor had to be convinced, of course.

President.- I believe that history will remember that in 2020, well, something very good happened for those who believe in the integration of the European Union, because if you look at what we achieved during a year that was critical and totally unprecedented, we not only saw the commitment of the European Central Bank, but also the SURE unemployment instrument, the joint purchase of vaccines, the vaccination certificate that we started to propose last year, and, obviously, the recovery and resilience mechanism, the recovery and resilience fund.

For me, this is a fundamental achievement from a political point of view. It is a political achievement comparable to the European single market, the entry of our countries into the European Union, or the single currency, the euro.

Right now we are still very close to that date, but in history, well, I believe that when people look back, they will see that this agreement was one of the main steps towards European integration.

P.- Well, are we facing a Hamiltonian moment?

President.- No, no, let’s see. What I believe is that there were many countries that were driving this debate with non-papers, with joint letters to the Commission, with meetings with the German Chancellor, with President Macron. Well, in the end, obviously, well, I remember those debates, especially with the northern European countries, with the Scandinavian countries.

One of the main reasons why they ultimately decided to reach an agreement is because the Recovery and Resilience Fund also represents a defense of the European single market, which is ultimately one of the main achievements of the construction of the European Union.

So the territorial dimension of this crisis is something we have to keep in mind, because the territorial divergence that could arise after this pandemic, which this pandemic could generate, was something that was going to be totally disruptive.

And that is something we all understood.

We saw that we had to strengthen the single market with this type of massive public investment.

P.- Besides those very concrete results, you spoke of austerity policies, do you think that the management of this crisis will have a positive impact on the reputation of the European Union in its respective countries, where perhaps there was also quite a bit of [inaudible]?

President.- Absolutely. Yes, yes. I believe that not only due to the fund but also due to the vaccines. And also, well, thanks to this coordination effort that we are promoting regarding the health of the European Union.

So obviously the image we gave as Europeans, as a European political project, is the opposite of what we gave after the financial crisis of 2008. And in the end, what we did was provide a positive response, not only to the crisis we were suffering, but, as Karyakos has said, this change, this brutal transformation, such as the digital and ecological transformations.

And so, well, we start from this triple inclusive approach: territorial, intergenerational, and gender. So these three inclusive perspectives were focused on these two main transitions. And I believe that is also the core of the Recovery and Resilience Fund.

P.- And is one fund enough, is a second one needed, or should it be a permanent measure that allows for joint borrowing in the European Union?

(KYRIAKOS INTERVENES)

President.- Well, to revisit Mr. Mitsotakis's reflection. If we compare the figures for public investment in my country, Spain, after the financial crisis of 2008, the level of public investment was ridiculous, somewhat depressing. The figures were very low because we did not have financial leeway to increase that public investment. The Recovery and Resilience Fund gives us the possibility to increase public investment.

But here the crucial question is the one Karyakos just raised. This public investment plan has to generate the financial conditions to then improve what are private investments, because what is ultimately needed is to create the conditions for sustainable investments, sustainable policies, not only from the energy point of view but also from the digital transformation, human capital, etc.

So if you take a look at Spain's plan, well, we focus mainly on the digitalization of the public sector. Also on the reform of Justice. And I already said it before, the vocational training system and the educational system. We are talking about major reforms that we need to develop in our countries, and the Recovery and Resilience Fund gives us the capacity to develop these reforms, but with a positive approach. And I believe that this is the fundamental difference between the situation we are living now and the one we suffered after the financial crisis.

P.- And part of the integration has to do with having some kind of emergency system, let's say. This is what the austerity countries wanted, that there would be some emergency system if those national recovery and resilience plans did not work. In any of the responses from the Commission that you have received, have they mentioned anything that could trigger alarms and require that intervention?

[KYRIAKOS INTERVENES]

President.- So far, the discussions we have had with the Commission have been very positive, very positive. And in the end, our citizens must know that all the reforms included in our plans are reforms that are already public. People know them. They are reforms that were also included in the specific country recommendations, which, on the other hand, are part of the agreement we reached in June 2020.

The experience we have had so far with the Commission during all these months of negotiation, from July until now, has been very positive.

P.- Well, change also occurs by drawing conclusions after facing a crisis. This year is a very interesting year from the perspective of European politics, as the German Chancellor, Mrs. Merkel, has said, she will retire this year. So, how do you see Europe after the era of Chancellor Merkel? Do you think it will change a lot, or are you already accustomed to it in the Council?

Well, I was not… I was not president during the financial crisis of 2008. I remember the reputation that the German government had at that time in my country. But right now, public opinion thinks just the opposite. I believe that Mrs. Merkel and her figure will endure in history. She will be considered one of the main leaders who was able to provide positive responses and endow the European project with this pro-European vision to address the various challenges it faced.

I have a very good and fluid relationship with Angela Merkel, although we come from different political groups, but I see that she has a much more pro-European vision than even some colleagues from my political group at the European level.

And I believe she quickly understood that this economic crisis, this social crisis unleashed by the pandemic from the beginning, well, had to have a different response than what the European Union was able to provide during the financial crisis of 2008.

[KYRIAKOS INTERVENES]

President.- Her presidency was remarkable, not only from the perspective of the Recovery and Resilience Fund agreement. The agreement with China regarding investments. So I believe her presidency has been more than notable, that of last year.

P.- I would like to ask you one last question, because we need to start gathering these reflections and recapping. We see that there is a question that differentiates you. I find it striking that your family has been in politics for a long time. Yours has not, Mr. Sánchez. So I would like to know, at what point did you decide that you wanted to dedicate yourselves to politics? At what moment did this idea arise for you?

President.- Well, in my case, I was very young, I was 14 years old. My grandparents could neither read nor write, and I realized the injustice of the dictatorship, which had lasted 40 years in Spain. When I was 14, President Felipe González was already in office, and I realized that the Socialist Party was a party that was able to modernize Spain, that made it possible for Spain to join the European Union at that time and everything that happened afterward.

So if I had to answer that question, what was that moment? Well, it was when I saw that it was my grandparents, my grandparents, who could not read or write and who had suffered this historical injustice that many people suffered during Franco's dictatorship in Spain.

[KYRIAKOS INTERVENES]

P.- Last question for both of you. You must have seen an erosion of the political landscape in the European Union and also in your countries, right? How do you see the classic political parties of the center, left, or right? Do you think they still have a long future ahead of them?

President.- Well, I believe this crisis vindicates social democrats. Really, when we talk about solidarity between generations, climate change, we are talking about social democracy. Or at least that is how I understand social democracy.

When we talk about the need for a strong, robust welfare state, a robust healthcare system, well, we are obviously talking about the foundations of social democracy in Europe.

When we talk about the need for an inclusive perspective regarding this great transformation we are experiencing, the digital transition, well, I believe we are also talking about social democracy, so in the end, in the past, Europe has evolved and has become what it is today thanks to the approach of this social democratic vision to provide the responses that our society needed in the past, that it needs now, and that it will need in the future, which I believe social democrats will obviously have an increasing presence in the future.