Prime Minister Poul Nyrup Rasmussen's speech at the conference marking the 100th anniversary of the September Agreement, September 1, 1999.

Denmark Poul Nyrup Rasmussen · Prime Minister of Denmark

1 September 1999 · Conference marking the 100th anniversary of the September Agreement · The Royal Library, 'The Black Diamond', Denmark

Context
Rasmussen addressed a conference at the Royal Library in Copenhagen on September 1, 1999, marking the 100th anniversary of the September Agreement.
Main themes
September Agreement centenary, Danish labor market model, history of Danish labor movement, collective bargaining, employer-union relations, Danish welfare society, social partnership, Danish exceptionalism in Europe, industrial society origins, class struggle and conflict resolution, corporatism vs. Danish model, mutual recognition and agreements
Duration
~34 min
86th percentile
Words
4,047
86th percentile
Sentences
253
93rd percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.71
13th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from Danish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 32%30%
  • Economic 32%30%
  • Social 18%17%
  • Geopolitical 9%8%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

253 sentences in 99 paragraphs

The Royal Library, 'The Black Diamond'.

The Danish model lives on.

I am pleased that we have become quite wealthy here in the country. Otherwise, we would not be able to sit here in such beautiful surroundings.

Our wealth has not come by chance. It has not come in quite the same way as in many other countries. Therefore, the wealth of our country also has a very special character.

The wealth has come because the start of the industrial society was based on the simple principle: 'An agreement is an agreement. If you recognize us, then we recognize you. If there is a disagreement about what we have agreed upon, then it must also be resolved.'

Trivialities? Perhaps okay today - but it was not so back then. Back in the early days of the labor movement, when the industrial society was being born, the class struggle was indeed in full swing. Here, as in all of Europe.

In the late 1800s, the struggles unfolded - some places more peacefully than others. Seen in the light of history, it happened peacefully here with us.

With the message 'Community makes strong', the workers joined together in groups and trade unions, and with targeted actions, called 'turning screws', the workers pressured the employers with varying success to give them better working conditions.

The conditions were harsh back then.

When we see 'Pelle the Conqueror', when we visit the Workers' Museum, when we walk in Copenhagen out in Nørrebro, it also gives us a sense of how it was back then. Copenhagen, the construction workers - yes, they won with varying success, but the working conditions were terrible. Horrific housing conditions, poverty, and toil.

This is how it looked in the beginning!

On their side, the employers banded together in what is now known as the Danish Employers' Association. This allowed the employers to centralize control and use lockouts to counter the workers' actions. The workers' countermeasure was to form LO, the Danish Confederation of Trade Unions.

The dynamics we see here are special in Europe - in the sense that the movement towards a unified employer side and a unified trade union side was unique. The opposition between the two sides and the actions taken at that time were not so special compared to the rest of Europe.

But one of the secrets of today's welfare society is how to resolve that conflict. Could it be resolved by bringing it into some frameworks that ensured we did not unnecessarily use resources that could have been used differently for the construction of society? - or was it the constant unregulated struggle that drew resources to itself and affected production?

We could have chosen a different direction than the one that drew resources to itself and affected production. We could have chosen a different direction than the one we chose. I do not believe that the Danish choice was random. It is worth remembering that we did not choose a French or Italian direction, where factories were occupied, - and where there was not even complete agreement on what kind of labor movement was occupying what. That has plagued them ever since, as you know.

When we compare the currents in Europe with what happened in Denmark, I think we can be proud. We chose a Danish direction. There were no role models from other countries; it was completely unique.

* * *

We entered the September Agreement, which became and remains the cornerstone of the agreement model that has now lasted for over 100 years.

The September Agreement of 1899 is fundamentally important for everything that followed. An agreement is an agreement. It still is. If there is doubt about how the agreement should be interpreted, we have someone to interpret it for us. It is still not known in many places in the rest of Europe.

If you recognize us, then we recognize you. This is also not taken for granted in the rest of Europe. There are still countries, such as Italy and France, where trade unions cannot agree on who should represent the collective agreement - even though the employers say they are willing to negotiate with whoever represents the company.

We used our efforts wisely to produce a foundation for a society to grow up and benefit the poor, benefit the workers, benefit the employers, benefit the industry, benefit our society.

This is not a corporatist society. A corporatist society - that was what we saw under dictatorial rule in Spain and Portugal: The Danish model is a completely different kind. It is Danish, and it is based on mutual respect, careful balance, and well-prepared techniques and approaches. And the state's respect for the parties, not the state's dictate of the parties, as we have seen in Portugal and Spain. And not a dictator like in Spain, who at that time 'bought' some of the Spanish workers - the rest were thrown in prison - by giving them job security in their working conditions.

The September Agreement was a natural consequence of the developments of the preceding years, which the parties themselves had led.

They found the solution themselves. Without state intervention. Or almost without state intervention. For there were in the state - then as now - wise people who said: We think it is wise that you now want to negotiate your way to agreement period by period. But you have a problem: Who will determine what is right and wrong if a dispute arises during the interpretation? Therefore, part of the agreement was the establishment of a permanent arbitration court to resolve disputes about the agreement. Only the state could provide that. We made a commitment and implemented it after the agreement in full accordance with the parties.

The state showed the parties its acceptance by transferring a public institution, which was not defined as 'public' at the time, to a private body, which was also not entirely defined as private.

The time immediately after the September Agreement showed that the state recognized the agreement as the cornerstone of the labor market and the development of the labor law system.

This delicate sense of the three parties' roles in relation to each other is again a very crucial cornerstone in understanding the secrets behind the Danish welfare society as we know it today.

One could say that the state acts as a midwife in solving the practical problems that arose in the wake of the September Agreement. In 1908, the famous 'August Committee' was established. It was a state committee, but it was characteristic that the members were representatives of the parties. The chairman was an independent jurist. Then came the laws on the Labor Court and the Conciliation Institution, which meant that the state followed the committee's recommendations.

* * *

The September Agreement and the follow-up on the work of the August Committee became the background for the labor law system that we know today. That it is the parties that are the driving force in the system is perhaps best seen in that something as important as the right to strike and lockout is not regulated by legislation.

It is not without reason that the September Agreement and the subsequent main agreement are called the Labor Market Constitution. So even back then, conflicts in the labor market were something the parties had to resolve themselves. Proximity and responsibility yield the best solutions.

In parallel with the development and organization of the labor market, we began the construction of the Danish welfare society. It was an unspoken mutual prerequisite and, in reality, also mutual dependence. Stability in the labor market and gradually advancing responsible improvements were the prerequisites for the construction of the welfare society.

But there was something else that also emerged. A mutual understanding that conflicts would inevitably arise along the way. There have been conflicts since the beginning. Nevertheless, today we can say that the Danish model in our society is not a contradiction to competitiveness and employment growth but a prerequisite for it.

* * *

This is, in fact, the lesson of history: The interplay between the modern welfare society, - which is based on the fact that we can all count on a fundamental security if things go wrong for us - and wise agreements – This interplay is the prerequisite for our country to have the greatest human and thus also labor market mobility.

One does not become less mobile due to security; one becomes more. One dares to take chances, pursue education, change jobs if one is sure that one is not lost, even if one has lost once or twice. Therefore, I have always believed that the description of the Danish model also includes that we have an unemployment benefit system that is fundamentally important for the collective agreement models to function as they do.

My message today is therefore also: We are not at sunset for the Danish model or the Danish welfare society at this turn of the century. We are at dawn!

It would be a fundamental mistake to believe that a deterioration or a fundamental replacement of the unemployment benefit system would lead us into a better world - that is what economists call 'incentive structure', I believe.

I would like to say that there is no good alternative to the unique combination of wise agreements and an unemployment benefit system that ensures that people do not face an economic downturn when they become unemployed, but that they can use the period of unemployment to qualify for new jobs.

We have seen other paths. Take Germany: Instead of an unemployment benefit system like the Danish, one gets such long notice periods that neither German workers, society, nor employers benefit from.

I believe that in the global next period for the Danish model, we are better equipped to handle the challenges of globalization than many others. We have seen that the unique combination of welfare, agreements, and the unemployment benefit system has led us to manage the tremendous changes the agreement model has undergone - from central to decentralized negotiations. We still have negotiations, still have agreements, still have orderly conditions, not unregulated, not jungle laws, - but still always the mutual respect, regardless of what level we are working at. And we have created the trust representative system, which in my opinion is completely unique and incredibly important to take good care of.

Modernize - yes, we must always do that, but we must take care of the foundation.

* * *

The National Labor Council is not found in many other places in the world either. Here, the labor market parties also take responsibility for how things are going centrally and regionally with the Danish labor market. Not just a market, but to a large extent an awareness on both sides that it is people, and educated people, who are Denmark's most important raw material.

And thus, the next big step we have slowly begun to take is the modernization of our adult and continuing education system. It is immensely important to organize it well and wisely. A long and careful process lies ahead of us, but both parties must again play a very important role - in collaboration with the government and the state.

It is the constructive interest opposition, where energy is channeled into forward-looking avenues. It is not the destructive jungle-like power.

* * *

The Swedish Nobel laureate in economics, Gunnar Myrdahl, once said: 'The only miracle I wish to talk about is the Danish one.' And Gunnar Myrdahl certainly notes how it can be that this country, Denmark, has become, yes, perhaps the world's richest society in the way we now like to measure it. The opportunities were fewer here than in so many other places. Nevertheless, the average economy per capita is greater than in most other places, and we also try to distribute welfare, regardless of who one is born to, better than in other places. And that is the model Myrdahl is concerned with.

The Danish model has shown that it is incredibly flexible. Just take a little trip back in history. We got through the great lockout in the 1920s. We got through stagnation in the 1930s with deep poverty. The war in the 1940s. The major conflict in the 1950s. Growth in the 1960s. Then came the war again, the great oil crisis in the 1970s, where we tried to act wisely, but where the rest of Europe could not really keep up. We analyzed a lot about it, can you remember, but we did not get through. Now I hope that in the new Europe we can learn - also from the mistakes of the 1970s.

* * *

The major structural changes in the 1990s and the lead-up to them in the 1980s are also an emphasis that we can have a basic model that can also renew itself. The Danish model has survived as strongly as ever, - or what?

In any case, we have gotten through major changes until now. But if the truth be told, it is also difficult here and there. It is difficult on the employers' side. Some of the large ones believe they should be bigger. And it is also difficult on LO's side. Some of the large ones believe they should be bigger. And when one becomes half-large in a family, one increasingly wants to decide for oneself. I can understand that, but my appeal today to those who want to become bigger and decide more for themselves would be: Think carefully!

Our historical experiences from a well-coordinated labor market, where the main organizations have a well-defined coordinating, unifying responsibility – our experiences that this is one of the foundations of the Danish model. Here, I am not only speaking on behalf of the government and Danish society. I am actually speaking on behalf of everyone. It is my deep conviction that we are best trained and best suited if we have well-defined role distributions. And the well-defined role distributions also include the Danish Employers' Association and LO - and the other main organizations, which do not overlap but complement each other.

I can assure you that when we meet trade unions and employer organizations out in Europe, I always note that there are a number of organizations from France or Italy. Each of them represents essentially the same sectors. It is impossible to figure out: Who is saying what and on whose behalf?

Here in the country, it is possible to find out! When the chairman of the Employers' Association says it is this way and that way, that voice stands clear. And we can agree or disagree, but the central point is that the voices are not to be misunderstood. The voices are representative. This naturally also applies to LO.

We must not come into conflict with the representativeness ourselves. If we do, we will start taking steps towards models that we fundamentally do not want.

My message today is: Take good care of the Danish model and be aware that it is possible to renew it, it is possible to introduce new areas of responsibility into it. It is possible to decentralize it. But the basic structure has proven to be akin to dawn and not akin to sunset.

* * *

What we are now facing - tripartite negotiations in a new guise - is not directly comparable to the tripartite negotiations we have had in the past. The tripartite negotiations today are based on the labor market we have today and on the roles of the two parties we have today.

The starting point is that much is more decentralized than it was before. The external conditions are very different from what they were before.

I am convinced that we can handle globalization, but I do not believe we will manage it automatically. I believe we have better conditions than many others.

It would be a great failure on our part if we do not together: the two parties, the government, society, and the Parliament, find the answers to the technological challenges - the renewal of our adult and continuing education. We must find answers at each workplace, find answers on how we adjust the way we enter into agreements - without failing the Danish model.

* * *

I would just like to offer a few simple pieces of advice.

I see the outlines of a new responsibility society emerging. Alongside the responsibilities of the main organizations, the trade unions, the federations, and the employers' organizations, we can see a responsibility at the individual workplace, a personal responsibility for our entirety.

For it does not help much if each of us only cares about our own little interest. We must constantly see our interest struggle in relation to the whole that must also hold together.

I do not, for example, believe that the solution is to throw ourselves into a large import of foreign labor because certain sectors feel that they are now lacking labor. I do not say this to provoke, or because I happen to have the background I have. I say it out of deep conviction that we must renew, we must further educate, we must continue to educate our own workforce, and there is still much to be done here. That is also what the adult and continuing education effort is about. I also say it for another reason: It should be possible in our country to employ many, many more of those people who have names other than Jensen, Sørensen, and Rasmussen. It should be possible. And if it is not possible in our country, then it is certainly not possible in other countries. And we cannot accept that.

Among the people who were born elsewhere but now have residence and work permits here, citizenship for some, we have unemployment that we cannot accept. I would therefore also today urge that the main responsible parties of the Danish model take on that task - on the terms of the Danish model.

It is possible if there is a will. Renewal, renewal, and renewal - without failing the values and the enormous strength that the Danish model is built on - that is the future.

* * *

Out in Europe, they have not followed that path. Out in Europe, something else has happened. They talk about European agreements. But remember: The kind of agreements they talk about, we would almost call 'mutual understandings' in Denmark.

I do not believe that we will see wage conditions agreed upon at the European level in the future of Europe. That would not be a good idea.

But I believe that in Europe's future within the economic and monetary cooperation, we will see the exchange of experiences in a more systematically organized way. That is a good idea. We have much to contribute. We have good inspirations for others. Therefore, I also hope that the labor movement sees that vision.

I remember many years ago in 1972, when we had the first referendum on Europe, that DA and LO published a little pamphlet that said 'We crack the nuts ourselves'. And that is also true. But I do not think there is anything wrong with us being inspired by each other. There is also nothing wrong with us in Europe agreeing on what it is that we should actually compete on.

I envision the day coming in Europe when we, for example, say: 'Now we should no longer compete on who has the lowest corporate tax or no corporate tax at all'. It is a common interest to create a somewhat uniform calculation basis.

Let us compete on what is our raw material - people and their education!

I therefore believe that Denmark should join the Euro area.

I am completely convinced that it is in Denmark's interest. I also look forward to working hard for it. We are already well underway.

This country is built on the principle that where decisions are made, we are also present.

Our country, Denmark, is built on the idea that presence and participation in negotiations is one of the secrets to the future of the welfare state. Therefore, Denmark must be where decisions are made about Denmark.

That is why we should join the Euro.

The other is our companies. I am quite sure that companies in these months are assessing how many currency hedges they need to take out to ensure that the contracts they have entered into will hold when the time for reckoning comes. It is not very good when all the others can avoid it.

Also for the sake of the companies' competitiveness, we must be where the others are, the 11 Euro countries. Also for the sake of employment.

If anyone has fought for employment policy to become an agenda in Europe, it is us. All the way back to the early 80s. We got it through in the Amsterdam Treaty: We have an agenda that is Danish. But then they agreed among the 11 others that they would discuss it themselves. We must be in the club where they talk about employment! That is done most concretely and bindingly in the Euro-11 area.

* * *

My third argument - there are many more - but let me mention the most important when all is said and done: The Euro is not just a currency that competes with the dollar and the Japanese yen. The Euro is a currency for a large market, where well over half of the total export goes to Denmark.

But that market is not just a random market, like in Asia or elsewhere. It is a regulated market where we have set labor, employer, and above all political conditions that we consider natural, but which are certainly not natural elsewhere in the world.

There are requirements for the environment. There are requirements for the recognition of fundamental rights, minorities, respect for human rights. There are also certain basic welfare principles internally. There are occupational health and safety regulations, etc.

A market with a human face, where we all compete on reasonably fair terms. That provides an enormous outlet externally. Also because our mutual dependence in the Euro area far exceeds 1/3 for all countries. In relation to the outside world, we are only dependent to the extent of 8-10%. We therefore have quite a bit of freedom to shape our own future in Europe. That presupposes that we decide to do so.

And if we do, then we have an enormous responsibility to leave our mark on the entire blue planet.

* * *

In the global world order, we will see Europe play an important role. If Europe decides to do so.

'Social leadership' or a humane, reasonable, respectful leadership in a world that has such difficulty figuring things out after the Cold War. That is also the responsibility we must help to lift!

In the upcoming WTO negotiations, it should be such that everything we consider reasonable in Denmark - that must also influence world trade. For the benefit of them, but certainly also for our benefit.

Recognition of fundamental rights, the right to organize, the right to negotiate with one's counterpart, prohibition of child labor, respect for the environment - all those things that we consider natural should slowly spread to other regions of the world - in our interest and in theirs.

There is much to be done. The Danish model is thriving and strong. It may creak along the way, but it certainly has before.

I look forward to being part of the continued lifting and welcome you to the new century. The mutual respect from my side towards you is unwavering. When we say something in the newspaper along the way - both the ministers of the government and I - it is not to irritate you. It is to offer a few good pieces of advice along the way. I have a sense that you do not hold back from giving us some good advice either.

Tit for tat, when friendship is to be maintained!

Congratulations on the Danish model. Good luck in the future.