President Piñera inaugurates the Competition Day seminar.

Chile Sebastián Piñera · President of Chile

7 November 2018 · Competition Day seminar

Context
Piñera addressed the Competition Day seminar in Chile on November 7, 2018, inaugurating the annual event hosted by the National Economic Prosecutor's Office.
Main themes
Free competition, social market economy, antitrust enforcement, consumer protection, collusion prevention, National Economic Prosecutor's Office, free trade agreements, market regulation, economic ethics, monopolistic behavior, Chile's economic model
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,320
88th percentile
Sentences
135
77th percentile
Readability
37
29th percentile
Grade
16.0
83rd percentile
Syntax
3.52
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 65%60%
  • Institutional 18%16%
  • Social 13%12%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 7%

135 sentences in 65 paragraphs

Good morning, friends:

Before discussing this very important topic, which is free competition, I want to share an anecdote.

At the beginning of the 90s, when I was newly elected as a senator, the rector of a very important university invited me in the morning to participate in the afternoon in a major seminar on constitutional reforms. I said to him, "Why are you inviting me? It’s not my expertise, it’s not my specialty; there are people who are just as qualified or more so." "To make a long story short," he said to me, "there was a person invited who canceled this morning, we looked for a replacement who also couldn’t make it, so in the end, I resorted to what I could." And he told me, "Get used to it, senator, because from now on you will often have to speak on topics to an audience that knows much more about them than you do."

That is an introduction to talk about a topic that I know is the dedication of many of you.

But I want to tell you, from the bottom of my heart, that all the ethics and effectiveness of the social market economy rests on free competition. If there is no free competition, the ethical sense of the social market economy is lost. That which Adam Smith said, that "the baker, the butcher, does not strive out of affection for his consumers to serve them well, but because he wants to progress." And the only way to progress, when there is free competition, is by providing better services, at better prices, and thus capturing the will and loyalty of your consumers.

But also, Adam Smith said that "whenever two or three businessmen gather, even in social meetings, within a few minutes they are talking about how to agree to raise prices."

And therefore, given these two realities, the existence of free competition is a fundamental pillar, not only for the efficiency of a social market economy system but also for the ethics and morality of a social market economy system.

And thus, in this matter, we must always be vigilant, never let our guard down, always looking beyond the horizon, because it is much better to anticipate and thwart any potential monopolistic behavior than to arrive when the damage and harm has already been done.

That is why, for the past 15 years, the National Economic Prosecutor's Office has been holding this "Competition Day" seminar, and it is a very good opportunity not only to analyze how much we have advanced in this area — and undoubtedly, in Chile we have made significant progress — but above all, how much we still have to advance, because let us remember that human ingenuity is infinite and, consequently, public authorities, which must regulate and set the rules for the proper functioning of systems, must move even faster than the ingenuity of civil society.

For that reason, the work that the National Economic Prosecutor's Office has carried out in its 45 years of existence, created in December 1973, has undoubtedly been fundamental to legitimizing and giving effectiveness to a model of resource allocation and development, such as the social market economy.

We know all the virtues of competition. Competition improves the efficiency of the system, as long as people compete in the right and appropriate way, that is, striving to incorporate new technologies, identify new needs, and thus satisfy consumers through better quality or lower prices. Both favor the consumer.

When the objective deviates from those two directives, non-competition harms the consumer and, consequently, harms society.

And for that reason, it is very important to understand how we can be attentive to ensure that there is the best and greatest competition in the markets.

Chile made a decision a long time ago, which in my opinion is not only good from the point of view of comparative advantages, efficiency, and integration, which was to open our economy, but it was also a tremendous instrument to ensure that competition occurs not only among producers located in our country but also among all producers interested in meeting the needs of the inhabitants of our country through goods or services.

And that is why a very good ally of a healthy and competitive economy is the 64 markets with which we have Free Trade Agreements, representing more than 86% of global GDP and two-thirds of consumers. That is a great instrument, a great tool, but it is not enough.

That is why the work carried out by the Prosecutor's Office and the Tribunal, to be permanently one step ahead, anticipating, seeking mechanisms to prevent even the temptation of collusion, and the other, judging when behaviors deviate from what the law establishes, and which it establishes with very powerful arguments, both ethical and effective, is absolutely fundamental.

Today we are making progress in Free Trade Agreements, not only because they are effective mechanisms to better take advantage of comparative advantages, the specialization of labor, and thus increase our country's capacity to improve the quality of life for all its inhabitants, but also because of their effect on free competition in our country.

We are advancing in a new Agreement with the European Union; we are perfecting our Agreement with the United States; we have just sent to Congress the new Free Trade Agreement with Argentina; in the coming days, we will sign a Free Trade Agreement with Brazil. This is a permanent task of opening our economy.

But it is also true that it is essential to continue advancing in terms of perfecting competition within our country. And in this matter, not only the Prosecutor's Office and the Tribunal but all citizens and all observers can play a very important role.

Many times, the evidence of anti-competitive behavior is so strong and so clear, and yet it manages to persist for a long time.

Ensuring the defense and promotion of free competition is a fundamental commitment of our Government, because we are fully aware that by doing so we are fulfilling a dual role: improving the efficiency of our system, but also making the system more ethical, fair, and preventing abuses of dominant or monopolistic positions.

An example of this task was what we did in our first Government. For example, number portability: we all know that there is competition in the telecommunications market, but we all know that no one wants to lose their number, and therefore losing the number means having to communicate with all your reference group to inform them of the new number. And thus, when the number belonged to the company, we were undermining free competition, putting barriers to the free mobility of people. When the number becomes the property of the person, it obviously improves competition in the industry, as reflected in the drop in prices and also in the greater mobility we have seen.

The same happens in industries like, for example, the Isapres. Undoubtedly, pre-existing conditions and waiting periods limit mobility, and when one has no mobility, has only one provider, the possibility that that relationship is not equitable or lends itself to abuses increases significantly.

That is why one of the reforms we are going to introduce is to eliminate waiting periods, eliminate pre-existing conditions, so that there is mobility, even for those who have an illness or those who have a waiting period, that is, are in an Isapre. For example, a woman has no protection until several months after contracting the plan if she becomes pregnant.

And naturally, we must seek a risk compensation mechanism so that this does not mean destroying the industry.

But always giving more power to the consumer benefits competition, because we are all consumers, and consequently, that relationship of distributing power equitably cannot be tilted in one direction or the other, because the opposite can happen, that excessive protection for the consumer inhibits the free production and distribution of goods and services.

There are many other examples, and that is why I remember that during our first Government we tasked a great economist, who is no longer with us today, Francisco Rosende, to chair a commission to seek areas where we can improve competition. We have done the same this time. And that is why I take this opportunity to ask the Minister of Economy — whom I have asked many times — the Prosecutor's Office, the Tribunal itself, that any suggestion to improve our institution that allows increasing and facilitating free competition will be very welcome and well considered.

The elimination of barriers to entry is another way to ensure that there is greater competition. What is important is not so much how many players there are in an industry, but whether the industry can be challenged, because if there are few players in an industry and they behave competitively, there will not be many incentives for others to enter, because the price will reflect the cost and normal profitability. If they start to behave non-competitively and there are barriers to entry, we are in trouble. If there are no barriers to entry, those same signals will allow the system itself, through new players in that industry, to correct that potential competition situation.

And therefore, we must be very attentive to where there are barriers to entry in industries and how we can eliminate them, so that we have a prevention mechanism.

I have often said that transparency is the best antidote against corruption, because there is no better police than public lighting, nor is there a better disinfectant than sunlight. When people know that what they are doing is known or will be known, they behave differently than if they think it will never be known. That is part of human nature.

And that is why improving the transparency of the public sector is essential, because citizens have the right to know what the authorities they elect with their votes are doing, and also how the resources they finance with their taxes are being spent.

Transparency is a great antidote against corruption and many other evils.

In the past, transparency was very difficult because it was very expensive for everything to be transparent, it was very cumbersome, it was very complex; now we have a formidable ally, which is information technology, which allows us to make available to anyone interested, at practically zero cost, marginally, and that makes everyone observed or aware that they can be observed. And that changes attitudes significantly.

The same happens with lifting barriers to entry in different industries. And believe me, those who have barriers to entry are very happy and comfortable with them. We talked with the Minister of Economy, that many people, when they come to talk to one, come to say, "the market must function, but in an orderly manner." That means, with those of us who are inside, not with anyone.

That is a demonstration of human nature to seek to protect their market area while wanting everyone else to be in free competition.

Or when they constantly come to ask us to take resources from one sector to transfer them to another sector, and it generally coincides that the one in front is the one who receives, not the one who gives.

For that reason, we still have much work to do, and there the Sustainable Project Management (GPS) project aims to lift that enormous bureaucratic barrier that hinders, obstructs, and delays investment projects for reasons that are not justified. If there are some investment projects that should not be done, when there are good reasons, but we should not stop an investment project for years for an absolutely insufficient reason; it will allow for more investment, more investment means that markets will be more challenged, more players will be able to enter different industries, and that is a very important task that the Ministry of Economy is carrying out.

And the second task is the National Productivity and Entrepreneurship Office (OPEN), which seeks to be permanently reviewing legislation, laws, regulations, and norms, because many times regulations accumulate and challenge the law of mortality. When a regulation is necessary, it appears; when it is no longer necessary, it persists, and consequently, we fill ourselves with a regulatory apparatus, with laws, that makes it very difficult to open up space for new players to enter, to generate greater competition, and we are also hindering, with that type of regulation, innovation and entrepreneurship, which are absolutely fundamental in this society we are facing today.

That is why we introduced in August the bill that evaluates bills from the perspective of productivity, in order to regulate, review, and question the enormous regulation. We are about to send a bill that has never been sent in Chile, which is not a law that creates new obligations or new requirements, but rather, on the contrary, a law that repeals laws. The law is presumed to be known, and today in Chile we have more than 20,000 laws; I believe that no one, not even Watson, is capable of knowing and understanding those 20,000 laws.

But, in addition, and following recommendations we received from the National Economic Prosecutor's Office, we have submitted a bill to remove entry barriers in some sectors, for example, that of notaries. We paid close attention to the study that was conducted on the issue of notaries and conservators, and undoubtedly, there are many entry barriers there; and those who are within those barriers do not want to eliminate them. This is somewhat like what happened with medieval cities when they were besieged by enemy armies: those outside wanted to enter, and those inside wanted to leave. Only here, those outside want to enter, and those inside do not want anyone to enter.

And that is why removing entry barriers is a permanent task; the work of removing entry barriers will never be finished, because entry barriers are also dynamic. They used to be legal barriers; today they can be technological or regulatory, or absurd. For example, what happens with the food industry for children, where all the regulations are made for a Chile that had malnourished children, and therefore, it was important that children's food had many calories. That has changed; today the problem is obesity, and yet we continue with the same regulation, and consequently, international competition does not enter Chile because it will not prepare a product specifically for a regulation that only benefits those who have the technology and the procedures. If we lift that regulation, which is part of the program, we will improve the nutrition of our children and increase competition in a very important industry.

But in addition to that, some time ago, a couple of days ago, we received from the working group, one of the 5 tables of National Unity for Major National Agreements, which referred to how to enhance, strengthen, and increase our potential growth. And within those proposals, which are 100 proposals, there is a chapter specifically aimed at improving competition in our industry.

And that is why we have analyzed with great care; I was telling you that we want to discuss these issues with people like you, who have dedicated or are particularly interested in improving competition, in order to advance by receiving the wisdom, experience, and knowledge from all the parties involved, and not as often happens where the remedy is worse than the disease.

And I would also like to announce some measures that we are in the process of taking. First, to repeat the good experience of number portability, which over the last 5 years allowed 10 million people to change companies.

What does that mean? When a person voluntarily changes companies, and another company voluntarily accepts that person, there is a gain in welfare for society as a whole. It did not happen before because they were captive, and when one is captive, the possibility of abuses starting to occur, even progressively, is very high.

We want to do the same with loans, especially mortgage loans, so that people have a simple and quick mechanism to be able to - if they have better conditions at another bank - take their loan and mortgage to the other bank. Today it is very difficult because the bank that has the mortgage does not lift the mortgage until it is paid, and the bank that has to lend does not lend until the mortgage is lifted, and that is a problem that leaves the debtor trapped. If we achieve a system that allows the transfer of the loan and the mortgage, and therefore, the bank that lent will be paid, and the bank that wants to lend will do so voluntarily, we will be generating much greater mobility in that important market.

Also, in terms of digital pharmacies, we know that there is a serious problem in the market for medications. It is a matter of comparing why in Chile many medications, not all, because in the case of generics in Chile a different reality occurs, but why are they twice as expensive as in other countries that have higher tariffs than ours?

One of the things we want to do, in addition to the Digital Hospital, which is a technological revolution, because we are always thinking that the problems of the future are solved with the same tools of the past.

In health matters, the revolution that is coming is of a degree and magnitude and depth that we are innovating. Many countries are coming to Chile to study this experience of the Digital Hospital, which allows us to have basically a large database, with the medical records of Chileans; progressively we will reach all Chileans, another database in which all medical knowledge, diagnoses, is stored. And, therefore, by combining those two databases with artificial intelligence, we can make a diagnosis much faster, much more accurately, and practically at no cost, which will help all specialist doctors or general practitioners to have a more precise diagnosis and be able, consequently, to leverage technology to make a giant leap in health, without more hospitals and without the need to increase all resources, but by applying new technologies that help us do things better.

The same goes for digital pharmacies. When doctors can provide their digital prescription and put it in the cloud, and consequently, it is available to all pharmacies, there will be many companies like Cornershop that will provide the service, saying, "Look, I can deliver the medication to your home, and I will compare all the pharmacies in the country to see where the cheapest one is," and that is fundamental. And once I use the prescription, it cannot be used a second time, if it is with a retained prescription, which will also improve safety.

All this mechanism of using information, and here information has a dual nature, because information improves competition. That is why we are working very actively to ensure that people, consumers, are better informed and, therefore, instead of having to go compare prices pharmacy by pharmacy, or store by store, they can do it from the comfort of their cell phone, simply and user-friendly. For example, tufarmacia.cl: you enter where you are, what medicine you need, if you are willing to accept a generic or a bioequivalent, and which area you want to be informed about, and they will inform you if you want your commune, your province, your region, they will inform you of all the prices. And, therefore, you will make the comparison instantly, with artificial intelligence.

And that will mean that the pharmacies that are more expensive will start to lose customers, and that will mean that they will have to lower their prices, and that is what generates the virtuous dynamic of competition.

And, therefore, information is a very powerful element, but information can also have the other side of the coin. When all the information is concentrated in a few hands, as is happening today, where we unknowingly give much of our information to certain algorithms or certain systems, and ultimately they sell us the information that we ourselves provided. If that industry is concentrated, and this is a central concern at this moment in the United States and Europe, which are dealing with the big information companies, like the giants we all know. From that point of view, there is a double effect of information; it is very beneficial, but if it is overly concentrated, it can end up being the main mechanism that will threaten people's freedom in the future.

We also want to open up competition in many industries that are closed. For example, the cabotage industry in Chile is closed; cabotage cannot be done in Chile with ships that come from abroad or that are foreign, because it is reserved for the national industry and, consequently, that greatly increases freight costs within our country.

A country that is 4,200 kilometers long, which has the sea as its main means of communication, is not fully utilizing the maritime transport capacity to reduce costs and also decongest and all the other advantages. Why? Because it is an industry that is closed and defends itself very well.

Returning to the issue of medications, we are going to establish a Fast Track, so that if an original, bioequivalent, or generic medication has already been approved by an international agency that provides reassurance and trust, such as the FDA or the European Agency, we establish a Fast Track system for it to be incorporated into the Chilean market quickly. Not as it is today, where we have a "traffic jam" - as we also have a "traffic jam" in the Competition Tribunal - that we need to lift the "traffic jam" to be able to expedite the processes; we discussed this with the president of the Tribunal, and I am sure he is more concerned, more committed, and more occupied with this than all of us.

And, therefore, there we have another very important element to improve competition in all industries.

Finally, we also have an issue with payment systems. For a long time, in Chile, it has been allowed and tolerated that the Great Payment System - which had a great creator at its origin - negotiated with a single hand with all merchants, and therefore, it was legal; it had been authorized by the Competition Tribunal. That is something we want to change, and therefore, establish that the relationship of how acquirers relate to issuers is much more competitive and not that we legally give an institution the ability to centralize demand. Because if that is allowed in that industry, why do we not allow everyone, for example, producers of any product to organize and have one person market their product on their behalf? What we are creating is a step back in terms of free competition.

And, in addition, we have asked the Minister of Economy - and here we need a lot of help and collaboration - to review once again the Consumer Protection Law. Not always putting all kinds of procedures, because the best defense for the consumer is timely, accessible, and truthful information, and free competition. That is the best defense for the consumer. Only when that does not work should one incorporate, some think that by filling it with regulations, that someone pays for them; all those regulations are paid for by someone, and therefore, in the end, often the excess of regulations ends up harming rather than benefiting the consumer.

For all these reasons, I wanted to take the opportunity to congratulate the initiative to celebrate this Day of Competition, which hopefully will not be just one day a year, but that we are all, particularly the authorities who have the constitutional mandate to ensure competition every day, with antennas alert, eyes open, to anticipate, to prevent, and when that is not enough, to sanction quickly and effectively, because the faster the sanction, the greater the exemplary effect on the rest of the industries, and the greater the satisfaction experienced by those who were the victims of those monopolistic behaviors.

That is why the commitment we have as Chile, our mission as a country, few generations in the world, and in Chile, have had to face two great missions or challenges as great and transcendent as we have. The first was to recover our democracy, our rule of law, our freedoms; we did it, and we did it very well.

The second is to transform Chile, the poorest colony of Spain in Latin America, into the first fully developed country, that is, integral, inclusive, and sustainable development. And we can achieve that if we grow at 5% per year, which we have done many times, and for long periods; before the end of the next decade, our per capita income will be higher than that of countries like Spain or Italy today.

And, therefore, that is the great mission, to conquer development, defeat poverty, create a society with greater equality of opportunities, a society with greater social equity, with greater social mobility. And for that, being vigilant and attentive every day, and not falling into "the error of the foolish virgins," who fell asleep, is absolutely essential.

That is why I place the utmost importance on the country project we are promoting, that we have the institutions, but also the culture, the attitude, the will to not allow, to not tolerate any act that threatens free competition, and the best for that is, in addition to an open economy, in addition to a more transparent economy, institutions that are vigilant to prevent and avoid non-competitive behaviors and institutions that punish as they should those who threaten the common good by engaging in monopolistic conduct.

That is why I congratulate you, have a great Day of Competition, and thank you very much.