CLAUSE 12.—(Special responsibilities of Governor-General.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

5 March 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill (Committee stage) · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on March 5, 1935, during Committee debate on Clause 12 of the Government of India Bill, questioning the word 'legitimate' in the Viceroy's duty to protect minorities.
Main themes
Meaning of the word 'legitimate' in Clause 12, Viceroy's special responsibility for minorities, protection of the untouchables, withdrawal of British protection from minorities, discretionary powers of the Viceroy, understanding with certain classes in India, legal construction of the clause by a court, Instruments of Instructions, request for fuller Government explanation, abuses and oppressions left unchallenged
Duration
~5 min
17th percentile
Words
632
17th percentile
Sentences
24
13th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
11.8
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.36
87th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
52nd percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 75%75%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

24 sentences in 7 paragraphs

I think my right hon. and gallant Friend the Member for

1821

Newcastle-under-Lyme (Colonel Wedgwood) was well advised to raise this question. I am bound to say that when I read the Clause it did not occur to me that there was all this significance to be attached to the word "legitimate." Obviously, and on the face of it, we would not expect the Viceroy to protect the illegitimate interests of minorities, but after the explanation of my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State, it is clear that a definite and important significance is attached to the introduction of this word "legitimate." In the ordinary course, this sentence would have read simply "safeguarding the interests, etc." One would have thought that the Viceroy, on whom we are showering all these various functions, to whom we are entrusting this immense process of discrimination in all these matters and the power of deciding when to intervene and when not to intervene, on whom we are imposing these many extraordinarily subtle and complex tasks—one would have thought that this high functionary, this gifted being, would be able to distinguish between interests which were legitimate and those which were not legitimate, without the necessity of stating it, in the terms of the Statute.

It seems to me that we are here in the presence of some understanding which has been reached with certain classes in India—and for what? My hon. and gallant Friend the Member for North Islington (Colonel Goodman) raised the question of the untouchables. What does the Secretary of State regard as the legitimate interests of the untouchables? We know what their interests in the ordinary sense are. Their chief interest is to be treated as human beings. But what are their legitimate interests? How much are their interests narrowed down by this word "legitimate"? I should have thought, now that British protection was going to be withdrawn from the minorities, in the first instance, that the Government would have been most anxious to confer upon the Viceroy the widest and most unfettered discretion in dealing with the minorities and giving them protection.

We have not heard from the Attorney-General or the Solicitor-General anything upon the legal aspect of this question but obviously, if ever such matters

1822

could be brought to examination in a court, the court would put a construction upon these words. I know that the acts of the Viceroy are not subject to examination by a court, but in so far as these words can be construed by a court, it is perfectly clear that a very definite construction will be put upon the word "legitimate." I say that this word has been put in to safeguard and to shelter abuses and oppressions which have lasted so long and are so deeply rooted and so widely spread that it is not found convenient to attack them. I should have thought that the Government, in making this charter for India, would have considered it worth while to write boldly and simply that the Viceroy was to be responsible for protecting the interests of minorities. The right hon. Gentleman the Secretary of State has, for purposes which have certainly not been made clear to this Committee, introduced this limiting word, and I trust that we shall hear from someone on the Front Bench a fuller explanation. We have been told to look into the Instruments of Instructions. It may be legitimate—I beg the Committee's pardon, I should say reasonable—to go to the Instruments of Instructions for guidance upon the point, but why is it necessary to write this word "legitimate" upon the face of the statute I cannot understand it. There is evidently something obscure behind it and, in my view, the Government ought to offer the Committee a further explanation.