Government Of India Bill.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill

5 March 1935 · House of Commons debate (Committee stage of the Government of India Bill) · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill, speaking in the House of Commons Committee in London on March 5, 1935, moved to report progress on the Government of India Bill and pressed the Secretary of State on the Princes' demands for amendments.
Main themes
Motion that the Chairman report progress, Princes' Assembly at Bombay, amendments demanded by the Indian Princes, Clause 12 of the Government of India Bill, Governor-General's power to interfere in States' internal administration, Clauses 2, 6 and 8, proposed motion to recommit the Bill, Morning Post reports of Sir Akbar Hydari and Sir Ramaswami Aiyar, call for a comprehensive government statement, Secretary of State for India, government accused of being duped and misled
Duration
~7 min
24th percentile
Words
844
24th percentile
Sentences
40
25th percentile
Readability
68
97th percentile
Grade
9.2
13th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
10th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 89%85%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

40 sentences in 11 paragraphs

I beg to move,

That the Chairman do report Progress, and ask leave to sit again.

I desire to put a question to the Secretary of State and to offer him an opportunity of giving some information to the Committee. I quoted the other night some extracts from speeches alleged to have been made in the Assembly of the Princes at Bombay, which seemed to show how wide, various, vital and fundamental were the amendments which they would require in the Government of India Bill. The Secretary of State had then no knowledge of what had occurred, but I wish to know whether, in what is practically a week since then, he has been able to obtain and is able to give us further information about the discussion which took place, whether those extracts were accurate, and whether he can tell us anything about the consequential effects which they will necessarily have on the Bill.

I see in the "Morning Post" to-day verbatim reports of speeches by Sir Akbar Hydari and Sir Ramaswami Aiyar which certainly disclose differences with the Government which, if they are to be met, will entail a complete remodelling of the Bill. They already affect Clauses 2, 6 and 8, and we have dealt with them. Unless entirely new information is forthcoming, a case is disclosed for a motion to recommit the Bill in respect of these Clauses, because it is perfectly clear that, if they stand in the form in which they have been passed by the Committee, the Princes will not accept the Bill. Then, according to the arguments of the Government, it is impossible that their scheme can go forward; that is the Government's case. I do not know how many Members have read the report which appears in the "Morning Post" to-day. It seems to me that there ought to be an official report in matters of this kind which become public in this country. Whether they should become public is another matter, but they have become

1774

public, and we are bound to judge the facts as they are presented to us. Anyone who has not read these two columns in the "Morning Post" should really do so without the slightest delay, because it is essential to an appreciation of all the matters which are under discussion. Anyone who has read them will see what a serious position we are in. Take the Clause we are now discussing, Clause 12. Sir Akbar Hydari says:

Then there are Clauses 12 and 127, by virtue of which the Governor-General eau at any time really interfere in the internal administration of your States on the ground that you are not doing your federal duties.

That is what he is reported to have said. Did he say that? Is this an authentic speech, or is it invented from beginning to end If it be true, then this is a most grave and serious matter. Perhaps the Government are not ready to answer to-day, but they should fix a day in the near future when they will be able to tell us what are the differences between them and the Princes on this Bill, what are the Amendments for which the Princes are asking, and whether, and if so to what extent, they are able to meet those differences. Otherwise, are we not simply wasting our time I Are we not debating the whole Measure upon a false footing? I am advised that the Princes require vital and specific amendments to Clauses 2, 6 and 8, Clause 12— that is the Clause before us this afternoon—paragraphs (a) and (g), Clauses 45, 99, 127, 145, 147 and 156.

Where do we stand? Where do the Government stand? I have no doubt that we can arrive at a perfectly amicable arrangement, because anyone can see the difficulty in which the Government have been placed. To use the words of the "Statesman," that friendly newspaper that always supported them, they have been "duped and misled." Those are the words of the" Statesman." But that may not be the fault of the Government. It is certainly their misfortune, and we have to be careful that it does not become our misfortune. It seems to me that a new situation has arisen, and that the Government should make a comprehensive statement. If these facts are true, they should tell us how they propose to deal with the situation; and if they are not true they should relieve the anxiety of their followers upon the matter at the earliest moment. I am sure it will

1775

be much more simple to deal with this Bill when we know where we are. The Secretary of State said that it was desirable that we should know where we are at the earliest moment. When we know exactly what it is that the Bill is going to be we shall be able to give our attention to it. Meanwhile, I await with the customary respect, and even unusual interest, the answer which I invite from my right hon. Friend.