CLAUSE 9.—(Council of ministers.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

28 February 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Government of India Bill (Committee stage) · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on 28 February 1935 during the Committee stage of the Government of India Bill, opposing Clause 9 as embodying dyarchy and urging a vote against it.
Main themes
Dyarchy at the centre of India, Clause 9 and the council of ministers, Statutory Commission report, Joint Select Committee conclusions, Round Table Conferences and White Paper, role of the Viceroy, Indian Princes and All-India Federation, Lord Lytton's criticism of dyarchy, provincial governments, vote against the Clause
Duration
~8 min
28th percentile
Words
953
28th percentile
Sentences
40
25th percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
3.29
81st percentile
Vocabulary
2.44
93rd percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 83%83%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

40 sentences in 11 paragraphs

It is usual when an hon. Member makes a statement in this

1358

House, as did the hon. Member for Springburn, for other hon. Members to accept his bona fides, especially in a matter of a personal character of that kind. Now that the Noble Lord the Member for Horsham has forced into the centre of our discussion this general question of dyarchy, I am bound to address myself to it. I do not agree that this is the only point where the question can be discussed; the vice of dyarchy runs throughout this Bill. That is the hideous blemish. That is the cause of the evils which we see and apprehend. Again and again I have heard dyarchy condemned. I have heard supporters of the Bill like Lord Lytton, with great experience, condemn it in unmeasured terms. There are the words of the Statutory Commission's Report, words of the greatest weight, declaring that this very thing that you are now doing at the centre is inadmissible, and giving weighty reasons why it is impracticable and full of vice. You are departing from the Report of the Statutory Commission and you have cast that upon one side, although it was agreed to by all parties. You have left that safe, sure ground and you have embarked upon the very precarious and unstable footing of the Round Table Conferences, the White Paper and the Joint Select Committee.

Compare the Report of the Statutory Commission and the way it deals with dyarchy with the jejune apologetics of the Joint Select Committee; look and see how the Statutory Commission approached this subject with a view to ascertaining the truth, while the Joint Select Committee approached it with a view to carrying out the policy which was put to them by the White Paper. They were, as has been properly stated, a body to find reasons for supporting preconceived conclusions. When you compare and read those passages, I wonder that the Noble Lord had the face to get up and draw any conclusions. He mentioned paragraph 32 of the Report of the Joint Select Committee. Here is the explanation of why the solid arguments of the Statutory Commission have been thrown over by the Joint Select Committee. Paragraph 32, which the Noble Lord mentioned, furnishes the reason. Here is the reason for the tergiversations of the hon. Member for Finchley (Mr. Cadogan) and of his catherine-wheel contortion on that.

1359

subject. He was one associated with the weighty words of the Statutory Commission. As soon as he got into the Joint Select Committee he fell under the evil, ministerial influences with which that body was packed—hopelessly packed—and, of course, lacking the moral strength to stand against the tide and the prevailing currents of opinion— Perhaps I ought not to put it in that way. Shall I say, allowing himself to succumb too easily to the seduction of drifting with the sea and floating with the tide, if my hon. Friend will allow me to substitute those words for the others which I inadvertently used? What is the reason given for the desertion of the opinions of the Statutory Commission on the subject of dyarchy and the substitution of the opinions of the Joint Select Committee? It is this—and I am going to read only a sentence:

The Princes have … stated … that they are willing now to enter an All: India Federation— and they insisted on responsibility. I wonder indeed that the Noble Lord should raise that point to-day, because he is like a man standing upon the trapdoor of a scaffold, leaning forward to draw the bolt and to precipitate himself, in hopeless logical and argumentative confusion, into the pit. The Noble Lord has certainly not helped the case of the Government by the intervention, which, however ardently intended, has not been a fortunate one.

We take the strongest exception to this Clause, although, until we were provoked by the Noble Lord, the discussion had been conducted in a very quiet and good-tempered spirit. Yet it would be a mistake to suppose that the greatest objection cannot be taken to this Clause, and we are bound to vote against it. We are bound to testify against it, as it embodies the principle of dyarchy. The position of the Viceroy we begin to see in detail in this Clause, how he is to combine his strong executive function with the delicate handling of Ministers. We see the different points of view brought to a collision in the very central organism of the Government, and we see this central organism racked and strained in this way and in that by all those innumerable stresses at the very moment that, over the whole expanse of

1360

India, 11 provincial governments are being brought into existence. We are forced to express our repugnance and our destestation of this Clause at this time; it is certainly our duty to do so.

I do not intend to repeat upon this question arguments which I have used on Second Reading and at other times, but let the Committee realise quite clearly what they are going to do when they vote that this Clause stand part. They are introducing dyarchy into the centre of India on the sole pretext that the Princes wish to come in, which is not true, and that they have demanded responsibility. For that hon. Members are voting—for a basis which is going to be shorn from under their feet; for the establishment of a system so vicious that it has been condemned by every authority which has dealt with it, and by the highest authority which could be accepted in this House, namely, by our own Statutory Commission.