CLAUSE 12.—(Special responsibilities of Governor-General.)

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament

28 February 1935 · House of Commons Committee debate on the Government of India Bill · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on February 28, 1935, in Committee debate on Clause 12 of the India Bill, urging that health be added to the Governor-General's special responsibilities.
Main themes
Health as a reserved responsibility of the Governor-General, amendment to Clause 12 sub-section, grave menace to the peace, health or tranquillity of India, threat of pestilence and bubonic plague, need for supreme direction in epidemics, criticism of the Under-Secretary's speech, Secretary of State's refusal to accept the amendment, Governor-General's powers under the Bill, British mission in India, communal riots, constitutional reform Bill
Duration
~6 min
19th percentile
Words
681
19th percentile
Sentences
31
18th percentile
Readability
64
93rd percentile
Grade
9.8
19th percentile
Syntax
3.02
50th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 61%55%
  • Social 29%26%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Geopolitical 4%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 10%

31 sentences in 8 paragraphs

I must say that I think the extremely well-expressed and competent speech of the Tinder-Secretary was not at all adequate to the issue before the Committee. He gave a very clear account of the elaborate provisions of the Bill and threaded his way through that labyrinth with every proof of the assiduity and thoroughness with which he has studied its details. But, after all, let us get back to the central fact. We are not now pressing to set up machinery at all; all we are pressing to assert is a principle and a duty. Let me read the words of the Sub-section as it is proposed that it should be amended:

The prevention of any grave menace to the peace, health or tranquillity of India.

Health is probably going to exact a far graver toll of slaughter, casualties of a blind impotent approach, than anything that will happen in the communal riots which will follow the passing of this Bill, and to the peace of India that is a matter formidable in its character. Surely, the Government ought to assert, and allow the House of Commons in this clause to assert, that fact among the supreme reserved responsibilities of the Governor, so as to shield India from any grave menace to its health. It is not very much to ask that it should be put

1458

in here, and in this form. You may say, that all this sort of arrangement with local and Provincial Governments of this and other lands will not work. Everyone knows that when we are dealing with pestilence you want supreme direction. That is what you require. I remember, many years age, living in an Indian city during a hot summer when 40,000 people died of bubonic plague, and the resistance of the population to the necessary measures of the Government was quite marked. It even reached the ears of the European community, the trouble there was in enforcing the necessary provision of feeling under their armpits to see if the tumour had begun to swell and so forth; and in these examinations the greatest trouble was shown. All this rests in the highest mission which the British have in India.

It may be that you will ask how it should be expressed in later Clauses, Certainly we are not saying that the Governor-General is to interfere in every matter affecting the health of the community. He has all the local bodies and other splendid institutions which are dealing with it, and why, you might say, interfere on every occasion?—Certainly not, but this is a supreme ultimate responsibility, just as vital as the defence of India and the maintenance of tranquillity in India, in order to shield enormous masses of the human race from the ravages of pestilence, and from pestilence which may sweep like the black death through the land. And to say that the Governor-General has not that responsibility is, surely, a menace and a grisly hiatus in the scheme which you are putting up for the future government of India. I do not think that it is at all satisfactory. The Secretary of State refuses to deal with the matter. He will not allow it. There is a special adjuration in the Clause as to the matters in which the Governor-General is to interest himself. In 99 cases out of a hundred it would not constitute "a grave menace," but even when there is a grave menace to the teeming population crowded together in circumstances which seem incredible to western experience, you will not arm him with or summon him to the discharge of that duty. You leave it out of the Bill. My Noble Friend has just said that he has the power to-day, bid you take it away from him by the Bill,

1459

which you call reform. You take away from him the right, the power to lift the shield of Britain against sweeping pestilences which may devastate India. You will not even give him the invocation to do the duty, and you call it a constitutional reform Bill.