- Context
- Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on December 5, 1938, in the debate on the Committee's report on the Official Secrets Acts case, criticising the Secretary of State's handling of the matter and urging attention to air defences.
- Main themes
- Official Secrets Acts and a Member's breach, Committee of Privileges report, Captain Hogan and Territorial officers, shortage of guns in an anti-aircraft brigade, ministerial optimism versus realities, Secretary of State for War's response, duty of Ministers to hear unwelcome facts, parliamentary scrutiny of air defences, democracies versus dictator countries, Member for Norwood's letter
- Duration
- ~12 min
- Words
- 1,396
- Sentences
- 43
- Readability
- 52
- Grade
- 14.1
- Syntax
- 3.34
- Vocabulary
- 2.01
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other43 sentences in 14 paragraphs
I certainly submit to the House that the right hon. Gentleman, while not making any statement which was inaccurate, was putting a favourable gloss upon a very unpleasant aspect of affairs and upon very unpleasant facts, and that when he made these statements to the different units which found themselves in a deplorable condition, it raised anger in their breasts. That is the case which I have made. I told this House at the time that the strain of official secrecy upon officers and men was almost
927
unendurable, and the evidence in this report clearly shows that it was so. We see the Colonel of the Brigade standing by his subaltern officer, we see the Adjutant, Captain Hogan, a professional officer, ready to risk his livelihood rather than that the truth about the matter should not be brought to the attention of the responsible Minister. That was the feeling that moved them. They read his speeches, they listened to his speeches, they had the feeling that he thought all was going on extremely well—perhaps not as well as we should like, but still moving forward—and they wanted to confront him with the realities, the grim realities, the practical realities, as they saw them around them in their daily work. We now know that one of the batteries in this Brigade remained for a week during the crisis in its war station without having a single gun.
Of course, when facts like that come out, when people have guns that are called "for training" passed from one to the other—like the fatal sisters of the North, who had one eye which they passed round from one to the other, until Perseus seized it—when that statement "for training" is slipped in, it has the effect of lulling the public into thinking they have all the guns they require for defence. These things undoubtedly do raise questions in the breasts of officers, and especially officers who are Territorials and who do not depend for a permanent career upon their service to the Crown, but who make sacrifices and generously give of their service to the Crown—they raise feelings of profound indignation. I was very glad to see the tribute which was paid by the Committee to the impression made upon them by the evidence of Captain Hogan. We are all glad to know that he received his promotion in due course, and I am sure the House will wish that this episode shall involve no fetter upon his further usefulness to the Crown.
Everybody is glad to see the energy and the drive which the Secretary of State contributes to his important office, and we all hope that he will not weaken those impressions by making mistakes of judgment. At any rate, on any showing, I say that he ought to have been extremely grateful to the hon. Member for Norwood for thrusting the facts before him, even if that were done in a somewhat unceremonious manner. Nothing is
928
more dangerous than for a Minister, a Service Minister above all, to let himself be surrounded by people who say comforting things to him. Every Service Minister ought to have at least one brute close at hand to thrust forward, in all secrecy, the ugliest and most unwelcome facts. In this case the task was assumed, unofficially, by my hon. Friend, but I cannot really see why the Secretary of State should have been seriously offended. He might have thought the letter was a little presumptuous, but, after all, it was a matter on which he was being served, and he should have asked himself, "Are these allegations true?" He admitted that they were, and if they were true, I think he should have been content that they should have been put to him in a discreet and secret manner, even if the threat of a question, which he knew would never be asked if he protested against it, was held over in the background. I am sure this was not occasion for riding the high horse.
When a Minister is apprised of facts of this kind, even by only a private Member, I am sure, from my long experience of the relations of Service Departments with the House, he ought not to take it as a matter in which an authoritarian spirit should be displayed. It is much better to be pulled up roughly by a passer-by than to blunder into a pit of ignorance and error because you are not told the facts. I did not like the sudden access of officialism and authoritarianism which seems to have overcome, to have taken possession of, the Secretary of State when he received the letter from my hon. Friend, and he proceeded to act with a very strong hand—a court of inquiry, the Official Secrets Act, and so forth. It was only when this House began to move that a number of careful reconsiderations of the defences of the position were undertaken, but at the first the Member was to be threatened with the Official Secrets Act, and he was to be brought up before a Court of Inquiry, even at the very moment when this House was taking an interest in the case. I am sure that that was not the natural way to deal with a matter of this kind. In some of the dictator countries they get very far away from the truth because nobody dares to tell the persons possessing high executive power what the facts are. They get no unwelcome information, as I could give instances of, it is resented as almost
929
an act of disloyalty, and consequently it may be that here is a side-line by which the democracies, with all their difficulties, and Parliamentay Governments may come back into their own.
Whatever Ministers may say or do, they cannot help living their lives in the House of Commons, and they cannot help being accessible to Members in many quarters and receiving information and checks which are of the utmost value to them in their work. I have done with the Secretary of State. I was certainly not accusing him of wilfully misleading, but I said that the vein of optimism in which he dealt with these matters was so far removed from the actual facts as we now know them that it is not to be wondered at that the strain proved unendurable, something snapped, and representations were made to him which undoubtedly involved a breach of the Official Secrets Acts. For the rest, I am entirely content with the report of the Committee. They have discharged their difficult task with a singular combination of rectitude and tact, and I expect that in this matter we owe a Special debt to my right hon. Friend the experienced chairman of the Committee, whose influence upon the proceedings was by no means measured by the number of questions which he asked.
I think that the most serious implication rests upon Members of Parliament who, in many cases, if they had had their way, would have been glad to see the whole of these proceedings brushed away as trivial and needless, and who might easily have made the public think that the House of Commons attached more importance to presenting a solid front in support of the Government than to finding out what was the actual condition of air defences, and insisting that they are put right. Now a breathing space is, no doubt, open in which Members, in view of the facts now disclosed, may consider well whether they should have kept all their indignation for those who brought these matters forward with a great deal of personal stress and strain, and whether the essential duty of making sure that the defences were properly maintained ought not now to receive higher priority in their mind. I join with others in expressing my thanks to the Committee, and I consider that this incident has come to its conclusion. Now we may all be sure that it will not be without very
930
careful advice, very prolonged scrutiny of all the circumstances that a Minister will in future invoke the Official Secrets Acts upon a fellow Member, and probably, it seems to me, a very long time will elapse before any case similar to this again requires the attention of the House of Commons.
