Official Secrets Acts.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

5 December 1938 · House of Commons debate on the Report of the Select Committee on the Official Secrets Acts · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on December 5, 1938, in the debate on the Committee of Privileges report on the Official Secrets Acts, accepting it and criticising the Attorney-General and the Secretary of State for War.
Main themes
Report of the Committee of Privileges, Duncan Sandys and the threat of prosecution, Official Secrets Acts, conduct of the Attorney-General, Secretary of State for War and his speeches to troops, parliamentary privilege, impartiality of committee members, Prime Minister as committee chairman, relationship between MPs and legal officers, exposures of the recent crisis
Duration
~7 min
22nd percentile
Words
783
22nd percentile
Sentences
23
13th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
14.4
71st percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 61%61%
  • Ceremonial 17%17%
  • Geopolitical 13%13%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

23 sentences in 7 paragraphs

When, in June and July, we debated, under very intricate

923

Rules of Order, these matters now the subject of this report, there were many personal issues which were significant and exciting. However, in the time that has passed since those matters were raised, such great and grievous things have happened that one has not the same sense of proportion as existed then, and I do not think anyone would care to pursue at all unduly, matters of individual action on this side or that, having regard to the difficulties, of which we are all conscious, which beset our actions in public matters, and the many errors to which we are all prone. I must say that having taken some part in this matter, I accept the report of the Committee with very great cordiality. Anyone who reads this report through, can see the diligence and care which the members of it gave to the discharge of their duties, and I believe the House as a whole will feel that the report has dealt with this incident in an exhaustive, skilful and, above all, a fair manner.

My hon. Friend the Member for Norwood (Mr. Sandys) is found to have used a threat, which he never intended to turn into action, with the object of gingering up the Secretary of State for War and letting him know how things stood, in the public interest. How greatly this was in the public interest was revealed by the exposures of the crisis through which we have passed. My hon. Friend is young and if he passes through his political life with no greater reproach than this report casts upon him, he will, I think, be ranked among the enviable few. The Prime Minister, of course, emerges with magnificent honours, but I think he will feel, as I certainly do, some misgiving about the efficiency with which the Committee of Privileges of which he was Chairman and I was a member, managed to discharge its functions. We had severe scorn poured upon its activities, and I am bound to say that some of the arrows fired by my hon. Friend the Member for Oxford University (Mr. A. Herbert) on another occasion, seemed to me to fall upon joints in the Parliamentary armour which I, personally, endeavour to assume. Perhaps I may be allowed to say as a personal matter that an aspersion was cast upon me when this subject was last debated by my hon. Friend the Member for Oxford University

924

who suggested that, in view of my relationship with the hon. Member for Norwood, I ought not to have sat upon the Committee of Privileges. Odd as it may seem, that point occurred to me at the time, but when I saw that the Attorney-General, whose conduct was directly under review, and the Prime Minister, whose Government was intimately concerned, found—neither of them—the slightest difficulty in acting in a judicial capacity as members of the Committee of Privileges, I felt that I ought to try to live up to their standard.

The Attorney-General receives a rebuke in this report. The rebuke is not serious in its personal aspect, but it raises some large general issues which, I entirely agree, merit the careful examination which they have received from the spokesmen of the Opposition. But the rebuke is not serious in its personal aspect, because my right hon. and learned Friend is protected by his well-known goodness of nature, kindliness and geniality. Even though he may be thought to have made an error of judgment here or there, no sense of bitterness could possibly attach to him in regard to what he has done in this matter. I hope, however—and I agree entirely with what the right hon. Gentleman who spoke for the Opposition has said—that in future he will be very careful to draw a good broad line between the relationships which subsist in the House of Commons and those unpleasant legal functions which are necessarily vested in his office. One does not like conversations which begin with "Have a cigarette," and finish up somewhere in the neighbourhood of Wormwood Scrubs. The burden, such as it is, falls upon the Secretary of State for War, and I must say I think he brought it all upon himself and upon everybody else. When a Minister in charge of a Service Department goes about making speeches to troops in which he says all sorts of things which merely by looking round they find very difficult to accept at their face value, he runs a very great risk of stirring up those officers and men to anger and hampering himself in the discharge of his own duties.