- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on February 21, 1939, in the debate on the defence loan resolution, praising the Chancellor's financing and urging a Minister of Supply and firmer Anglo-French military arrangements.
- Main themes
- Defence loan of £800,000,000, bloodless war, deterrence against aggression, appointment of a Minister of Supply, Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence and Lord Chatfield, Anglo-French solidarity and staff arrangements, government record on the League of Nations and collective security, aircraft production and Lord Swinton, British military commitment to a continental war, munitions supply for large forces, financing defence by loan versus taxation
- Duration
- ~36 min
- Words
- 4,341
- Sentences
- 151
- Readability
- 49
- Grade
- 13.7
- Syntax
- 3.32
- Vocabulary
- 2.12
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other151 sentences in 42 paragraphs
I certainly have not come down to the Committee this afternoon for the purpose of making a controversial speech, but rather to touch upon some of the broader and completely non-party aspects which are presented by this Debate upon the loan. But I must say that I think my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister tried not only the Opposition but others as well rather high by the tone of his remarks about the failure of the League of Nations and collective security. I do hope the Noble Lady the Member for the Sutton Division of Plymouth (Viscountess Astor) will refrain from interrupting. After all, the League of Nations and collective security were not ideals which were solely the province of the Parliamentary Opposition. They were not doctrines pressed upon the National Government, and repudiated by the National Government, who are now vindicated by the evident failure which has overtaken these hopes. It was the other way round. It was the National Government who adopted these principles and popularised them, gathered to them the whole force of this country, and fought the election upon them. The Government's General Election manifesto contains this sentence, among many others:
The League of Nations will remain, as heretofore, the keystone of British policy.
The Foreign Secretary of those days, speaking a little while before, in July, said:
The more I look at the future prospect, the more I am sure that a system of collective security is essential to peace and stability, and the League of Nations best provides the necessary machinery.
248
And in September the attitude of His Majesty's Government had been one of unwavering fidelity to the League and all it stands for. The ideas enshrined in the Covenant, and in particular the aspiration to establish the rule of law in international affairs … have become a part of our national conscience.
We may all deplore the unhappy and turbulent events which have swept much before us, but I hope my right hon. Friend will realise the very great share that he and all who sit with him have had in presenting these ideals to the country and in gaining the support for them of great numbers in the country who are absolutely loyal in their desire to support policies which he puts forward, and I hope he will make it clear that it was in no spirit of airy satisfaction that he referred to the undoubted downfall of so many hopes and ideals which the Government had encouraged.
However, I did not come to chide, because my first desire is to congratulate the right hon. Gentleman the Chancellor of the Exchequer upon the way in which he is handling the immense task which has descended upon him. This is no time for financial pedantry. The period through which we are passing is not an ordinary period of peace. It is a period of what we may call bloodless war. We all hope and pray that this war will remain bloodless, and that, after an interval as short as possible, real peace will emerge. But in this present midway condition, quite unparalleled in our history, it is essential to the realisation of our hopes that the full strength of Britain, actual and potential, should be used to the highest advantage; and the Chancellor of the Exchequer is, therefore, quite right to use the powerful heavy weapon of British credit, which has hitherto been so carefully kept bright and clean, as far as he can without blunting or breaking it. Of the extent to which he can use it, I must say that he and the Treasury, with their many varied sources of information and the great apparatus at their disposal, are certainly the best judges.
Moreover, the Government have no incentive, no unworthy incentive, to take more from loan than from credit, to trespass unduly upon borrowing powers, because it is perfectly well known that whatever new additional taxation they think necessary will be supported by an overwhelming majority in the House, and
249
will be paid punctually by the taxpayers in the country. Therefore, they are under no political pressure to use the credit instrument further than their prudence and considerations of practical common sense justify. Although it is very difficult to form an independent opinion, without expert information, upon so complicated a matter as the public credit at the present time, I must say that it seems to me that the right balance has been struck by the Chancellor of the Exchequer as between revenue and loan expenditure in defence, and certainly the presentation and general acceptance of this massive Loan Bill, the Resolution for which we are now discussing, has added to confidence at home and is a factor on the side of stability abroad.
Whenever we speak of "bloodless war" it must not be supposed that it is not attended in every country in this anxious, melancholy time by strain, by loss, and, in some countries, by a very severe degree of privation and suffering among the mass of the population. Moreover, the bloodless war is becoming intensified. There is hardly a day when the papers do not show that it be becoming intensified. The strains resulting from it will in this year, still more if it is prolonged, test not only the financial and economic strength of nations but the health of their institutions and the social structure of their civilisation. It is certainly not an hour in which we should indulge in any vainglorious boastings. Nevertheless, it is right to say, as the Chancellor of the Exchequer indicated, with proper modesty but undoubted truth, that probably we can stand this strain, which may be prolonged, better than any other community in the world. That is from every point of view, not merely because of the financial and economic strength of the country but from the association of the whole people, through Parliament, in the processes of government. It is a great comfort and source of additional security that both the Opposition parties, in spite of many grievous differences which exist, and in spite of the many searching criticisms which they may make, and which ought to be made, are nevertheless not in any way challeging the principle of these exceptional measures which the Government feel it their duty to propose. On the contrary, the only political risk which Ministers run is if they
250
are thought to have proposed too little, or if they are reproached with not having proposed it soon enough.
It is evident that the coming financial year will see a very great accretion to our defensive strength. For the first time, the great aircraft production factories will be earning sums upon a scale which has hitherto been attained only in Germany—and it should not be forgotten that most of them were created under the administration of a Minister who is no longer in office, Lord Swinton. I do not in the slightest degree detract from the keenness and energy which the new Minister has imparted, but as so often happens, one sows and another reaps. I suppose we shall, in this coming year, be spending what Germany has been spending for a number of years past. We might just face that fact, which is in one way encouraging and in another way casts a grave tinge upon one's thoughts. But even now, in this present time, there is a great new flow of defensive equipment in every conceivable field, a flow to be measured by the immense sums which the great factories will soon be earning and which will be recorded when the new weapons reach the hands of the fighting troops.
I do not propose to dwell unduly today, although I should be entitled to do so, on the fact, now generally admitted, that if we had started earlier and planned on a bigger scale and executed these plans with more vigour, and if we could have reached in March, 1937, or even in March, 1938, the position that we shall occupy in March,1939, we might even now be at the top of the hill. At any rate, we should have a much easier and surer prospect opened before us. Unhappily, everything everywhere at the present time moves forward together, and the measures which a few years ago would have headed off the evil, stopped it, are now themselves out of date. Much as we abhor the waste, folly and danger of the world armaments race, much as we dread the climax to which it seems to tend unless interrupted by other events, there is no part of this House, and there is no part of this country, where there will be found any desire to slacken our efforts. On the contrary, the whole desire of the nation is not only to support, but to spur the Government in their exertions. There is, however, one consolatory reflection which I will make under all reserves. I
251
do not want to complicate any argument I may hold on some future occasion, but I do feel that it is better that a Government should be accused of holding back and the nation should seem to be pressing forward in matters of defence than that it should be the other way round, that the Government should be trying vainly to drag sacrifices out of a sluggish or reluctant nation. Undoubtedly, the Prime Minister has only to ask from the nation whatever is thought necessary for the safety of the country, and the very fact of his unchallengeable association with ideas of peace, which he is always ready to face in that cause, will win him immediate allegiance. I make that point.
The very vastness and variety of British armaments production now coming into being renders all the more necessary the proper and efficient co-ordination of Defence and of Supply. Once again I appeal to my right hon. Friend to appoint a Minister of Supply, and to group under him, piece by piece, section by section, and step by step, as may be found convenient, the immense complicated system, or hotch-potch, as some may think, of committees and sub-departments which are now involved in this gigantic task. We need not argue about styles and titles, or about a particular word or phrase which has a prejudicial association connected with it. What is essential is that there should be one Minister able to give executive directions through the whole field of munitions production, or almost the whole field, because there is a special reservation to be made with regard to the warship building of the Admiralty. Such a Minister must be in the House of Commons, because it is in the House of Commons that all questions connected with the organisation of industry, the restraint of profiteering, and the expansion or dilution of labour naturally lie. Here it is where the Members are who know about these things, and they must have constant access to the Ministers whose decisions are affected. This wide group of questions has nothing whatever to do with those ranges of strategic policy with which the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence is charged.
I was very glad to read in the newspapers of Lord Chatfield's appointment. I see no reason why the broad, general views of an eminent sailor should not be at least as sound in this Sphere as those
252
of an eminent lawyer. Lest my right hon. Friend the Chancellor of the Duchy should think that I am casting a stone at him, let me assure him that I have never looked upon him as an eminent lawyer. I like to look upon him as a practical gunner and artilleryman. The discharge of his present duties begins upon a background of practical experience gained in the field. There is no reason to doubt that Lord Chatfield brings to his task ability and experience of the highest order, and there is not the slightest reason why the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence should not be in the House of Lords, especially at a time like this when we have the Prime Minister in the House of Commons. But the whole question of Supply is a House of Commons affair, and you will rind that Lord Chatfield will be hampered and embarrassed in his task if he allows himself to be burdened with the totally different functions reserved for a. Minister of Supply.
The table before which the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence ought to be seated should be a table with four legs and not a table with three legs. The Navy, the Army, the Air and the Munitions Supply are the four spheres and the four partners whose action it should be his duty to concert. He should not be the actual head of any one of these spheres. Here would be a practical, a natural and harmonious organisation. It would enable the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence, after hearing all the claims of the three Fighting Forces, and after hearing from the Minister of Supply what possibilities were open in his field, to assign, both in quantity and in quality, the necessary priorities which should be given to the different arms, the different processes and the different weapons, the manufacture of which is proceeding. All these processes would best be related not only to the general war policy of the country as known to the Minister of Supply in charge, but also related to the available reserves of the country which cannot at any stage be separated from strategy or war policy at the present time.
It would then be for the Minister of Supply to deliver the goods, and I am quite certain that would be quite a whole-time job for any man, however young and able he might be. I urge my right
253
hon. Friend the Prime Minister to reconsider this matter. He gets nearer to it with every alteration which is made, in the functions of the Duchy and so forth. We get nearer and nearer to it. Why not take the last step? I really do not know what new argument to use to melt the heart of my right hon. Friend. I believe there are overwhelming arguments. I believe that expert official opinion is almost ovenvhelmingly in favour of one man having the power of giving direction over this field, but the argument that I will use—my last hope—appeals to my right hon. Friend's personal amiability. Will he not at least relieve me of the painful feeling of which I cannot rid myself, that we should, long ago, have had a Ministry of Supply if only I had not advocated it?
Let me further address myself to the main desire of all of us, wherever we sit, that this bloodless war should not suddenly explode into a bloody war. That is the task upon which all our hearts are set. No doubt there are different methods which some would advocate in this quarter or in that, but I believe that the overwhelming weight of British opinion, and of American opinion, which is now so potent a factor for averting war, accepts the position that the best chance of preserving peace is to accumulate deterrents against aggression. This Money Resolution of £800,000,000 which we are now considering is one deterrent. What is happening across the Atlantic is another, what is happening in France is another, what is happening in the East of Europe is another. But the aim should be to assemble and gather together, if possible, overwhelming deterrents, and then form a basis of strength and not of weakness, to attempt a general settlement followed by a general disarmament, which is also the common aim in all parts of the House. We had that position of overwhelming strength after the War was over, and we failed to use it, and we had it even seven or eight years ago, and it may be long before were gain it, but the regaining of the strength must be a preliminary to a settlement which would enable a broad measure of disarmament to set the world free from the shackles with which it is being loaded year by year. That has always been the constant theme I have tried to put to the House in the six years I have been addressing it upon the subject.
254
I therefore welcomed ardently the declaration which my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister made a fortnight ago of the complete solidarity between the British Empire and the French Republic in the event of an act of unprovoked aggression against either. That declaration has, I gather, not in any way been deprecated by any of the self-governing Dominions. It certainly was cordially hailed throughout the United States. I do not intend to pursue this argument into the field of foreign policy, because we are confining ourselves to the defence aspect this afternoon, but I wish to point out that the declaration which the Prime Minister made of our solidarity with France is a major deterrent upon violent action at a time when pressures are inevitably rising, and must inevitably continue for some time to rise. No doubt the fact that the Prime Minister is known by all to be a sincere and untiring worker in the cause of peace made it all the more widely acceptable because it has stripped it of the slightest suspicion that it should be a part of any aggressive, ambitious or Imperialistic design between the two powers concerned.
But why should it stop there? It is now six months since assurances were given in this House that thorough staff arrangements with the French Republic for combined defensive action would be made. No doubt many conversations have taken place, but when I was in France a little while ago it seemed to me, from what I heard, that they had hitherto moved far too slowly, and now that we have made a public declaration in such sweeping terms, and are so profoundly committed, it would be the height of improvidence not to have every technical detail arranged to the best advantage between the expert authorities. Of course any arrangement between expert authorities affects a decision which alone can be taken by Governments. They merely enable these decisions, should opportunity and occasion arise, to be armed with carefully worked out plans.
Before the War we had detailed arrangements but we had no commitments. Now, we have the fullest commitment, and it would be most wrong not to accompany it by the most thorough and prompt arrangements. There is something to be said, and much is said from time to time in some organs
255
and guidance, for the advantage of having neither commitments nor arrangements, but to have commitments without arrangements and without complete arrangements, is surely to have the worst of both worlds. I hope that perhaps some reassurance on this point may be given this evening by the Chancellor of the Duchy, if the Prime Minister would permit him, in the course of his winding-up speech.
This question of arrangements leads me to another grave but unavoidable subject, assuming the House is going to face the facts of the situation in which we are and to which we may be moving. Suppose that our hopes of peace and a settlement are frustrated and that France and England become the victims of unprovoked aggression, what is the character of the contribution which each will make to the common safety and, more than that, to the common survival, for that is what would be at stake? There is clearly only one answer to such a question as that. The British Empire, once engaged in a life and death struggle, supported by the conscience of its people, will hold nothing back from the common cause. I remember well that after Sir Edward Grey had made his speech on 3rd August, 1914, in this House, I was immediately approached by several most influential and eminent people, all in favour of a declaration of war, who urged that no British Expeditionary Army should in any circumstances be sent to the Continent and that British assistance should be confined to money and to the Fleet. These ideas, which had widespread countenance, were simply brushed aside as if they did not exist by the inexorable force of events and the overwhelming movement of national feeling. No one, once the honour of the country is engaged, would tolerate for a moment the insulting idea that one ally should do the paying and the other most of the dying.
I am absolutely sure, whatever may be said, whatever reluctance there may be to face the issues which have to be faced, that, if we should ever be engaged in another world war, which God forbid, Britain and the Empire would intervene not only with naval, air and financial power, but with the whole manhood of the British race and all the component parts of the King's Dominions throughout the Empire. If that be true and were
256
made known beforehand, it would constitute another valuable deterrent against the very dangers which it is our chief desire to avoid. There would be no use at the present time in our trying to raise a large Army upon the continental model. That would be a matter of years. There may be many improvements which past experience will suggest, but what will happen should war unhappily break out is, in the main, what happened last time. The recruiting offices would be besieged by more than a million volunteers demanding to be armed and led to the front, wherever it is. We had upon our hands in those days for nearly two years hundreds of thousands of volunteers for whom there was no equipment, no cannon, not even rifles, and, as for the supply of munitions for so great a force, it had never even been dreamed of by anyone on any side in any Government office, even in the well-thought-out essential military arrangements which had been made.
Has it been thought out now? Has it been provided for now? Remember that should a new war come the men at home in this island will frequently see women and children, it may be their own, killed before their eyes by air bombing. Can you doubt for a moment what their reaction will be? The blood in our veins gives us the answer. The British people, exposed to such torture, would not demand peace, they would demand arms. That is the only reaction; it is the reaction which we have seen taking place in Barcelona. That is the reaction which will certainly take place if that cruel ordeal should come upon us. It seems to me that the production of munitions for an army should long ago have been undertaken upon a scale immensely greater than anything which the War Office have been allowed hitherto to contemplate, and it is another reason for the immediate appointment of a Minister of Supply. It is not a question of allowing plant and factories to come to full fruition, there is a need to provide, quite definitely, for the supply of munitions for very large forces which will be pressing themselves upon us should this hateful evil of war ever come upon us.
Moreover—to continue dealing with unpopular and unpalatable topics—we ought surely to have available in the first few months of war military forces larger than anything of which we have yet heard. We ought to have some statement on this
257
subject. What is done with that force is another matter, but the forces which are being prepared should be known, as they are in respect of the strength of the Air Force and as they are in respect of the vessels of His Majesty's Fleet. I have mentioned before that by Christmas, 1914, no fewer than 14 British divisions, including two cavalry divisions, had actually been engaged. Where such a force should be employed is a matter to be concerted between allies, to be decided in the light of circumstances, which may never arise but which should be foreseen; that it should be ready, and that there should be behind it all the necessary supplies, ammunition factories, as well as those needed for a later expansion, cannot, I think, be denied. By making these arrangements and by showing that we have it in our power and in our will to make them, and that our people will support us in making them, we shall complete that series of deterrents upon which we may rely, not with absolute assurance but I think with a very valuable measure of hopeful confidence.
The burden of anxiety weighs heavily upon all of us in these days, but it is with a sense of relief that the House gives its support to this large financial measure. When we calculate the losses which are caused to enterprise, to trade and industry, by the uncertainty which overhangs all our affairs and those of so many other countries with whom we trade, the sums which seem so vast when read out from the Table are petty compared to the deprivation of the whole world of its right and power to move forward into a great age of production and expansion and the elevation of the standards of life and labour. We cannot grudge any sums necessary to reach security. We long for the day when the British people and other peaceful nations will be able to go about their business in a confident and tranquil spirit, without having to live in a state of suspense from month to month, living from hand to mouth, and looking to the radio or to the newspapers to find out what alterations in our own domestic affairs may have been wrought by some dictatorial speech delivered in other countries, some of whom we have succoured and some of whom we have defeated in the field.
