Privileges.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

11 July 1938 · House of Commons debate on the Report of the Committee of Privileges · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on July 11, 1938, in the debate on parliamentary privilege, defending the Committee of Privileges' report and urging that the Executive remain servant, not master, of Parliament.
Main themes
Parliamentary privilege, Report of the Committee of Privileges, responsibility of the Secretary of State for War, subordinate Court and higher authority, officers obeying orders, rule of law over force, continuity of tradition, Disraeli on force and tradition, the Executive as servant of Parliament, Prime Minister as Leader of the House
Duration
~5 min
17th percentile
Words
638
17th percentile
Sentences
25
14th percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.12
63rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.26
64th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 71%68%
  • Geopolitical 17%16%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

25 sentences in 6 paragraphs

That was not a case where officers set themselves against the authorities, they resigned their commissions, but I should be straying rather far from the narrow path along which I have to progress if I attempted to deal fully with that matter, although I am quite capable of discussing it in detail. But military questions, obviously of the highest consequence, are raised in view of the fact that it appears that this Court is alone responsible for its action and that there is not responsibility higher than this Court. I shall not press any further upon this subject, though I feel astonished that we have not had an appeal to the Chair by the Secretary of State for War to be allowed, almost as a personal matter, to stand between this subordinate Court and the censure which is now directed upon it. Every instinct would have prompted him to spring up and say not merely "I take the full responsibility" in the technical sense, but to say it precisely that these officers were obeying the orders of a higher authority in everything they did. The blame does not rest upon them but on those who have told us that they accept responsibility for their action. That is all I wish to say on this particular subject which I might, indeed, have illuminated a little further but for the conditions under which we are discussing the matter.

Although there has been some feeling expressed to-day I do not think that we have anything to regret that this incident has occurred, or that it has been raised, or that the matter has gone forward to the Committee of Privileges or that Mr. Speaker has ruled upon it as he has. There are some of the younger Members of this House, and some for whom youth is no longer an excuse, who seem altogether not fully to appreciate the dignity and Privilege which may in certain cir-

980

cumstances envelop even the humblest of us. This dignity and these Privileges lie at the very foundation of our Parliamentary system. We have taught this system to a large part of the human race, and it flourishes and is cherished throughout the British Empire. We are trying to convince the rest of the world of its superiority over various forms of tyranny, personal, party or sectarian. I think this has been a highly educative episode to foreigners. I think this Report will be read with the greatest interest abroad, and admiring and envious eyes will be turned towards this country from many lands. The lessons of this Report should be proclaimed. Here we see that force does not rule, but law. Law rules largely in virtue of customs transmitted to us by our clear-sighted, resolute and faithful forbears. We see in this Report, going back as it does in its purview over the centuries, that all wisdom is not new wisdom, that continuity of national life is precious and exalting and adds to our safety as well as to our comfort. Mr. Disraeli, in one of his most famous sayings declared:

Nations are ruled by force or by tradition.

There is no humiliation in bowing to tradition. It is especially becoming in the Prime Minister, with a large majority at his back, to do so. I congratulate the Prime Minister on having, as Leader of the House, which is a separate function he discharges, enforced the customs of Parliament to his own inconvenience and even to some extent in his own despite. We cannot too boldly proclaim the salutary principle that the Executive is the servant and not the master of Parliamentary institutions, and that good government and happy nations arise from the proper balance of forces and functions within a State rather than from the subordination of all to any of them.