Press point by the President of the French Republic Emmanuel Macron at the end of the first working morning.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

25 August 2019 · G7 summit, first working morning

Context
Macron addressed press at the 2019 Biarritz G7 Summit, reporting on working sessions covering Iran, the Amazon, Ukraine, trade, and global growth.
Main themes
G7 summit discussions, Iran nuclear deal and regional stability, Amazon crisis, Ukraine crisis and Russia, international trade tensions, global economic growth, WTO reform, international taxation modernization, OECD framework, France-US relations, multilateral cooperation, sanctions policy
Duration
~16 min
54th percentile
Words
1,894
54th percentile
Sentences
98
62nd percentile
Readability
31
18th percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
2.51
4th percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
72nd percentile

G7 / G20 Summit Communiqués Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 41%36%
  • Ceremonial 22%19%
  • Economic 21%18%
  • Environmental 13%11%
  • Institutional 3%3%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

98 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Very well, we had an extremely useful discussion yesterday, and I truly believe in the spirit of what the G7 should be, which is an informal, free, intense, and very long discussion where we essentially covered three topics: the Amazon, Iran, the Ukrainian crisis, and the question of Russia. And so I will obviously have the opportunity at the end of this G7 to report on all of our discussions, but I find that yesterday's exchange really allowed us to see the areas of convergence, the points on which we want to mobilize together on these three issues, to sometimes clear up misunderstandings that existed, to also see our differences and how this collective can be useful, and there is a real willingness to mobilize on these three topics that were discussed at length. This morning we talked about international trade, taxation issues, global growth, and there too we know the tensions that may have existed, but I also believe that everyone was able to explain themselves; the discussion was very free because it was informal, but I also believe that everyone clearly reiterated their desire for global growth to move forward again, and therefore it needs calming, multilateral work without naivety, where we need to protect intellectual property, where we need to protect our countries against any form of unfair competition, but within a concerted framework, and for that, we will undoubtedly need to profoundly transform the World Trade Organization with a willingness to find, in a concerted manner, at least among us seven and, if possible, more broadly, the ways and means to modernize international taxation within the framework of the OECD. So for me, these are very good discussions, and we will continue them this afternoon on the subject of inequalities, this afternoon on Africa, and I will also report on these advances obviously at the end of this summit.

Unidentified speaker

(Inaudible) President TRUMP says he does not agree that, that he had agreed with you, that you could send a message as president of the G7. He says you speak for France, I speak for the United States.

Emmanuel MACRON

No… But he is absolutely right, and I think that is exactly what we must collectively avoid, which is to have these kinds of spins, as they say, where the press messages respond to each other. We had a discussion yesterday, this discussion on Iran revealed two common lines of force: first, no member of the G7 wants Iran to ever have nuclear weapons; secondly, all members of the G7 are deeply committed to the stability and peace of the region and therefore do not want to engage in actions that could harm it. In this context, we discussed our different initiatives: Shinzo Abe has taken initiatives regarding Iran, I have taken several initiatives, and we reported on them. The G7 is an informal club; there is no mandate given within the formal G7 to one or the other, and therefore there are initiatives that will continue to be taken by each of us to achieve these two objectives. That is what is very important. And what we concluded from our discussions yesterday is that we will continue to act, each in our role. Obviously, when I speak, I speak on behalf of France, but I speak in light of yesterday's exchange, saying that to achieve these two objectives, we are taking useful action. But the G7 is not a body where a formal mandate is given; we are not a structured organization where there are mandates and competencies. We are seven sovereign countries, seven sovereign powers that agree around the table.

Unidentified speaker

Were the seven really in agreement that the United States' maximum pressure policy is yielding results? That is what the Americans are telling us.

Emmanuel MACRON

What is important is that we reach this final result, and I think we are all useful in this exchange. If the Europeans had not remained within the framework of the JCPOA, Iran would have exited it. So it was useful for some to stay. If there had not been a policy of sanctions and pressure, there might be less willingness to move on other issues from the Iranians. So you know what matters today is to achieve these two final effects. I try to be as humble and pragmatic as possible: what do we want? More visibility so that there is no nuclear capability in Iran and stability. The situation is fragile; we all need to be mobilized, and at the end of the game, it will be a very good discussion to know who did what and thanks to whom. I am even ready to say that it is thanks to whom we want; there is no right of ownership, but that we have succeeded in achieving these two objectives is the most important.

Unidentified speaker

And regarding the sanctions, is President TRUMP in agreement to ease them (inaudible)?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, listen, we are not at that level at all. I think it is very important that on these subjects we do not go too fast nor make each other say things because these comments can have an unnecessary effect. So I will be very cautious on that; I tell you there is a consensus on these two objectives, and we will continue to act, sometimes even in a very discreet manner to make it effective.

Unidentified speaker

(Inaudible) What are you going to do in the coming weeks?

Emmanuel MACRON

Continue to discuss.

Unidentified speaker

And will you go there in person?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, it is about, there are telephone exchanges; the minister, as you know, ZARIF came to Paris on Friday, so we will continue the exchanges in this form. We will continue, but I want to be very clear: President TRUMP is right, there is no formal mandate given within the G7; that does not exist.

Unidentified speaker

You wanted concrete advances on international trade; did you have any this morning?

Emmanuel MACRON

I hope so; we had a very good discussion, and I hope that in the coming hours, in the coming days, we can really finalize our clear desire to profoundly modernize the World Trade Organization and to act together on taxation within the framework of the OECD; I think these are really two useful things. But I also hope that we can have a very clear and positive message, which was really what emerged from our discussions this morning, on the need to stabilize the global situation, to pacify the global situation. I believe that everyone, everyone is committed to that. And so these are two very concrete subjects on the WTO and taxation at the OECD because, as you know, it was also a contentious issue: since we could not agree at the OECD, the European Union tried to find a tax on digital activities. There were these tensions, and that is why about ten countries, including France, made the decision to have a tax that at one point clashed with certain American companies. I clearly told President TRUMP yesterday that if we find a solution together within the framework of the OECD, we do not wish to keep our tax; it is very imperfect, our tax. It is much smarter to have an international tax, but today our international tax system is not good. If we can initiate this international dynamic, it is the best possible solution: it is good in relation to what President Trump wants and what he said, that is to say, “a country cannot tax my companies; I want it to be done internationally or it should be me,” and it will be good for us because it achieves the same objective.

Unidentified speaker

Mr. President, regarding the Amazon, please, since you spoke about it, I believe, last night with your counterparts, were there any convergences, divergences, and if so, which ones?

Emmanuel MACRON

So there is a real convergence to say we all agree to help as quickly as possible the countries affected by these fires. There are several this morning — Colombia has called on the international community — and so we must show our presence, so we will finalize that. There are contacts being made with all the Amazon countries by our teams so that we can finalize very concrete commitments of technical and financial means. Then there is the question of reforestation of the Amazon. There are several sensitivities that were expressed around the table because all of this also depends on the Amazon countries. We know the attachment to national sovereignty that these countries have, which is entirely legitimate; France, I remind you, is one of them: we are one of the nine Amazonian countries through Guyana. But we must be very clear: while respecting sovereignty, we must have a reforestation objective, and we must help each country to develop economically. But the stakes of the Amazon, for these countries as for the international community, are such in terms of biodiversity, oxygen, and combating climate change that we must proceed with this reforestation. And so what we are working on is an international mobilization mechanism to be able to help these countries more effectively, but with them. There you go, and that is what emerged from yesterday's discussion and on which we continue to work effectively. I will really have to...

Unidentified speaker

Is Mr. TRUMP (inaudible) to be able to make agreements with him (inaudible) does not change his mind the next day?

Emmanuel MACRON

Mr. TRUMP is the President of the United States of America.

Unidentified speaker

What does that mean?

Emmanuel MACRON

It means the world's leading power and our allies. And so very clearly, that is why when he arrived yesterday afternoon in Biarritz, the first thing I wanted to do was to spend time with him; we had a wonderful moment, we had lunch for two hours, we talked about all the topics in a very useful way. And I think it is this direct dialogue that really allows us to move forward effectively. Last night's discussion was also extremely concrete and allowed us to make progress, and so I am confident. I know what his objectives are; he is very clear, and by the way, he is someone who does what he said to his voters. It is normal that he wants to defend the interests of the economy, workers, and the American population, and he is also fully aware of his responsibilities as the world's leading power. And so in this context, we are making useful progress, and that is what the G7 is for. There you go, we are going back, thank you very much.

Unidentified speaker

(Inaudible) You talked about a new tax cut. (inaudible)

Emmanuel MACRON

But that is what the United States has decided and what they are committed to doing.

Unidentified speaker

(Inaudible) So nothing new then..(inaudible)

Emmanuel MACRON

It is not at the G7 level that we decide to make budget cuts or tax cuts. But we clearly said that in this agenda we needed to coordinate to think about mechanisms to stimulate growth. It can be tax cuts for some, it can be regulatory simplifications, it can be budgetary stimulus, but we need to boost our global economy. I am going back. Thank you.