Interventions by the President of the Government at the World Economic Forum panels

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

27 January 2010 · World Economic Forum panels

Context
Zapatero addressed panels at the World Economic Forum in Davos on January 27, 2010, discussing Spain's economy and the eurozone amid the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Eurozone stability, Spain's fiscal deficit and austerity measures, Spanish banking sector resilience, European economic coordination, Stability Pact compliance, euro as a successful currency, savings banks restructuring, globalization and financial crisis response, Spain's economic track record, European Union integration
Duration
~26 min
76th percentile
Words
3,068
76th percentile
Sentences
112
68th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
13.5
62nd percentile
Syntax
3.34
85th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
13th percentile

World Economic Forum · Davos Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 55%53%
  • Geopolitical 14%13%
  • Social 14%13%
  • Environmental 9%9%
  • Institutional 5%4%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

112 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Panel "RETHINKING THE EUROZONE"

Q.- Spain is a country that has experienced considerable and rapid expansion, but is now facing a high level of unemployment and deficit. Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, can your country meet the requirements of the Stability Pact of the European Union?

President.- The first statement I wish to make is that the euro is a successful project, which has been, is, and will be a strong currency, and has provided price stability, disciplined fiscal policy, and further integrated the countries that make up the eurozone. And, of course, Spain, like all the countries in the eurozone, is responsible for complying with the Stability Pact, as it has done throughout its history since we joined the Monetary Union.

We are going to comply by reducing our deficit, so that, as the Commission has set, by 2013 we will be back at 3 percent of Gross Domestic Product. We have a track record as a serious and compliant country, and we are going to do it. Tomorrow, the Government will approve an Austerity Plan, as well as a reform plan in the area of Social Security, and I must say that our starting conditions when the financial and economic crisis began were quite reasonable: we had a surplus, four years of surplus, and we had a debt twenty points below the European average, which still stands; and, consequently, a strength as a country.

Q.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, Spain has become a multinational player, partly due to the banks established in Latin America and also in Great Britain. Are you concerned about the health of the banking sector in Spain currently? It seems that there are a number of banks that are very exposed and others that may be stronger at the same time. What is the current situation of the banking system in Spain?

President.- We must be one of the few developed countries, with a certain size in our economies, like Spain, where the banking map has not changed at all in the last ten years, because the financial crisis has not led to the bankruptcy of any bank in Spain. We are the exception. Moreover, some of our banks, like Banco Santander, have been called, for example, to Great Britain to take charge, to some extent, of the problems in the financial sector.

We have held up very well as a financial sector because we have had very prudent supervision and regulation, and now, after the crisis that has occurred in the financial system, there logically needs to be a restructuring of the small and medium-sized entities, of what in our country are called Savings Banks, which we are undertaking with a special program that by spring, before summer, will produce a significant restructuring to adapt to the new size of the economy, which, logically, is a smaller size in the financial system.

But our financial system is a good example and it is somewhat shocking that from certain opinion spheres, after what we have seen in countries like the United States, like in England, like in Germany or in others, there is talk of the Spanish financial system when it should be precisely to highlight the resilience and good management that our central bank has had, with the support of the European Central Bank, which is an institution that gives us credibility, solvency, and security.

Q.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, how has entering the eurozone felt for you? Has it been an obstacle? I think this is what you spoke about at the beginning when you said that the euro has been a success as a currency. Right now, you are the President of the European Union at a very complex moment of transition. Do you think that the political coordination among European leaders at this time of crisis was strong enough? Is it a club? Has the eurozone been a club that has lived up to this moment of crisis?

President.- Perhaps this is one of the most interesting lessons that Europe can offer and one of the most enriching experiences, because we are in the time of globalization and the first great economic and financial crisis of globalization has left us a universally shared lesson: that coordination and cooperation among countries and regions is necessary.

This is what Europe has been building for decades and the euro is and has been a great support for the entire area, for the sixteen countries that make it up. No one is going to leave the euro, but countries will continue to join the euro in the future. Just as no one has left or will leave the European Union, we have a long list of countries that want to integrate into the European Union, which is the best proof of the success of this project.

The eurozone has given us stability and has allowed us to combat the crisis, with a response from the European Central Bank, a monetary response, to facilitate opportunities for our financial markets, for our financial institutions, and to continue being the guarantor of the Stability Pact, which it also complies with and develops with great independence, alongside the Commission.

I repeat, no one is going to leave the euro, but we will have more countries in the eurozone. The euro club is a strong club, with a solid bond of mutual support. Let no one be mistaken. This is what we have said as the Twenty-Seven and the Sixteen. It is true that when the euro was conceived and launched, there were those who said that the euro was not possible, that the attempt would fail; then they said it would not last; later, that it would fail at the first crisis. However, it has demonstrated that in periods of growth it has provided macroeconomic stability, has given price stability, has facilitated economic integration, and now, in times of crisis, it has been able to withstand. There is nothing more to compare the differentials, in general, of the countries in the eurozone with those that are not in the eurozone. The eurozone countries have held up much better.

Therefore, now what we have to do, in the next stage, in a new stage, is to strengthen the cooperation and coordination of the countries that have a single currency with the Central Bank, which has the monetary policy. We need to cooperate more and within the European Union we need to forge more coordination.

The Eurogroup needs to be strengthened; it is the natural partner of the European Central Bank; but if we want the currency to have the greatest political and institutional backing, we need to strengthen the Eurogroup.

All the countries that are part of the euro know what it has brought us and we know what we have at stake as Spaniards, as Italians, as Greeks, as Finns, or as Europeans, first as Europeans who must fulfill our responsibilities, and I believe we will fulfill them despite some of the voices that rigorously analyze the euro, which is good, although some of those voices are the ones that have never liked the euro nor do they like the euro to continue gaining ground and strength. And this must be said very clearly.

Q.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, what steps is the Spanish government taking now to convince those who are asking for structural changes in return?

President.- I would like to make a brief introductory remark about the policy we are implementing and the changes we want to carry out.

The first remark is to remember that our country has twenty points less public debt than the average of the European Union; it has grown, but it has twenty points less. For example, another fact: we dedicate 5 percent of our income to debt payment; France and Germany dedicate 6 percent. Perhaps this fact is unknown, but it is a fact from Moody's and, therefore, I find it relevant.

Spain needs to gain productivity, and for that, it is essential that we continue to increase our efforts in Research, Development, and Innovation, and the government I lead has doubled that investment; and it is fundamental to strengthen our education system. But I must remind you that at this moment our economy is among the top seven in terms of receiving the most investment in the world and in terms of those that invest the most in the world, and that, contrary to what we have heard at some point, we are gaining competitiveness. In the last two quarters, we have been gaining market share in international trade. That is our situation.

We are going to make reforms. The first of these, in the field of austerity and fiscal consolidation, will involve significant restrictions in Chapter I, in Chapter II, and also something in investments. We are going to reform Social Security to consolidate a system for the next fifteen or twenty years and, therefore, strengthen what is our social protection. And we are also going to introduce modifications in our labor institutions, fundamentally in the area of collective bargaining, in the area of mobility, and in the area of ease of hiring, especially for young people and unskilled individuals who, as a result of the high level of unemployment in our country, have more difficulties integrating into the labor market.

We want to do all this in the next fifteen days; we will explain it to the public, and I have great confidence because Spain, since we were allowed to be free and democratic and since we could enter the European Union, has a record of service and compliance with its responsibilities in modernizing its economy, its social protection system, and its economic openness to the world that I believe is impeccable.

However, I must say that I think it is a fundamental idea, as a European and as a Spaniard, to point out that the European Union and the eurozone will not renounce their social welfare model, their social protection model, their social cohesion model. It must be clear: it will not renounce. We want a competitive economy like the best, but with social cohesion. We do not accept nor do we resign ourselves to being a competitive economy at the expense of social protection. What does this translate into? It translates into the fact that we have to be more productive and innovative than anyone else, and work a lot. But Europe has demonstrated in its history that it can do it, and now it is faced with the challenge of demonstrating that it can once again take up that mantle, as it has done in other times in its history.

Panel "REDESIGNING GLOBAL GOVERNANCE"

Q.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the European Union has set objectives in the fight against climate change that have not been met, but about which everyone feels very good. I am talking about these objectives that are not going to be met. Are these objectives a failure?

President.- It is true that the need to make changes regarding what the fight against climate change entails is fundamental. The European Union has set a good example because it has reached a common position that we defended in Copenhagen and, moreover, we were willing to go further in reducing emissions by 20 percent by 2020 and potentially reaching 30 percent depending on other actors.

Now we are in a constructive position again and we also have trust placed in Mexico. We hope that Mexico can achieve what was not achieved in Copenhagen, and certainly, the European Union is in favor of binding agreements, is in favor of bringing together those countries that truly want to commit, and I fully agree with the President of Mexico, who is a good example for forging understanding between developed and developing countries, which is a historical lack of vision not to collectively address this issue.

Just as any protectionist reflection in the financial crisis, in the economic crisis, is a lack of vision, a short-term decision that serves nothing for the country that attempts it, no matter how powerful it may be, taking a step back in the fight against climate change will only delay decisions that the world will have to make inevitably. It only decides how long it will take us. If leaders, globally, have the capacity for anticipation and vision for the future, we must do it as soon as possible and make a binding, demanding agreement that will be good for all countries. We cannot let what happened with climate change happen to us as it did with the financial system: that what we allowed to grow and grow to limits that have led to a truly serious situation. From 1999 to 2007, trade grew by 166 percent in the world and financial transactions by 366 percent.

Q.- Let me speak clearly: economic growth would have to be reduced in the next twenty years because we have to comply with CO2 emission limits. This is what Prime Minister Stephen Harper has presented. The only way to achieve the objectives set by the European Union would be to reduce economic growth. Are you comfortable with this new measure? What do you think about it?

President.- There is no element that makes us think that this implies less economic growth. Why? Because the innovation that arises from the demand to reduce emissions, technological innovation, the effort to seek new sources of employment and innovation will likely compensate for the potential for growth. I believe we need to be aware of two things at this moment of globalization: either we seriously address inequalities and the one billion people who live in misery in the world, or the future is compromised for everyone.

It is the same as with climate change or the financial system, which has given us a serious warning and now we have to regulate it, to supervise it, for having let it be. We know that, as long as there are one billion men without education and without health, the future of Humanity is compromised, and all our well-being, and we know, since we have discovered with scientific truth that emissions cause a change in the climate and, if we do not take action against climate change, we will also be compromised. I have enormous confidence in the capacity of talent and innovation to face all possibilities. What is lacking is sufficient political will, and in Europe, there is sufficient political will.

We are the largest donors in development aid, the largest. Sixty percent of development aid to end misery, lack of schools, diseases, and pandemics is European, sixty percent, and the greatest commitment in the fight against climate change is European. And from Europe, we must call on the other great powers to assume these two commitments.

Q.- (Bill Gates) The world has made significant progress in the last twenty years regarding poverty, and we have the Millennium Development Goals, which aimed to halve poverty as well as the number of children dying from hunger. We are making progress in this area, and there are many key elements. We do not have means that include developing countries. I am curious to know where that work is going to come from.

President.- I previously stated that the most serious imbalance in the world is the difference between rich countries and poor countries, and especially all those who are excluded and who are in misery. There are one billion people in misery, one billion out of 6.6 billion. There have been advances in this last period, but there is an enormous task ahead if we do not want to see a new crisis that, fundamentally, like the one we have experienced, has its ultimate cause in imbalances. And trade alone is not enough; there are countries that cannot even process products for trade because they lack infrastructure, they lack technological training, or they lack education, or they have a health situation that permanently destroys that country. Therefore, development aid, fulfilling the Millennium Goals, is a task of as much responsibility as climate change.

As you know, Spain is the country, among developed nations, that has increased development aid the most in recent years. Now we have a strong deficit, and I am going to make, tomorrow we will approve it, a budget adjustment of reduction, of austerity, in the General State Budgets; but I will not reduce development aid. And I hope to explain this to my compatriots because every time we give an expectation to those one billion people, to those millions and millions of children who have no opportunity, we are giving an opportunity to all.

I share what Mr. Gates says. I believe that this forum and the entire international debate only make full sense if those who have the least voice and the least power count, and they must count in all institutional areas.

Even so, I agree with the Prime Minister of Canada on the issue of financial regulation because we must also put things in their proper terms; we have made significant progress. I believe that, both in the G-20 and in the European Union, we have never advanced in such a way that we are close to having common rules, more integrated supervision, and more guaranteed stability, although there is still work to be done. It is true that there are announcements from France, from England, or from the United States about possible taxes on transactions or other types of benefits or assets from financial entities; but let us hope, because that could ultimately have a common channel, which would be desirable, in the overall financial system, which would provide stability, security, and guarantees.

But, of course, we cannot, in addressing the new regulation and supervision of the financial system, leave behind the Millennium Goals, which are, for me, as important, if not more so. That is why the financial crisis cannot be an argument to reduce development aid, and the new globalization, or the new formation of global governance, cannot exclude the least favored countries, especially Africa. Africa is the great pending subject of the entire international community; Africa has conditions and capacities, and what it needs is a new era in which it is opened to trade, helped in the development of infrastructure, achieves technological transfer, is trained in education, and eradicates all pandemics, and we give it the opportunity that has long been denied to it.